Members have an update on the work programme from me. I was keen to set out our likely work programme for November to June so that the public and interest groups could have a sense of what we are doing and when, which will allow them to make comments to the committee in good time.The key points to note are the timeframes for undertaking work on existing and forthcoming Executive bills. We must undertake stage 2 of the Water Services etc (Scotland) Bill, after which we will move on to the proposed environmental assessment bill. Other bills are coming soon.I would like members' agreement to a few matters. Do members wish to receive an informal briefing from Executive officials on implementing instruments that are associated with common agricultural policy reform? I ask members to note the time commitments that are likely to arise from other business such as subordinate legislation, petitions and budget scrutiny, which we will have to programme in.I suggest that early in the new year we should examine European Union issues—we do that quarterly—and that we combine that with oral evidence from the Minister for Environment and Rural Development on the priorities for the Luxembourg presidency of the EU. It is important to try to hear about that near the start of the presidency.Members will remember that we published a research report on sustainable development and that an Executive response is due by 22 November. If members agree to explore those points further, we could take oral evidence from the minister before Christmas.Those are the key items on my agenda. Do members agree to defer decisions on a committee away day? I discuss that in depth in my paper. Richard Lochhead has intimated that he wants to add an item to our agenda, but before we hear from him, is the committee broadly happy to agree those points?
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Sarah Boyack only · show everyone- Sarah Boyack Lab 12
- Karen Gillon Lab 5
- Richard Lochhead SNP 4
- Rob Gibson SNP 2
- Maureen Macmillan Lab 2
- Nora Radcliffe LD 2
- Mark Ruskell Green 1
Sarah Boyack’s contributions
12 contributionsMark Brough is whispering to me that we could build a meeting outwith Edinburgh into an inquiry—we will discuss proposals for inquiries under this agenda item. The committee has made one or two visits, but it has not met formally outwith Edinburgh for some time. A meeting outside Edinburgh would have to have a specific purpose, but I agree with Karen Gillon's general point.If there are no comments about the matters that I raised, I will take it that the committee is happy with the work programme.
We normally receive the agenda for European council meetings about three weeks in advance. We could ask the Scottish Parliament information centre to produce a background briefing on the fisheries council that identifies the key issues following last year's negotiations. We could certainly hear from the minister, although I am not sure whether we should do that at the meeting at which we will take evidence on sustainable development, given that we are about to start stage 2 of the Water Services etc (Scotland) Bill. However, we could attempt to find a slot in our programme. I see that members are nodding, so we will add that point to the list of topics for ministerial scrutiny.The clerks and I have considered future inquiry work and my paper identifies two slots: one in January and February and one in May and June. We will have dealt with stage 2 of the Water Services etc (Scotland) Bill, if not by Christmas then certainly soon after, so we should have a five to seven-week slot after that. After stage 1 of the proposed environmental assessment bill, there should be another slot before the summer recess. Those are two reasonable slots in which we could carry out inquiry work.SPICe has produced a paper that sets out a range of issues that we might want to consider, so the matter is open for discussion.
You are right that the committee has not used reporters in the past year and a half; we have tended to do full committee reports. If we were to use reporters, that would certainly expand our capacity to pick up different bits of work.
You did the Caledonian MacBrayne report.
And I was just about to write you down as a volunteer.
We got our first report on the Water Environment and Water Services (Scotland) Act 2003 this year and we will get our second update next year. Given that we did not go into the issue in as much depth this year as we had intended, because of the busy agenda on the day, we did not make the most of the opportunity. A committee member might therefore like to take on the issue and report back to the committee. In parallel with our consideration of inquiry topics, we should think about issues that can be taken on by reporters.
The question is whether we have a brief inquiry with a reporter involved or a better evidence-taking session. I will not force members to take a decision today; we can add the subject to our list of topics and return to it.
Okay. The last contribution has made my comments much easier, as it was broadly the suggestion that I was going to make. We have talked ourselves into undertaking two broad areas of work. There are crossovers between them, but the key thing is to get the most benefit out of them.I also want us to keep going on the sustainable development front. Having agreed that Ross Finnie should come before the committee in December to talk to us about the Executive response, it would be good to follow on from that with a session on a practical topic that we can all get our heads round. Climate change is probably the obvious topic, not just because of the G8 summit, which Mark Ruskell talked about, but because we are expecting the Executive's climate change strategy. If we were to select that topic, we would provide a bit of scrutiny at a time when it would be quite useful.If members are happy with the suggestion, we will make climate change our first piece of work and deal with it as a practical follow-on from our work on sustainable development. I do not want to lose that work, either on the parliamentary side—which we have not yet considered—or the Executive side, but given that our report on sustainable development examined the policy process, it would be good to consider a particular challenge in the light of that work. We should do that work at the start of the year.Members have a range of views on the rural development work, but there is a reasonable consensus that if we did it in May or June, that would give us more time to think about the issues that we would like to consider. Rural development would be a good topic on which to have one or two reporters. We can do background work before we get to the committee inquiry, think of potential places to hold community discussions and think through which Executive ministers we would like to involve and the topics that we would like to consider. The work is potentially big, but if we take a little time and use reporters, it should be meaningful. That does not mean that we will cover absolutely everything that members have suggested, but we will cover broadly what members have come up with. Are members happy with that suggestion? I see that Karen Gillon disagrees.
Today, I am trying to get broad agreement on the topics that we will consider and when. Obviously, we will produce a much clearer set of agreements on exactly what we will consider. At present, I seek the committee's views on the two broad topic areas, but we will need to return to them and discuss them in depth. After today's meeting, I was going to ask the clerks and SPICe to produce a paper on the two broad topics on which we have agreed, which are climate change in the context of sustainable development and cross-cutting rural development issues, with one or two policy areas. When we have that detailed paper, we can batter through it and reach agreement. We may disagree about the breadth of our work on rural development and the topics, but when we have a paper with a first set of suggestions, we can see how we like them.I am keen to pick up the comments that Richard Lochhead and Karen Gillon made about getting out of Edinburgh—the rural development work lends itself nicely to that. However, to do that properly, we need to have a detailed work programme. I am not suggesting that we leave that until next summer but proposing that we agree it before Christmas, which will allow outside organisations to get a feel for what we are going to do. We can also discuss the topics on which we might want reporters. Rather than leaving the matter until the summer, we would be using the time between now and then constructively. If members volunteered to do pieces of work, I would expect them to be done before we carry out the formal inquiry.
Could one member speak at a time, please? I do not want interventions in a committee meeting.
I do not think that we will get complete consensus on the issue, but we have broad agreement on the topics that we will consider and the order in which we will consider them. I suggest that, within a couple of weeks, we bring back a paper on the issues and get into the nitty-gritty. If there are disagreements about the use of reporters, we will thrash that out then. It is up to the committee to decide how to use reporters, but we can have the debate on that later.I thank the representatives of SPICe for attending and I thank members for that discussion, which will be recorded in the Official Report. When we agree on the content of our work, our discussions will also be available to members of the public and interest groups so that they can see where they slot in.As agreed at our previous meeting, we now move into private session to conclude our draft report on the budget process for 2005-06.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Nov 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 10 November 2004 Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 6
- Work Programme Procedure · 29
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.