Agenda item 3 is to take evidence on the section 23 report, “Reshaping care for older people”. Committee members have the report, and the Auditor General is here with her colleagues Fraser McKinlay, Claire Sweeney and Rebecca Smallwood. I invite the Auditor General to brief the committee on the report.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Reshaping care for older people”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland 34
- Claire Sweeney Audit Scotland 13
- Hugh Henry Lab 10
- Mary Scanlon Con 10
- Tavish Scott LD 7
- Bob Doris SNP 5
- Colin Beattie SNP 5
- Ken Macintosh Lab 5
- Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland 3
- James Dornan SNP 3
- Willie Coffey SNP 3
- Rebecca Smallwood Audit Scotland 2
The record
100 contributionsThank you, convener.In 2010, the Scottish Government and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities launched a 10-year change programme on reshaping care for older people. The programme aims to improve the quality and outcomes of care, and to meet the needs of an ageing population. People in Scotland, as in most European countries, are living longer and, by 2035, a quarter of us will be aged 65 or over, up from 17 per cent in 2010. Many older people are in good health and, in many instances, they provide care and support to other people. However, older people are more likely than younger people are to be admitted to hospital in an emergency and to have multiple and more complex health problems.The report before you today assesses progress with the programme of reshaping care for older people three years into the 10-year programme and considers the impact of the change fund that has been in place for two of its four years. We also hope that the report will inform the planned integration of health and social care services.We found that reshaping care for older people is an ambitious programme that affects most health and social care services. Implementing the programme is challenging for the organisations involved, which need to change services for the future while meeting people’s current care needs and managing the pressure on existing services—you heard a fair bit about that earlier. Given the scale of the changes, strong leadership is needed at a national and a local level to take the agenda forward.In 2011-12, NHS boards and councils spent approximately £4.5 billion on care for older people. I have commented in previous reports on the slow progress that has been made in moving money to community-based services, even though that has been a policy focus for a number of years. Locally, organisations need to do more to target resources on preventing or delaying ill health and supporting people to live independently in their own homes; they also need to make better use of data to focus on reducing unnecessary variation, and to monitor and spread successful projects.The change fund amounts to £300 million over a four-year period, and it represented 1.5 per cent of all spending on older people in 2011-12. The fund has helped to improve partnership working by bringing together NHS boards, councils and the voluntary and private sectors to improve care and support for older people. The fund has also led to a number of small-scale initiatives across Scotland. Given the scale of the challenge in reshaping care for older people, though, we think that NHS boards and councils need to have clearer plans to ensure that successful projects are sustained and expanded to change mainstream services over time.The core principles of supporting older people to live independently and improving partnership working have been a policy focus in Scotland for a number of years, but progress has been slow. National performance measures have not kept pace with policy changes and a greater focus on outcomes is needed. National monitoring is not sufficient to show whether NHS boards, councils and their partners are successfully implementing the policy and, in particular, what impact it is having on older people.The report makes a number of recommendations to help the Scottish Government, NHS boards and councils increase the pace of change. In particular, we think that the Scottish Government needs to set out clear measures of success when it introduces such new policies in future, and then regularly monitor and publicly report on performance against the measures. NHS boards, councils and their partners need better information to support improvements in services for older people. There are particular gaps in information on community-based services. Given the scale of the challenge involved in reshaping services and the growth of the elderly population in Scotland, it is very important that the recommendations are addressed in a timely fashion.
Thank you, Auditor General.We are sitting on a time bomb here. The biggest challenge facing Scotland today is how to deal with the massive increase in the number of older people and the attendant health demands and care needs. Is there any evidence that the current system is sustainable?
The Government’s own evidence suggests that, in its current form, the system is not sustainable, which is why the reshaping care for older people programme was put in place in 2010. As you have suggested, the population is ageing very fast, and that is much more apparent in some parts of Scotland than it is in others.The change is a very difficult one to make, because we need to keep providing services now while developing services for the future. Moreover, as people get older, they tend to have more co-existing medical conditions that make it more difficult to maintain them at home. That is absolutely why we think that it is time for the programme to really pick up pace and for progress to be seen.
But if, as the Government has accepted, the current system is not sustainable and if, as you have outlined and again the Government has accepted, services need to be reshaped but, as you have indicated, the pace of progress needs to be stepped up, because we are clearly not meeting the requirements or matching demand, what will the consequences be if services are not reshaped in time and the current system proves not to be sustainable?
The short-term consequence is likely to be the increasing pressure on acute hospitals that we have set out in a number of reports and which committee members will be aware of with regard to A and E waiting times, increasing emergency admissions to hospital and difficulties in discharging people to their own homes or better environments after their treatment. When reshaping care for older people was launched in 2010, the Government’s own estimate was that, without change, the amount of money spent on older people’s services was likely to rise from £4.5 billion a year to around £8 billion a year, which is a huge increase at what will be for the foreseeable future a time of very tight resources for public services.That pattern is not in anyone’s best interest. It will mean that the health service will spend more time treating older people in acute hospitals where many of them do not need to be and where, as the cabinet secretary made clear in the earlier evidence session, their health might actually deteriorate rather than improve. It will also make it harder for other people who need acute hospital care to access it in a timely fashion. That is absolutely why the investment in developing community-based services and ensuring that individual older people get the care and support that they need to live healthy independent lives in their own homes for as long as possible needs to happen now.
