link
I reconvene the meeting, folks, but first of all I give apologies on behalf of Michael McMahon. As convener of the Welfare Reform Committee, he has had to go downstairs to meet a group of people with mental health issues who are coming to his committee next week, and show them the committee room. He will probably join us again in 15 or 20 minutes.
Agenda item 2 is an evidence-taking session on devolved taxes implementation with Eleanor Emberson, who is the head of Revenue Scotland at the Scottish Government; John King, who is the director of registration at Registers of Scotland; and John Kenny, who is the head of national operations at the Scottish Environment Protection Agency. As members have received copies of the most recent progress update from our witnesses, we will go straight to questions. The witnesses are all veterans of the committee, so they know the drill, so to speak.
I will start off with a question for Eleanor Emberson. In your update report, you say that the most recent estimate for the total cost of the set-up and first five years of operation is £21.2 million, but that figure excludes an estimated £730,000 for the costs of the Scottish tax tribunal, which were included in the financial memorandum to the Revenue Scotland and Tax Powers Bill and Revenue Scotland’s previous progress report. Why have those costs been excluded as a quite separate issue, given that they were not excluded before, and why has there been a quite significant 9 per cent increase in the costs of establishing and running the system for the devolved taxes?