We move to agenda item 5. We have a written submission from the Scottish Government on the Auditor General for Scotland’s report “NHS in Scotland 2013/14”. Members will recall that, at our meeting on 14 January, we took oral evidence from the Scottish Government on the report and agreed to note the evidence and the report. Having considered the Government’s response, and given that the AGS will report again on NHS performance at the end of the year, I am minded to note the report. What are colleagues’ views on that?
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“NHS in Scotland 2013/14”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Paul Martin Lab 3
- Colin Beattie SNP 2
- Tavish Scott LD 1
- Mary Scanlon Con 1
The record
7 contributionsThat is perfectly fair. However, through you, convener, I might ask the Auditor General and Audit Scotland about consistency. Under the previous item, Colin Beattie made a point about consistency of data and, halfway down the front page of paper 4, which is the Government’s response, we read:
“For simplicity, we have decided that as from April 2015 we will use the term LDP Standards”—
whatever the heck that means—
“to replace HEAT targets and HEAT standards.”
Where is the consistency there? The response goes on to say:
“The former HEAT targets on delayed discharge ... will be covered in the new Integration Indicators”.
That does not say that they will be the same; it says that they will be “covered”.
Convener, you will remember that we used to criticise the Tories for changing the way in which they counted unemployment in the 1980s. This looks like the Government doing exactly that again. It is changing the way in which something is counted and expecting us to follow it. Perhaps you can ask Audit Scotland to stop the Government changing the way in which it counts things, which means that parliamentarians and others cannot keep an eye on what is going on.
I think that, in one of our previous evidence sessions, I established that a standard is a HEAT target that has not been met.
I am content to note the report, but I want to raise two points. First, I am not entirely sure whether the constant referral to a legal requirement comes under the responsibility of Audit Scotland. There is an assumption that there is a legal requirement, yet the patient can do nothing. There is no law that a patient must be given treatment within a certain time, and there is no sanction against a health board if the “legal requirement” has not been met. I would like a bit of clarity on that, although I am not sure that it is Audit Scotland’s responsibility.
Secondly, in recent days, there has been quite a lot in the news about health boards, for obvious reasons. I get a bit fed up with hearing that the solution to delayed discharge—which is also known as bed blocking—and most of the other problems is the integration of health and social care. We have had integration of health and social care in Highland for two years, and NHS Highland has just as many problems as any other health board in Scotland. I say that in the presence of the Auditor General, who is now in the public gallery, because I hope that she will look at the success that we have already had through the integration of health and social care to see whether it really is a panacea to solve all the problems in the future. As a representative of the NHS Highland area, I do not think that it is.
link
I am happy to note the report. However, on the issue of HEAT targets and HEAT standards versus LDP standards, I think that it was this committee that triggered the change by pointing out the confusion arising out of the two figures, although we did not suggest the name. I am not sure what LDP stands for, to be honest.
I am told that it stands for local delivery plan.
link
I think that it is our fault.
Are colleagues content to note the report?
Members indicated agreement.
11:40 Meeting continued in private until 12:16.
In this meeting
Everything on 25 Feb 2015 →- 10:00 Decisions on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
- 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 155
- 11:15 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 9
- 11:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 7
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.