In preparing the report, you have obviously spoken to different departments or sections of the Scottish Government and certain key officials, and I presume that you have also looked at what councils are doing at a local level. My understanding is that, under the legislation, anyone with a community care need should be offered a community care plan, the identification of which helps the local authority in aggregate to determine what resources are required, what gaps there might be and how services might be reshaped. Do you have any evidence that local authorities are preparing community care plans for those who require them?
I will ask Claire Sweeney to pick up the specific point about community care plans but, in response to your question, I think that any approach needs to happen at two levels. First of all, there needs to be planning for individual people’s needs, not only through the community care plan but as a result of older people contacting their GP for all sorts of reasons, which should indicate that they might need more support to stay at home more safely for longer.We also found and have described in the report some really good examples in Perth and Kinross and Lothian of health and social work services working closely together to use data about the services that older people are using to identify variation that is not explained by obvious factors and to explore what sorts of services would be a better solution to meeting individual needs as well as reducing the pressure on acute services.11:45
We did not look in great detail at what is happening in each local authority area as part of the work for the report, but we are carrying out work to look at self-directed support and the raft of changes that that will bring for social work services in the next short while. In the report, we highlighted in case study 3 gaps in understanding about people’s needs locally. The position was difficult to determine from the national information that is available.Members will see that we highlighted at various points in the report that, although we have information on activity and the number of people who get certain levels of home care, there is a big gap in national information on needs and the appropriateness of services. That was a big problem for us in pulling together the information about what good care looks like and seeing whether the trend information in national data shows good and bad practice.There is definitely a gap in the national information on needs. We did not look at that in every local authority area, but we will pick it up through the work on self-directed support.
One of the problems that we have is that older people’s care is like a jigsaw—every piece fits with another piece and is integral to getting the bigger picture. Our local authorities are struggling to cope with demand and are stretched. Many skilled and experienced people have left under voluntary redundancy schemes because councils have struggled to stay within their budgets. Councils now have no flexibility to raise local funding, so many have had to resort to looking at increased charges and reduced service levels. That must be part of the bigger picture.I am not necessarily criticising local authorities. I do not know the situation in other members’ areas, but I know from dealing with my constituents that few people are offered a care plan as a matter of course, although they and their families should have one, because it helps them to assess whether the requisite level of service is being provided. I suspect that that is partly because council staff are under enormous pressure. That takes us back to the discussion about treatment time guarantees. We pass legislation, but it seems to have no effect.If care plans are not being provided—although I understand that they are required by law—how do individuals know what they are entitled to and how do councils assess the aggregate demand and negotiate with health boards on reshaping services in the way that is necessary to sustain people at home?
You are absolutely right that the issue needs to be looked at across the system. It cannot be considered in relation to just social work services or just acute services. As Claire Sweeney said, the work that we are doing on self-directed support is looking—from the individual up—at what is happening to assess each individual’s needs and to have a proper discussion, with the individual in the driving seat, about how they would like those needs to be met, against a backdrop of tight resources in social work services and the NHS.It is interesting that the self-directed support policy that the Parliament has introduced has the potential to turn the system on its head so that it starts with the individual, in the way that has been described. In the report on older people’s care, we are looking at the challenge of shifting resources, in line with Government policy, from acute services into the right range of services on the ground to meet needs so that, when people say that they would like help with getting to the shops and using community facilities, services can help them to do that. We are coming at the issue from both ends, which are both important.
Exhibit 11 on page 28 provides quite a good summary of the progress that has been made on reshaping care for older people. As an ex-teacher, I looked at the marks, which show improvement in three out of eight commitments—the commitments on third sector capacity, respite care and reducing emergency admissions.When I look at the other commitments, I see serious cause for concern. In particular, the first commitment states that“We will double the proportion of the ... health and social care budget that is spent on care at home”,and yet the proportion has in fact fallen from 9.2 to 8.7 per cent.On commitment 3, which relates to the change fund, it appears that there is no difference. The progress report on commitment 5 states:“The Scottish Government has not defined what it means by ‘waste’ and ‘unnecessary variation’.”If there is no definition, how can progress be measured?On commitment 7, the report states:“National data is not available”.How can an audit committee or an Auditor General measure anything when there is no data? Finally, on commitment 8, the report states:“There is no centrally available information”.We have made progress on three of these eight commitments, which should be our framework for looking at progress across the board, but in one there has been no change and as for the other four there are no definitions and no information. Am I right to be concerned?
