I will comment later about the work programme. I echo Karen Gillon's point, which I was going to raise. The Executive indicated in a parliamentary answer that the Environment and Rural Development Committee has not yet met formally outwith Edinburgh, which is quite surprising, given the committee's remit.I think that the convener said that Ross Finnie will give oral evidence to the committee on sustainable development. Given that the negotiations that will take place in the fisheries council in December promise to be even more crucial than the disastrous negotiations of the past two years, it might be useful to take that opportunity to set aside 45 minutes for pre-fisheries council scrutiny. It is important that we do that, because the talks will be crucial.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Richard Lochhead only · show everyone- Sarah Boyack Lab 12
- Karen Gillon Lab 5
- Richard Lochhead SNP 4
- Rob Gibson SNP 2
- Maureen Macmillan Lab 2
- Nora Radcliffe LD 2
- Mark Ruskell Green 1
Richard Lochhead’s contributions
4 contributionsI will kick off by supporting Mark Ruskell.I would like the committee to investigate two subjects. It is important that whatever we do connects with the people of Scotland and not only with the non-governmental organisations and the usual suspects, as tends to be the case with many committees. I am thankful that that has changed slightly in the past few years, but we must ensure that we reflect the priorities that exist outwith the chamber and outwith the committees and that we connect with the people of Scotland.I support the suggestion that we should investigate climate change. The people of Scotland are concerned about climate change and, for some of the reasons that Mark Ruskell has outlined, the time is right to consider it. Given the increased incidence of flooding in Scotland and the extreme weather conditions, people will connect with an inquiry that is undertaken by a parliamentary committee into climate change. Scotland also has international obligations to make a contribution to tackling the problem. An investigation into the impact of climate change in Scotland and a suggested response to the problem would be worth while. I would not necessarily suggest that we should scrutinise the record of the Government here and tie the inquiry into what it is doing; committees have a remit to conduct straightforward inquiries, so they do not always have to scrutinise the Government. We should do what we think should be done, rather than respond to what the Government is doing.The second issue is rural development. I will pick up on some of the issues that Karen Gillon mentioned. A rural development inquiry should certainly be one of our two inquiries. We should have an inquiry into rural housing, because that is one of the biggest, if not the biggest, social issues in rural Scotland. The matter has been neglected by the Scottish Parliament since it was set up in 1999. The Rural Development Committee held two major inquiries, one of which was into obstacles to integrated rural development while the second was into changing employment patterns in rural communities. Both those inquiries flagged up two major issues that have not been addressed in detail. One was the lack of transport infrastructure in rural Scotland and the second was the lack of rural housing. We should focus on an issue that will chime with the people of Scotland, and that issue should be rural housing. The Water Services etc (Scotland) Bill has again flagged that up as a major issue. No parliamentary committee has conducted an investigation into rural housing since 1999. Such an inquiry would be warmly welcomed throughout Scotland if we were to choose to conduct one. We should build in some of the cross-cutting themes that Karen Gillon mentioned and examine how sustainable development links into one particular policy area.We should use reporters as often as possible, given that we do not seem to have much time on the agenda for inquiries. Perhaps we could make a special effort to appoint reporters. I note that there is an NFU Scotland briefing after the meeting into the impact of milk prices on the dairy sector. Such issues would be perfect for a member of the committee to produce a report on. Perhaps we could talk about that briefly.
My view is that the job of reporters is not to do work on behalf of a committee in the run-up to big inquiries, but to carry out mini-inquiries into issues that would not otherwise be covered. I am slightly uncomfortable with the talk of reporters feeding into big inquiries, because those are separate matters. There are many pressing political issues that the people of Scotland would like committees to take up, but due to time constraints, they cannot do so. In those circumstances, committees should appoint reporters to carry out short, sharp inquiries and report back. There should be no relationship between reporters and wider inquiries.I am pleased that we are going to consider climate change, but the idea of an inquiry on cross-cutting rural development issues suggests that we may end up simply having conversations with ministers. That would be worthy and good, but a rural development inquiry will be successful only if we take focused evidence, mainly from communities around Scotland. The committees perform best when they are out having public meetings, taking evidence and stirring things up in rural Scotland. I cannot see how that will happen between now and summer with a relatively short inquiry into cross-cutting rural development issues.
The committee has not been outside Edinburgh once.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Nov 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 10 November 2004 Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 6
- Work Programme Procedure · 29
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.