Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“NHS Financial Performance 2012/13” and “Management of patients on NHS waiting lists—audit update”

Wednesday 19 February 2014 Public Audit Committee About 09:30 Committee business 249 contributions · 14 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

249 contributions · showing 1–200
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Agenda item 2 is two section 23 reports: “NHS Financial Performance 2012/13” and “Management of patients on NHS waiting lists—audit update”. At our previous meeting, we heard from Paul Gray, the director general for health and social care, who is here again, as is the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing, Alex Neil, who is accompanied by John Connaghan and John Matheson, who have been at the committee previously, and Professor Jason Leitch. I welcome them all to the committee.Cabinet secretary, I believe that you would like to make an opening statement.

Alex Neil SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing · Airdrie and Shotts
link

Yes, if that is okay.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

You have never been shy about talking, so on you go.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I learned that from you, convener.I thank the committee for allowing me to make some opening remarks. I will start with the excellent financial performance of the national health service in Scotland. I welcome the Audit Scotland report on that, which acknowledges that the NHS managed its overall finances well and that, for the fifth year running, all boards achieved their financial targets. As the committee has had a particular interest in how we can improve long-term planning and increase financial flexibility, I will briefly outline what we are doing in those two areas.We believe that there is a strong and effective focus on long-term financial planning, and we have evidenced that in discussions with Audit Scotland. As part of NHS boards’ local delivery planning, they develop a three to five-year financial plan, which is submitted annually to the Scottish Government. Of course, boards look much further ahead in planning long-term delivery of services, and major investment in the NHS is informed by the Scottish capital investment manual, which takes a horizon of 25 years plus.The committee is also interested in flexibility, so I would like to advise that we have, and make available, the facility to afford boards sensible flexibility to accommodate local circumstances, such as brokerage. One component of that greater flexibility is the use of the Government’s arrangements with the Treasury to carry forward an agreed level of resource from one year to the next. That type of wider financial planning allows us to ensure that resources for health are fully utilised and to provide flexibility to individual boards based on their need.I will say a few words about NHS performance. Much has been said in recent months on the delivery of waiting time targets. We should acknowledge that Scotland’s consistent record of improved delivery over the past 10 years has seen waiting times progressively reduced to being the best in the United Kingdom and at their current all-time low. Although I am pleased that Scotland is delivering more than 98 per cent of the treatment time guarantee, I have advised all boards of the need to meet and then sustain that guarantee.Since the committee’s previous meeting, we have obtained the plans for 2014 from the boards with the biggest challenges, which are NHS Grampian and NHS Lothian. I have been personally advised by their chairs and chief executives that, with the investment and recruitment plans that are in place for 2014, they will meet and then maintain the treatment time guarantee—for Grampian, that will be from the end of summer 2014 and, for Lothian, it will be from the end of the calendar year 2014.Confidentiality clauses were also a topic of discussion at the previous committee meeting. In fact, those are used in settlement agreements not only across the national health service in Scotland but with employees elsewhere in the public sector and in the private sector. In response to the committee’s interest in the number of such settlements, I can advise that, in the national health service, we have used them approximately 150 times in the past three years. I should say that we are absolutely clear that no NHS board will use such settlements to prevent staff from voicing concerns about any aspect of patient safety or malpractice—indeed, it would be illegal to do so.More generally, the Public Audit Committee may be aware from previous correspondence from Sir Peter Housden, the permanent secretary, that we are committed to strengthening the process by requiring public bodies and health boards not only to consult Government before committing to a settlement agreement but to report on their use of such agreements in a transparent manner in their annual reports. Proposals are currently being developed, and health boards will be consulted as part of that exercise across the public sector. Thank you, convener, for allowing me to make an opening statement. I look forward to the questions.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Thank you, cabinet secretary. It is worth emphasising what I have said about excellence in the national health service—it would be wrong to take any criticism as a criticism of the efforts of individual staff or to question their commitment to a publicly funded NHS. The issue for us is to look at the strains and stresses on the NHS and to consider whether the Government is properly factoring them in, so that we can assess whether we are adequately resourcing the service and planning for future demand. I return to what you said about the treatment time guarantee. You have said what will be done to ensure that health boards meet that guarantee, and you will be aware from the Audit Scotland report that few of them were doing so. Mr Gray previously told the committee that he has accepted that the Government was not fulfilling the will of Parliament in that regard. Do you agree with that?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The treatment time guarantee was set down by Parliament in the Patient Rights (Scotland) Act 2011 and is now a legal duty on the national health service. By definition, if a health board is not meeting the treatment time guarantee it will not meet the requirements of the legislation. That is why we are insisting that every health board meet the guarantee, and I have made it absolutely clear to the two health boards that have had the greatest challenge in doing that—NHS Grampian and NHS Lothian—that they have no option in the matter; it is a legal requirement and they must get themselves into a position, as they are doing, to meet the guarantee.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Do you agree with Mr Gray that it may not be possible to ensure that there are no breaches of the guarantee?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

In a system that deals with the number of patients that we deal with every year, there will always be a substantial risk. For example, in a small hospital where there is only one consultant in a particular discipline, if that consultant becomes ill suddenly and is absent for a period of time, there is a chance that the guarantee may not be met. However, until now, across the health service as a whole, we have achieved a rate of more than 98 per cent in relation to meeting the treatment time guarantee, even with the problems in Grampian and Lothian. I think that, by any standard, most folk would accept that that is a credible performance, but the law says that we must reach 100 per cent and we will get there.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Why put into law that particular target but not, for example, the right to be treated in accident and emergency within a defined time period?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That relates to legislation that the Parliament passed three or four years ago, and obviously—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

The legislation was promoted by your Government. Why that target?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The legislation was also supported by other parties.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

But it was promoted by your Government, so why that target and not others?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I will explain that if you will let me finish my sentence. It was the wish of the Parliament to pass that into legislation, and it emanated from the terrible waiting times that we had prior to 2007. As a former Deputy Minister for Health and Community Care, you will remember that, way back in 2001-02, waiting times for some procedures that are now down to 12 weeks were measured not only in months but, in some cases, in years. The public’s primary concern was that waiting times and waiting lists were far too long, and that was the top priority. The reason for not putting other targets into law is that the degree of public concern about waiting times and waiting lists—for A and E, for example—has not been so great. The latest statistics on A and E show that we are meeting our 95 per cent target, and most folk would accept that that is a reasonable performance.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Tell me, then, what is meant by a legal right to treatment.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

It means that everybody who has been referred for treatment has to have that treatment within the 12-week period. There is also the 18-week target, which is from the initial contact with the general practitioner to treatment, but within the 18 weeks we have the 12-week target, which is from referral for treatment to the treatment. That is what it means, and that is, in law, what every patient is entitled to expect.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

If the patient does not get that, what happens?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

A whole range of things happen. First, there is redress under the legislation that pre-dated the 2011 act. Patients can go through the formal national health service complaints procedure, and if they are not happy with the outcome they can go to the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman. In addition, they can, if they so wish, resort to law.Under the legislation and the specific guarantee, there are additional measures that boards are duty bound in law to carry out if they do not meet the guarantee. They have to write to the patient and explain why they have not met the guarantee, and they have to ensure that, where a patient has not been treated within the 12-week period, they are treated as soon as possible after it. Our statistics show that the vast bulk of people are treated well within a 15-week period.I am sure that you are aware that that is what the legislation states.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