That is one of our findings in the report. There are eight commitments under the reshaping care for older people policy, which we have set out in our report. On three of them, things are moving in the right direction, but on another three there is simply not enough information to know what is happening—
I am sorry to interrupt, but there is not even a definition.
A definition of the way in which the commitment will be measured?
That is right.
You are absolutely right. A lot of work has been going on in Government, particularly with the joint improvement team, to come up with measures that would allow all those commitments to be monitored and progressed, and we have recommended that it needs to pick up steam. I ask Claire Sweeney to talk you through the progress that is being made of which we are aware, and where that should leave us in the future.
We note specifically that on commitments 7 and 8 there is just no information to enable us to form a judgment. The same is true of commitment 5. Although it is fairly clear, there is no definition of what is meant by “waste” and “unnecessary variation”.
How can you measure the information if there is no definition? You do not know what you are measuring.
The terms need to be defined before we can start to measure the information and reach a judgment on how the Government is performing.On commitment 7, one issue that lies behind the reason why the information, which relates to older people not being admitted directly to long-term institutional care from acute hospitals, is not there is the lack of a link between NHS data and local authority data on care. That comes through in a number of areas of the report. As the two data sets are very different, there is an issue.We know that people are making efforts to address that at a local level and that in some areas people are sitting down and looking at what services their local population is using in the round. However, we simply could not measure that at a national level.Similarly, on commitment 8, although we can give you a certain amount of information on the use of telecare, which we have included in the progress column, we do not know whether that use is in line with the people who are assessed as needing those services. There are big gaps in some of the indicators.
If we come back to the commitments in a year’s time, will we have a definition for commitment 5? Will the NHS know where patients are being discharged to under commitment 7? Is the information being gathered on commitment 8? Is a commitment not set in the knowledge that there is a way and a means to measure progress and decide whether the commitment is being met?
We certainly think that it should be; that is one of the report’s main messages. The reshaping care programme is good and detailed but where there are clear commitments the Government should be setting out how it will monitor and report on progress against them.
You say that the Government should be doing that, and that there should be a means of measurement, but we are saying that there are no means of measurement in the report.
We say at paragraph 51 that NHS Health Scotland is currently developing a series of outcomes to measure progress on reshaping care for older people, and that is due to be available in spring of this year. We will be keeping that area under review and will report back. The committee may wish to explore that area with the Government to see what progress is being made in that regard.
Forgive me, but we are constantly being told that more robust information will be coming forward on that. I appreciate that your problem is the same as mine.My final question is on exhibit 1. The increase in the percentage of the population aged 65 and over up to 2035 ranges from 13.6 per cent in West Lothian to more than 22 per cent in Dumfries and Galloway. I was a bit disappointed to see that there are so few diagrams to illustrate the trends. Between 1999 and 2003, the convener and I were on the Health and Community Care Committee, which considered the Community Care and Health (Scotland) Act 2002. I still remember clearly the intentions and principles behind that act, and I would have found some diagrams about the trends helpful.Exhibit 6 illustrates the trend in spending on “Care Homes”, “Homecare” and “Other”, and shows that spending in all those areas has been falling from 2009-10 to 2011-12. Why do we not have more up-to-date information on that issue? We are now in 2014, and I would have hoped that we would at least have had figures for 2012-13 so that we could look at the trend. Nonetheless, the resource for care homes, home care and other care for the elderly has been falling since 2009-10.
I will ask Claire Sweeney and Rebecca Smallwood to comment on how up-to-date the data is. On the broader point about the trend in local authority spending, that goes back to the convener’s earlier point about the pressures on council budgets in particular.We make the point in the report that although council spend on home care had been rising in real terms it has now started to fall. We know that there are pressures, and a key part of what the new health and care partnerships will do when they come into being should be to ensure that it is possible to look at the whole budget—in other words, all the resources that are being spent on all the people in an area—and to make the best decisions about how money should be moved to deliver the services that older people need.
A falling budget and a 20 per cent projected increase in demand have to be a significant concern.
That is at the nub of why we think that progress in this particular policy area needs to pick up. We are all getting older by the day and we know that the challenges are there. The money needs to shift to ensure that the services are in place. Fraser McKinlay might want to pick up the point on council budgets in general.
As Mary Scanlon has set out, the pressure that exists with declining budgets and increasing demand makes the agenda in using the full resource that is available to the public sector partners in an area very important. Community planning must be a key part of that. Specifically, as Caroline Gardner mentioned, it will have to be an enormously important part of the agenda for the new integrated health and adult social care bodies that will come into being next year.The point that we repeatedly make is that we should gather information not for its own sake or as an end in itself but to enable people locally to make the right decisions and invest the money—the scarce resource—that they have at their disposal in the most effective way.Information gathering is not just about making our lives easier as auditors by making it easy to get information—much as we would like it to be easy to get—but about how we can be confident that the public pound that is spent in the local area is spent in the most effective and efficient way, given the scale of the challenge that lies ahead.
