Our next petition is PE892, by Ronnie Beaty, which calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to amend the Education (Scotland) Act 1980 to set down minimum safety standards for school bus provision, including the provision of certain safety signs; to make regulations under the Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984 requiring the use of certain safety signs and lights on school buses and making failure to comply with such signs an offence; and to seek the necessary powers to require bus operators to remove such safety signs from school buses when they are not in school use.Ronnie Beaty, who is accompanied by Janet Beaty, will make a brief statement in support of the petition. I welcome both of them to the meeting. After Ronnie Beaty has made his statement, we will discuss the petition.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
School Buses (Safety Measures) (PE892)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 11
- Ronnie Beaty 10
- Rosie Kane SSP 5
- Helen Eadie Lab 4
- John Farquhar Munro LD 3
- Sandra White SNP 3
- Stewart Stevenson SNP 3
- Charlie Gordon Lab 1
The record
40 contributionsGood morning. I thank the Parliament for giving our family an opportunity to speak. We do so on behalf of our family and other families.I hope that members have read Erin's story, which has been provided. Following a year in hospitals, her on-going care costs will probably be horrendous and they will continue into old age—she is now nine. If those costs are multiplied by the number of children who are injured, the full costs that are involved will be appreciated. Erin's case is by no means rare.Malcolm Bruce raised the same concerns in the House of Commons in 1998, but no action has yet been taken. People do not seem to have grasped the seriousness of the situation and children are still being killed and severely injured. Councils, parents and children are asking for change, so why are children being allowed to be placed in situations that endanger them?On our journeys to and from Edinburgh over the months, we have seen buses on outings with no children aboard proudly displaying school signs. Some signs are riveted on, some are stuck on and some are inserted in destination boards. Such signs are a nonsense and defeat the whole purpose of encouraging safety.Many health and safety signs have been upgraded over the years, but school transport signs appear to have stayed the same. There are more visible signs on building sites, lorries and refuse trucks than there are on school buses. There are double-deckers that are marked as school buses in our area and possibly in members' areas. They are painted yellow, but they do not even have seat belts and they carry twice as many children as single-decker buses do. Last year, many school buses were used as public transport in our area—I am sure that that happens in other rural areas. Such buses contain a mixture of children and fare-paying members of the public.A law is needed to prevent vehicles from passing school buses as passengers are being loaded on to, or unloaded from, those buses. We all know about the distinctive American school buses. The American experience is probably not appropriate for the United Kingdom, but we can probably learn much from what happens there. Signs with a visible impact factor that give clear and adequate warning are needed, rather than signs that are high up on different places on buses and signs that can hardly be seen when it is dark. There could be flashing amber lights on each side of buses or flashing panels with words scrolling along the signs, similar to those that are used by the motorway police. There are similar panels on the television screen in the Parliament's reception area—words scroll across the screen. Signs could be bought that are slim, inexpensive and easy to install, that are operated by the driver and that are designed so that they can be easily removed. Strobe light bars could be fitted internally to the front and back windows. I am sure that it is not beyond industry or the Parliament to find a solution.We must explore urgently the possibilities for change. Costs would be involved, but they would not be excessive. Costs are normally associated with improvements, but how much is a child's life worth?Our ultimate aim is to have similar laws passed in this country to those that apply in America, so that cars cannot pass school buses when those buses are offloading passengers. That would be the most sensible approach.Another option is having dedicated school transport. Buses could be bright yellow and there could be plenty of warning lights. Such buses should not be used as public transport. Signs on any vehicles that say that children are on board should be made illegal if no children are being carried—that is a crucial safety factor. Such signs have been used for a long time for the wrong purpose and people have come to see such signs simply as signs.Erin has told us that she does not want other children on school buses to be hurt. My family appeals to members on behalf of our family and other families. The committee may think that we are asking a lot, but if members ask anybody whose child has been killed or severely injured, they will probably say that we are not asking for enough. Our family has spoken about the matter for so long that we have begun to talk about Erin's law.I tried to get figures from the national health service information and statistics division, but that does not come under the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002. The division supplies figures only at a cost of £250 for each set, which is grossly unfair. If no solution is found to the problem, children will continue to be killed and severely injured. We need to deal with the issue. If something is not done, I will come back before the committee, by God's grace and if I am granted permission to do so. I will have sackloads of letters from every parent in Scotland who has had a child killed or injured, which will make sad but profound reading.Thank you for listening and for giving my family the opportunity to speak for ourselves and for other families. We will leave the petition with you, but with the expectation that the law will be changed.
