link
We are nice and early, so we have plenty of time to ruthlessly interrogate our witnesses—not that that is the plan; we will be asking you questions based on two fascinating papers.
I open by saying to Jim Cuthbert that his Holtham indexation relative population growth equation caused a lot of chat in the pub last night. A lot of the lads disputed some aspects of the equation and the findings. No doubt we will continue that discussion tonight while watching the football.
I will get straight into the formal proceedings. Our next item of business is to take evidence as part of our inquiry into Scotland’s fiscal framework. I welcome to the meeting Jim Cuthbert of the Jimmy Reid Foundation and John McLaren of Fiscal Affairs Scotland. Members have received papers from both our witnesses, so we move straight to questions from the committee, and I will open.
You have provided details in your papers that answer a lot of the questions that I will ask you but, for the record and for the purposes of discussion, I will ask some of those questions anyway. I say that just in case you wonder whether I have actually read your papers—I can assure you that I have read both papers, but I wish to expand on some of the issues in them.
In your introduction, Dr Cuthbert, you write:
“it is extremely difficult to see how the Smith Commission proposals can be implemented in a fair and equitable way, and without adverse unintended consequences, unless deep-rooted reforms in the constitutional and funding arrangements for Westminster are also implemented.”
You go on to explain yourself in great detail.
Can you talk about the no-detriment principle as you understand it and the impact that you believe it would have on public expenditure in Scotland?
Dr McLaren, once Dr Cuthbert has answered, I am more than happy for you to respond to his comments if you so wish—I will also ask Dr Cuthbert to respond to your comments.