I think that Rebecca Smallwood can answer the question on how up-to-date the data is.
Exhibit 6 is based on published information that uses the local financial returns. At the time of the report’s publication, the 2011-12 data was the most recent that we could get, as the data for 2012-13 was not yet available.
Do you have any information to suggest that the downward trend is continuing?
We will not have anything on 2012-13 until the data is published.
Nothing at all. Okay.
Before I bring in James Dornan, I would like the witnesses to clarify something. Commitment 7 states:“We will ensure older people are not admitted directly to long-term institutional care from an acute hospital.”When an older person is ready for discharge from an acute hospital but they do not have a home to go back to, where will they be discharged to, if they are not to be discharged to long-term institutional care?
That commitment is about preventing older people from going directly into care homes when they are discharged from hospital if there are alternatives that better meet their needs. For example, someone could receive rehabilitation services or additional support at home to try to enable them to live independently in their home. The aim is to prevent the situation in which people are automatically referred to a care home or institution, even though alternative services could be put in place.12:00
Because no national data is available, you just do not know where they are going.
Yes.
I seek clarification on commitment 5. We are looking for definitions. Are the discussions that are taking place on, say, bed blocking and trying to get people back into their homes happening only between the Scottish Government and the health boards or are other partners involved?
Our understanding is that a lot of that discussion is going on through the joint improvement team, with all the partners that are involved. One of the strengths of the change fund is that it has brought those partners together. That is important, because the problems are not ones that a health board, a council or a voluntary organisation can solve alone.
The issue is that many of the partners define things such as waste slightly differently, and you are trying to get a definitive description.
As we show earlier in the report in an example on NHS Lothian, the challenge is that, not just across Scotland but even within health board areas, there can be real variations in the types of services that are provided. Some of that variation might be proper and might reflect the fact that people are sicker, poorer or older in a particular area, but the challenge is that we do not know how much of the variation reflects people’s needs and how much of it reflects issues such as there simply being no other services that could support people or there being a GP practice that is not good at thinking about alternatives to referring people to hospital when a crisis occurs. The challenge is to understand what necessary variation is and what “unnecessary variation” and “waste” are and then to drill into that and tackle it.
Do you have any idea of the timetable for the partners coming to some sort of conclusion?
That is a good question. Rightly, the programme is a 10-year one, and the change fund is a four-year fund that we are two years through. One reason why we think that the monitoring information is important is that it is important to be able to track what is happening across those 10 years rather than wait until the end and look at the difference that the programme has made. So the answer is that it is a 10-year programme but we cannot leave it until 2020 to see what is different.
link
I commend the Auditor General and her team for pulling together information on what is a hugely complex and changing landscape. I have a couple of brief points to make before I go on to my substantive question.Ms Scanlon referred to exhibit 6; she is absolutely right that spending on care homes and home-care provision has reduced in the past couple of years. However, I see that reduction as being fairly minimal and would not gauge it as a long-term trend. I am being honest about that—I genuinely do not agree with Mary Scanlon that it is a long-term trend. I have a reason for saying that. I agree with her that the yellow line in exhibit 6, which is for “Other” provision, has completely flatlined, although I would say that the long-term trend is that budgets for care homes and home care are up.The biggest thing that I pick up from exhibit 6 is that the traditional methods of working with older people in the community are pretty much still what are used. If that was not the case, the “Other” line would be starting to increase. I acknowledge that—as Ms Scanlon said—in the past couple of years the money for care homes and home care has slightly dipped, but the big thing is that the “Other” line has pretty much flatlined. What is your analysis of that?
Claire Sweeney and Rebecca Smallwood will keep me right on this. I think that you are broadly right, but in the “Other” line we are seeing a much smaller focus on things such as day centres and other more traditional types of care that are perhaps less valued by older people and are of less help in enabling them to stay healthy and independent at home for longer. Claire Sweeney will amplify that for me.
In paragraph 32, we describe in a little more detail what is in exhibit 6 and we highlight what is included in “Other”, which I think is helpful.There are two issues around council resources for social care services. The first is the intention in respect of reshaping care of older people. Integration of health and social care is, to a degree, about supporting people so that they do not access acute services, hospital services and social care services unless it is absolutely necessary, and so that they can live independently. It is also about communities working with people to support them at home as long as possible. The changing focus over time has led to much greater focus on community support and helping people to stay at home through, for example, improved access to telecare.The second issue is the change to self-directed support, which will be a big change for social care services and on which we are doing more detailed work that will change the focus of those services over time. We are already starting to see signs that that is having a big impact in some areas on how social work services, and social care services more broadly, are being planned and considered in relation to future provision. We will see that change over time because of the policy change.
