Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Reports

“The 2013/14 audit of North Glasgow College”

Wednesday 19 November 2014 Public Audit Committee About 11:00 Committee business 40 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

40 contributions
Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We move on to item 3. The committee has received a response from Glasgow Kelvin College regarding the Auditor General for Scotland’s report. I invite questions and comments from committee members.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

What I see before me is very disappointing. It seems to be a litany of errors and misjudgments. I draw the committee’s attention to the conclusions on page 1 of the Scott-Moncrieff report, which is annex A in our papers. I will cite some of the individual components:

“The Remuneration Committee had not met for a number of years”.

Reasons are given for that, but they are pretty weak. The remuneration committee should be meeting periodically.

“The Committee received inadequate management support”.

“The Committee was unaware of the SFC guidance”.

The members of the committee are paid to know about that guidance; they are professionals, and they are supposed to be aware of it. The report goes on:

“The College had no severance policy requiring compliance with the SFC guidance.”

Why not?

Comment is made further down the same page, at paragraph 6:

“the governance applied to this agreement was inadequate.”

The chair of the board also chaired the remuneration committee and authorised the payments.

We could go through the report bit by bit and take it apart. Paragraph 45, on page 9, says:

“We have no evidence that any specific HR advice was received by the Committee.”

The whole thing is absolutely shocking. It is hard to know where to start. Who made the decisions on gardening leave? Who decided that that was a good idea? It was never used, so it is clear that it was poorly thought out.

The report by Scott-Moncrieff does not come to any conclusion other than the actual facts, which I suppose is all that it can do, but what is the college doing with it? What is its next step? The situation is completely inadequate and appallingly poor. It is a very bad indicator of how colleges handle such matters.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

North Glasgow College no longer exists; it has merged into Glasgow Kelvin College.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Indeed, but we are looking at a snapshot in time and what happened around it.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Indeed—exactly.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

What happened was certainly not best practice. Matters were poorly executed. The situation has to be investigated further to ensure that there is no recurrence.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you for that. I cannot say that I disagree with anything that you said.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

My concerns are around the governance of the situation. I used to be on a remuneration committee. We met when required and we always ensured that our decisions were reported to the full board and put on the public record. For me, that is one of the big issues.

There are a number of issues around the amount of money that has been paid, the gardening leave and the fact that the college seems not to have complied adequately, as it should have done. There are lessons to be learned there.

The deputy convener is right that North Glasgow College no longer exists, so there is not really anybody who is to blame, but we have to take the lessons from this case and ensure that the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council gets the message out to all the colleges and to other bodies for which it is responsible.

Colin Keir SNP Edinburgh Western
link

My interest is in trying to get an idea of when the board of North Glasgow College knew about the issue and what the role of the non-executive members was in pulling all of this together. For me, the issue going forward is whether people in the college system at present are aware of the rights and responsibilities of non-executive board members in pulling this sort of thing together and ensuring that what happened does not happen again.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I think that you are right. If we were looking for a template for how not to do things, we probably have it in front of us today.

Before looking at how the committee will go forward on the issue, we will hear from Ken Macintosh.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

The report tells us that there was no audit trail for the process. That fact has been flagged up and criticised. However, the remuneration committee gave evidence that it was aware of the settlement and approved it.

For me, the worrying thing is that the Scott-Moncrieff report states that

“The full costs to the College were not ... identified because of confusion ... or misinterpretation of the guidance from the SFC”

and an assumption that the costs would be funded. The college merger process was highly controversial and political and it received quite a lot of scrutiny and attention. I would like to be reassured about what monitoring of the process took place and I would like to know what the relationship was between the SFC and the Government, not just for this merger but for the other college mergers.

I would therefore like to know whether it is possible for us to ask the SFC what it knew about the process. It knew that three colleges were coming together and that, because only one principal would be required, arrangements would have to be made for the other two principals. The question is how much involvement the SFC had, how much notification it was given, and exactly—

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That is a good point, particularly given that, as Colin Beattie said, the remuneration committee was unaware of the SFC guidance.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I think that I am also right in saying that the additional funds that were required led the college into a deficit position, which was very serious.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

That is exactly it. The committee obviously made an assumption, and it clearly felt that it had received an assurance from somebody.

I would also like to put the question to the Scottish Government. How far was it kept in the loop and what notification was it given by the SFC or the colleges about the process?

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Okay. We have gathered thoughts from around the table, and what the Scott-Moncrieff report indicates gives us cause for serious concern. Our options in response are that we can note the report, we can seek further written or oral evidence on the issues raised in the section 22 report from the Government, the SFC or other relevant stakeholders—I am aware that we are looking for assurances—or we can refer the report to the Education and Culture Committee.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I suggest that we need further comment, certainly from the SFC.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Are you talking about oral evidence?

