I welcome the opportunity to discuss the audit and accountability arrangements for the further devolution of powers following the Smith commission’s recommendations.
As I indicated in my letter of 5 May, it is important that appropriate and robust arrangements are put in place to support the new powers and responsibilities and to allow the Scottish Parliament and its committees to hold to account those who collect or spend public money in Scotland. The committee’s consideration of what those arrangements should look like is as timely as it is important, as we await the publication of the United Kingdom Government’s Scotland bill later this week. More work will be required in the coming months to develop audit and accountability arrangements at the same time as we discuss and develop the detailed proposals to devolve the powers themselves.
Since the publication of the draft clauses, we have been working with the UK Government to ensure that the Scotland bill delivers the substance and the spirit of the Smith commission’s recommendations. We have offered comments across a range of the subjects covered with the aim of developing legislation that the Scottish Government can support. There is, however, some way to go to achieve that. The recent Devolution (Further Powers) Committee report concluded that, although the draft clauses achieved their aim in some cases, in other areas they fell short. Once we see the bill, we will be able to assess how far the UK Government has taken on board the range of comments that have been received since January. We will also have a firmer basis on which to take forward the work to develop the necessary audit and accountability arrangements.
The transfer of powers to be delivered through the Scotland bill will have implications for a range of organisations that will, in the future, be accountable to the Scottish Parliament. The work to put in place appropriate arrangements to reflect that development will need to continue alongside parliamentary consideration of the bill’s proposals, both at Westminster and in this Parliament. The committee’s consideration of those issues and its eventual report will help to ensure that the UK Government and the bodies concerned give the issues the prominence and attention that they deserve.
The Scottish Government’s approach will be to ensure that the audit and reporting arrangements that are put in place enable this Parliament to scrutinise satisfactorily the use of the transferred powers and what is spent on them. We will take a pragmatic view, seeking to build on existing experience of what works well, and that view will be informed by the comments of the committee and Audit Scotland.
It is important that, whatever the specific arrangements are for individual bodies, they are clear, consistent and transparent in terms of responsibilities and reporting. Where bodies have an established relationship with the Government, there will be existing frameworks for accountability and audit. Where it is clear that those arrangements work, we will build on them in a proportionate way that provides efficient and effective accountability while minimising additional burdens. Where new requirements arise, the Government will prepare to ensure that appropriate arrangements are in place to establish effective scrutiny in partnership with the committee.
I am happy to answer any questions that the committee may have.