link
That fleshes out what exhibit 6 is saying.I am sorry to be a bit of an anorak about this—I have a much larger question that I want to ask—but I would like to ask next about exhibit 11. I share Ms Scanlon’s frustration about whether we are able to collect the information for auditing purposes. However, I also think that the situation is fairly understandable.Commitment 5 says:“We will improve quality and productivity through reducing waste and unnecessary variation in practice and performance with regard to emergency admissions and bed days across Scotland.”I look at that commitment and ask how we can quantify that. Then, I look at one of the key recommendations at the start, which says that we must“do more to understand the reasons why activity and spending on services for older people vary across Scotland”and goes on to mention things such as benchmarking activities and costs, identifying areas for improvement and ways of identifying and rolling out good practice.If each local authority and health board is currently looking at service reform, and each area is doing that differently because the Government has made it clear that the approach is about locally led solutions, including the involvement of the voluntary sector via a kind of co-production process, it becomes quite difficult for the centre to monitor and audit what is going on. In saying that, am I giving the Government a “Get out of jail free” card? I do not want to do that. Alternatively, is what I am saying reasonable? If it is, how could the Government capture that information more systematically?
That is a reasonable thing to say. In case study 4, on page 42, we talk about what NHS Lothian and the Lothians councils are doing. We think that they have started doing good work using data to explore what is happening in quite small parts of the health board area—down to the level of individual people—in terms of emergency admissions, use of social care services and so on. As you suggest, that information can be used to find out whether anything is missing in Edinburgh, East Lothian or wherever that would help to avoid emergency admissions, or to keep people safer at home for longer. We have identified two areas where that is happening well: the Lothians and the Perth and Kinross Council area, with NHS Tayside. We did not find evidence that it is happening as well as that consistently across Scotland. We think that that needs to happen.It is also true that, at national level, it is hard to monitor or understand such variations, and the gaps between information systems make it hard to track overall progress on the policy. If there is a particularly high level of emergency admissions for people over 65 in a part of Scotland, we cannot link that to whether, for example, the level of home care is less than the national average; we cannot say whether it is the people who are getting home care who are being admitted to hospital or those who are not. There is a bit of both, I think. That is why the Government has to clarify what it means by “unnecessary variation” and say how it will monitor progress on the policy so that the areas that are lagging behind can be given the support that they need in order to catch up, given the scale of the challenges.
link
That is a much more nuanced view.I always wear two caps when I sit in this committee. In wearing not just my Public Audit Committee cap, but my Health and Sport Committee cap, I come to an issue that can and should be audited: the change fund.I will return in a second to the fact that the change fund represents 1.5 per cent of the overall budget, but there have been misinterpretations about what the £300 million that will be spent over four years on older people is for. Those are not additional moneys that will then disappear; rather, those moneys provide short-term funding for local authorities, health boards and the third sector to get round the table and change provision in each health board area so that, when the change fund ends, that new service provision is embedded in the core budgets in each area. In other words, I would not expect the new health and social care corporate body models that are to roll into town with the Public Bodies (Joint Working) (Scotland) Bill to turn around in a couple of years and say, “Well, we were given £300 million, but we haven’t got that now, so what do you expect us to do?” That is not what the change fund is for.How and when do you expect to audit it? I guess that it would be in two years, when the change fund has run its course, before a successor committee would be in a position to look into the matter. Will there be an interim monitoring process? How can you guide this committee and the Health and Sport Committee to follow the process?
You are exactly right: the change fund’s purpose is not short-term funding; rather, it is to leverage the £4.5 billion that is spent on the services across Scotland. Fraser McKinlay will pick up your questions.
I will make a very similar point. The clue is in the name: the change fund is designed to change how services are delivered. Inevitably, you want to start small and test out and pilot things. As Mr Doris says, given that we are two years through a four-year programme, our concern would be the extent to which the bodies are able over the next couple of years to “embed”—to use Mr Doris’s word—the changes and make them a core part of their work, so that that just becomes how business is done and how the service is run. Claire Sweeney will say a little about what the joint improvement team and others are doing on monitoring because that—as we say in the report—is definitely an issue. We see some good examples of local working, but the challenge is about scale and pace, which is about making the changes more quickly and everywhere. It is also about—as Mr Doris said—whether in two years, when we assess the change fund’s impact, we will be able to see that there has been a fundamental shift in how services are being delivered, or whether we will be looking at a series of relatively small-scale projects that have delivered good things for a relatively small number of people. That will be the big test over the next couple of years.
link
That is helpful.
Some of the things that we were looking for are directly related to that. In looking at what the change fund was being used for, rather than just look at small-scale projects and where new things were being tried out, we tried to see a connection between how much a service cost and its impact on people and the rest of the system. In the change fund’s first two years we saw greater focus on the testing side. The joint improvement team has more recently tried to focus on the evidence base and how spreadable are the initiatives. The team has asked for all areas to give details about the extent to which tried projects have spread. Therefore, more information is available about the extent to which some of the initiatives will stick, and which shows that they are not just expensive initiatives that will not be replicated in other ways. In addition, the impact on people who need access to those services is being a bit more clearly tracked than it was at the start of the change fund process.