Thank you for bringing a very important issue before us. I am sure that members will want to ask questions and to get more detail on the issue that you have raised with us, so that we can determine in the most positive light what to do with the petition.
I offer my commiserations to Mr and Mrs Beaty. You are right to say that you speak on behalf of many families. I have personal friends whose daughter was badly injured and will have on-going problems for the rest of her life. What you say is absolutely correct.I will not ask you a question, but I will give my strong support to your actions. I will do everything that I can to help you with the issue in the Parliament. When I was a spokesperson for roads and transportation on Fife Council, this was a matter of serious concern for parents. I never ceased to receive letters and presentations on the issue from parents at community council meetings all over Fife to which I was invited. I know that you speak for families all over Scotland. I wish you good luck and pledge support for you this morning.
Thank you.
I, too, pledge support for you. You are not asking for too much or even for a lot. Similar requests have led to the twenty's plenty regime being introduced in some communities on an advisory basis. In many areas, such as here in Edinburgh, it has been advanced to a mandatory limit, which has undoubtedly saved lives.What you are asking for will not only save life and prevent injury. There is also intimidation by traffic when children get on and off buses, which leads to many difficulties for young people. I have looked into the issue a great deal over the years. The solution that you seek is really important. I do not know what it should be, but I can see the sense of having a light that flashes when children are getting on and off buses. Your petition has made me think a lot about signs becoming almost decorative—like an advert on a bus to which people no longer pay attention. When people do not pay attention to adverts, the companies that place the adverts do something drastic to ensure that people start to pay attention. That may be the way in which we need to approach the issue. I offer my regards to Erin and your whole family. Thank you for bringing the petition to us today. I will support it.
Good morning. As you heard from Rosie Kane, there is a great deal of sympathy and support for the petition that you have brought before the Parliament. The question that it falls to me to ask is, what can we in the Scottish Parliament do to change the legislation?I suppose that it is all down to attitude. In your presentation, you suggested several simple modifications and improvements to the signage, and even the vehicle, that would help. I suppose that those measures would be resented by the operators. The system here is not the same as that in America, which you mentioned, where there is a dedicated fleet of buses for school transport. We have not reached that stage in Scotland. However, I know that many local authorities are considering the possibility of introducing a fleet of buses for school transport, because for some school transport in local areas there is a limited choice of operator.Another problem is that the operators will resent the idea of distinguishing the buses by using paint or some colour code. At some point, they may want to resell the vehicles and fluorescent or gaudy colours will be detrimental to the value.You made some suggestions about signage. I have seen buses with the wee square thing at the back with a picture of a couple of kids on it, but, as you say, we see similar signs on many buses that are not on a school run and the signs are disregarded. How can we overcome that? You suggested some sort of illuminated sign that would be operated by the driver. How could such a sign be incorporated at the front and rear of the bus?
I will respond to the point about colourful vehicles first. That is the bus companies' problem; they are transporting children and safety should be paramount, regardless of the colour of the buses. I do not know about this part of Scotland, but where we come from—and probably in John Farquhar Munro's area too—the school transport is old, old transport. We get the rejects from central Scotland. The yellow double-deckers are—believe me—very old. I do not know what is done with them later, but they are probably past the point of resale.Orange flashing lights could be placed on panels anywhere. In this day and age, there are so many innovations that nothing is impossible as long as it is on a sensible scale. It would not be hard to have soup-plate-size orange flashing lights or to have strobe lighting. I think that we have all seen the strobe strips on emergency vehicles, which are really effective.None of these things is expensive and none of them needs to be fixed to the bus. If the bus is being used for another purpose, the signs can be taken down. There would be a cost element, but there is a cost element to everything. There is a cost element to our coming here, but we wanted to put forward a case that we felt could save children's lives. Everything is relative.I do not mean to be cheeky or rude, but many bus operators probably operate at the cheaper end of the market. Often, that is because councils give them limited funding—we return to the old story of funding. Funding responsibilities lie with the councils, the Scottish Executive or Westminster. That is not really my concern; my concern is to put my case on how I think children's lives can be saved and how children can be less severely injured.
