Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Waste (Scotland) Regulations 2005 (Draft)

Wednesday 12 January 2005 Environment and Rural Development Committee Subordinate legislation 30 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

30 contributions
Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

We have more subordinate legislation on our agenda. We are now considering the draft Waste (Scotland) Regulations 2005. Parliament must approve the draft instrument before it can formally be made, so we have before us a motion, in the name of Ross Finnie, inviting the committee to recommend to the Parliament that the instrument be approved. The minister will move that motion for us. The Subordinate Legislation Committee has considered the instrument and made no comment. Before we come to the debate on the motion, it is our usual practice to allow members to ask for points of clarification or to ask questions about the instrument and how it will be put into effect, while we have officials at the table. Once we move on to the formal debate, we will not be able to ask the officials questions. I ask the minister to introduce the officials and to make any opening remarks. I shall then move on to points of clarification or questions from members before we have the general debate. I know that one or two members have points that they want to raise.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

Barry McCaffrey put his finger on the relevant subparagraph of that previous instrument so quickly that it seemed prudent to retain him. I am also joined by Charles Stewart Roper from the waste side of the Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department, who is much more familiar with the detail of the regulations. The draft regulations complete the process of extending the protections afforded by waste regulation to all forms of farm waste and non-mineral waste from mines and quarries. It seems entirely appropriate that the controlled waste regime be extended to cover those industries, as it does all other industrial sectors. We can all think of examples of waste from those industries that is environmentally dangerous as well as being a blight on our local amenity. However, there has been a big change for those affected, and the regulations make use of flexibility and European Community and Scots law to ease their transition. As an example, I draw the committee's attention to the fact that it will still be permitted for farmers to burn non-hazardous waste in drum incinerators, under exemption. I know that there has been some speculation about that in the press and elsewhere, but there is no point in our banning a practice outright when there is no reasonable alternative, and we are not doing so. I welcome the assistance given by NFU Scotland, the Scottish Rural Property and Business Association and the Crofters Commission, which have helped in considering the many drafts of the regulations on behalf of land-based industries. Extending the ambit of the controlled waste regime is not the only effect of the regulations. They address other aspects in which Scotland's practice falls below the best standards. For example, the draft regulations firm up the duty on householders to take care of how they dispose of their waste. They should ensure that they deal with their waste in a manner that does not cause harm to the environment or to human health, and should transfer waste only to proper persons. In most conceivable circumstances, that will mean the local authority. It might surprise some people to learn that householders are not already under such duties, and it is very much in keeping with our domestic drive against fly-tipping that such duties should be established, especially as much of what is fly-tipped in Scotland is household waste. There is no excuse for that. The other major change that the draft regulations introduce will extend the separate regime for the protection of groundwater, hitherto provided in the Waste Management Licensing Regulations 1994, as amended. A systematic regime for dealing with threats to groundwater was established in the Groundwater Regulations 1998. There is no point in operating two separate systems.On the effect of the draft regulations on various interested parties, I have mentioned that coming under the controlled waste regime will be a big change for farmers and mine and quarry operators. On the other hand, the change has already been made in relation to the burial and incineration of waste and in relation to hazardous waste. The outstanding changes will have relatively little effect. As I said, we are making the transition as easy as possible.Local authorities have a major role to play in dealing with waste. The duties that we are placing on householders will encourage them to use the services that councils have a statutory duty to provide. Making agricultural waste into commercial waste will mean that farmers can strike a price with councils to remove their waste. That price must be reasonable for both parties. Provided that the waste is properly segregated—that is desirable in itself—councils should experience no adverse impact on their landfill allowances.Our firm belief that the draft regulations will have relatively few financial implications is supported by the regulatory impact assessment that we commissioned from the independent consultants ERM. ERM says that our proposal will meet the requirements of the waste framework directive"at a relatively low cost to the Executive, the regulator (SEPA) and the business sectors affected. It will also minimise potential costs to human health and the environment caused by waste management."If approved, the draft regulations will make the relatively few outstanding changes that are necessary to complete the process of bringing Scotland's waste regime up to the best European standards. In England and Wales, the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs published a consultation paper on 9 December 2004, which kicked off for those two countries the same process that we are completing. That is a tribute to the emphasis that the committee and the Scottish Parliament have given to handling waste.I am happy to take questions.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

First, I apologise that I will have to leave the meeting in a few minutes.I will ask the minister about the definition of waste and what is classified as exempt. Farmers have brought it to my attention that contracts are in place whereby some farmers recycle paper crumble from a local paper-mill by mixing it with manure on their fields, but that the waste exemptions cover only waste from paper-mills that is from virgin paper, rather than recycled paper. The regulations will—ironically—hit those farmers because they recycle recycled products, which means that the waste is classified as commercial rather than exempt. How do we influence what is classified as waste? How is waste defined?I will also ask about the wider issue of definitions, given the recent case involving Scottish Water's recycling of sewage sludge pellets for use at Longannet. The minister will be aware that regulations are preventing that, which is causing serious problems because half the sewage sludge that is created in Scotland goes to Longannet.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

Those are two entirely separate questions. The definitions of waste give rise to interpretation difficulties. In general, if anything that is designated as waste is not changed from being waste by a subsequent process, its next use must comply with the regulations.