You said that patients have the right to use the complaints procedure and to go to the ombudsman, but those things would be there anyway, for example for those whose accident and emergency waiting time guarantee is not fulfilled, or whose out-patient requirements are not met. They are there for anyone. A legal right is not required. What is different about the legal right compared with other aspects of complaints procedures?Mr Gray told us that, if someone’s legal right is not fulfilled, they can go to judicial review. You and I know that judicial review is both time consuming and exceedingly expensive. It might be an option for you or me, on the salaries that we earn, but it is not easily available to most of our constituents. What rights, other than those that exist in relation to any aspect of the NHS, distinguish the legal right from the other targets?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The additional rights in respect of the treatment time guarantee that were built into the Patient Rights (Scotland) Act 2011 are as follows. First, “The Health Board must—(a) make such arrangements as are necessary to ensure that the agreed treatment starts at the next available opportunity”.That is not in law for any other target, although we tried to introduce it.Secondly, it must“(b) provide an explanation to the patient as to why the treatment did not start within the maximum waiting time”.Again, that is not in law for any other target.Thirdly, it must“(c) give the patient details of—(i) the advice and support available (including in particular the patient advice and support service described in section 18).”That is not there for any other target. The patient must also be given details of“(ii) how to give feedback or comments or raise concerns or complaints.”That is not in law for any other target.Fourthly, “In making the arrangements mentioned in subsection (2)(a), the Health Board—(a) must not give priority to the start of any treatment where such prioritisation would, in the Health Board’s opinion, be detrimental to another patient with a greater clinical need for treatment,(b) must have regard to the patient’s availability, and(c) must have regard to other relevant factors.”Although we tried to introduce those things for every target, they are not in law elsewhere. It is unique to the 2011 act that they are built in as legal requirements.If you go back and look at the stage 1 evidence, the stage 2 amendments and the stage 3 debate on the bill that set up the treatment time guarantee, you will see that a universal view was held right across the Parliament that there should not be additional legal redress.Let me quote Jackie Baillie—I quote her often because she is full of wisdom. Speaking as the Labour Party’s official health spokesman, she agreed that we do not want to create a compensation culture or a “bonanza for lawyers”. We would all agree that we do not want to end up with an American system in which the lawyers dictate everything and we lose sight of what the patient needs. Of course, that is why your own party did not move an amendment for further legal redress beyond what was already in the bill, and Parliament signed up to that.09:45

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

But that brings us back to the question why we should bother putting the provision in legislation in the first place when it is so complicated, there is no evident easy route for patients to exercise their legal rights, and there does not appear to be any impact on the health boards that fail. It becomes a farce because, even if people know their legal rights, they are not able to exercise them. Paul Gray has said that the option is then to go to judicial review.Cabinet secretary, this morning you have read out a list of things that should happen if the target is not met. Through you, I ask Mr Gray to provide the committee with details of the number of times that each health board has had to do the things on the list that you read out. That will let us know both the scale of the problem and, for example, that people who are having to wait are being informed and the requirements are being met. Presumably those statistics exist.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

To describe the situation as a farce is ridiculous. The farce was when people had to wait months for treatment.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

We accept that.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

They are now getting their treatment within 12 weeks. We inherited the farce of long waiting times and long waiting lists, and at the time our priority was to deal with waiting lists and waiting times. We have done that so dramatically that we now have by far the best waiting times in the whole of the United Kingdom. If you compare us with Wales, where the waiting times and the accident and emergency turnaround times are way out of control, you will see that the Scottish health system is doing brilliantly. To describe that as a farce is a bit ridiculous.You also said that people are not able to exercise their legal rights. That is not true. They are exercising their legal rights under the 2011 act. All the procedures that I outlined are being used.The statistics that you asked for are available, convener. We will send them to the committee. They have already been published, and we will send any additional information that the committee wants, because I am keen to ensure that it has all the information that it requires to do its job of scrutiny in order to make sure that we are delivering on the legislation.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

I am asking for information on each of the categories that you listed. I want to know how many times each health board has actioned each.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

That is fine, if the information is there.You misinterpret what I say if you suggest that I was describing what has happened with waiting lists as a farce. What I said was that it is a farce if people cannot exercise their legal rights. Mr Gray has previously told us that people could end up going to judicial review.I have not come across any cases in which health boards have written to people. Have you had to intervene with any health boards in the past couple of months in relation to individual cases in which people are telling you that their legal rights have not been met?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

No one has come to me and said that their legal rights have not been met when they have had a problem with the treatment time guarantee. Every patient who has come to me as the constituency MSP for Airdrie and Shotts has been told why there is a problem. We will absolutely give the committee information on any health board that has not carried out its legal duty. If any member of the committee, the Parliament or the public believes that they have an example of when such a legal duty has not been carried out, they should write to us and let us know because we will then take corrective action to make sure that it is carried out.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

That is helpful.Are you saying that you have not had to contact any health board on behalf of any individual who has said that their treatment time guarantee has not been met?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Do you mean as an MSP or as the cabinet secretary?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

As an MSP, I certainly have not had to do so, and as the cabinet secretary I do not recall having had to do that. However, we will double check to ensure whether any of us has had to do that, and we will certainly provide the information. I am determined to ensure—it is in our interests to do so—that every health board in Scotland abides by the law.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Could you also provide us with the details that are given to each patient on how they can exercise their legal right? Is that in the form of a leaflet, or is a letter issued to them?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I have two points on that. First, information is given to patients at every stage. For example, if a patient is unable, for their own reasons, to attend within the 12 weeks, they are told what will happen and what their legal rights are. As the primary legislation says, if for any reason a health board is unable to fulfil the guarantee, the patient has to be told. At that stage, the health board has to tell the patient why that is the case, when they can expect to get their treatment and whether there is a choice of locations where the treatment can take place. We will give the committee a flow chart that shows, right through the system, from the time that a patient goes to their general practitioner, what should happen in law if the treatment time guarantee is not met and what information they should be given.Secondly, we are reviewing the process. The treatment time guarantee has been up and running for more than a year, as it was introduced from 1 October 2012. I want to ensure that we not only tell patients but tell them timeously and in language that is easy for them to understand, is not too legalistic and is in various formats. Obviously, many patients like to be emailed. I would like us to use the method of communication that is preferred by the patient. We are reviewing the process, and we will publish the report of that review by the end of June.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

What sanctions are taken against health boards if they do not meet the target?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

If a health board does not meet the target, we sit down with it, as we have done with NHS Grampian and NHS Lothian. Rather than take a legalistic approach, our preferred approach is to work with a board to get it into a position whereby we can ensure that it will deliver. In the cases of Grampian and Lothian, that involves a fairly substantial investment programme. For example, the investment programme in Grampian includes the commissioning of three new theatres in the area between now and the summer of 2014 to ensure that the board can deliver on the treatment time guarantee. Most other boards have met the guarantee in most months, although there might be the odd month in which they have not met it. Overall, as I say, even with the problems in Grampian and Lothian, we are still at more than 98 per cent. I think that, as far as the public are concerned, that is a fantastic achievement.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

I will ask briefly about patients’ rights, and then come on to an audit question. The 12-week waiting time guarantee is entrenched in legislation, and the convener explored how people can exercise that right. However, in relation to the responsibilities of Government and health boards, would new primary legislation be required to withdraw the target? My reading is that the 12-week target is a Government target that is entrenched in law so, if a future Government wished to disavow the target, it would have to pass primary legislation. Is that the case?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

To abolish the treatment time guarantee, the primary legislation would have to be changed. An act of this Parliament created the treatment time guarantee.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

