I call the meeting to order and welcome members of the public—although I am not sure that we have any this morning—members of the press, colleagues and the Minister for Environment and Rural Development and his officials. We have two instruments to consider under the negative procedure: the Common Agricultural Policy Schemes (Cross-Compliance) (Scotland) Regulations 2004 and the Environmental Information (Scotland) Regulations 2004. The Subordinate Legislation Committee has considered both instruments and a copy of an extract from its report has been circulated, which comments briefly on only the environmental information regulations.We agreed to take evidence from the minister on instruments implementing reform of the common agricultural policy in Scotland when the first set of such instruments were before us. I am pleased that we have the minister here today. Given that the environmental information regulations relate significantly to the freedom of information regime, which came into force on 1 January, the minister has also agreed to give evidence on those regulations. Two fairly substantial pieces of work are therefore before us. I intend to take consideration of the CAP instrument first; we will have a debate on it to allow members to comment on it or ask questions about it. Once we have dealt with that, we will move on to the environmental regulations. It was remiss of me not to remind everybody to switch off their mobile phones.`
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Common Agricultural Policy Schemes (Cross-Compliance) (Scotland) Regulations 2004 (SSI 2004/518)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ross Finnie LD 15
- Linda Rosborough Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department 7
- Mark Ruskell Green 7
- Sarah Boyack Lab 6
- Maureen Macmillan Lab 6
- Alex Johnstone Con 4
- Roy McLachlan Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department 2
- Richard Lochhead SNP 2
- Rob Gibson SNP 2
The record
54 contributionsGood morning. As the convener has indicated, the new system of farm support started just over a week ago. The new system gives us an opportunity to develop a more competitive and sustainable agricultural industry in Scotland in line with the agricultural strategy. Implementing the new system has been and is a substantial task. The paper that we sent to you before Christmas on implementing the CAP reforms in Scotland set that out and showed you the process for clarifying and creating the new system.It has been challenging because, regrettably, one or two quite important late changes have emerged from Brussels, over which we have no control. Clearly, it would have been highly desirable for all the instruments to have come to the committee before 1 January. I am afraid that, for technical reasons, which we can elaborate on if you wish, that has simply not proved possible. Notwithstanding that, we have worked very closely with all the stakeholder groups, including environmental organisations and producer groups, on how the details should be applied in Scotland. We have worked hard to keep those stakeholder groups and end users—farmers and crofters—involved and informed. We have held several well-attended meetings throughout Scotland in developing and finalising the regulations. There will be a series of regulations, the first set of which is before you now. The Common Agricultural Policy Schemes (Cross-Compliance) (Scotland) Regulations 2004 were laid before the Parliament at the beginning of December. They implement the Scottish framework for cross-compliance and the standards of good agricultural and environmental condition. They will be followed by regulations on the beef national envelope, on the single farm payment scheme and on the appeals mechanism. There will also need to be a United Kingdom statutory instrument on the integrated administration and control system—IACS—to cover matters that must be designated not at the discretion of the European Union at a regional level, but at a member-state level. I take this opportunity to make it clear that the new system provides a subsidy in return for farmers meeting environmental and agricultural standards. In my opinion, it is right that there should be increased accountability for that money. I want there to be far greater disclosure information about all farm subsidies under the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002. I would be happy to proceed to any questions that the committee may have in relation to the instrument before you.
I wish to ask you about wetlands. We received a letter from you saying that they were now to be included in the register of protected areas. While the Water Environment and Water Services (Scotland) Bill was being considered, we discussed how we might help farmers to let their land revert to wetland in cases where it had been reclaimed and used for grazing. As I was driving down to Edinburgh on Monday, looking at the flooding by the Tay, I wondered whether we ought to be thinking about this more. Is there anything in the cross-compliance regulations to encourage farmers to convert their land to wetland or let their land revert to wetland where it had been wetland historically?
There are two elements to that. I will deal with the first, and Roy McLachlan will elaborate on the second. You will be aware that the legislation that we passed nearly two years ago, the Water Environment and Water Services (Scotland) Act 2003, transposed the water framework directive into Scots law. Having got that legislative base, we are still developing a number of areas. There is the whole question of river basin management and flood plain management, if we take wetlands in their widest sense. We are still working towards the implementation of that. I will ask Roy McLachlan to address the specific question about wetlands. During your journey south, you noticed, as have we all in recent years, the fact that too many of our flood plains have been built on. We need to do something to restore the situation, which has forestry and agricultural implications. I invite Roy to discuss how specifically the cross-compliance regulations apply to that.