Charles Stewart Roper Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department
link

We are obliged to use the European definition of waste, which is founded on the question whether something has been disposed of by some agent. The courts ultimately decide the detail of the definition of waste; whether a substance is waste is a judgment for them.To be precise, the issue of exemptions—particularly for paper crumble—relates not to the draft regulations, but to the last set of amendments that were made to the Waste Management Licensing Regulations 1994, which altered many exemptions. Paper crumble that comes from a recycling process involves an environmental risk, because it may be contaminated. That might not be true in any particular instance, but a general risk exists. The judgment is that that risk is significant enough to push that substance out of what can legitimately be spread on land under an exemption. In itself, that does not stop the activity because there are regulatory routes through licensing to accommodate it. The judgment is merely that the practice has sufficient risk to make it not legitimate to include it in the list of exemptions.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

The second issue is slightly different, because it does not depend wholly on the definition of waste. Lord Reed's judgment has several elements to it. Scottish Power's principal case, which was that the residue was less harmful than had been argued by the Executive and SEPA, was not upheld by Lord Reed. He found that the waste that is used in the process as it currently operates was sufficiently hazardous for it not to be given an exemption.A second complicating factor in that case is that there are processes that are capable of dealing with sewage sludge in a way that would not fall within the mischief of the regulations. I must be careful in what I say but—as I understand it—in Scottish Power's opinion the difficulty is that the investment required to get its process to meet the standard would not be justifiable, given its view of the general condition of the Longannet plant. That is a commercial decision for Scottish Power, but the company cannot say that it is not possible to have a system that would allow it to meet the regulations. I agree that Lord Reed's decision makes difficult the question of how Scottish Water is to deal with sewage sludge, but there are a variety of land uses for it. I have been more relaxed about saying that since our introduction of more stringent regulation of handling sewage sludge. The fact that we have a stricter regulatory regime means that we have ample scope for sludge to be dealt with. In the longer term, I hope that someone will recognise the potential benefit of investing in the kind of energy production that takes place at Longannet. We must accept that Lord Reed's judgment was pretty clear. Scottish Power's case—that the waste that was used in that process was not so hazardous that it could not be granted an exemption—was not upheld in court. It is not for me to second-guess the courts.

Maureen Macmillan Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Will you clarify the impact that the amended regulations will have on householders? What will be allowed and what will not be allowed by way of waste disposal within householders' curtilage? How will that be monitored? Will householders be informed about the new regulations?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

I presume that the regulations will apply to every householder in Scotland, because you said in your opening remarks that they would firm up the duty on us as individual householders.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

That is right, but although householders will not be able to treat, keep or dispose of controlled waste in a manner that is likely to cause pollution, we do not believe that that obligation will necessarily be burdensome.Maureen Macmillan made the point that we should co-ordinate our activity with that of local authorities to ensure that householders are aware of the new regulations. If the main way in which householders treat, keep or dispose of waste is through their local authority, it does not seem that they will be at significant risk. However, the committee and I know that there are many people who seek to dispose of waste in ways that do not involve their local authority.However, some householders may believe that it is open to them to choose how to dispose of waste, and for them to do that would breach the regulations. We also have European obligations. At the end of the day, the regulations will not make much difference to the ordinary citizen because the vast majority of people deal with waste perfectly properly. However, as we all know, a number of citizens do not do so; we must bring them into line and ensure that they dispose of waste through their local authorities and in a way that does not breach the regulations.

Maureen Macmillan Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Householders might burn rubbish at the bottom of their gardens, not realising that they are doing something that is outside the law. There is room for confusion about what people can and cannot do.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

You have rightly put your finger on the essential remedy to that problem, which is the dissemination of information from the Executive to local authorities and from them to ordinary householders. There have always been inspection regimes and local environmental officers. We hope that a combination of those regimes and the work to clarify to ordinary householders their obligations will reduce significantly the small number of incidents that give rise to serious environmental damage in communities.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

The regulatory impact assessment had three options. You have chosen the second. You rightly rejected the third option, which was a complete revision of the waste regulations, but is there potential to revise the regulations in the future? If so, at what point will that be done?