That is a pretty strong protection, so it is important to put that on the record. Time and again, whenever I raise issues in relation to targets on waiting times or whatever, I always take the view that, when targets are missed, it is important to identify that that has happened, but it is more important to consider what is done to address the issue. That is a clear role for the committee in auditing the process. My questions will refer to that and to budget decisions.I am delighted that the Auditor General’s audit update shows that in my health board area in Glasgow the waiting time guarantee target is being met in 100 per cent of cases but I note that, as has been mentioned, the figure for NHS Grampian is 96.1 per cent. The cabinet secretary mentioned the development of three new operating theatres in that area. I would certainly find it helpful if the audit process showed not just the part of the picture in which waiting times targets, which are a legally entrenched right, are missed but the investment decisions that each health board has taken in order to address the problem.I do not know whether there is a role for the cabinet secretary in that regard or whether we need to raise the issue with the Auditor General. However, as far as audit scrutiny is concerned—and, as a member of the Health and Sport Committee, I know that its scrutiny of the matter is very different—can you give us any information or signpost us to anything that would allow us to look at the health boards that are doing well and those that might have capacity or financial issues, consider what they are doing to address those issues and find out whether that sort of thing can be quantified in a way that we can audit and scrutinise?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Absolutely. We will send you the full list but let me give you some examples, starting with Grampian and Lothian, of what we are doing.NHS Grampian has invested £18 million in a programme to increase capacity by building three new theatres and employing more doctors, nurses and support staff. That project has been planned over this year, and its final phases will be completed shortly. NHS Lothian has a £37 million investment plan for increasing internal capacity over the next three years, and it reckons that it will reach the treatment time guarantee by the end of the financial year.We have provided NHS boards with £29 million specifically to deal with waiting times in the current year, and you might have noticed that yesterday I announced an additional £1.5 million for increasing capacity at the Golden Jubilee hospital. Of the 1,500 extra operations that will be carried out at that hospital as a result, 1,200 will be for cataracts and 300 will be for joint replacements.I can give you more examples from my list. NHS Ayrshire and Arran is investing around £9.7 million in recruiting 13.5 whole-time-equivalent consultants, nursing and other clinical support staff to increase capacity in orthopaedics, cardiology and oral and maxillofacial services. Borders is investing £1.46 million for the same purpose, Dumfries and Galloway £2 million and Fife an additional £2.3 million. All that is on top of their normal investment programmes. Supplying the committee with a full list and that information will not be a problem.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

That would be very helpful, cabinet secretary. When the committee returns to the issue this time next year or whatever the appropriate time might be, the question in my head will be whether, given the levels of investment that you have identified, there has been any improvement. If there has, that will be fantastic and we will recognise that; if not, we will certainly ask questions about why the money has not been used in the most appropriate and effective way. If you can provide the committee with a list setting out a financial sum for each health board and a summary of their action plans using those finances, we will be able to audit whether that money has been used effectively to meet their 12-week guarantee.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

I am glad that the whole committee shares that commitment.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

A recurring theme that the committee has noticed is the availability and quality of information on which decisions are being taken. Clearly there is a deficiency across the public sector in the way that figures are being produced—and indeed a question whether they are being produced at all. Page 24 of the report says:“ISD Scotland is developing an electronic benchmarking tool of key indicators”.I note that“The ... tool will be available from January 2014”but are there any implementation dates for the different health boards?Moreover, paragraph 41 of the report says:“NHS boards should continue to improve their own internal monitoring.”Clearly the boards are having to build on their current systems in order to produce meaningful figures, but are we satisfied that the process is being adequately monitored and driven forward?10:00

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The NHS’s electronic benchmarking system is up and running. Indeed, yesterday, John Connaghan, who has overall responsibility for performance and delivery, and I were going through a number of areas, looking at the benchmarking of certain procedures and how well some boards were doing compared with others. Now that the system is up and running, we are benchmarking regularly to compare boards and find out where some could do better.Of course, we benchmark not just procedures. We also benchmark the use of prescription drugs, the bill for which will be about £1.3 billion this year for the national health service, because we reckon that if every health board was as good as the best we could save a significant amount of money. In implementing the Auditor General’s recommendations for saving £26 million by doing certain things, we are, in that benchmarking exercise, also looking at how we can improve on those savings. After all, we want to save money where we can and ensure that it goes to front-line services.Similarly, I draw your attention to the report on the NHS estates that we published last Friday and which contains a very interesting table summarising the benchmarking of certain costs right across the health service, broken down by board. For example, it compares cleaning costs per square metre and sets out the range of costs across the boards in that respect. We are benchmarking that information to find out where we can get better value for money by getting those boards whose costs are out of line into line with best practice. All that work is being driven by the electronic version of the benchmarking information that you mentioned; in fact, it is allowing us to step on the accelerator.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

That sounds like good news.My only other question is about whistleblowing procedures, which the committee has discussed at length in the past. Of course, everyone has referred to the whistleblowing in the Lothians. Can you assure us that such procedures are in place across the whole of the NHS and that they would prevent the recurrence of the situation that happened in NHS Lothian?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Absolutely. We have put in place very robust whistleblowing policies and procedures. For a start, we have the whistleblowing line. Ironically, we get more calls from the rest of the UK than we do from Scotland, but we cannot do anything about them.As I have iterated time and again when given the opportunity, I want people who see anything going wrong in the national health service or any practice being applied that should not be to blow the whistle. In fact, they have a legal duty to do so if something is going wrong or if some practice or malpractice is taking place.Secondly, I want to ensure—and we are ensuring—that there is no victimisation of any whistleblower. It is important for people to know that, if they blow the whistle, there will be no adverse impact on their career opportunities or any other aspect of their work for the NHS.With regard to confidentiality agreements and gagging orders, the Daily Mail—a wonderful, wonderful newspaper that I would be the last to criticise—does not seem to be able to make the distinction between a confidentiality agreement and a gagging clause that does not permit a person to disclose malpractice or whatever. Gagging clauses are illegal, and we do not do them. We still have confidentiality agreements, which are very often put in place at the request of the person who is signing them with us because there might be something about their own medical information or something else that they do not want to become public knowledge.We are looking at what more we can do to make the policy even more robust, because I am absolutely determined to get to a situation in which people know that we will not sanction in any way anyone trying to gag a current or former employee, or anyone else related to the national health service, who wants to blow the whistle on something. I make that absolutely clear.I will make something else clear, too. I have been looking at the information that is available to the Auditor General and, indeed, to this committee, and at the information that is available on confidentiality agreements in parallel organisations south of the border. I have asked officials to work with the Auditor General and this committee to ensure that both the Auditor General and the committee get whatever financial information is needed from confidentiality agreements to allow you to do your job of scrutinising public spending. That is another example of my being very keen to give—where I can, and in the spirit and the legal requirements of confidentiality agreements—both the Auditor General and this committee the information that they need to do their job.I have asked Paul Gray and his team to look at that and to discuss with the Auditor General and the committee how best we can make that happen.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I will continue the same line of questioning, if I may. I welcome your comments, cabinet secretary. I think that people will be encouraged, at least, by your intention in this regard. However, I am not quite sure that what you describe is happening in practice. Were you pleased to see the decline in the use of unavailability codes, which the Auditor General flagged up in her report?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

