Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Environmental Assessment of Plans and Programmes (Scotland) Regulations 2004 (SSI 2004/258)

Wednesday 23 June 2004 Environment and Rural Development Committee Subordinate legislation 42 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

42 contributions
Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

The minister is a minute early for the next item. I think that we can cope with that.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Item 3 is consideration of the Environmental Assessment of Plans and Programmes (Scotland) Regulations 2004 (SSI 2004/258). I remind members that Ross Finnie announced earlier in the year that it was his intention to bring forward subordinate legislation to bring us into line with the European directive on the assessment of the effects of certain plans and programmes on the environment. The regulations transpose the directive into Scots law, but it is the minister's intention also to introduce primary legislation later in the session.We are considering the regulations under the negative procedure. The Subordinate Legislation Committee has considered the instrument and has nothing to report to us. Members will recall that we invited written evidence from key stakeholder groups to generate responses from a range of interested parties for when we had the minister with us. We also have before us an excellent briefing from the Scottish Parliament information centre, which has been circulated to members. I invite the minister to talk through the policy objectives of the regulations, which are important not just for the Executive, but for the range of organisations that will be subject to their remit. I invite Ross Finnie to introduce his officials and to make some opening remarks.

Ross Finnie LD The Minister for Environment and Rural Development · West of Scotland
link

I am joined by Elspeth MacDonald, who comes from the solicitor's side of things, which is always a comfort when dealing with statutory instruments. Jon Rathjen will be in charge—I hope—of steering through both the regulations and, as you indicated in your introductory remarks, convener, the subsequent bill. I am much encouraged that you have been stirring up interest in the matter, so that you can add to the number of questions for us. That is a good procedure for any convener to be following. I am delighted to have this opportunity to give evidence on the Environmental Assessment of Plans and Programmes (Scotland) Regulations 2004. As you pointed out to the committee, the regulations are required so that we meet the European Union deadline for implementation of the directive, which is 21 July this year. The regulations form part of a two-stage approach by the Executive, as you indicated. The regulations ensure that certain plans and programmes that are developed by the public sector take full account of both positive and negative environmental impacts. They also ensure that the public have a right to see and comment on plans and to have their comments taken into account. They ask that authorities consider alternative delivery strategies and make clear the environmental choices of each approach. I believe that strategic environmental assessment should improve public services through better-informed decision making. Strategic environmental assessment will help us to understand better the potential effects of our plans on the environment, thus reducing the risk of unforeseen environmental damage being caused by late or insufficient environmental study. Strategic environmental assessment helps us to highlight both negative and positive aspects across the full range of environmental considerations, covering water, land, air quality, biodiversity, human health and the built and archaeological heritage of Scotland.Strategic environmental assessment will, I believe, help to create a culture of more creative thinking in the public sector to find ways to avoid, or at least mitigate, environmental damage. We can ensure that monitoring takes place to gauge and control long-term impacts. Strategic environmental assessment will increase the public's access to the information on which we base our decisions, thereby improving the understanding and scrutiny of those decisions. It is central to our plans that strategic environmental assessment will deliver better environmental outcomes. The regulations were subject to a full 12-week consultation, which was completed in March. The consultation has shown broad support for the principles of the legislation from environmental non-governmental organisations and public authorities. However, if we are to realise the many benefits of strategic environmental assessment, it is clear that we will need to ensure that the administrative process is effective and as streamlined as possible. Scotland is among the leaders in Europe in the policy area of strategic environmental assessment and we are rightly proud of that. SEA is a vital tool in our work to ensure that when we seek to introduce new public plans for change in Scotland the environment is fully taken into account, not as an afterthought, but up front in the first stages of development of any new strategy, plan or programme.I have set out the general principles that we seek to achieve and I will deal with any detailed aspects of the policy that committee members want to consider.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Thank you for that clear exposition of the regulations' objectives. I will kick off with the questions. The Convention of Scottish Local Authorities submission does not focus on the instrument, but raises a series of concerns about the proposed bill. For example, it raises concerns about resources and the potential overlap between different local authority processes and it focuses on planning. To what extent are you in dialogue with ministers with responsibility for planning, given that a planning bill is also being considered? I assume that the situation presents a good opportunity to avoid the problems that COSLA identifies and to introduce processes that mesh together and deliver the policy objectives that you set out.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

