link
Our next item of business is to take evidence on further fiscal devolution. The item will consist of two separate evidence sessions, starting with Professor Anton Muscatelli, who is principal and vice-chancellor of the University of Glasgow. Members have copies of Professor Muscatelli’s written submission.
We will go straight to questions from the committee; I am sure that Professor Muscatelli knows the drill. I will ask the opening questions and then open up the session to colleagues round the table. I emphasise that Professor Muscatelli has made it clear in his paper that he is speaking in a personal capacity and not as the principal of the University of Glasgow.
Professor Muscatelli, you have stated that
“there is no single ‘correct’ answer to the degree of devolution which should be implemented”,
as
“it depends on the balance of public opinion in Scotland.”
You highlight three principles that you say
“could be used to analyse a financial framework”,
and they are
“Equity ... Efficiency and Accountability”.
You go on to discuss
“major differences in political preferences and social attitudes”
and the
“vertically imbalanced fiscal systems amongst the OECD economies”,
of which the United Kingdom is one of the most obvious examples.
Let us look at some of the powers that could or should be devolved. One that you mention is income tax. You say that
“income taxation devolution presents the least difficulties”,
and that
“Further ... control over tax bands and thresholds would be a further evolution of the current system.”
Why would partial devolution of income tax be suboptimal, and complete income tax devolution optimal?
