The first petition is from Paul Macdonald on behalf of the save our swords campaign. It calls on the Scottish Parliament to oppose the introduction of any ban in Scotland on the sale or possession of swords that are used for legitimate historical, cultural, artistic, sporting, economic or religious purposes. Paul Macdonald will make a brief statement in support of his petition. Welcome to the committee, Mr Macdonald. Please make your statement, and we will discuss it afterwards.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Swords (Ban on Sale or Possession) (PE893)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Paul Macdonald 31
- Jackie Baillie Lab 13
- Michael McMahon Lab 10
- Rosie Kane SSP 8
- Sandra White SNP 6
- John Scott Con 4
The record
72 contributionsGood morning, all, and thank you for letting me speak on behalf of the save our swords petition. The petition represents the views of more than 2,000 Scots on the recent proposals to ban the sale of swords in Scotland. For those people, as for many more, the sword is of valuable and irreplaceable sporting, cultural and historical significance. Most of them are people whose businesses, trades, hobbies, practices and passions would be under direct threat from such a ban. They all recognise that street crime exists, and they wish only to see effective measures taken by Parliament and by the law to counter it as directly as possible.The petition was established because it was widely believed that the Executive's proposals were ill considered, entirely lacking in substantive research and would have no significant effect on street crime. They would make life difficult only for thousands of law-abiding citizens and legitimate practices and businesses in Scotland. The petition is a widespread national response and it poses some significant questions for the Executive. First, is such legislation necessary? It is widely felt that the Executive's decision to pass legislation for swords alongside that for knives in respect of criminal activity in this country is entirely inappropriate, misleading and unjustified. I ask the committee and the Executive: where is the hard evidence? There have been recent sensationalist media soundbites suggesting that swords should be of concern to the Executive and to the Scottish public, but no hard evidence or substantiated statistics have been produced to justify such claims. Legislation should be based upon hard facts and upon the effectiveness of the provisions that it contains, not upon irrational hypotheses and predestined ineffectiveness. Passing laws makes news, but passing unjustified laws makes unpopular those who create them. The proposals for legislation are unjustified. We must ask whether the proposed legislation would have any effect on street crime in Scotland. The petitioners, as well as many others, believe that such measures would have no effect upon the criminal mind and would not restrict any criminal in obtaining tools to supplement their destructive will. Even a complete ban on all sword sales in this country could not regulate against ownership of swords if they were bought legitimately elsewhere by mail order or through the internet. Licensing retailers would burden retailers only; it would not affect the criminal. Licensing purchasers of swords in Scotland would only encourage criminals to bypass such measures by buying elsewhere. Banning the sale of samurai swords—if the Executive could ever suitably define such—or any type of sword in Scotland would stop no one owning one when they can be purchased legitimately elsewhere. The Executive would merely be punishing dealers in Scottish antiques and collectables, tourist shops—from swords alone, tourist shops in Edinburgh contribute a seven-figure revenue to the Scottish economy each year—auctioneers, collectors, museums, martial artists, sports fencers, historical fencers, re-enactors, theatrical fight directors, stage and screen production companies, highland dancers and sword makers; it would not be punishing the criminals. If the Executive requires a precedent that highlights the ineffectiveness of banning tools that can be used towards criminal ends, it has only to review the statistics for handgun crime in the United Kingdom. Such crime has risen by more than 50 per cent in many areas, and by almost 50 per cent across the UK as a whole. In some areas, it has almost trebled. It now stands at its highest level ever, years after all pistols were banned in a futile attempt to stem a sociological problem. At present, citizens have the right to access swords for legitimate purposes. Until it can be conclusively proved that there is a significant problem with the ownership of swords, as there is with knives, that right and freedom should remain inviolate.
link
I was interested in your comments, because I have received correspondence from a constituent on the issue. However, let me test some of your assumptions. Are you saying that swords are not lethal weapons?
A sword is a lethal weapon only if it is in lethal hands—those of a person who is intent on doing damage.
link
So they can be used as lethal weapons.
As may most instruments, blunt or sharp.
link
I am just trying to establish some basic principles before we go on. Do you accept that the advice from the police to the Executive was that there is an increasing problem with swords being the weapon of choice of many young men in our communities?
The evidence of an increasing problem is usually derived from an increase in reported incidents and arrests by the police. A rise in the figures could also be a result of more effective measures by the police.
link
I am trying to establish that the measure is not being introduced as a result of media headlines, but because of information from the police—who are considered to be a reasonably reliable source—that there is a problem.
I ask exactly how many incidents have been reported and how widespread and serious the problem appears to be.
link
There is a difference between the media headlines and the information from the police, which is certainly that there is an issue. Given that we have established that there is a problem, although we are not quite sure about its scale, what do you propose as a solution to combat it, as it is clearly growing?
The problem seems to be with tools getting into the wrong hands. As such, we should target the wrong hands, rather than the tools that they can pick up. The problem is a sociological one, as is the problem of handgun crime. The problems in society have not been targeted, but the tools have, which does nothing to stop the wrong hands picking up the tools.
link
You seem to me an altogether reasonable individual so, on the basis that purchasers of guns are licensed, why do you think that a licensing scheme would not work? It would separate those who use swords legitimately, in the way that you describe, from people who would misuse them.