A lot of the unavailability is patient unavailability. In terms of the treatment time guarantee, patients have the right to say that they are not available because, for example, they are on holiday or on some business. We have tightened up the system enormously compared with the previous system. We have implemented the Auditor General’s recommendations to ensure that unavailability codes cannot be abused in any way or used to hide anything that is going on that should not be going on in measuring the time that it takes for people to get their treatment.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Can you clarify that you agree that the codes were misused by NHS Lothian?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I do not think that there is any doubt about that. I think that the report into NHS Lothian made that absolutely clear. Obviously, we have all learned a lot of lessons from the NHS Lothian experience. As you know, we have been working in a very detailed way with the Health and Sport Committee to ensure that we now have a much more robust system for ensuring that we have validated statistics and information to measure waiting times for patients.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I am glad that there is a new system. The Auditor General highlighted in her report that the general use of unavailability codes began to decline after it was identified as a problem in NHS Lothian; she also pointed out that that was not because it was revealed by scrutiny. In other words, she could not reveal the misuse of unavailability codes through audit, and it was revealed by a whistleblower. Do you accept that that is what happened?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I think that we all know that what happened in NHS Lothian was an abuse of the system. We have taken appropriate action. For example, the chief executive at the time is no longer with NHS Lothian. I think that my predecessor took very decisive action to deal with the NHS Lothian situation.In her report last year, the Auditor General did a complete review of the way in which we measure waiting times across all NHS boards. Although she was critical of some of the systems, a paper audit that was done to see whether any fiddling was going on found that there was no fiddling in any board other than what had taken place in NHS Lothian. I think that the Auditor General is now satisfied on that issue.Of course, we are improving the systems all the time. In NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, for example, when we came in in 2007 11 different information technology systems were being used to measure waiting times in Glasgow. We have got that down this year to one IT system. That is one way in which we can ensure the authenticity of the information that we are being given.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I just ask again: were you pleased by, and do you recognise the importance of, the whistleblower in revealing the misuse of unavailability codes?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Absolutely. I have just said that I want people who see malpractice to whistleblow, because I am not here to defend malpractice in any way, shape or form.I have had discussions with whistleblowers, some of whom have felt in the past as though they have been victimised. Where I, or any of us, can ensure that that does not happen, we will do so. I have made it absolutely clear on more than one occasion and in writing to every chair, board and chief executive throughout the national health service in Scotland that people who blow the whistle should be welcomed and we should listen to what they are saying and check it out to see whether it stacks up. We should ensure that people who blow the whistle are in no way victimised within or by the national health service or anyone working within it.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

In that case, why is a confidentiality agreement inserted automatically in every single settlement arrangement or compromise agreement within the NHS?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That has been standard procedure for a long time. As I said, I am looking at how we can be more robust. I am quite happy about looking at whether we can relax some of the procedures in terms of confidentiality agreements. There are of course legal implications. We need to be very cognisant of employment law and various other things. However, the one thing that I should stress is that even where there is a confidentiality agreement, the information on whistleblowing-type activity is specifically included in the agreement. It is written in that the person cannot in any way have action taken against them.If someone signs a confidentiality agreement as part of a settlement, and they leave the employ of the national health service and the next day they phone up the newspapers or get in touch with a local MSP to whistleblow, that would not be a breach of the confidentiality agreement and no action could be taken against them per the confidentiality agreement. No action would be taken against them; in fact, I would welcome such whistleblowing, because I think that where there is malpractice, people should blow the whistle.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

In that case, do you recognise that in a confidentiality agreement it is illegal for someone to even declare that there is a confidentiality agreement?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That is one of the areas that I am looking at. Obviously, this is historical because confidentiality agreements have grown up over time. I am looking at whether, even leaving aside the gagging issue, they are too restrictive. I am reviewing that at present.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

You suggested earlier that very often the agreements are inserted at the request of the individual concerned.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

In how many cases do individuals request confidentiality agreements?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Over the past three years we have signed 150 or so confidentiality agreements.

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

It is 148.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Sorry. I was two out. I do not have to hand the exact number of cases when an employee asked for the confidentiality agreement, but I am happy to see whether we can provide that, provided of course that doing so would not breach part of the confidentially agreement.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Interestingly, in your written response to the committee, you said that of the 148 settlement agreements over the past couple of years“all but one contained a confidentiality clause”. That sounds to me like it is automatic.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Well, perhaps I should ask Mr Gray this. I asked Mr Gray this question at our previous meeting, and it was in a letter that the committee sent to you, cabinet secretary. There have been 697—almost 700—of these agreements over the past five years. The specific question that we asked was how many of those contained confidentiality agreements.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I will let Paul Gray answer that.

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

Mr Macintosh, as I explained in my letter, the data is held by the boards. In an attempt to be helpful to the committee, I asked them to go back to the 2011-12 financial year for the data. I genuinely do not want to put in front of the committee information that is inaccurate or unvalidated, but my understanding is that the 697 agreements referred to included a number that were not in fact to do with settlements outside the normal early severance scheme. There was some confusion in relation to the response on that number, which I think was given via a freedom of information request.What I sought to provide to the committee was as accurate a number as I could back to 2011-12. That number is 148, of which 147 did, as you say, contain a confidentiality agreement. As I said to you when we spoke about this at my evidence session on 29 January, that is one of the issues that I have been discussing with the cabinet secretary. He has made clear that he will take a view on that level of usage of confidentiality agreements. When that view is reached, I have no doubt that the cabinet secretary will inform the committee.10:15

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I am sure that the committee is pleased that you found out about the 148 agreements going back over the past couple of years. Can you conduct the same exercise going back to 2007-08 for this committee?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

If I can, I will.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Thank you. Given that 147 of the 148 agreements in the past couple of years have contained confidentiality clauses, how many of the 697 agreements over the past five years do you think contain confidentiality clauses?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I am not prepared to answer that until I have done the exercise, Mr Macintosh. I would like to put accurate information in front of the committee.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Given that 147 of the 148 agreements contained confidentiality clauses, do you think that it is almost a matter of automatic policy?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

It appears to be so.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

So do you think that maybe the vast majority—maybe 99 per cent—of the 697 agreements contain confidentiality clauses too? Is that a likely scenario?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I would be speculating, but it is probable.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

The cabinet secretary stated earlier that very often such clauses are inserted at the request of the individuals concerned. Can you give me any examples of that?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I said that sometimes they are inserted at the request of individuals.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

No, cabinet secretary, you said that they are very often inserted at the request of the individual concerned. Those were your exact words—“very often”. How many examples do you think you will be able to find of individuals requesting such clauses, given that they are automatically inserted in every agreement?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

It would be very difficult to get a precise figure, but we will see whether we can give some indication to the committee of the number of requests—

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Cabinet secretary, why did you say that the clauses are very often inserted at the request of the individual concerned if you cannot back that up with any evidence whatsoever?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I am just going by the anecdotal evidence that I have collected in my 18 months in this job. When I have spoken to individuals as well as to people on the health boards, I have heard that sometimes there is information that the individuals themselves do not want to be disclosed.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

So—hang on a second—we have gone from the statement that they are “very often” inserted at the individual’s request to the statement that you understand, anecdotally, that they are “sometimes” inserted at the individual’s request. Is that right?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I am saying that confidentiality agreements should not be abused. They cannot legally include gagging orders. When people leave the national health service under difficult circumstances, traditionally—going right back through many previous Administrations—confidentiality agreements are drawn up. That is not new; it has been done for many, many years.Sometimes, the individual does not want to have some of the information released, apparently, but obviously, there has been no statistical collection to date of the level of detail that you are looking for. We will establish whether we can quantify the number of times that there have been specific requests from the person signing the confidentiality agreement. If we cannot quantify that, we will come back to you.I meet patients, staff and NHS people generally day in, day out in this job and, obviously, I have 15 years’ experience of hearing from constituents as an MSP as well. I am telling you that, certainly, a number of people have told me over the years—both people who have signed agreements on behalf of the health board and people who have been signatories—that there were elements within the contract that the individual concerned did not want to be released to the public.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Health secretary, you are saying that this has been going on for years and that—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The confidentiality agreements have been standing practice for a long time.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

