There are three issues here. The first concerns what economists call the economic rent that is derived from North Sea oil, which is possibly captured by taxes other than corporation tax. Secondly, there is corporation tax on North Sea oil. Thirdly, there is the rest of corporation tax.
From my note, members will have noticed that I am an avid disciple of Adam Smith, and I am honoured to be speaking a quarter of a mile from Panmure house, where he wrote “The Wealth of Nations”. I am pleased that the Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth feels that it is right to start from Adam Smith’s principles. Smith argues that rents are the most appropriate subject for taxation—in a modern context, I would say taxation at a devolved level. The pure principle of tax policy, as laid out by Adam Smith and his successors, especially David Ricardo, leads me to suggest that rents from the North Sea should be the next tax base that the Parliament should control.
There are three easy reasons why I say that, within a continuing union, corporation tax should not be devolved: Amazon, Starbucks and Google. All members will have seen the performance of representatives of those companies before the Westminster Public Accounts Committee. Given an opportunity to avoid tax, multinational corporations will do so. Given that that is the case, if a Parliament such as this one—I know that Northern Ireland is asking for the same power—were to take control of corporation tax levels, there might be some gain in terms of the revenue that is received by this Parliament but, as sure as eggs are eggs, there would be a loss to the revenue that is received from corporation tax in the UK. As my note says, I therefore do not think that, within a continuing union, corporation tax should in general be devolved.
Corporation tax on North Sea operations is a slightly different matter, because North Sea oil is where it is—you cannot pretend that it is in Luxembourg. Therefore, devolving the whole of North Sea tax is perfectly feasible, as well as being desirable on the grounds that Adam Smith set out.