I do not mean to cut across Bob Doris, but a number of members have pointed out to me that Parliament convenes at half past one today. I have at least four members who wish to ask questions, so I ask Bob Doris to make a very short contribution, after which I will move on.
link
In that case, I may just have to make a comment, so that I can put the matter on the record, rather than have an exchange with the witnesses. My final question was about how the issue fits with the Public Bodies (Joint Working) (Scotland) Bill. I have in front of me the stage 1 report that went to Parliament. It mentions COSLA’s desire to top slice some of the acute hospitals’ budget for reform of health and social care at local level through health and social care integration.I know that that is something that the Government has ruled out and will not set minimums on, but there was silence from local authority partners about how much of their budgets they were willing to put into the pot. There was a great demand for the NHS to put money into the pot, but we do not know what local authorities would bring to the table or, just as important, how the voluntary sector would fit in and be part of the co-production process. Is that something that you and your team would want to follow through in the years ahead? That £4.5 billion now goes on to the table for radically reforming health and social care for older people.12:15
The spirit of the Public Bodies (Joint Working) (Scotland) Bill, and of the policy, is about being more transparent about how money is spent; you can see that in the examples that we have used from Perth and Kinross and from Lothian. What is working there is the health board, the council, the third sector and private sector providers sitting down and asking what is happening to older people, where there is room to improve care, what is likely to improve the situation and how they can try that and track what happens. That is the way forward. There is a need for monitoring at national level as well, and if we can join that up through all the policy initiatives it should be possible to make a step change in the quality of services for older people and their ability to stay at home for longer.
Point 4 of exhibit 11 on page 28 states: “The Change Fund has provided about £35 million to help unpaid carers, directly and indirectly.”Is that the scale of the spend on the small initiatives that was described earlier?
No. I think that that money is specifically for carers. Claire Sweeney will talk you through that.
There is a little more detail in paragraph 61 on page 34 about the focus of the change fund resource on carers. The report highlights the fact that there was a lot of attention on that because it was seen as being one of the potential solutions for supporting people for longer in their own homes.
Am I right that the change fund was worth £70 million in 2011-12, and £300 million over the four-year period, of which £35 million per annum is being spent—or has been spent in the first couple of years—in that area? I am trying to understand the split and how the money is being spent.
Paragraph 61 sets out that at least 20 per cent of the overall change fund was to be spent on supporting carers, with £50 million being allocated for that purpose between 2012 and 2015. However, in reviewing the change fund plans, the joint improvement team has identified that in some areas more than that was being spent on carers, so it has been identified as a particular priority for the change fund plan. More attention has been paid to how that money is being used than is being paid to some other areas of the change fund plan, because it was seen as such a significant issue.
You also say, in paragraph 54, that 30 per cent of the fund is underspent. There are a lot of different things going on.
That is right.
Is Fraser McKinlay’s point that some initiatives are going on, but that it is difficult to quantify them? I cannot find any assessment in the report of how much is being spent on local initiatives; I take the point that they have got to be local to drive the process. We know that £35 million is already being spent on respite care, which is entirely fair and as it should be, but what is the rest being spent on?
Paragraphs 54 and 55 summarise what we know from the joint improvement team’s evaluation of the change fund. The short answer is that there is not a complete picture. We say that the returns that come back to the joint improvement team do not account for the whole allocation in 2011-12 and, as you said, there was in the first year an underspend, which partnerships were allowed to carry forward into the following year.There is a plan to evaluate the change fund in 2015. We think that it is important that how it is being used is well understood now, so that we can build on success and stop spending money on things that are not having the desired impact.
If I understood Bob Doris’s point, the fund is to ensure that £4.5 billion is being spent in the right way, and you have only two years of the change fund left to achieve that. It sounds as though we are not very far down that road.
We think that there is not enough clarity about how the change fund is being used, although we say that it has done some good things. It has genuinely improved partnership working, in particular by involving the voluntary and private sectors more in the discussion, and there are some good examples of local projects. What we have not seen is the information that would let people spot those good projects and think about how to spread them.It is worth saying that the health service in particular has some great experience of doing that in relation to the patient safety strategy and the early years collaborative, and has developed a very strong method for saying, “We want to change this aspect of services. Here’s how we expect it to happen, here’s how we will monitor it, after which we’ll review the situation and reinvest.” That sort of approach could make a real difference to the change fund, and to reshaping care for older people more generally.
That seems to be very fair.You say at the very start of the report something that I think is said in all Audit Scotland reports about the need for strong national and local leadership. Ten years equates to two and a half Governments, but most ministers and MSPs can hardly look ahead to next week, never mind to 10 years from now. How strong is the drive to achieve the change, given that we are halfway through the change fund period and a long way from the eight years by which time the whole thing is supposed to be done and dusted?