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

I always see such potential. I share the general view that Mark Ruskell articulated in his first question on the first instrument that we considered today. When we have regulations we should try to get people to comply with them in the first instance and then assess how effective they are and ask whether we can raise the bar. The major reason for the present regulations is that, although only two industries were not controlled by the previous regime, their impact could, if not regulated, be damaging. We must assess how effective the waste management regime is and, on the basis of that assessment, perhaps seek to raise the bar. I do not disagree with Mark Ruskell that we must constantly try to improve, but we must do so in a way that brings people on side. We can regulate until we are blue in the face, but if we have hostile users, all we will get is people who seek to avoid following the law. We need to establish standards and to demonstrate what improvements have taken place. Assessment is required—we will continue to do that.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

My point is not really about raising the bar, but about looking for a win-win situation. The impact assessment states that, in the long run, complete revision of the regulations would reduce costs to businesses. Clearly, if we want businesses to recycle more, reducing costs is a good way forward. The question is about how we move the system forward. The minister has a latent interest in zero waste and, at some point, we will need to consider the regulations in order to reduce costs for businesses and increase our recycling, reuse and reduction. I am interested to hear more about that.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

To be honest, I do not have a specific timescale, but we are moving towards a position of constant review. In the past, we tended to pass regulations and say, "That's okay. We've done that; tick the box." The department and I are genuinely concerned about measuring outcomes; we are not just interested in regulation, which was how we worked in the past. Now that we have regulation, we are much more concerned about measuring the outcomes. The further we go down that road, the more we will become aware of the need for further changes to regulations.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Why do the courts, rather than the Scottish Executive or you as a minister, decide what is acceptable for various categories of waste? That is more of a philosophical question. I note that some of the definitions are quite politically charged and, as Charles Stewart Roper outlined earlier, they certainly have financial implications. Do you think that it is correct for the courts to decide what is regarded as waste, rather than the Scottish Executive?

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

As Barry McCaffrey said earlier, we always try to get a definition that will define the Scottish position and at the same time comply with European regulations, but occasionally we are driven in our interpretation of such a regulation by the need to be quite clear that we keep within its ambit as laid down in the directive.

Barry McCaffrey
link

What is considered to be waste is very much driven by the waste framework directive, which starts off broadly by stating that waste is anything that it is intended will be discarded. For a number of years, the European Court of Justice has had to interpret that case by case and to decide whether something is being discarded as waste. It takes into account a range of circumstances, including the potential of the material to harm the environment. The classic example in the domestic context is Lord Reed's having to grapple with the circumstances in which dried sewage sludge was disposed of at Longannet; in that case, he had to consider all the circumstances. The key factor is whether the matter that is being discarded can harm the environment.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

A European issue on which we are trying to take a view—we will continue to try—is the extent to which improved recovery techniques allow us to reconsider criteria for assessing whether material that has properly been defined as waste, but is processed, can be removed from the ambit of the waste regulations. There have been substantial technical improvements with which I am not sure the legislation has caught up. Perversely, if we continue to describe such material as waste and therefore require a licence to use the end product, that might militate against our having more techniques for reuse and recycling. That must be considered at European level.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

That is what my question was about. The environment is changing, given the options that might be available. We do not want to discourage technical ways of dealing with waste if they have wider environmental or social benefits. It is difficult to trade those things off, but we have to join the dots between different policies on recycling and waste management rather than have a narrow definition. Such a definition might strictly be correct in relation to what was desired when it was drafted, but we might now have a different view.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

Absolutely—my department is pursuing that. I have a simple example that we resolved because there was a slight error in the information. There is a plant in Scotland that burns chicken litter for energy. One of its by-products is residue that is left after the heat treatment, which can be used as a fertiliser. That has been analysed and checked and there is nothing wrong with it, but it falls within the definition that the convener mentioned, so it is necessary—the material

having been designated as waste—to find a way out of its being so designated. If that is not done, the fertiliser would continue to be regarded as waste and no one could apply it to the land unless they had a waste licence. In this case, we found a way out, but it is an area of the law that requires examination. I do not want anything to stand in the way of reuse and recycling of materials.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

That was helpful. We have had all our questions clarified—

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I still have a short question in relation to option 2, which mentions small additional costs for businesses to comply. Will SEPA have any costs that have not been mentioned so far?

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

From the information that we have, our general view is that the impact of the regulations will be to bring other bodies within their scope and that they will cover minor mineral wastes. We have consulted those bodies and do not think that the regulations will impose a burden on them that they are unable to manage. In some senses, consolidated regulation is helpful to such bodies because it means that they know what is brought within the mischief of the regulations. Having total coverage across the piece will be helpful, but there will be instances in which they will have to implement the regulations. However, we do not think that the regulations will have anything other than a fairly neutral effect.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I have a separate and small question on the previous subject, although I do not necessarily want to take up the committee's time at the moment. Richard Lochhead mentioned paper crumble from recycled paper. Can the minister come back to us in writing about whether an exemption could be extended to that area, or tell us how that would happen? It would be interesting to know that in the context of the minister's answer to the convener's question.

Motion moved,

That the Environment and Rural Development Committee recommends that the draft Waste (Scotland) Regulations 2005 be approved.—Ross Finnie.

Motion agreed to.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

I thank the minister and his officials.

  1. Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 12 January 2005 Committee business · 2
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 54
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 11
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 30
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.