Under the cross-compliance regulations, farmers may allow land to revert for environmental benefit, provided that they notify us in advance that they are doing so. The one caveat is that the land has to be able to be returned to agriculture in future, if that is the desired policy at the time. In addition, and outwith the cross-compliance regulations, we have agri-environment schemes—notably the rural stewardship scheme—in which farmers receive an annual payment per hectare for allowing lands to revert to being wetlands.
So encouragement comes from the agri-environment schemes rather than from the cross-compliance regulations. The regulations seem to be neutral—people can do things if they want to, but there is no encouragement.
There is, because farmers will not receive their single farm payment if they do not comply. That seems pretty fundamental.
No, because they would get their payment if they had a meadow beside a river and kept it as grazing land.
No, I really have to emphasise this point. The inspection regime will ensure that people meet all the requirements of cross-compliance. Meeting those requirements is the fundamental precondition for receiving the single farm payment. It will not be good enough simply to say, "I've got my farm and this is the way I've always kept it." People will have to meet all the cross-compliance requirements that are set out in the regulations before the committee.
I understand that. However, the grazing lands next to the River Tay are farmed not as wetlands but as ordinary fields. Perhaps it would be better environmentally if those lands were to become wetlands, but the regulations do not encourage that.
All right—but one would love every measure to do everything. As Roy McLachlan has explained, we can assist through the agri-environment programmes, if not specifically through the regulations.
That is what I wanted to have you clarify.
Environmental gain through the creation of wetland grazing areas is covered in the advisory guidelines as an example of good practice within the overall cross-compliance measures. The guidelines are therefore not simply neutral; they are more positive.
Thank you. That is what I wanted to know.
I think that we have teased out the answer to that question.
I want to start by saying to the minister that, having read through the regulations, I find nothing that I would not consider to be good agricultural practice. It is therefore reasonable to expect the farming community to pursue the measures. The regulations will alleviate the fears that some people had—that the conditions would be so onerous as to make farming practice difficult.I want to ask about the enforcing or, if you like, the policing of these regulations. Will it be necessary to expand significantly the manpower of the Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department? Will the enforcing and policing of the regulations have cost implications?
We certainly hope not but, before elaborating, I want to say that it is always good to have the warm and full support of a dairy farmer for any agricultural measures.We are trying to co-ordinate the inspection regime across all the regulations. The department has spent quite a bit of time ensuring that we do not have multiple visits to farm premises. Over a reasonable time span, we want to ensure that we are able to visit a range of farms. We will be considering how to programme that.We hope that not less than 5 per cent of those in receipt of the single farm payment will be subject to cross-compliance inspections, failure in which could lead to penalties. The question would then arise whether people had simply failed to comply, or whether they had deliberately failed to comply. If we believe that someone is simply deliberately ignoring the regulations, they will be brought within the penalty regime.
I assume from that answer that there will be a degree of flexibility in cases in which a farmer has difficulty in conforming to the regulations. I assume that in such cases the first course of action would not be to remove the entitlement to support, but to retain the entitlement and give the farmer the facility to comply subsequently.
The difficulty with all regulations, not just agricultural ones, is that there is always a subjective element. We have gone to some lengths to train and prepare our agricultural staff and we will continue to do so to try to ensure that we apply the regulations uniformly across the piece, which we are conscious is required. We do not want to be accused of using subjective judgment in the application of the regulations, although there will inevitably be an element of that.There are two types of cases. In cases of negligence, the farm payments may be reduced by 3 per cent, but in cases of simple non-compliance more substantial reductions may be made. The system contains a clear penalty element.
My next question is on a slightly different tack, but it is still on the subject of enforcement and policing. Since we joined the European Union and became involved with the common agricultural policy, accusations have been made periodically that regulations have been enforced more strictly and with more impact in the United Kingdom than they have been in other European countries. Those accusations were sometimes true and sometimes not. How can we ensure that the present regulations will not be imposed in Scotland in a way that will impose an economic disadvantage on farmers in comparison to their competitors in other European countries?
As you say, there is an anecdotal perception that we have applied the agricultural subsidy regime more stringently than other countries have. You will recall that, in 2000, we set up a little group of people from the agriculture sector to investigate and examine the way in which we applied the regime but, much to the group's astonishment, it had to conclude that we were not over-egging the regulations.I assure you that we seek to interpret and implement the new scheme as fairly as possible. However, we are conscious that substantial sums of public money are being expended through the single farm payment and that the public are entitled to expect compliance with the regulations that are before the committee. That is an important element. In my discussions with the industry, I have made it clear how important it is that both the letter and the spirit of the cross-compliance regulations are adhered to.
Will the so-called level playing field continue to be monitored on a Europe-wide basis?
