I have also considered the Basque case, read about it and talked to people about it. It is true that the overall burden of taxation there must be consistent with that in the rest of Spain. VAT is theoretically devolved but, under European rules, it cannot vary so, in effect, it is assigned rather than devolved. Half of it is assigned in the rest of Spain as well.
There is a slightly lower rate of corporation tax. That is more a matter of signalling. It is a headline rate that says that the Basque Country is open for business. I do not know that 1 per cent makes that much difference to investment decisions. It annoys other regions of Spain, but saying that the Basque Country is open for business is part of the objective. There is a slightly higher rate of marginal income tax, so the income tax is more progressive, which is compensated for by the slightly lower corporation tax rate.
Everybody who I talk to says that the detailed allowances are what really matters. Like Scotland, the Basque Country has a big problem of very poor private research and development performance. It has the same industrial structure as us—the old heavy industries that, traditionally, did not invest a lot in research and development—so there is a massive research and development effort that is disproportional to the rest of Spain, and there are a lot of tax credits for research and development.
Taxation policy is also linked to other fields, such as labour market policy and industrial reconversion. Whenever I talk to the Basques about the matter, they tell me that the point is not the headline rates or the overall burden but the detail of how they use the taxation as part of a broader social and economic strategy. It seems to have been fairly successful.
The system is extremely complex because there are four separate authorities: the three Basque provinces plus Navarre. That is for historical reasons that are untouchable. Nobody says that it makes any sense.
I have also talked to businesspeople and the trade unions. The business community likes the idea that the tax authority is close. It is not worried about it and says that it can cope with complexity. It likes the idea that it is in direct dialogue with Government about taxation rather than having to go to Madrid to do things.
The other interesting case is Canada, where there is extensive devolution of taxation. It is not devolution, in fact—it is a federal system so, by right, provinces have extensive income taxes, sales taxes and corporation taxes. The sales tax coexists with a federal value added tax called the goods and services tax. The provinces deal with that in very different ways. In Québec, the authorities have decided to link their sales tax to the federal value added tax; in the other provinces, that has not been done. In Québec, they have decided to de-link their income tax from the federal income tax and to have their own tax regime, whereas the other provinces piggyback on the federal tax regime—people just pay a proportion of their federal taxes to the provincial authorities.
If we look at the details of the possible policy divergence, there is scope for quite a bit of differentiation. Québec is very different from Alberta in its tax structure. Recent evidence suggests that Québec, because of its tax and welfare mix, has been able to resist the tendency to greater social and economic inequality in the rest of Canada. Those might look like marginal differences, but they can make a considerable difference to policy outcomes.