Thank you, convener. I will say a few words to amplify the executive summary of the paper that we provided to the committee.
The what works Scotland initiative is a collaborative venture by the University of Glasgow and the University of Edinburgh, but it is really a network of academic and practitioner partners from across Scotland. Essentially, we are involved in trying to develop, use and understand evidence to make better decisions about public policy development and reform. We are funded by the Economic and Social Research Council and the Scottish Government. Our starting point is the Scottish approach to public policy and, clearly, prevention is at the heart of that.
As we say in the executive summary and as was discussed in the previous evidence session, our view is that although prevention is by no means a new idea, it is now central to the Scottish approach. As we heard earlier, there seems to be a large degree of consensus about the aims and objectives of prevention. The problem is that, when we start to dig into the issue, it starts to get much more complex.
I will not say any more about definitions of preventative spending, as the convener has just talked about them. However, I add that we see prevention as a question or a classic wicked problem. It is hard to pin down a definition of prevention and work out exactly what to do about the problem, as it is understood. The framework of the causality between the nature of the problem and the solution can often be difficult to unpick, and it is situationally specific: it depends on the place, the sector and the time period that we are looking at. That means that there are probably no general silver bullets or single answers to the question, but there is a need to empirically examine as we go along each issue in each realm around a set of general principles.
In our paper, we look at a number of illustrations of evidence from academic sources and grey literature evidence. James Mitchell can talk about them later, if that would help. For my part, I have been quite interested in the economics of prevention; in particular, I have looked at some of the interesting work that NHS Health Scotland has done recently on how prevention could be used to address some health inequality issues. That work suggests that there are cost-effective routes to and ways of reducing inequality but that, as was indicated in previous evidence sessions, it is often hard to find savings, target them, ring fence them and then use them in a preventative way. That is often where the challenge comes from.
In paragraph 1.10 in the executive summary, we stress the need for caution on short-termism. The wicked problem nature of a lot of prevention issues makes it hard to pin down a timetable for outcomes. We think that one of the ways in which we can make progress on prevention is to embed it in the culture and nature of organisations as a process. As someone said previously, changing the mindset to make prevention part of the everyday life of public sector delivery is probably a more compelling way to move forward. That is about how we embed the concept in institutions and in the leadership of those institutions, and how we make prevention part and parcel of the way in which parties such as community planning partners collaborate.
There is an interesting discussion by the New Economics Foundation about the principles of prevention. On the last page of our paper, there are four bullet points from the NEF that highlight the challenges that exist in trying to embed prevention in the system and transition towards a greater use of prevention. That is about trying to measure the benefits, costs and trade-offs of prevention in comparison with standard practice, and trying to better understand the cultural, social, economic and political barriers to prevention. It is about trying to build alliances around prevention, which involves engaging organisations’ leaders, politicians and citizens in a public debate, and trying to stimulate a wider debate about the whole purpose of prevention.
There is a lot more in our paper, but I hope that that gives a flavour of it to get us started.