Our next section 23 report, on managing early departures from the Scottish public sector, probably has Kenneth Macintosh’s name all over it. We have received evidence from the Scottish Government on the Auditor General’s report. I invite questions and comments from members on the issue. As I named you, Kenneth, we will go straight to you.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Managing early departures from the Scottish public sector”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Mary Scanlon Con 5
- Bruce Crawford SNP 3
- Ken Macintosh Lab 2
The record
10 contributionsI remind members of the evidence that we have taken on the issue. The Auditor General produced a report that flagged up weaknesses in the approach to early departures. In evidence taking, we explored further difficulties with the use of confidentiality or gagging clauses. Initially, we got a rather unsatisfactory response from the head of the civil service, but the Government says that it is going to change its practice and its policy. The difficulty that we have is that the Government said that it had a policy of not using confidentiality clauses in the national health service but we know that not only does it use them, it uses them in virtually every case and the use of such clauses has been growing every year. The worry is whether we have the ability to monitor the commitment not to use them.
From now on, the Government will report on the matter annually to Parliament, and it has expanded the number of bodies on which it will report and will collect the information centrally. That is to be applauded, and I look forward to receiving those reports. The only point that I would make is that, although the Government will report on settlement agreements, it will not report on voluntary redundancy which, as members can imagine, is one of the biggest schemes and one of the biggest costs.
Given what we heard under agenda item 3 about the redundancy programme for senior management at colleges, it is extremely important that Parliament can at least cast an eye over, if not ask further questions about, how much money is being spent on redundancy, because we are talking about huge sums of money—hundreds and hundreds of millions of pounds. The second part of the issue is confidentiality agreements.
We should bear in mind that, although the Scottish Police Authority is covered, Police Scotland is not—in other words, settlement clauses and redundancy payments for police officers are not covered. There have been a couple of cases, which have been widely reported, of officers leaving and being given very generous settlements, and then being re-employed a matter of weeks later. The situation is similar with universities. I am pretty sure that colleges are covered but universities are not. We should bear that in mind.
Otherwise, I am happy to note the submission and delighted that the Government is to report to Parliament.
I agree with you—I think that we have moved forward on the issue. There is now a presumption against the use of confidentiality clauses. It is fair to say that there is more transparency, although whether there is enough is another matter. The Auditor General is in the room, so I am sure that she will have noted what you said about Police Scotland.
I agree that we should note the submission, but Ken Macintosh made some pretty sweeping statements and, without looking at some of the numbers, I am not prepared to accept what he said as far as the health service is concerned. I would need to look at the figures. Because Ken Macintosh says something, that does not make it right.
It was the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing who made the remark in question.
I think that Ken Macintosh was talking about the historical situation. We are moving forward.
But the main point as far as voluntary exit schemes are concerned is that, as is made entirely clear in the letter that we got from the head of the civil service,
“The numbers of staff leaving through voluntary exit schemes and the associated costs are reported in the consolidated annual accounts for each public body. They are ... reported centrally to Parliament.”
Therefore, there is oversight by the Parliament of that aspect.
I remind members that, at the end of our meeting on 5 November, the Auditor General confirmed that she would report back to the committee with further information on the number of settlement agreements and the use of confidentiality clauses in the NHS, along with any concerns raised by local auditors.
I would like to correct the record, because I made a mistake—I missed out the word “not”. I should have said:
“They are not reported centrally to Parliament.”
However, that information is available in the annual accounts.
There is more transparency; whether there is enough transparency is another matter.
Do members agree to note the submission, bearing in mind the fact that we will receive a further report from the Auditor General?
Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 19 Nov 2014 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 10:00 Section 22 Reports Evidence session · 101
- 11:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 40
- 11:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 9
- 11:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 10
- 11:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 4
- 11:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 8
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.