I am sure that there is a lot of support for you and a lot of sympathy for your suggestions. However, an educational programme is needed as well.
Correct.
There must be an educational programme for pupils, bus operators and bus drivers, but, more particularly, for motorists. Motorists often disregard the little signs on buses. Legislation would have to be introduced to make it quite a serious offence for a motorist to disregard a strobe light, a flashing light or even a stationary bus that had school pupils aboard. All those things have to be considered.As I wondered at the outset, what can we do in the Scottish Parliament? We do not have the authority to advise the Department for Transport on what should happen.
I think that you can put a forceful case to Westminster for legislation. The issue has already been raised in Westminster, in 1997, but I am not sure whether it has come up since then. During the seven years since 1997, a horrendous number of children have been killed. I do not know how you take the matter to Westminster; I leave that to the experts. All I know is that it really has to be done. If I have to go to my elected Westminster representative and take the matter forward through him, I will do that. If I have to go to Westminster, I will do that, but it would be really nice to know that the Scottish Parliament backs us on the issue, and I am sure that your support would carry a lot of weight in taking the matter to Westminster.
My sympathies to you and to your granddaughter, Erin. School transport has always been an issue, even when my kids were small. In the west of the central belt, we used to get the old buses, so I know that something has to be done. Three kids being shoved on to one seat with no seatbelts is something that has to be dealt with, and I know that the situation has never been rectified. However, I know that the Parliament's Education Committee is examining various issues to do with school transport. The big problem, which John Farquhar Munro highlighted, is the sad fact that, although we are responsible for child welfare in education, we are not responsible for the transport part of it. That is nonsense, but we must consider the practicalities and see exactly what we can do.I shall list what I think are the priorities, and perhaps you can say what you think could easily be attained through the Parliament and what your priorities are. You have mentioned that Aberdeenshire Council no longer has monitors on buses. When my kids were small, that was mandatory; there had to be a parent on the bus who could take the kids off and on. That is a practical measure that we could reintroduce and which might help in some way. You also mentioned flashing lights, but we do not have dedicated transport for schools. That is a big problem, and the reality is that we probably will not get such transport. However, your suggestion about flashing lights and, more important, about motorists not being allowed to overtake a school bus would benefit not just school kids but everyone who uses the transport system. I would like such a measure to be extended, because a lot of elderly pensioners need to use buses and motorists can cause problems for them, too. It is not simply a case of protecting school kids; the field is much bigger than that. You are to be congratulated on mentioning that motorists should not be allowed to pass a bus when it is stationary at a bus stop. That carries a lot of weight; it is not just about school kids, but about everyone who is travelling. I am sure that it would be quite easy to use strobe lights, or whatever they may be, on the buses, and the bus companies must be persuaded to do something.Having said that, however, I would like to hear your views on what would be the most practical and easiest things for the Scottish Parliament to do, even within a couple of months, such as introducing monitors, and on what would be the hardest things to do. What priorities would you want the Public Petitions Committee to highlight if we were to send the petition to the Education Committee with our comments, so that it did not look impossible to achieve?
The most important thing that we can do now is probably to make it illegal for the signs to be displayed when there are no children on board the buses. That is of paramount importance, because when those signs are left in place safety arrangements are made to look ridiculous and the system just does not work. Warning lights are a necessity. There must be an additional visible element to the yellow and black sign showing two children crossing, which can be stuck at the top or bottom of a bus or in a window. There have to be alternatives. As I said, it cannot be beyond the wit of Parliament and industry to come up with a costing for such measures. Like Sandra White, I would like the ultimate rule to be that, when a bus stops to offload or pick up children, cars simply cannot pass it. Erin was almost on the pavement on the other side of the road when she was hit. She was not just getting off the school bus; she was well across the road when she was hit. Somebody who specialises in health and safety would probably need to examine the matter, because it is complicated. I do not know whether the Parliament has a health and safety committee. Perhaps such a committee could be instructed to take a fresh look at the situation, considering the figures on children who are killed or injured. It might produce other suggestions. The question is open.
While you talked, different reasons occurred to me why buses are used to transport school children in rural and urban areas on outings or to go to and from school. When councils introduced the twenty's plenty scheme, it was advisory. Some areas—unfortunately not all—have made the scheme mandatory. The situation is fragmented and there is no expectation of a safe road in a built-up area.I am concerned that, although you said that Malcolm Bruce raised the issue at Westminster in 1998, nothing has happened. Erin might never have been involved in that terrible accident if something had been done.
