Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026 · Votes to 12 Nov 2026

Amendment · S4M-14942.2 · Session 4

Keep CalMac Public

Lodged by Tavish Scott LD Lodged 24 Nov 2015 Debate 25 Nov 2015

Amendment to S4M-14942 Keep CalMac Public

The amendment

As an amendment to motion S4M-14942 in the name of David Stewart (Keep CalMac Public), leave out from "and may be privatised" to end and insert “; believes that EU law requires the £1 billion Clyde and Hebrides Ferry Services 2016-24 contract to be tendered; recalls that the previous Labour/Liberal Democrat administration came to the same conclusion after investigating alternatives during the second session of the Parliament; notes that a subsequent European Commission state aid investigation has since reaffirmed this; recalls that a Labour/Liberal Democrat administration motion, which gained the approval of the Parliament on 14 September 2005, stated 'that the tendering of the Clyde and Hebrides lifeline ferry services is required to protect these vital services', while the SNP conversely argued during that debate that it 'does not believe that tendering is necessary'; understands that, irrespective of which company wins the 2016-24 contract, ministers will maintain control of routes, services, timetables and fares, and vessels and harbours will stay in public ownership, and considers that the negotiation of a robust contract could ensure that jobs, staff terms and conditions are also protected.”

Vote

No recorded vote on this amendment. Most motions are never debated, and many that are debated are agreed without a division. Vote records are published from 2011.

Other amendments

2
  1. Keep CalMac Public
    Alex Johnstone Con Lodged 24 Nov 2015
    Defeated
    13 for, 101 against
  2. Keep CalMac Public
    Derek Mackay SNP Lodged 24 Nov 2015
    Carried
    60 for, 41 against

Supporters

No MSP has added their name to this amendment.

In the Official Report

1 contribution mention S4M-14942.2
  1. 25 Nov 2015
    Clyde and Hebrides Ferry Services
    Tavish Scott LD Meeting of the Parliament

    That was exactly the same position that Fergus Ewing used to take when he sat in the same chair making a different legal argument and using different criteria. The Altmark case was highlighted at that time, too. I take the point about the …