Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026 · Votes to 12 Nov 2026

Motion For Debate · S4M-14942 · Session 4

Keep CalMac Public

Carried Lodged by David Stewart Lab Lodged 23 Nov 2015 Debate 25 Nov 2015 1 supporter

The motion

That the Parliament pays tribute to ferry workers at the public sector company, Caledonian MacBrayne (CalMac), and their vital role in maintaining lifeline ferry services to Scotland's western island communities; notes that the next contract for Clyde and Hebrides ferry services (CHFS) is currently out to tender and may be privatised as Serco is bidding against CalMac to take over these lifeline public services; recalls the argument made to MSPs in a briefing paper from February 2015 from the STUC and the CalMac unions, RMT, TSSA, Nautilus and Unite, that the Scottish Government could have pursued legal arguments with the European Commission to exempt lifeline Scottish ferry services from regulations requiring regular tendering of public sector contracts, a process which is disruptive, expensive and biased toward private sector bidders; believes that the Scottish Government should exercise its power to stop the current CHFS tender process in order to pursue an exemption for Scottish ferry services, and further believes in supporting and promoting publicly owned and operated Scottish ferry services across Scotland.

What MSPs voted on: the motion as amended

Labour’s motion was rewritten by an SNP amendment (S4M-14942.3) before this vote. A vote ‘for’ was a vote for the SNP’s wording.

That the Parliament pays tribute to ferry workers at the public sector company, Caledonian MacBrayne (CalMac), and their vital role in maintaining lifeline ferry services to Scotland's western island communities; notes that the next contract for Clyde and Hebrides ferry services (CHFS) is currently out to tender
124 words removed by S4M-14942.3and may be privatised as Serco is bidding against CalMac to take over these lifeline public services; recalls the argument made to MSPs in a briefing paper from February 2015 from the STUC and the CalMac unions, RMT, TSSA, Nautilus and Unite, that the Scottish Government could have pursued legal arguments with the European Commission to exempt lifeline Scottish ferry services from regulations requiring regular tendering of public sector contracts, a process which is disruptive, expensive and biased toward private sector bidders; believes that the Scottish Government should exercise its power to stop the current CHFS tender process in order to pursue an exemption for Scottish ferry services, and further believes in supporting and promoting publicly owned and operated Scottish ferry services across Scotland.
S4M-14942.3 SNP ; further notes that the Scottish Government is undertaking a fair, open and transparent procurement exercise in line with strict European Union procurement rules, maritime cabotage regulation and associated guidance; recognises that the current tendering exercise has been improved on, compared with that undertaken by the previous Labour/Liberal Democrat administration, which decided that it was a legal requirement to tender the current contract in 2005; indeed, recalls statements by members of the previous administration that ‘tendering of the Clyde and Hebrides lifeline ferry services is required to protect these vital services’; welcomes the first report from the Independent Procurement Reference Panel, which includes local authority, union, community and industry representatives, and concluded that the tender process has been fair, open and transparent, and believes in supporting and promoting publicly owned and controlled ferry services, evidenced by a record £1 billion investment by the Scottish Government in vessels, ports and ferry services since 2007.

Final wording as read into the Official Report at Decision Time. The marked changes are worked out by this site from the amendment texts and match that wording.

Amendments

  1. S4M-14942.3 SNP Derek Mackay Agreed vote, 60–41
  2. S4M-14942.2 Liberal Democrat Tavish Scott Fell per the Official Report
  3. S4M-14942.1 Conservative Alex Johnstone Defeated vote, 13–101

Signatures by party

1 MSP besides the lodger · 0 from other parties
Lab 1

Party on the day each MSP signed. Signing a motion is voluntary and not whipped. Who signs whose motions

Vote

1 division
  1. 25 Nov 2015
    Keep CalMac Public
    S4M-14942as amended by SNP
    Carried
    65 for, 36 against, 13 abstained

Amendments

3
  1. Keep CalMac Public
    Alex Johnstone Con Lodged 24 Nov 2015
    Defeated
    13 for, 101 against
  2. Keep CalMac Public
    Tavish Scott LD Lodged 24 Nov 2015
    No recorded vote
  3. Keep CalMac Public
    Derek Mackay SNP Lodged 24 Nov 2015
    Carried
    60 for, 41 against

Supporters

1 MSP

Lab 1

Show all 1 supporter by party

Lab 1

Party shown is each supporter’s party when the motion was published.

In the Official Report

4 contributions mention S4M-14942
  1. 25 Nov 2015
    Clyde and Hebrides Ferry Services
    John Scott Con Meeting of the Parliament

    The next item of business is a debate on motion S4M-14942, in the name of David Stewart, on keeping CalMac public. Before we start the debate, I remind members that legal proceedings are on-going in relation to the procurement process for …

  2. 25 Nov 2015
    Decision Time
    Tricia Marwick Meeting of the Parliament

    There are seven questions to be put as a result of today’s business. I remind members that, in relation to the debate on keeping CalMac public, if the amendment in the name of Derek Mackay is agreed to, the amendment in the name of Tavish …

  3. 25 Nov 2015
    Decision Time
    Tricia Marwick Meeting of the Parliament

    Therefore the amendment in the name of Tavish Scott falls. The next question is, that amendment S4M-14942.1, in the name of Alex Johnstone, which seeks to amend motion S4M-14942, in the name of David Stewart, on keeping CalMac public, as a…

  4. 25 Nov 2015
    Decision Time
    Tricia Marwick Meeting of the Parliament

    The next question is, that motion S4M-14942, in the name of David Stewart, on keeping CalMac public, as amended, be agreed to. Are we agreed? Members: No.