We will continue to ensure that we do so but, as I say, we have gone to great lengths internally to ensure that the regime is not disruptive, particularly given that inspection continues to be a key element in the enforcement of the regime. We intend to co-ordinate the requirements for inspection in a way that will not lead to multiple farm visits, which are the most disruptive aspect of the regime for the economic progress of individual farms.
link
I welcome the regulations, but I have a question about monitoring and review. The regulations will establish a baseline from which we can, I hope, go on to improve the condition of our agricultural environment over time. On some aspects, particularly soils, we have a long way to go to meet best practice and to show substantial improvement. I want to quiz the minister a bit more on that. How will the Executive review the conditions and monitor them over time? How might we go beyond what is proposed and set more stringent standards as conditions improve over the years and decades ahead?
Mark Ruskell's question contains two separate elements, which I want to separate out into what might loosely be called issues concerning the management of the land—such as the different ways in which we monitor things such as soil condition and quality across the piece—and the way in which those issues interface with the regulations that are before us today. We must remember that it is not entirely at our hand to change the level and range of the standards that apply under the common agricultural policy instrument. On the other hand, that does not prevent the Scottish Executive from having a general land environment policy or from seeking to use other instruments to achieve that policy. The issue is how we mesh those two things together.I am conscious of the point that has been made. It is all very well to specify what constitutes a good agricultural standard today, but surely we must have an aspiration about where we want to be tomorrow. I am sympathetic to that view. However, I must inform the committee that the standards that are set under the regulations are required to reflect those that are given in the directive.
As well as the need for equity in the application of the directive across Europe, a consideration is that setting the threshold too high could ultimately mean that we suffer disallowance if we fail to meet the standard that has been set. As the money is European money, we are required to have discussions with European auditors. They have been surprised at the standards that we have set on good agricultural and environmental condition. They felt that we have set ourselves a challenging task. Such issues also need to be taken into account.
We will stop at that point because we are experiencing some technical difficulties. As members may have noticed, the microphones have not always switched on for the correct speaker. I understand that we need to suspend the meeting for a couple of minutes to reboot the system.
Meeting suspended.
On resuming—
Before we were interrupted, Linda Rosborough had just answered a question that Mark Ruskell had asked. He wants to pursue the topic further.
link
I hope that you can hear me a bit better now.Clearly, there is an issue about improving environmental conditions across Europe. There will be some variation. For example, it has been said that the English standards are a lot higher than those of other countries. I am a great believer in progress and I think that the point is to effect change that will result in improving environmental conditions across Europe. How will you monitor progress in Scotland and feed that into the process of moving the baseline? If progress is not being monitored and reviewed, how can we ensure that the whole of Europe, including Scotland, makes progress on improving the condition of soil, wetlands and so on?
There is a requirement to assess the impact of the system in the new framework for the single farm payment scheme. In the past, that was not normal practice for pillar 1 schemes. That requirement will be replicated in other European countries, and the impact of the scheme will be measured in that way.
link
How will that monitoring be effected in Scotland?
Our analysts will work out a programme of monitoring but they have not started doing that yet.
link
Will that feed into an eventual review?
We are required by Europe to analyse the impact of the programme that we are implementing, which will then feed into European consideration of the impact of the programme.
link
Is there a timescale for that?
No.
link
Clearly the requirement to keep land in "good agricultural and environmental condition" is meant to ensure compliance with various European directives. Does it ensure compliance with the water framework directive?
The GAEC requirements do not do that. Perhaps Roy McLachlan can help with that question.
That is not one of the 18 regulations that are within the statutory management requirements for cross-compliance.
link
Will it become one of the regulations that will ensure compliance?
It is more likely that there will be regulations to take further the water framework directive. Among other things, we are working on what other regulations are required. We have the framework, because we have passed the 2003 act and we have done a lot of work with the Scottish Environment Protection Agency and others to analyse river basins and get a better idea of the base level, catchments and characteristics. You will be familiar with all of that. The next element of our work will be to decide whether we need powers to ensure that the landowners and managers who are within those catchments are doing what is required to meet and raise the standard. The next trick will be to ensure that we do not end up with silos. We need a lot of cross-fertilisation, which leads us to consider the crossover between forest management and, for example, water-basin management or land management. We are conscious of that but we are still at the stage of trying to work that up. When that comes forward, we would like to think that—Interruption. It sounds like an alien species has just landed in the room. We would like to think that we could co-ordinate that in a way that brings the desired effect.