The point that you raise picks up on my comment that, if the policy is to be effective, we must be able to persuade those who administer public bodies that an effective and streamlined procedure is in place. We have to step back slightly and recognise that we are talking about strategic—I emphasise the word "strategic"—environmental assessment, which, if it is properly executed by a public body, should by definition assist in the detailed planning application process in relation to specific projects that might arise as part of an overall plan.The key to the concern that COSLA raises, which is not unique to COSLA, is to understand the essential nature of public education. We are saying to public bodies, "When you embark on drawing up a plan, you should consider right from the outset what the plan is for and whether it would have a significant environmental impact that you should be taking into account." I think that people have not quite understood that the legislation is not simply about adding to the process along the way; it is about a cultural change in the approach to drawing up such plans. I accept that COSLA has reservations about how that might be implemented but, in transposing the EU directive into the regulations, which will be repeated with additions in the proposed bill, we have tried hard to be explicit about what is required, as set out in schedules 1 and 2 to the regulations, with a view to allaying the fears that people tend to have that such instruments are simply bureaucratic nightmares.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

You have accurately summed up the challenge that you face.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

Indeed. I would like to give the impression that I have at least thought of that aspect.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

That is partly why we elicited comments from the key bodies that strongly support the principle of strategic environmental assessment and bodies that will have to carry out such assessment. We wanted those bodies to engage with the contents of the statutory instrument and to think about how they might need to change the way in which they work and we wanted to give them an opportunity to make representations to the committee before we heard your evidence. The instrument is subject to the negative procedure, so it is a question of take it or leave it. We wanted to raise the level of debate about the matter and to encourage people to start to think about the impact that the SEA process will have on their business.

Eleanor Scott Green Highlands and Islands
link

I have been and still am keen on the principle of strategic environmental assessment. Now that the regulations are in front of us, I am finding it quite difficult to understand the process, but I welcome the principle.COSLA also said in its submission: "The decision on whether an SEA is required will be taken by the authority responsible for the strategy."That is reflected in the flow chart that we were provided with, which describes the key stages of strategic environmental assessment. The question is whether a proposal is likely to have a significant effect on the environment. Will the minister assure me that the definition of a significant effect will be clear enough to the bodies that are involved and that they will not be able to avoid undertaking an assessment by saying that they did not think that a significant effect would be created?

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

We have had interesting discussions about that. Elspeth MacDonald and I will not bore the committee with our lengthy discussions on the ordinary "Oxford English Dictionary" use of the word "significant" and the legal definitions that have a bearing on the matter.We must remember that if the body concerned concludes that a project will not have a significant effect, it will have to publish a justification of that. A different public process for accessibility will exist. If interested parties believe that a public authority might be taking a narrow view and trying to escape the mischief of the instrument, that authority will have to justify its decision and state reasons why it believes that a plan or programme does not meet the test.You are right. It is possible to dodge about the issue, but I have given the subject much thought and I have difficulty in believing that, after reading the word "significant" and taking account of what is set out in schedules 1 and 2, any responsible public body could simply leap out and say that a plan was inconsequential. The word "significant" is applied to the criteria in schedules 1 and 2 and to the information that is required. A body must also justify why it has taken the view that assessment is not required.

Maureen Macmillan Lab Highlands and Islands
link

COSLA has said that because a local authority will decide whether an SEA is required, if that authority decides not to have an SEA and goes ahead with a development, it could be open to legal challenge. COSLA has given one or two examples—I do not know whether it has brought them to your attention. For instance, it says that if a local authority decided that a pupil could not be picked up by a school bus, that could be challenged on the ground that, if the pupil's family had to use a car as a result, that would have a detrimental environmental impact. Perhaps that is becoming a bit silly, but COSLA has given that example. Do you appreciate the concerns of local authorities that they will have to conduct an SEA for just about everything, in case of legal challenge?

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

I am disappointed by that view, although I am aware that a number of people hold it. If a local authority thinks that one child not being picked up by a school bus will have a significant environmental impact, I am disappointed. If that local authority's solicitorial and other legal advice is that it would be likely to be taken to court on the basis that that had a significant environmental impact, I would be disappointed not only by the local authority's policy, but by the advice that the decision would give rise to a legal challenge.I am glad that you have raised the issue, because we must recognise that we are talking about environmental assessment that is strategic. That is important, because currently the strategic aspect is ignored, which means horrendous consequences from several major developments and from small developments that accumulate and produce plans and procedures that take no proper account of their impact.I return to my introduction. We have a huge exercise in educating authorities that effects must be significant. If they are significant, we jolly well want them to be in the process at the outset and we want to know and plan for them more comprehensively and strategically than in the past. You reported what COSLA said. Giving examples that make assessments sound ridiculous is almost an attempt by local authorities to say that they will not undertake assessments. That is not justified in the context of what is in the directive and the regulations or, ultimately, what will be in the bill.