You say that you have no statistical information but that you would like to try to gather some. Perhaps I can refer you to my own parliamentary questions on this issue, because the use of compromise agreements in the NHS has been rising over the past few years, particularly since 2007. Perhaps you could refer to the answers to those questions. The point is that this involves an extensive use of public money. How much money do you think is spent—or could you find out how much is spent—enforcing or including these confidentiality clauses in NHS contracts?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

As I said earlier, I am happy—unlike any of my predecessors—to get any information on the costs to the Auditor General and to the committee to allow the committee whatever information it needs to do the proper scrutiny. I am further reviewing the role of confidentiality clauses precisely because I have concerns that they may be unnecessary or overrestrictive in many cases. One of the reasons why the number has gone up is that there has been a substantial increase in the number of people who are employed in the national health service since we came to power.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Will you find out exactly how much is being spent on enforcing gagging clauses?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

If the figure can be obtained, we will be happy to share it with the committee. I honestly doubt that it can be obtained, but we will ask the central legal office.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I may ask you later to comment on the cases of Dr Jane Hamilton and Mr Rab Wilson, who has petitioned the Parliament.How many public interest disclosures, or protected disclosures, have there been in the NHS in the past five years?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

We can give you that information—we will try to get it for you.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Do you believe that any of the 697 people who have signed confidentiality agreements has made a protected disclosure?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

We will come back to you on that. I will not give you information that I have not checked out beforehand.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Does the use of these clauses encourage an attitude of transparency in the NHS, which you spoke about earlier?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

One of the reasons why I—unlike any of my predecessors—am reviewing their use is that I want to ensure that they are not being used to hide what should be transparent. I am sure that many such agreements were signed when Mr Henry was a junior health minister.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Well, the agreements were not signed by the minister, but they would have been signed at that time.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Does the health service in Scotland have anything to learn from the Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust scandal in particular?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Absolutely. We have responded not just to the Mid Staffordshire situation but to subsequent reviews, such as the Keogh inquiry and the Berwick inquiry that followed it. Professor Leitch was a member of the team that was chaired by Professor Don Berwick, who describes the health service in Scotland as the safest in the world.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Is legal protection for whistleblowers as strong in Scotland as it now is in England?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I am not legally qualified to make a judgment on that. You will have to ask a lawyer.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Before I bring in Tavish Scott, I note that Mr Connaghan told the committee twice that he was the whistleblower in the NHS Lothian situation. Why did a senior member of your management team have to use the whistleblowing process to rectify a problem?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Mr Connaghan said that he identified the problem in reviewing the management of information. I am happy for him to expand on that.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Before he comes in, I will give you his exact words.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

He said:“I can remember exactly what happened with NHS Lothian because I was the whistleblower.” He went on to say:“That report was made public in, I think, March 2012. As I said, I was the whistleblower.”—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 29 January 2014; c 2097.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

As I said, my interpretation of that—John Connaghan can speak for himself—was that he, as the person who has primary responsibility for reviewing performance in delivering information, identified that there was a problem.

John Connaghan Scottish Government
link

I am happy to amplify that, convener. In any such complex situation, there are a number of layers. It is true to say that unfair offers by NHS Lothian of treatment by an English healthcare provider were identified, so we need to acknowledge that the very first issue was raised by a member of the public, probably around October 2011.However, there is a world of difference between that issue and the issue of the deliberate manipulation of statistics that eventually unravelled in NHS Lothian. It is in that respect that I made my remarks about being a whistleblower on the matter. I have checked my assumptions on that with the investigating officer in NHS Lothian, with ISD Scotland and with my team. It is clear that deliberate manipulation was uncovered by that team, so I am happy to stand with some degree of humility alongside the other whistleblowers in that situation.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Was there someone other than you who was the whistleblower?

John Connaghan Scottish Government
link

I am not quite sure, but I certainly recall what we did in the team that uncovered the deliberate manipulation. I am not aware of anyone else who wrote to NHS Lothian at that time to say that that area needed to be subjected to detailed internal audits; I referred at the previous committee meeting to my letter of 6 January.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Does the health service keep a record of whistleblower complaints?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

In the sense that we have a register?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

We do not per se, because the whistleblowing takes place primarily in the boards. Each board would be able to tell you how many times someone has raised an issue internally.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

But there is a whistleblowing procedure—is that correct?

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

When someone uses the whistleblowing procedure, is a record kept of the complaint that is made?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Each board will have its own record, yes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Right. So NHS Lothian will have a record of the whistleblowing complaints that have been made.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Will the records show that, on the matter that we are discussing, Mr Connaghan—and not anyone else—was the whistleblower?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

No, convener—you know fine that that is not the case. Mr Connaghan was operating as the director for delivery and performance, and he was using the word “whistleblowing” in a slightly different context.We are having an adult conversation about whistleblowing, and we are talking about people working in national health service boards who see malpractice and report it. Mr Connaghan’s job is to audit the performance of each board. In that respect he said that he was, in essence, the equivalent of the whistleblower.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

No, no, no—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

You are playing with words, quite frankly.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

I am not playing with words. You are trying to introduce words that were not there, such as “in essence.” Ken Macintosh asked Mr Connaghan a very specific question—he asked:“Are you suggesting that the whistleblowing about NHS Lothian had nothing to do with what happened?”John Connaghan said:“I can remember exactly what happened ... because I was the whistleblower.”He then repeated that, saying:“As I said, I was the whistleblower.”—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 29 January 2014; c 2097. That was all in the context of a discussion about whistleblowing. You have told me today that NHS boards keep a register of whistleblowing. Mr Connaghan has said that he was—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I did not say that boards keep a register; I said that they will have a record of every case.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Okay—they will have a record. So we can go back to NHS Lothian and ask for that record, and ask the board to confirm that Mr Connaghan was in fact the whistleblower. He did not say “in essence”—he said, “I was the whistleblower”, twice.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Fine—why don’t you do that, then?

John Connaghan Scottish Government
link

I will make a suggestion. I said that the NHS situation was complex, like peeling back the layers of an onion. It may well be worth your while asking NHS Lothian to give you a sequence of events.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Never let it be said that this committee is not full of entertainment and liveliness.Cabinet secretary, you mentioned NHS Lothian in the context of investment planning to deal with the treatment time guarantee. The letter that Paul Gray helpfully provided to the committee states:“NHS Lothian has the biggest backlog, and as the Committee is aware, is making use of private sector facilIties to manage this down. I expect a significant reduction in the use of the private sector as their internal capacity comes on stream.”That is a statement of fact about what is currently happening.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

How much will the use come down by? Do you accept that there will always be some degree of private sector involvement in NHS Lothian?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Not just in NHS Lothian. There are certain types of services that are available only in the private sector, for various reasons, so there will always be a small private sector contribution in the health service in Scotland.However, the latest available figures, from last year, show that 0.8 per cent of our budget was used in the private sector, which can be compared with a figure of 11 per cent south of the border. For the purposes of this conversation we would not define the private sector as including GP contractors or dental contractors; we are talking about the use of private hospitals and so on.With regard to capacity in NHS Lothian, two things are happening. First, we are improving the capacity in the NHS. I have referred to the Golden Jubilee hospital—where patients from the Lothian area are prepared to go there, that facility is made available.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

But it is a statement of fact, as you have indicated, that the private sector will have a small but significant role in continuing to manage the complex issue that NHS Lothian and other boards are facing.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Yes. Indeed, as part of the local delivery planning guidance, I have asked every health board to review their use of the private sector with a view to reducing that use, particularly where the capacity exists in the national health service in Scotland. There is little point in our using taxpayers’ money to double fund capacity, in effect, if capacity exists in the health service.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Will you be so good as to keep the committee updated with that programme?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I have a question about the difference between the 12 weeks and the 18 weeks that you helpfully mentioned in your earlier remarks to the convener. Does the NHS keep statistics on the period between 12 weeks and 18 weeks?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