In a sense, that goes back to the convener’s opening questions about the scale of the challenge. In exhibit 3, we track the policies in this area back to 2000. In truth, such policies did not start in 2000; there has actually been a formal policy in place for as long as the Parliament has existed. What is different now is not only the speed at which the size of the ageing population is increasing, but the fact that after 10 years of growing resources we are now in a period of tight resources. That means that the problem of sustainability is much tighter, and that the need to focus on what is working and to ensure that we are learning from that right across Scotland has never been more important.
Thank you.
link
Given the time, I will restrict myself to one question of clarification. In paragraph 23 on page 16 of the report, you carefully state that the “figures are ... real terms”. Is the fairly dramatic move from £4.5 billion to £8 billion that is outlined in paragraph 22 also in real terms?
I am pretty sure that it is, but Rebecca Smallwood will keep me straight on this. The £4.5 billion to £8 billion increase is the Scottish Government’s estimate, and I would have expected the figures to be bigger if they had to account for inflation.
I think that we will need to come back to you on that.
We will double check and come back to you, but I think that those are real-terms figures.
link
The point is important, given the dramatic nature of the increase. We need to know the basis of it.I have another question that brings us back to the issue of the data not quite giving us what we want. In the final couple of sentences of paragraph 38 on page 23 of the report, you say that the“percentage of homecare clients receiving intensive homecare has increased from 24 per cent in 2005 to 32 per cent in 2013”while the overall number receiving home care has fallen. Is that a result of councils raising the bar and only accepting people who have greater needs? In other words, they are looking to accommodate people with the greatest needs, with the result that those at the other end are dropping out. Is that borne out by the figures?
It is. It has been the case over quite a long period that eligibility criteria have been increased to focus on those with the most intense needs instead of giving people one, two or three hours of home care across the week. There is a debate over whether that is the right approach and whether there is value in providing lower levels of care that can help to keep people more independent. Of course that debate will become all the more intense when, as the report in general shows, resources are tighter.
link
The same paragraph says:“Information on the number of hours of care people receive at home is often used as a proxy for need (with more than ten hours of homecare being considered ‘intensive homecare’).”Is such analysis valid? I suppose that, crudely speaking, the number of hours could determine the intensiveness of the home care but surely the type of home care should also be taken into consideration.
You are absolutely right, and I ask Claire Sweeney to pick up the issue.
You have drawn out one of our biggest challenges in this report, which was to use information that gave us an in to the issue of need and the appropriateness of treatment and care. There is actually not much information that tells us very much beyond counting units of provision for social care services. The issue is, I think, nicely highlighted in the report with the comment that it is not really possible to tell whether people use more than one kind of service, whether levels of service provision are low or high or, indeed, whether that is a good or bad thing. Throughout the report, we were trying to pinpoint what a good service might look like in the reshaped model of older people’s services, and we found it quite difficult to pin that down because the information at national level is either not joined up or not collected in a way that would help us to do that. There is definitely an issue about not having good enough information about appropriateness of treatment and levels of need, and that is reflected in that particular paragraph.
link
Clearly, the information will lie at council level, but it is not gathered at the national level at all.
In case study 3, we talk about the index of relative need, which is a tool that is used to measure dependency. Most councils in Scotland use it when they assess an older person’s needs and the services that they require, but in 2012 only 8 per cent of the records that came back from councils to the Scottish Government included that information. That is an example of the data that we think could be useful both in helping to plan the way in which services are developed in future and in thinking about the sustainability of the model of care that we have and how to make best use of the money that is spent.
link
Convener, in view of the time, I will leave my questions there.
Thank you. I call Ken Macintosh, to be followed by Willie Coffey.
I want to return to a subject that everyone has pursued. You state that“There is little evidence of progress in moving money”from health“to community-based services”.Do you have any evidence or good examples of where that has been done successfully?
In overall terms, it is clear that money is not transferring. The figures in the report demonstrate that things are pretty steady, and actually the overall level of local authority spend fell between 2011-12 and 2012-13. That is not to say that it is not shifting in some localities and some council and health board areas, but across the country the Government’s commitment to shifting that relative spend is going in the wrong direction rather than the right one. That is happening for reasons that we all completely understand to do with the difficulty of making the shift at a time when finances are reducing, the number of older people is increasing and we need to keep on running the acute hospital service. However, the shift is not happening just now.
You have summed up the dilemma. You point to weak leadership, but could a different conclusion be drawn? I can see how we could put more resources into community-based care and expand that sector, but I cannot quite see how we could ever decrease investment in acute care. That is a different conclusion altogether, is it not? Do you tend to the view that, no matter how hard we try to shift resources away from acute care, that will not happen, and all that we can ever do is to maintain the level there while we increase preventative care?
