Thank you, convener.
The report looks at the process of establishing the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service; the progress that the organisation is making in reforming how it delivers fire and rescue services; and some of the financial challenges that the organisation faces in future.
I will briefly summarise our findings under three headings: the formation of the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service and its governance arrangements; the costs and savings associated with the merger; and reviewing future service delivery. It is important to note that I have focused on the merger process, rather than the longer-term reform that the fire service is undertaking. I will keep the latter under review and may report on it in future.
Overall, we found that the Scottish Government and the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service managed the merger of the eight former fire and rescue services effectively. The Scottish Government clearly defined the roles, expectations and initial targets for the chair of the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service Board and the chief officer, and eight of the 10 recommendations that we made in our earlier report, “Learning the lessons of public body mergers”, have been implemented or are in progress.
The board is starting to perform well in providing strategic direction for and effective scrutiny of the management of the organisation. It has demonstrated in a variety of ways that it is committed to improving its performance. One important aspect of the new arrangements is the network of 17 local senior officers who are responsible for maintaining links with local authorities. That structure is proving to be effective.
On costs and savings, the financial memorandum to the Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Act 2012 estimated a cost of £39.5 million for the establishment of the Fire and Rescue Service. The actual cost was £35.7 million, which is around 10 per cent lower. Reported savings to date put the service on track to exceed the overall expected £328 million of savings by March 2028 that the financial memorandum anticipated. However, as a result of future cost pressures and likely reductions in public sector budgets, we estimate that it may face a funding gap of £43 million by 2020. The Fire and Rescue Service does not yet have a long-term financial strategy to show how it will close the funding gap. It is now crucial that it agrees a long-term financial strategy by March 2016 that sets out how that will be done.
It is clear that this has been a challenging period for the organisation and its staff, but Her Majesty’s fire service inspectorate in Scotland concluded that there had been no impact on the public across the merger period. The Fire and Rescue Service’s performance is improving, and it is making progress in removing important differences in how the eight predecessor fire and rescue services were managed and operated.
Although the merger was managed effectively, in some respects the hard work of reform is yet to come. The Fire and Rescue Service is conducting a number of reviews to determine how it should deliver a national service in the future and is addressing some of the important differences, on which we have previously reported, in the way that the service was delivered throughout Scotland in the past.
Those reviews aim to ensure that the Fire and Rescue Service’s resources are used as effectively as possible to provide a sustainable service that reflects current and future risks. Ensuring that they are completed promptly and inform the development of a long-term financial strategy is a matter of urgency for the service and a key part of the next phase of the reform process.
As always, convener, my colleagues and I are happy to answer questions from the committee.