Thank you for giving us the opportunity to talk about the economic statistics that we produce. There are challenges in producing comprehensive economic statistics for Scotland. The national accounts, which my area of responsibility covers, are indicators that describe the Scottish economy—things such as gross domestic product and the flow of goods and services around the economy.
Historically, not many indicators about the Scottish economy were produced. For many years, services and production have been indexed, but it was only post-devolution that people started to bring those things together in a formal GDP measure. Seven years ago, the Scottish national accounts project was established to try to fill in some of the gaps in the national accounts data that are available for Scotland. That has come a long way, although there are still areas for further work.
We now publish a new bulletin that tries to bring together all the different data sources, to tell us a lot more about the Scottish economy. We have a lot more indicators, such as savings ratios and estimates of imports and exports and capital investment in Scotland. We publish detailed information about specific sectors of the economy, such as manufacturing exports and retail sales. Elsewhere in the Scottish Government a lot of information on the labour market is published, as well as statistics on income and poverty and business.
Compared with other parts of the United Kingdom, Scotland is pretty well served with economic statistics. The Scottish national accounts project’s aim was to produce a range of indicators, so that we would have a full set of national accounts for Scotland. By no means are we there yet; there are certainly a lot of gaps.
In a lot of cases it is not straightforward to do this for Scotland. We are not able to collect financial information from firms, because their accounts do not break down their UK operations. It is very difficult for large firms to provide a Scottish figure for their operations. It is a particular problem for trade, because firms do not record statistics in the required way. For example, exports from Scotland to the rest of the UK are particularly challenging to measure, and measuring imports from the rest of the UK to Scotland is even more challenging.
We are continually looking to improve the coverage of economic statistics. It is important to stress that we do not set our priorities by ourselves; we have a lot of engagement with external users. I welcome this engagement to get your thoughts on things that we should prioritise. We are lucky to have an active external user group, which is made up of academics—indeed, it includes some of the witnesses that the committee has had to talk about this subject.
Recently we had a meeting at which we said that we would prioritise improving data on imports to Scotland and on capital investment in Scotland, looking at the links between the offshore and onshore economies and looking at the timeliness of our key outputs, to see whether they can be improved for users.
We are focusing on those things, but it is a long journey. We will always have challenges with the data not being as good as it would be for the UK, because businesses just do not structure their accounts in the necessary way. That is the challenge that we face.