We measure the whole thing, and ISD regularly publishes validated figures on waiting times. We publish information on how many people are seen within the 18-week period. There is a threshold of 10 per cent, and in recent times we have consistently met that, with over 90 per cent of people being seen within 18 weeks.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

But there is no legal attachment to the 18-week period. It is purely—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

That is correct. The only legal attachment is to the 12-week period.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

It may be that most patients are seen within 18 weeks—90 per cent are, according to your figures. However, do you accept that, for most patients—for you and me and our constituents—the period between first seeing a GP and seeing a consultant is just as important as the 12-week period that is covered by the legal guarantee?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

So why not have a legal guarantee for the full 18-week period?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Again, we are going over the discussion that took place during the passage of the bill.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

As you know, there were various opinions at that time on whether we should have any targets. Some people took the position that there should be no targets in statute. The Government’s position was that, because of the particular concern around the period from referral for treatment to receipt of treatment, we should put a target for that into statute, but that was the only target that we would put in statute. That debate was had at the time, at stages 1, 2 and 3 of the bill.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I understand and accept that. I did not agree at the time, and I made my position clear, but—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I do not have any quotes from you, Tavish.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Don’t tempt me. I presume that you accept that, when ordinary folk go to their GP to get sorted out because something is wrong with them, that is where it starts.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

You have made some strong statements this morning about wanting to review particular areas of NHS policy. Ken Macintosh has just raised that with you. If you believe in the point about a legal guarantee, is there not a public expectation and desire, which you have been keen to mention this morning in relation to the 12-week period, for a guarantee for the full journey from the point at which the person sees their GP?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Absolutely. If people go to their GP and the GP says that they need to see a consultant, they will obviously want to see the consultant as soon as possible, particularly if certain conditions that are potentially life threatening are suspected. As you know, we have the specific 31-day and 62-day targets for cancer. That reflects the degree of anxiety felt by anyone who has suspected cancer. We do not have a parallel target for every condition under the sun. If you have a wart on your finger that needs to be burned off, the anxiety about that will be a lot less than the anxiety about other, potentially serious illnesses. We have the generic 12-week and 18-week targets, and then, for example, we have the two cancer targets of 31 days and 62 days.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

But the Government has no plans to bring forward legislation in relation to the 18-week period. It is just a target.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I have absolutely no plans to extend legal guarantees.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Thank you. I have a further question about this area. I presume that you accept that you are putting health boards under some significant ministerial pressure in relation to meeting the statutory targets. You said that clearly to the convener and the committee this morning. Does that have consequences for how boards deal with all the other responsibilities that they have to deal with, not least the financial ones?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I am keen to ensure two things. The first is that we plan appropriately for the national health service. We are working on the 2020 strategy. We have the vision and the route map, and we are working on the detailed plan for how we will realise the vision for 2020. We carry out fairly regular reviews of the health improvement, efficiency and governance, access and treatment targets and standards—indeed, we are about to start one—and I am anxious to ensure that we meet the targets. We have to achieve the treatment time guarantee target, but I want to do it in such a way that we do not misallocate resource or prioritise areas that should not be prioritised vis-à-vis other areas that should be prioritised. Indeed, that is built in to the legislation at an individual level.Secondly, I want to make sure that the way in which we achieve targets is driven by clinical judgment not just by bureaucratic targets set by politicians, and that is obvious in the way in which we issue guidance and try to manage these targets. For example, one of the reasons why we have the threshold for the 18-week target is that there is an element of clinical judgment. Cataract operations are a very good example. I am not a medic and Jason Leitch can correct me if I am wrong, but I am told that if someone has had a cataract operation in one eye, a minimum period of time should pass before they have the operation for the cataract in the second eye. It would not be the right thing to do, clinically, to have that second operation too quickly after the first. There might well be a target for that operation, but clinical judgment must reign supreme because it is the right thing for the patient.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

That is fair. I asked you a general question and you gave me a general answer.The reason that I raised the subject of oncology in Aberdeen for parliamentary debate was because of my concern, which I think is understandable, about patients from the northern isles being transferred to other places, including Little France and NHS Lothian. I have been told by health professionals and managers in the system that some of those transfers were caused simply by targets. The managers were under pressure. How will you rationalise a process that puts a huge amount of ministerial and bureaucratic pressure on health boards to deliver when, as you rightly say, they have to make clinical judgments all the time?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

First, before we set the targets, we obviously take into consideration the need to ensure that we are not cutting across what should be the right clinical judgment. That is why we consult widely before we establish a target or a standard.Secondly, we review targets and standards from time to time. For example, I recently had a discussion with the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Glasgow about the application of targets to make sure that they are not undermining the role of clinical judgment. I want to be sure that none of our targets do that. That is why, for example, the threshold on the 18-week target prevents that pressure from building up.On oncology in the north of Scotland, we have had an issue around the availability of oncologist specialist consultants, and we are recruiting vigorously to fill those vacancies. I think that I am right in saying that there is a particular challenge in the north of Scotland and the rest of the UK in recruiting colorectal oncologists. There seems to be a particular shortage of them. When something like that happens, particularly when we are talking about cancer, rather than wait until we have recruited new oncologists, we make sure that patients are treated elsewhere in the system so that they get the treatment that they require as a matter of clinical urgency.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I have one final question on information relating to the monitoring of performance. The matter was raised by the Audit Scotland report. It is about ISD publishing detailed data back to October 2012 to address trend analysis for the period in relation to the Patient Rights (Scotland) Act 2011. Is that what is going to happen?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I am not charge of when official statistics come out. There is now the UK Statistics Authority and the UK statistics code. ISD, I and all my officials are governed by the codes. We provide ISD with all the relevant support, co-operation and information that we can, but it has to follow the code and all the instructions from the UK Statistics Authority.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I understand that. The committee is being told that all NHS boards will be providing detailed waiting time data to ISD by April this year, which is two months later than was reported to Audit Scotland, and that data will not be published until the end of August 2014. Is that your understanding of the position?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Yes. That is because, once we supply the information, my understanding is that it then has to go through the validation procedure that is laid down by the UK Statistics Authority.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

So it will be published in the summer, by August 2014.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Cabinet secretary, in your opening remarks you talked about the financial performance of NHS boards and you said that all boards met their targets. We know that the NHS in Scotland is an £11-billion-a-year service and that, overall, the service reported surpluses and actually made some savings. However, one of the recommendations in the Auditor General’s report was to look at the flexibility in setting the financial annual resource limits. Is it in the Scottish Government’s current thinking to allow the boards a bit more flexibility from one year to the next to plan their work?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Absolutely. At present, it is like trying to land a helicopter on the eye of a needle at the end of every financial year in every board area. Within our powers, we have as much flexibility as is required among the boards. We have 22 boards plus the central agencies and the Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland. From time to time, particularly towards the year end, it is necessary to reallocate funds, vire funds or brokerage funds internally, and we do that. A good example relates to the Victoria hospital project in Fife. The completion date was slightly behind schedule, so the original financial plan for Fife was affected. We therefore took action to ensure that NHS Fife had the necessary funding to complete the Victoria and that that did not affect the on-going provision for existing patients and facilities in Fife. That is a fairly standard part of the financial management.We think that the best way of facilitating our ability to do that more is the budget exchange mechanism, which would allow us to carry forward in the order of £30 million towards the end of the year. If we allow the health boards themselves to carry forward funding, there is a danger that they will start to build up reserves. In the college sector, some colleges built up very large reserves that were not being spent on college provision, and I do not want the same thing to happen in the health service. We think that using the budget exchange mechanism is a better way to work. I ask John Matheson to explain it in more detail.