At some point, we will get feedback on where we fit with the rest of Europe in relation to how the scheme is impacting on the wider environment. That picks up on the point that Alex Johnstone made about whether we are going too far and on Mark Ruskell's point about whether we are going far enough—I am sorry for broadly paraphrasing everybody's views. It will be useful for us to get a sense of the overall achievements that are likely across Europe.
I was interested in the minister's reference to a female being an alien species. Alex Johnstone has asked about many of the points that I was going to raise. I would like more information on the inspections. Given that farmers will have to adhere to many regulations, can you say how many times each farm will be inspected and by whom? Will a plethora of organisations be involved or will the inspections be co-ordinated so that only one body looks after them?
SEERAD is the principal inspector in relation to any regulations that we enact. As I have made clear, we are trying to ensure that there is a single inspection, something that is helped by the fact that fewer schemes are now in operation. Under the regulatory regimes that are swept up in these regulations, there are elements that are still the responsibility of SEPA and SNH. However, especially because the total number of agricultural schemes has been reduced, we believe that the number of farm inspections will be reduced. Of course, as there are 20,000 or so farms to be inspected, we will still have a substantial burden of inspection to carry out. As I indicated in my answer to Alex Johnstone, we are anxious that multiple inspections do not take place on a repetitive basis. However, we still have to be absolutely sure that we cover a good sample across the board each year. It is important that the regulations are adhered to.
Has there been any analysis of whether farmers will have to do less paperwork for cross-compliance than they had to do for the previous CAP schemes?
On aggregate, it is almost as if there must be less. Not so much on the cereal side perhaps, but on the livestock side, which makes up 48 per cent of Scotland's output and where five or six schemes are being replaced by the single farm payment, it is inevitable that the number of forms that have to be filled out will be reduced. There will be one single farm payment form to complete, and I hope that we will move towards improving our ability to accept such forms online. We will continue to reduce the level of form filling per se and increase the ease by which that can be done. A substantial number of farmers will have far less form filling to do.
I welcome the minister's comments about the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 and the money that farms receive as subsidies. In the past, there has been difficulty in accessing that information because we have been told that EU regulations made it impossible to divulge certain information. Has that now changed? At what intervals will we be told about the payments to farms? Can the minister confirm that the subsidies contained in a single farm payment could be more than £1 million and that such a payment may be made to one farm?
Several questions are raised in that. First, the historic position was that, under certain European regulations, information was almost equivalent to some of the information under the Data Protection Act 1998, so we were unable to release it. Secondly, the position has now altered, and we are not inhibited in our ability to implement in full the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 in the same way. That said, I caution that, although the 2002 act allows for retrospective inspection, we are not entirely clear on the matter, because of the way in which the regulations are worded—indeed, our lawyers are wrestling with that problem. Although the relevant European regulation has been changed, we are not entirely convinced whether the effect is retrospective. Notwithstanding the fact that the 2002 act has only just been implemented, it is possible to go back in time with an FOI request, and to look into things such as payments. I am prepared to comply with requests about frequency and regularity. I hope that, by the tone and tenor of his remarks, Mr Gibson is not suggesting that it is a bad thing per se that Scottish farms that have come together to be more effective and efficient in the marketplace are receiving larger single farm payments. Their size and holdings are above average and they are larger than most of our European competitors, but surely that is not a bad thing. Under the common agricultural policy, a farm must either justify or be justified in obtaining those payments. They receive them only if they meet the requirements of the scheme. To make inferences about the size of payments is unfortunate, particularly given the situation in Scotland, where farms are genuinely larger—indeed, the Executive has encouraged farms to join together to become larger units.Although the environmental aspect is a big issue, an equally big issue is the need to have viable farming in Scotland. Without it, 65 to 75 per cent of the land mass would have no one looking after it, which would be equally undesirable.
We could debate whether large equals sustainable in the context of our earlier discussion. I was merely trying to emphasise that we are now able to gain access to information that could be misinterpreted by the public. I do not wish to misinterpret the facts about whether someone is receiving the appropriate amount of money. It was wrong of the minister to suggest that that was the inference behind what I said. What is interesting for people is that they can now find out about the scheme. I hope that the minister will now answer the final part of my question about how often the information will be made available. Will that be done annually? The information would be helpful to the committee.
I have made it clear that we intend to comply with the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002. We have not yet come to a view on what is the most appropriate way in which to do that, as we have not been able to discuss the matter as yet with the relevant people. I made it absolutely clear that we will be fully FOI compliant in relation to agricultural subsidies.
Okay. No member is indicating that they want to ask any further questions. We have covered quite a lot of ground. Are members content with the instrument and are they happy to make no recommendation to the Parliament?
Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 12 Jan 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 12 January 2005 Committee business · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 54
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 11
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 30
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 12
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.