We move to item 4, under which we will consider a response from the Scottish Government to the committee’s “Report on Accident and Emergency—performance update.” There are two areas in which the Scottish Government has committed to come back to the committee with further information. Members have a letter from Audit Scotland confirming that it is preparing an impact report on its previous report, “Accident and Emergency: Performance update”. The impact report will be published after the summer recess, and we will comment on the areas that we have identified in paragraph 38 of our report.
I note from paragraphs 3 and 4 of paper 3 that the Scottish Government will provide further updates, which I would welcome. I find it quite incredible that we have to wait for three months to get a definition of “self-referral”—only one person can self-refer, and that is oneself. I find it slightly odd that we have to wait for three months to get a definition of ourselves, but there we are. I have been around for only just over 60 years, and I look forward to getting a definition of myself so that if I self-refer in future, I will know who has done it. I look forward to getting a definition of “self-referral” in three months’ time.
I also had my sceptical hat on when I read the Government’s response to the committee’s report. It has responded with recommendations that mainly commit to reviews, collaboration, sharing good practice and a lot of other civil service and Government jargon, as well as committing to further updates. I suppose that it is good that we have alerted the Government to some of the issues in accident and emergency that were covered in the media this morning. To be honest, though, I feel that we have been a little bit fobbed off and kicked into the long grass. I seriously await a definition of myself, and I look forward to hearing more accident and emergency updates in three months’ time; I hope that some clarity will be forthcoming at that point.
The area is very much work in progress and the committee has done good work in highlighting some of the issues that the national health service faces. To be fair to the NHS, it has picked up on those issues. Mary Scanlon mentioned specifically the definitions of self-referral and 999 emergency referrals. It is clear from what Paul Gray says that the question is one of consistent interpretation.
We have had that problem with data before. Consistently, over the years, there has been a problem in comparing data in different areas of the NHS. If some consistency and clarity are to be brought to that process, that is a good thing, and I can understand that it will take two or three months to get the changes in place.
The committee is doing its job by focusing on those things and by getting the NHS to focus on them. If we look at the conclusion to paper 3, the fourth bullet point in paragraph 7 might be the way to go. We can get a progress update and recommendations in the next Scottish Government progress report, which will be published in May 2015. That is a reasonable horizon.
I am concerned that there is a risk that, as MSPs, we could end up looking at a lot of detail, which, although we might like that, would be more appropriate for another committee. There is a risk that we might start doing the Health and Sport Committee’s job for it.
We have examined the issues and listed a range of points that need to be looked at. The Government has given us a substantial response to those points. My instinct, wearing my MSP-on-an-audit-committee hat, is that we should leave the Government to work the matter through, and we should ensure that we go back to it on a sensible timescale. If the Government has told us that it will give us certain things in three months, that is fine: let us have those. Otherwise, we should perhaps just refer the issue to the Health and Sport Committee, to the extent that it has not already picked the issue up, and see where that committee wants to go, rather than doing its job for it.
I was not going to say anything, but I so disagree with that. Given that the whole purpose of committees is to be consistent in their pursuit of evidence, and following Colin Beattie’s very fair observations, we should look at the issue again. The Health and Sport Committee will not have a clue about the particular area that we have looked at. It will be looking at a lot of other things and that issue will be just one in a huge amalgamation of vast amounts of other information.
We should do the job that we are paid to do, which is to be consistent about what we look into, and take the three-month report—as Colin Beattie rightly said—so that we keep our eye on the issue, rather than dropping, it as committees normally do.
I appreciate that we have quite a few new members on the committee, but we have had excellent evidence sessions on accident and emergency in the past. Self-referral is a significant issue, given that there have been huge increases in self-referral, and everyone agreed that we need to understand it. Does that increase mean that people cannot get general practitioner appointments? Is something else not working? Why is there such a huge increase in accident and emergency cases?
In order to look forward—and I find the Government looking forward to seven-day working and so on, on which Hugh Henry asked a lot of questions—we need to understand why there has been a significant increase in self-referrals to accident and emergency before more resources are put in.
I am with Tavish Scott on this one: there is nothing here that we need to ignore. We are doing our job correctly and the matter should not be referred back to the Health and Sport Committee, which has more than enough to do. Looking into self-referral is an important part of our work: it was an important part of the evidence sessions and it is a critical part of our audit, because it concerns a complete change in patient behaviour.
I understand the concern about micromanagement. It is not our job to micromanage the NHS, but we have a constructive job to do in pointing out anomalies and in working with the NHS to highlight the issues and help it to take matters forward. Sometimes, it needs a wee bit of focus brought from an external party such as the committee to ensure that that happens, and I think that it is responding. Some of the stuff that is coming back from Paul Gray is fairly positive. Yes, there is civil service jargon in there, but the NHS is moving in the right direction and we have a responsibility to ensure that it keeps doing so.
As a new member of the committee, I am happy to go with the wisdom of members who have followed the issue for longer. I agree that we should proceed in the way that Colin Beattie said, according to bullet point four of paper 3, which suggests that we take a progress report in May.
Okay. We will return to the issue in May, after the Scottish Government’s progress report is published, and we will seek an update on the committee’s recommendations. Is that agreed?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.