John Matheson Scottish Government
link

I have a couple of points. We have flexibility at the moment, although we welcome the Auditor General’s comments. We focus on long-term financial planning, but the artificiality of having to deliver something by 31 March each year can run counter to that. We agree three to five-year financial plans with boards and look at their financial planning assumptions.The brokerage and the banking arrangements that the cabinet secretary referred to are designed to allow boards some flexibility, in recognition that they might have double-running costs. For example, that happened when NHS Forth Valley moved to the new hospital in Larbert, and we are in discussions with NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde as it looks to the commissioning of the south Glasgow development in a couple of years. We are considering the double-running costs that will be involved in that and whether the board can bank some money with us. We have a similar arrangement in relation to Dumfries and Galloway royal infirmary.We are in discussions with colleagues in the Scottish Government on how the budget exchange mechanism could further support that approach. Within the £12 billion that we spend, it would give further flexibility centrally and more weight to the movement away from having to deliver on 31 March each year. It works well at Scottish Government level, so we are discussing with colleagues giving that flexibility to the health and social care directorate.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Overall, on a year-by-year basis, the boards still have to broadly stay within their allocations. If all the boards reported an overspend next year, the alarm bells might ring in this committee. In the context of the flexibility that you are talking about, how would we get the sense that that was not an issue and that the measures had been approved and agreed? If something like that happened, how would we get the sense that an alarm bell should not ring?10:45

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

We monitor the situation throughout the year, and John Matheson and his team are in regular touch with the finance people in each of the health boards. We look not only at the money that is already committed but at the balance that is available for the rest of the year, to ensure that they stay within budget. If there is a challenge, such as arose at Larbert or at the new Victoria hospital in Fife, or with the Greater Glasgow NHS Board’s project, which is the largest health building project in the entirety of Europe—£842 million is a lot of money even for Greater Glasgow—we manage that challenge in conjunction with the health boards to ensure that the cash flow and commitments are in tune with the plan. As John Matheson said, if we need to brokerage a bit of funding, particularly towards the end of the financial year, we have the flexibility to do that.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Turning to waiting times, there has been discussion around the table about the 98 per cent compliance with the guarantee. I only ever achieved a 98 per cent exam mark in my first year at university and I was absolutely delighted with that, but I have never achieved such a mark since then. That is a fantastic performance, but some of today’s discussion seems to suggest that it is a problem. I do not think that it is a problem, if health boards are genuinely pursuing the 100 per cent target, as they are legally required to do. The 98 per cent compliance rate that has been achieved is a fantastic performance by the NHS. You referred to times gone past when people would wait months or even years before getting treatment. I would like to ask a more general question about the impact on the nation’s health. What has the introduction of targets such as 18 weeks or 12 weeks done in terms of benefit to the health of the nation and driving forward improvement?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

For individuals, the result has been enhanced health outcomes. One thing for which we do not have a specific target, but where we are keen to make progress, is reducing the amount of time that people need to spend in hospital for any procedure. The longer someone spends in hospital, the worse their health outcomes will be compared with what could be expected if they spent less time in hospital. That seems ironic, but that is the truth of the matter, not just in Scotland but internationally. The first benefit of improvements in meeting the targets is enhanced health outcomes, particularly for those with life-threatening conditions such as cancer. We still have a long way to go to be as good as the best in Europe on survival rates for lung cancer, for example, but we are in a far better position than we have ever been with lung, bowel, breast and other main cancers. Secondly, there is a huge benefit to the economy because if somebody is on a waiting list for months before they can get a procedure and they have to be off work during that period, they lose income and they may have to go on long-term sick pay, at a cost to the exchequer, and their health will deteriorate until the procedure is done. There can be a significant financial loss to the individual in such circumstances, but there is also a big financial loss to the state, so the quicker we can get people into hospital and get their procedures done, and the quicker those who are in work can get back to work, the more everybody benefits. Companies benefit, the economy benefits and the individual benefits financially; the financial benefit is huge.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

You said that there are clinical reasons behind the 12-week target. I do not understand why it is 12 rather than 10, 11 or 13. I previously asked how quickly we pick up people after 12 weeks if they have not been seen within that period. Sometimes when we set a target, we forget to collect information at the tail end. I know that Mr Gray responded to the question in his letter, but as a member of the Public Audit Committee I am keen to keep a close eye on the issue. If something is medically important about 12 weeks, I would be keen to see some response about how we pick up those for whom the target is not met and how we perform in treating them.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I can give you that statistic. I am looking for it now, but I am sure that John Connaghan will have it. What is the percentage of people who are treated within 15 weeks?

John Connaghan Scottish Government
link

The answer was in Mr Gray’s letter. I think that it was over 99 per cent.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

So nearly all the people were seen within 15 weeks.

John Connaghan Scottish Government
link

One of the hidden benefits of having a relatively tight performance regime on waiting times is encapsulated in the reference to transforming the patient pathway in the document “18 weeks: The Referral to Treatment Standard”. One benefit has been a transformation in the amount of day-case surgery, which has benefited patients and is making the NHS a little more efficient and productive. There are hidden benefits from transforming the system, making the entire journey a little slicker and pushing the boundaries of clinical practice.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

Professor Leitch has not had a chance to speak. He can say a word or two about the health benefits of the targets.

Professor Jason Leitch Scottish Government
link

Apart from the benefits that have been mentioned, we know for sure that healthy life expectancy is increasing and that in-patient hospital mortality is reducing. That is partly the result of the increased work on healthcare-associated infections, the Scottish patient safety programme and other things that we have done in the healthcare system, but it is also partly the result of treating people earlier.Someone who waits two years for a hip replacement is likely to get comorbidities in those two years—their heart disease or lung disease might get worse, for example. If we treat the initial cause more quickly, people get out of hospital more quickly and they are healthier when they are out as they can undertake their normal activities. Early treatment of acute disease is better for the individual and for the population’s health.John Connaghan is correct to say that such an approach is more efficient. If someone is treated earlier for their hip replacement, their wisdom teeth or whatever they are waiting for treatment for, they are healthier when they have the treatment, which is much better than waiting longer, when the person will be sicker. If they are sicker, they are in hospital for longer. That is bad for the patient and their family and for the system, because it is less efficient and less productive. More efficiency means that we can use the hospital service for the correct people—the people who need that care—at the time when they require it.The surgical mortality rate in Scotland has fallen by a quarter in the past three years. I am not aware of such a reduction anywhere else in the world. That is partly the result of what we have done on safety and quality, but I have no doubt that it is also a response to the fact that we are treating people more quickly.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I am hearing that the health service is performing well and is delivering positive health outcomes for the population. How far can we push that? Should we worry about the health of a person whose treatment has not met the 12-week target? How far can we push the improvement in performance? I know that budgets are not infinite and that some degree of sense must be applied. One day in the future, could we bring down the 12-week limit?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