Erin and probably thousands of others might not have been affected, including dozens of kids who have been killed needlessly since 1997.
What did Malcolm Bruce do and what was the result at Westminster?
I do not know too much about that. I know that the proposal was introduced as a bill and left. As far as I can see, no one has acted on it. Malcolm Bruce mentioned virtually the same points as I did. I found his proposal on the Hansard website only by chance. He described the same ideas, such as flashing lights, American-style buses and other safety features.
I will try to find out what happened to Malcolm Bruce's proposal. If the Scottish Parliament can do nothing about the matter, that concerns me greatly. The Scottish Parliament can build motorways, so it is a shame that we cannot slow traffic to save lives. I do not know why that is the position. I will try to find out what gives us the power to do one thing but not the other when one would benefit what you ask for whereas the other would be detrimental and would speed up traffic. I will try to get back to you on whether any loopholes or Swiss cheese holes exist. I can imagine a strip on the back of a bus with words appearing. Stopping for a short time to allow children safely to cross the road, as when a lollipop man or woman is present, would be a helpful similar solution.
Erin's mum was one minute late in collecting her. Members know what it is like for housewives. Nine times out of 10, parents are present to collect their children from the bus, but if something happens and a parent is a second late, that can be the result.
I will answer the question that Rosie Kane discussed. The petition is admissible because it raises issues that relate to the Scottish Parliament's powers. The Education (Scotland) Act 1980 set out the minimum safety standards for school bus provision and it would be legitimate for the Scottish Parliament to change those provisions. Some transport issues might be reserved, but the Scottish Executive also has powers in relation to transport, which could be tested. That is how the Scottish Parliament's powers relate to the petition.
I agree with the convener that the committee could take some steps. Our papers suggest that, in the first instance, the committee could write to ask the Scottish Executive's Minister for Education and Young People for his views.My understanding is that Scottish ministers have the power to give further guidance to local authorities. I note from our papers that ministers have not given guidance on the provision of school transport since 2003. One step in the right direction would be for ministers to give the issue higher priority by renewing the guidance on the provision of school transport.We could invite the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents to give a view on PE892. Recently, I was at a conference in Crieff—I think that Stewart Stevenson was also there, as were other colleagues. We were very impressed—
The conference was not organised by ROSPA.
That is right. The conference was organised not by ROSPA, but by the other accident prevention body. We could write to all the accident prevention bodies in Scotland to seek their views on the issue. All the local authority officers who were at the conference view the prevention of accidents as a very high priority. We could give a bit of an impetus to the accident prevention bodies' campaigning arm—they want to campaign to protect children in Scotland, as do members of the Scottish Parliament.I thought that I knew of only one child from my constituency who was injured, but I now remember another child from the same town in my constituency who was killed as a consequence of stepping off a bus and walking out from the back of the bus. That is just one other example of many—we read the newspapers every week, after all.I note from the papers that it may be possible to make law by regulations on matters that are reserved to the United Kingdom Parliament. If we can get the blessing of Westminster to amend some of the regulations, we could make a difference. When we have received all the responses, we could send them with the petition to the Education Committee. That would give renewed impetus to the issue. For the sake of the children who are to come, it is imperative that we get something done on the issue.Nowadays, when we are driving along the road, we see signage that uses technology in a way that we never dreamt of before. For example, if someone is about to drive through a village, new technology is being used to prompt them to slow down—a message flashes up, "Slow down, you are going too fast". Solar panels can be used to energise signage in remote and rural areas. That technology could be put in place at every bus stop at which children alight from school buses. The signage could be switched on by a special tag that is fitted to all school buses. There is a lot that we could attempt to do that would help to make a difference.
Stewart Stevenson has joined the meeting because of his interest in PE892. He has indicated that he wants to speak to the petition and perhaps to ask the committee questions on it.
