Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. I have the hardest job: I have to try to make the equivalent of a train timetable exciting to you, so I apologise.
Administrative justice is the foundation of social justice. Without it, we will not have a fair society. It is important that the Government machine is held to account effectively. The ombudsman is, in effect, the public voice to Parliament.
A complainant needs the full facts of a complaint so that he can understand how to make it effectively. Some of our members have not been given the full facts of their cases. Correspondence between the ombudsman and the bodies under jurisdiction has been kept secret, in line with the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman Act 2002.
The problem with the definition of secret is that it seems to be applied in many ways and the ombudsman has a tight grip on it. We need it to be properly defined, so we seek a change in the act to give us a more accurate definition.
The ombudsman has precluded many of our complainants, who have tried to get the correspondence to be able to rebut the arguments that are put by the bodies under jurisdiction. They do not know what the other side is saying. We do not have the advantages of the situation that applies in a court of law, in which both sides of the argument are put.
It is possible to redefine or to properly define what is private. The Welsh manage that by getting the complainant to sign a non-disclosure document when there is information that is sensitive and needs to be kept away from the public. In that way, complainants can defend themselves properly and can see the facts.
We need a wholly transparent system, which we do not have at the moment. We want all the evidence to be available to both sides so that, when the ombudsman makes a decision, the complainant can understand the facts. When the ombudsman does not find in favour of the complainant, time should be taken to give them an explanation. We need understanding. If people do not understand decisions, that causes them huge amounts of stress. We have members who are stressed and who have great difficulty in doing this sort of thing because they feel that they are not heard and are not given effective administrative justice.
The ombudsman has been in power since 2002. No one has independently investigated any of the cases that he has made decisions on for the effectiveness of those decisions and the quality of the justice that he delivers. We need real justice so that we can deliver social justice to the people of Scotland.