A licensing scheme could be effective in maintaining some control, but the measure could easily be bypassed.
It is unclear to me what representations you have made to the police or members of the Scottish Parliament. Did you respond to the consultation on the issue that has recently closed?
I certainly did.
In your view, what are the weaknesses of the proposed licensing scheme to which Jackie Baillie referred? I would like you to develop your arguments on the benefits or otherwise of such a scheme.
Retailers say that licensing will burden them with additional paperwork but will not prevent criminals from getting hold of tools if they require them. The problem is a criminal one, but the measures address the tools, which seems to be working backwards and ineffectively.
The problem for you is that you are a legitimate user of swords. If Parliament sees fit to allow you to continue to be a legitimate user, we must develop a method for that. Therefore, would the licensing scheme be of benefit to you, even though, as you rightly point out, the criminal element will always manage to find swords from other sources?
The law, as it stands, is already effective for legitimate sword use; there is currently nothing against legitimate sword use. No additional measures need to be taken to differentiate between criminals and law-abiding users.
In one word, are you in favour of or against a licensing scheme?
I am against a licensing scheme for the reason that I see it as being unnecessary.
I am a member of the William Wallace Society and obviously swords are on display at some of the meetings, marches, ceilidhs and so on that I attend. They are mostly there for ceremonial purposes.I am interested in the licensing scheme. I am also interested in what happens when someone purchases swords for an organisation such as the William Wallace Society. Do they get them from a shop and do they sign something? Does the shop know who will have the sword? Will you expand on how people get ceremonial swords?
As a sword maker, I am in a good position to answer that.Outlets exist throughout the country for various types of sword. Depending on what type of sword a person is after, there is usually an appropriate retailer or outlet. Some people are after collectable swords to hang on the wall. A quick walk up the High Street shows that many such items are available there. Specialist outlets are available for swords that need to stand up to contact use for re-enactments and for historical and sports fencing. The cost of those swords is usually much greater. To be honest, I have had some spurious callers who have asked for cheap swords, knuckledusters and all sorts. Of course, I say to them, "No. I am sorry. I do not know where to get those." Usually the higher price of a sword that is made for contact use will put off the man in the street who wants to use it for criminal acts.
Do you take a list of the names and addresses of people to whom you supply swords?
Certainly. All the swords in my market are made to order, so I have a note of addresses and contact details for every customer. That is a matter of course for any sword maker.
I assume that your name would be on the sword, so if one of your swords or a sword made by someone like you was found to have been used for criminal activity, it would be easy to trace that back to the person to whom it was sold.
Yes, I am sure that it would be. It would be easier with a sword that is made individually.
That is a form of licensing system in itself.
Yes. It is self-regulation.
The Executive states that police advice suggests that"the concealability, portability and availability of samurai swords in particular, make them the weapon of choice".Some of the swords that I have seen are perhaps 5ft or 6ft long. I question the concealability of that type of sword. What do you think of that statement from the police?
Knives are obviously more easily concealable, more easily disposable and much cheaper on the street. Knives are used over swords 99 times out of 100. I looked into the figures from Lothian and Borders police, which is one of the police forces in Scotland that differentiates between sword crime and knife crime. It did not get back to me about what constitutes a sword in its eyes, but comparison of the number of physical assaults carried out using knives and the number carried out using swords shows that 99 per cent involve knives and 1 per cent involve swords. The use of swords is hardly a great problem on the streets. There are occasional incidents but only a handful each year throughout the UK. That does not seem to me to be sufficient reason to impose legislation.
Would you say that a responsible, legitimate supplier would take cognisance of whom he is supplying the swords to and would have a list of those people? Rather than introduce legislation, would it be sufficient for it to be stipulated that a supplier must have a list of the names and addresses of people who bought swords?
That would seem to be sufficient as far as I can see. There would be a traceable source for anything that was sold.
I am sorry that I missed the start of the meeting, but my train was late. I should perhaps lodge a petition on the Glasgow to Edinburgh train in the mornings.You mentioned the handful of crimes that occur annually. I do not know whether you addressed this issue in your opening statement, but how or where would individuals obtain the swords that are used in those crimes?
It is difficult to say, given access to internet sources. Anyone can buy anything online these days. It has been suggested that some shops will sell to underage buyers. That should not be the case among retailers selling blades, but it is possible. Swords sold on the high street are largely ceremonial and decorative; they are not made for contact and they are likely to fall apart if they are used in that way.
I suspect that it is the ornamental sword that ends up being brandished in the street.
More often than not, that is what is used. That is largely because such swords sell for £20 or £30 on the high street, which is within the man in the street's budget.
Would it still be easy for individuals who wanted to obtain swords for whatever reason to do so online and to have them brought in from overseas?
Sure. It is not a problem to obtain any kind of edged weapon online; it is an open market, and perhaps it always will be.