Thank you, convener. I will make only one or two very brief comments. Much of what I may have said has been said already and the committee has made a very positive response to the petition. I am therefore optimistic that members will find a way of bringing forward the issue.I have one or two suggestions to make. The committee may not be aware that Aberdeenshire is the most rural county in Scotland; 2 per cent more people live in rural areas in Aberdeenshire than is the case even in the Highlands. That is the result of the influence of Inverness—I see that John Farquhar Munro is interested in that point. I draw to the committee's attention the recently closed consultation at Westminster on the Road Safety Bill. After my meeting with Mr Beaty in August, I made a late submission on the use of yellow signage to indicate that a bus is transporting school children.It would appear to be possible for the Executive, and hence the Parliament, to change the guidance that is issued to local authorities. For example, the contracts that local authorities have with school transport providers could require certain standards to be set for the use of signage on the back of their buses. In other words, a provider would lose a contract if they did not take down the signs when its drivers were not transporting kids. That measure would be much easier to implement than one in which the police would be involved, because it concerns a contractual matter that would come under the civil law and could be acted on quite quickly.Another possibility is the idea of having mobile 20mph limits. I am not certain whether that is within the powers of the Scottish Parliament and local authorities, but I believe that it would be possible to require, through regulations, school buses to have a flashing 20mph limit sign on the back that would come on when they stopped. A range of issues is involved. I have no monopoly on ideas in relation to this matter and I am sure that the Education Committee and the Local Government and Transport Committee will have further ideas. I reinforce the point that the continual use, in inappropriate circumstances, of school bus signage leads to the psychological phenomena of desensitisation—the fact that one sees something all the time means that one no longer sees it at all. In the short term, if the Scottish Parliament were to achieve only a situation in which the school bus signage only appeared when the bus was in use as a school bus, we would have gone some way towards addressing the concerns that Ronnie and Janet Beaty have brought to us. I will listen with interest to your disposition of this petition and will follow its progress, should there be any, in subsequent committees.
Thank you.Before we go any further, we will go back to agenda item 1. We have been joined by Charlie Gordon, who is the new member of the committee.Welcome to the committee, Charlie. Do you have any interests to declare?
I apologise for my late arrival. I declare that I am a director of Hampden Park Ltd and a fellow of the Institute of Contemporary Scotland.
We can now, with the full membership of the committee, discuss the recommendations on the petition. Helen Eadie made some sensible suggestions, which I agree with. We can take the issue to the Executive and ROSPA on the basis that the responses that we get back will go to the Education Committee. We cannot contact that committee at the moment but we can set down a marker to the effect that the petition should go to it. As a member of the Local Government and Transport Committee, I think that that committee should consider some aspects of the petition as well.
I think that the relevant body would be the Scottish Accident Prevention Council, rather than ROSPA. I have just looked it up.
Thanks. It is always helpful if we can write to the right people.
I suggest that we seek the views of the Scottish Parent Teacher Council, the Educational Institute of Scotland and Transport 2000, which is a road safety organisation.
I think that we should write to the bus companies, as they would have to provide the signage. Would it be within our remit to do so?
Many companies are involved. If we write to one company, we will have to write to them all.
We could seek their views by writing to the Confederation of Passenger Transport.
That might be the correct organisation to write to.
I think that we should do that.Paragraph 11 of the clerks' covering paper says:"Requiring buses to remove safety signs when not in school use goes beyond the powers executively devolved to the Scottish Ministers".Could we get round that by following Stewart Stevenson's suggestion relating to contracts?
I think that, under the provisions of the Education (Scotland) Act 1980, it is for the local authorities to determine what is required of a bus operator in relation to the transportation of students to and from school. Because of that, it might be worth our writing to the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities to ask for its perspective on the issue. Do we agree to write to the organisations that have been mentioned?Members indicated agreement.
For the first time, Aberdeenshire Council has just agreed to a bus contract for five years instead of three years. If you decide that it would be best to implement the changes that we have been discussing by means of a contract, you should be aware that it will be four years before that contract would come into effect. I am not sure whether it would be possible to incorporate such a change into a contract that has already been signed. The situation needs to change. I do not think that there is one person sitting at this table who does not represent a place in which a child has been injured or killed on the road.
You are absolutely right. We will develop those recommendations and write to the identified organisations. Two parliamentary committees might have a legitimate interest in considering the petition further when we return to it. I thank the petitioners for bringing their petition to us this morning.
In this meeting
Everything on 26 Oct 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 26 October 2005 Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 72
- New Petitions Petitions · 40
- New Petitions Petitions · 5
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- New Petitions Petitions · 24
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.