It is certainly very challenging to make the shift, but I am not sure that anybody has the evidence to say that it is impossible. There are different drivers. As you heard this morning, we have seen a dramatic reduction in average lengths of stay, which is due to people being treated as day cases or outside hospital. There are technological advances that mean that people who would have been treated in hospital can now be treated at home with drugs. Some of the challenges go the other way, because we can do new things that cost more, so an awful lot is changing.We focused on the first commitment under the reshaping care of older people policy, which is to double the proportion of the total health and social care budget for older people that is spent on care at home over the 10 years of the policy. There is something important there about understanding the different factors that are going on from the top, but also from the bottom up. It is important to understand what the variation is and how it can be reduced. Some of it may be entirely appropriate, as we discussed earlier, but some of it almost certainly is not. Tackling the places that could do much more to treat people out of hospital—and to give them a better quality of life in doing that—has to be the way to unlock this.
In paragraphs 62 and 63, you mention the role of the third sector, particularly in care, and the difficulties that you have in that area. Can you make any assessment of the role or value of the third sector in promoting community-based care? Many of us as MSPs see things such as lunch clubs, befriending, volunteer drivers and so on as both cost effective and important because they provide a culture and a supportive community that increase older people’s independence, but you do not seem to be able to make any assessment of such work in an auditable way.
I think that the consensus is that, as you say, those voluntary services can be both effective and highly valued by older people. However, it is also true that we do not have evidence of that at present. The stitch in time project, which we mention in paragraph 63, is intended to gather that evidence in order to strengthen the voluntary sector’s hand in discussions about where money should be spent in future. To a great extent, having the evidence makes it much easier to make the case for the shift.
Will that be published in time to influence the Public Bodies (Joint Working) (Scotland) Bill? The bill is about integrating health and social care, but it does not really involve the third sector in any meaningful way.12:30
That is part of the agenda of reshaping care for older people and the changes around the integration of health and social care services. In some areas across Scotland, that relationship has been gained in part through the support of the change fund by bringing together partners to start to think about the way in which resources are used in totality for that local area. That relationship is new; it has not really been done before. We are starting to see a greater focus on that in local areas, which directly involves the third and private sectors in most discussions about provision in the local area.The example in the report is in Tayside, where the integrated resource framework information is being shared with GPs. That is interesting because it starts to look at a much lower level of service provision for the population than has happened before, and we start to get into the options that are available to people. Again, there is a clear link to the self-directed support policy through thinking about the other options that might suit people better, and what might better meet people’s needs and improve outcomes for them. All the agendas are therefore quite closely linked.
Thank you. I think that I interrupted Fraser McKinlay earlier.
Claire Sweeney covered it.
Auditor General, I want to pick up on the issue of delayed discharge. The figure that is mentioned in the report is something like 305,000 days all in. From your comments in paragraph 67, it appears that the problem is half the size that it used to be, but it is still quite extensive. You also comment that 837 hospital beds or equivalent are being occupied for a year by patients who are otherwise ready to leave hospital. There must be quite a considerable cost attached to that. Do you know what that cost is?
It is possible to put a cost on it by basing it on the average cost of a hospital bed day. The question is how much that really tells us. As Mr Macintosh said, the problem is that, because of the pressure that we all put on acute hospital beds, if there is not an older person in that bed, it will be filled very quickly by someone else, so that sort of average cost is not particularly useful. That shows why stepping back and looking at the whole system is the only way to tackle the problem.
You hint at the issues in paragraph 66, but why are people being brought into hospital? Is there no discharge plan ready? Should people be admitted to hospital when there is no discharge plan for them? What are the main reasons for that?In your recommendations, I do not see a strong enough recommendation for dealing with that and smoothing people’s transition back into the community.
You are right to say that there is no specific recommendation about that. That is partly because the ways in which it can be tackled just by focusing on delayed discharge have already been done. That “easy work”—if I can put that phrase in inverted commas—has already been done, which is why the figures have fallen so significantly during the past few years.There is scope for people whose admission to hospital is planned to be clearer in advance about what they will need to get out again and, on the whole, that is done for them. If someone is going in for a hip replacement or a knee replacement, it is clear what is needed to get them home as soon as they are able to stand and move about, and those requirements are almost always in place. The problem arises when people are admitted unexpectedly as an emergency and something changes. If they fall and break their hip, it is much harder to get them home quickly because new things need to be put in place.It is important to look at the situation through the other end of the telescope, too. Services that can prevent someone from falling and breaking their hip and going into hospital are just as important as the services that will help them to get out of hospital once they are in there; they are possibly more important. As Claire Sweeney said, the ability to work with the GP, the district nurse, and the social workers to focus on older people who have had a history of falls and look at what would help to keep them safer can have a bigger impact than the assessment process once someone is in hospital.
I will leave it at that, convener. Thank you.
Thank you. I thank the Auditor General and her colleagues for their evidence to the committee. With that, we move into private session.12:34 Meeting continued in private until 12:39.
In this meeting
Everything on 19 Feb 2014 →- 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 249
- 09:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 100
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.