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Maybe we should ask for written evidence. That would allow us to look at what the SFC says and decide whether we should take it further. We might also need to look at some of the other stakeholders. It is a difficulty that the college no longer exists, because otherwise we would call on it to come forward.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Indeed. We should certainly seek comment from the SFC. My concern is that, if North Glasgow College was unaware of the SFC guidance, we need assurances about the new college structure going forward.

Bruce Crawford SNP Stirling
link

I am with Ken Macintosh on the issue. He hit the nail on the head in terms of the specifics regarding North Glasgow College. We certainly need to ask the SFC what it knew about the situation and what guidance was available to the college so that we can see what that looks like. We also need a general assurance from the SFC and the Scottish Government—although it will be difficult for the Government to say what happened in each of the colleges, because they were independent bodies at the time—about what they knew of the two other colleges’ processes.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Okay. Is the committee content—

Bruce Crawford SNP Stirling
link

But I recognise how tough it might be for the Government to get the information.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We are really looking forwards here. As was said, North Glasgow College no longer exists, but we want an assurance that, in future, we will be looking not at the worst of practice but at the best of practice.

Is the committee content that we write to the SFC and the Scottish Government to seek the answers—

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

What would we write to the Scottish Government for?

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It was Bruce Crawford who raised the issue of the Scottish Government.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

Yes, I know. It was both Bruce Crawford and Ken Macintosh, but—

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

The college seemed to assume that it would get funding. I would just like to find out whether the Government had any direct contact and what its involvement was. The assurance is clearly not auditable, so I want the Government to tell us what it knew about the process, whether it was kept informed and how much direct involvement it had.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

I am happy to write to the Government, but I do not really understand what it is that we are writing to ask. Are we writing to ask, “Did you tell somebody, ‘Don’t you worry, we will give you money to pay people off’?”

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Yes. I just want to find out what its involvement was.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

Surely it was the role of the Scottish funding council to manage that. I would have thought that it was the obvious place to write to, but if you think that there is benefit in writing to both the SFC and the Government, we could do that.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Gardening leave was mentioned by Colin Beattie and others. Given that we have a smaller structure of fairly successful merged colleges, it would be nice to get an assurance from the Government that guidance is in place and no one can plead ignorance in future. That is how I am looking at it.

We shall therefore write to the Scottish funding council and the Government to seek assurances on the points that members of the committee have raised today. Is that agreed?

Bruce Crawford SNP Stirling
link

First, I want to ensure that we know exactly what we are doing. On the specifics of the college involved, we need to know what guidance was available and what the Scottish funding council and the Scottish Government knew about it. More generally, in relation to the rest of the college structure, we need to know what the Government knows about what actually happened on the ground as the mergers went through.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

To go back to Colin Beattie’s point, I note that the conclusion of the report was that

“The Remuneration Committee had not met”.

That is not acceptable, as James Dornan said. The report also stated that

“The Committee received inadequate management support,”

which is also not reasonable, and that

“The Committee was unaware of the SFC guidance”.

I do not think that that is an acceptable excuse. Finally, the report found that

“The College had no severance policy requiring compliance with the SFC guidance.”

Moving forward, we want an assurance that those safeguards are in place and that lessons have been learned.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I add a comment based on examples that, although they are not similar to the case in point, raise the same issues of governance and accountability. Putting guidance in place does not guarantee that people will implement or even read it, and we have seen a few examples of that over the years. Ultimately, how can we make the boards of colleges accountable so that we can ensure that they practice and put in place the guidance that is issued to them? We expect them to do it and we hope that they will do it, but how do we make sure that they do it? We would hate to think that something like this could occur again without any line of accountability.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That is a reasonable point and it is something that we can ask the Scottish funding council about. It is unacceptable to say, “The guidance was there, but we didn’t know about it.”

Bruce Crawford SNP Stirling
link

To take up Willie Coffey’s point, we should ask the Scottish Government to explain how the changes that have been made to the college structure will approve accountability. That is the real issue.

Bruce Crawford SNP Stirling
link

Colleges used to be standalone organisations. Now that new arrangements are in place, we need to know how they will make governance better.

Mary Scanlon Con The Deputy Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I am happy to draft a detailed letter covering those points. It will be circulated to the committee to ensure that the issues that members are concerned about are covered. Is that agreed?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Section 22 Reports Evidence session · 101
  3. 11:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 40
  4. 11:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 9
  5. 11:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 10
  6. 11:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 4
  7. 11:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 8

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.