The final petition is PE1525, by Catherine Fraser, on access to justice. Members have the clerk’s note and submissions. As I have flagged up before, members will know that Catherine Fraser is a constituent of mine. She approached me in advance of the petition appearing on the agenda.
I was interested in the Scottish Human Rights Commission’s analysis of the petition. To summarise, it said that the denial of legal aid deprives the applicant to present a case fairly, which it refers to as
“an unacceptable inequality of arms”.
The SHRC says that that is a violation of article 6 of the European convention on human rights.
Members will also note that, since 2007, legal aid has been awarded only four times. Internal Scottish award criteria were developed following a test case.
My view—members know of my interest—is that it might be useful to invite the new Cabinet Secretary for Justice to come along and have a discussion, because the issue goes much wider than access to legal aid for defamation; rather, it is about access to legal aid generally. The Law Society of Scotland reflected that in its submission. However, it is important that committee members have their view.