The profile is one of rising demand and increasing complexity. The ageing population has two consequences for health policy. The first is a significant increase in comorbidity, because people are living long enough to develop more ailments. The second is an increase in long-term conditions.I will give you an idea of the volume that we are dealing with. We reckon that, at any one time, half Scotland’s population is engaged with the national health service. That might be for a repeat prescription or for something terminal. Of the adult population in Scotland, 46 per cent have a long-term condition. We are dealing with about 1.75 million A and E presentations a year. Every year, somebody sees a doctor more than 30 million times—I should add that that is not the same person. Last year, for the first time in the history of the national health service in Scotland, more than 1 million admissions to hospital—some were repeat admissions—were made. That is a record.I have a very interesting graph, which we would be happy to supply to the committee, showing what is happening elsewhere in the UK on waiting times. The graph, which is produced by the Office for National Statistics and is not based on Scottish Government statistics, sets out the “90th Percentile waits (unadjusted) for ONS’s 11 key procedures” for Scotland, England, Wales and Northern Ireland. For hip replacement, we are the best in the UK, England is second, Wales is third and Northern Ireland is fourth; patients in Wales are waiting twice as long as patients in Scotland. The same is true for knee replacement procedures, while the position on cataract operations is much the same. Wales and Northern Ireland face deep problems in angioplasty waiting times. In the graph, Scotland has shorter waiting times for almost every single one of the 11 procedures. The only exception is endoscope of bladder, for which our waiting times are slightly behind those in England, but in every other case, Scotland is ahead of the rest of the United Kingdom. In the case of varicose surgery, if I hold the graph up, you can see Scotland’s waiting time in blue, with England’s in red—perhaps those colours should be the other way around—Wales’s is in green and Northern Ireland’s is in grey. By any standard, the service that we are providing in Scotland is far superior to anywhere else in the United Kingdom.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I would like to see that graph at some stage.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

We are happy to provide this information to the committee and let members see how well we are doing.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

I have a final question. To return to the 12-week waiting time guarantee, when we achieve that target in 100 per cent of cases Public Audit Committee members will inevitably ask whether we can get any better and where the scope is to improve the guarantee. For example, if a medical intervention is needed, should we ask you to reduce the guarantee to 11 or 10 weeks? What happens after we reach the guarantee in 100 per cent of cases? How do we improve the situation?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I would rephrase your question to ask how, at a strategic level, we improve further the health outcomes of the Scottish population, rather than to ask for a discussion on the targets. At the end of the day, the strategic objective is to improve the health outcomes of the Scottish population. We are doing loads of things in that regard. The whole patient flow is changing right across the system and turnaround times are improving dramatically in A and E and elsewhere. We could give you a list—it would be endless—of all the initiatives that we are taking, including improvements to the use of theatres, providing a 24/7 service in many areas and so on and so forth.In addition, many of the leading developments in the life sciences sector will have a revolutionary impact on healthcare in Scotland. We are at the cutting edge of those developments. For example, the Glasgow Southern general hospital campus will not just include a new £842 million hospital, which will be the largest in Europe and where 10,000 patients and employees will be based at any one time, but include a new centre for what the European Union has renamed precision medicine. That will initially focus on better ways to treat cancer.I will give you an indication of what precision medicine refers to, although I will ask Jason Leitch to give you more information. Precision medicine will treat a person based on their DNA and their genetic make-up. We are getting so precise with treatment that if, for example, you have a tumour, your treatment will eventually be tailored not just to your DNA make-up but to the genetic composition of the tumour. The new centre puts Scotland at the cutting edge; indeed, we are the world leader in that field. Similarly, we will be investing even more heavily in imaging technology.We are very keen to pursue those new technologies as soon as possible because their impacts are transformational on how we will treat people in the future. Therefore, we should not just think in terms of getting a target down from 12 to 11 and a half or 11 weeks; we must think far bigger than that. I will let Jason Leitch add to that.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

A number of members want to come in, so if Professor Leitch wishes to send us a note on the issue, that would be fine.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I echo the convener’s comments and thank you for being here, which is helpful to this committee in the Scottish Parliament—not the United Kingdom Parliament—in looking at value for money and scrutinising. I have certainly found it helpful so far.First, I want to ask about the national resource allocation committee allocation formula, which used to be the Arbuthnott formula. You have mentioned the Grampian and Lothian health boards quite a few times today. The report that we have in front of us states that the NRAC underfunding to five health boards is £517 million. In fact, Lothian’s payment—or lack of—was such that it got £54 million less than expected in 2012-13. Lothian and Grampian are probably the two main health boards of the five. Could the problems and difficulties faced by Lothian and Grampian in meeting the targets—I hear everything that you have said about the new theatres—be as a result of their underfunding through the NRAC formula? I know that you have a timetable to ensure that all boards are given the recommended funding. When will they receive the recommended funding for their populations?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

First, as you probably saw in the statement that we put out last week, Grampian is getting an increase of 4 per cent next year compared with a Scottish average for territorial boards of 2.9 per cent. We have a long-term plan up to 2016-17 and we are determined that, by the end of that period, no health board will be more than 1 per cent outwith NRAC. In other words, within the next two years every board will be within 1 per cent of their NRAC allocation. I think that that is substantial progress from where we started a number of years ago. The announcement last week that Grampian will get a 4 per cent rise compared with an average rise of 2.9 per cent shows our commitment in that respect.I do not think that the capacity issues in Grampian and Lothian are primarily related to NRAC. I think that they are related to other issues. I will deal with Lothian, as I have spent a lot of time on Grampian. One of the major problems in Lothian is that Edinburgh royal infirmary was planned on too small a scale in terms of its bed capacity, which is roughly 20 per cent below what is required. There was probably a 10-year planning phase between the initial proposal to build a new Edinburgh royal infirmary and the opening of the new hospital. Some people warned about the capacity issue at the time. For example, I remember Margo MacDonald saying in her first election literature in 1999 to get elected to the Scottish Parliament as a Scottish National Party candidate that the planned bed capacity for the new Edinburgh royal infirmary was too low. It was too low because the population of Edinburgh had expanded so dramatically during the planning phase.One of the challenges that we have in Lothian is that, although we have a fantastic new hospital facility in the royal infirmary, it has undercapacity because its planned capacity underestimated the population growth in the Edinburgh area. As a result of that, we have a 20 per cent shortfall in the number of beds that we need at the ERI; and as a result of that, we have had to reopen additional bed capacity elsewhere in Edinburgh. That is nothing to do with NRAC; it is just pure bad planning, quite frankly.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am sure that £54 million a year would help a wee bit towards addressing the problems.

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

In terms of solving the problems, Lothian of course got a very substantial increase over a period. In terms of implementing NRAC, one of the reasons why we have been able to make so much progress in the past two years and why we will be able to make so much progress in the next two years is that we can bring the likes of Grampian and Lothian up to their NRAC allocation without penalising the other boards. People would argue that, by definition, Glasgow has more than its fair share at the current time. However, given the deprivation and poverty profile of the area that is covered by NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, which includes the convener’s constituency, I think that the convener would be down my throat if I did not give that health board a real-terms increase in its budget over that period.We are trying to ensure that everybody gets to NRAC, but we are doing it over a period of time so that areas that have reached that point already are not penalised, because they need the money as well. Of course, we could not do that if we were not getting the Barnett consequentials dedicated to the health service in Scotland. That is one of the reasons why we took the decision to ring fence the health consequentials for health in Scotland.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I know that time is moving on, so I want to be brief.I know that you are going to remind me that I was on the Health and Sport Committee when much of this happened—

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I wouldnae blame you for anything, Mary.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am sure.The position is that no patient should wait more than 12 weeks for their first appointment and that, once they have seen a consultant, they will not wait more than 12 weeks after their treatment has been agreed. That is 24 weeks.We know that 13 out of 14 boards met the 90 per cent referral-to-treatment target, which is 18 weeks. Are you saying that, if it takes 12 weeks for someone to see a consultant, they are guaranteed to have their treatment within six weeks?John Connaghan was helpful last time in relation to questions about standards and so on. When you are doing your uncluttering exercise and making the process easier to understand, will you think about the fact that the process that I have just set out is a bit confusing, to say the least?

Alex Neil SNP Airdrie and Shotts
link

I will say a couple of things and then I will get John to explain the patient flow, in terms of the targets.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 249
  3. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 100

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.