Thank you. Section 6 of the Landfill Tax (Scotland) Act 2014 provides a power to prescribe certain landfill site activities. If a prescribed landfill site activity is carried out at a landfill site, the activity is treated as a disposal of waste to landfill at that site. The list of prescribed activities in article 3 of the order relates to temporary engineering activity on a landfill site.
The order has its origin in case law concerning the United Kingdom landfill tax. In a case that Waste Recycling Group brought against Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs in 2008, the English Court of Appeal ruled in favour of Waste Recycling Group and concluded that engineering activities on a landfill site were classed as non-waste disposals to land and, as such, fell outside the UK tax. In response to the ruling, the following year the UK Government introduced the Landfill Tax (Prescribed Landfill Site Activities) Order 2009, to bring temporary engineering works into the scope of the tax.
It is the Scottish Government’s view that all waste material that is deposited at a landfill site should be subject to Scottish landfill tax, unless there is a specific exemption, it is deposited in a non-disposal area, or it is used in the final restoration of the site. Building on the experience of HMRC in that case, the order brings material from temporary engineering works on a landfill site into the scope of the tax. Activities relating to the permanent restoration of a landfill site are not, however, within the scope of the Scottish landfill tax, as we would not want to create any barriers to the full and final remediation of a landfill site.
11:45
A draft order was included in the public consultation paper “Scottish Landfill Tax—A Consultation on Subordinate Legislation”, which was published last June, and 85 per cent of respondents agreed with the proposed order. Ernst and Young LLP and SITA UK Ltd, for example, suggested that mirroring the UK list of prescribed activities would alleviate concerns about the possibility of waste tourism.