I tend to agree with you, but I am a legitimate user of a bread knife, for instance, and if there was an increased use of bread knives in crime, I do not think that Parliament would consider for a moment taking our bread knives away. I agree that we are talking about crime, criminals and people behaving in a violent manner using a sharp implement. I just wanted to say that because I heard you address the point. Thank you for your answers.
link
Are you aware that the Police, Public Order and Criminal Justice (Scotland) Bill that is before Parliament does not contain provisions for a licensing scheme?
Does it not have that provision?
link
No. It might be useful to say what the bill does, because we have all—including myself—been asking you about licensing schemes. I understand that the bill increases the maximum term of imprisonment from two years to four years, and raises the minimum age of persons to whom knives and"certain articles with blade or point",including swords, can be sold to people from age 16 to age 18. The bill makes no provision for the sale of swords. On the basis of what is in the bill, will you be supporting it?
I believe that you are talking about a previous bill.
link
I am talking about the bill that is currently before Parliament and is due to be considered by the Justice 2 Committee.
Ah yes. I thought that I was here to speak about a different bill on the sale of swords and non-domestic knives, which are a related issue. I have not raised that yet.
link
In my view, the consultation to which you responded led to the introduction of the current bill. There is no provision in that bill to cover the sale of swords and there is no mention of a licensing scheme.
Yes. I am talking about the consultation.
link
Right. So do you support what is in the bill?
It seems to be not too far-reaching and it might have some effect, so yes, I would support that bill, but I am addressing the consultation.
link
That is helpful. Thank you.
I have a question about the logic of the differentiation between legitimate use and illegitimate use. No one would dispute that the use of handguns in crime has increased, but that is criminal use and the police want to identify criminal activity. The proposals for licensing handguns allow the police to determine whether someone is a legitimate user of a handgun, or a criminal or illegitimate user of a handgun. You seem to have an issue with that. Are you concerned about licensing per se or specifically about the licensing of swords?
My main concern is about the effectiveness of licensing and whether it would have an effect on street crime. I do not believe that it would; it would affect only the law-abiding, legitimate users who would have to go through the application process.
If someone wants to sell a car, there has to be paperwork and licensing. If someone wants to use a car, they have to get a licence. Legitimate sellers and users of cars hold licences. Illegitimate users, or criminals, sell and use cars outwith the licensing provisions. Therefore, they are using those cars illegally. The police can determine what is illegitimate and what is legitimate. Surely a licensing system for swords would allow the police to determine a legitimate user—someone in one of the categories that you have mentioned—and an illegitimate user of a sword, or a criminal.
Such a system would determine that, and it would determine who was using swords legally, and for a legitimate purpose.
Is that not the purpose of a licensing system?
Sure, that would be the—
What about licensing alcohol? There are legitimate sellers and users of alcohol and illegitimate sellers and users of alcohol. The sale of alcohol requires licensing.
I agree that such a system would recognise those who are using swords legitimately, but I believe that such measures could be all too easily bypassed and that they would be entirely ineffective on the street.
I know what you are saying, convener, but I do not know whether you can compare driving to violent intent.
I am not comparing the two.
I know you are not, but you are making—
I am talking about the principle of licensing; I am not comparing one type of licence to another.
Violent crime is a specific and very separate issue. I know that you do not doubt that, convener. I think that the petitioner is making it clear that the issue is about the intent of the individual, and I take the point that if there were no swords anywhere in Scotland, if somebody wanted to go out and chib or stab somebody, they would find themselves a sharp instrument with which to do so. The issue may be a smokescreen to discuss swords, martial arts, highland dancing and everything else without talking about the individuals affected. Several years ago, I saw somebody brandish an ornamental sword, close to where I live. It was a man in his 40s—not a 16-year-old or 18-year-old. He was just going a bit berserk in the street. It had clearly come from over a fireplace. The issue is about violent intent and individuals who are intent on attacking somebody with a sharp implement. I do not believe that somebody will think, "Oh, there's a ban on swords. That means I cannae stab anybody any more." I think that they will probably find another way of meting out their violence. That is the point.
Yes, exactly.
We require recommendations on the petition.
link
I suggest that we write to the Scottish Executive and ask it about its intentions. There is a bill before the Parliament that does not contain licensing provisions and the consultation has just concluded. It would be helpful if the Executive could set out its thinking on the bill and on the debate that we have had this morning.
Once we get that response, we will be able to determine where the petition stands in relation to the Executive's intentions.
I suggest that we also contact the new violent crime unit at Pitt Street police office in Glasgow. The unit has done a great deal of research on such issues and its input might be interesting.
I do not have an issue with that. If the unit can provide information that would enlighten us, I do not see any reason why we should not contact it and ask whether it would be willing to provide us with some input. Thank you, Mr Macdonald, for bringing your issue before us. We will keep you informed on the progress that is made and the responses that we receive.
Thank you very much for the opportunity.
In this meeting
Everything on 26 Oct 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Wednesday 26 October 2005 Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 72
- New Petitions Petitions · 40
- New Petitions Petitions · 5
- New Petitions Petitions · 9
- New Petitions Petitions · 24
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.