Maureen Macmillan Lab Highlands and Islands
link

It also points to the fact that local authorities will need proper guidance on when they should require an SEA.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

I agree. I think that guidance will be required. We are trying as hard as we can to use language in the instrument and the bill that will enable people in local authorities to form a view, but we have no doubt that guidance will be needed to clarify matters, particularly in the initial stages of such an entirely new procedure and new approach. As I said, the key issue is that there could be quite a cost if one were to go way down the process of drawing up a plan before one said, "Gosh, we'd better start taking account of the legislation." Building that approach into the process right at the outset is the real way of reducing and minimising cost.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

That is a useful answer in respect of guidance. Authorities and organisations will have to exercise judgment, but guidance to enable them to do so intelligently would be useful.

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link

On more general issues, will the regulations allow the Executive to conform fully to the European directive that is driving the issue?

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link

You intend to introduce primary legislation subsequently. Will that legislation contain additional elements that have not been included in the regulations?

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

Yes. I will give a brief explanation. The matters that come within the mischief of the regulations have to arise from a regulatory or statutory requirement. The Executive's view is that that is very good, but a whole range of public policies do not necessarily emanate from a regulatory or statutory requirement. We are anxious to ensure that all plans and processes in public authorities should be brought within the mischief of the statutory environmental assessment requirement, so the bill will extend the range of plans and programmes that would become subject to that. So that we can have a comprehensive piece of legislation that addresses strategic environmental assessment, the regulations will be repealed once we get the bill through the Parliament. There would then be a more elegant piece of legislation.

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link

What timescale is envisaged for introducing the bill?

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

We do not have an absolute date at the moment, as we will be getting into the next parliamentary year, but there has been parallel consultation and we hope that the bill will be introduced relatively early, as I do not want the matter hanging about. I want a comprehensive, single piece of legislation and I hope that there will be no hiccups in introducing it. The usual vast number of bills and instruments are passing through the Parliament, but we hope that, if all goes well, we will get an early slot.

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link

Can I assume from what you have said that the regulations will bridge the gap between the current requirement and the bill and that, when the bill is introduced, the committee and the Parliament will have the opportunity to scrutinise not only the new measures in the bill, but the measures in the regulations that are reintroduced as part of the bill?

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

Absolutely. The bill will have to be treated like any other bill and will be open for discussion and debate. I hope that the due consideration that has been given to the regulations might narrow the focus of further scrutiny and debate, but it is not for me to try to fetter any committee or anybody who handles the bill—that is not my job. However, we should be clear that the provisions that are set out in the regulations will by and large be replicated in the bill, although the bill will have an extended scope. If we had not had the deadline of 21 July by which to be European directive compatible, we might have settled for just having the bill, but that was not possible in the parliamentary timetable.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I am interested in the concepts of quality and monitoring. Scottish Environment LINK has raised questions about the requirements of the directive in that regard. Flood prevention measures, for example, would require strategic environmental assessments. How will that fit in with the overall approach to climate change issues? How does the Executive inform that debate at present, given that, as we discussed previously, climate change issues are being shifted around from one place to another in the budget?

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

There is no doubt that a number of plans and proposals that have been drawn up and executed by local authorities have failed to take account of climate change and that there have been consequences. I would hope that, if the significant environmental impact had been considered, as required under the regulations, those consequences would have been flagged up at a much earlier stage. The issue is not so much about budgetary requirements and the Executive directing people on climate change issues; it is more to do with us being better informed. Some of the issues to which the Executive has had to respond have come about largely from a lack of strategic planning. We cannot foresee everything that will happen in every local authority throughout Scotland, but we will have a much better handle on what is going on if local authorities and planning authorities operating under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 are engaged in the SEA process. We will have a series of documents, the aggregation of which will give us a much better handle on Scottish Executive expenditure in this area. At the moment, the process is terribly dependent on individual public bodies having the care to look at whether there might be an environmental impact. The new legislation will change the balance completely.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

So the regulations would accelerate that process.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

I am in no doubt about that. I have to be honest—I think that we will have to take responsibility for the first few plans, but the regulations will be an important tool to get us to a point where local authorities throughout the country will be able to integrate with Executive plans and work with other public bodies to understand the cumulative environmental impact of their plans.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

We received a submission from Scottish Environment LINK, which has produced a checklist of what it thinks will come under the ambit of SEA legislation. It would be interesting for committee members to get your perspective on Scottish Environment LINK's judgment. There are quite a few plans, programmes and strategies on the checklist over which it leaves question marks, but there are some for which it ticks the box to say that they will be covered and some for which it crosses the box to say that they will not be subject to SEA. Can you to respond to us in writing on that? I would not dream of asking you to respond to all the plans—there are about 40 or 50 of them—but your views would aid our discussion when we reach the bill stage. The whole process is about transparency—what will be included and what will not, how we define "significant" and how we reach a sensible judgment in relation to all the organisations that you expect to be pulled into the ambit of the legislation. Your response would help us to determine whether we are all making the right kind of assumptions about what is meant to be included.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

That is good. Thank you.

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

My question is along the same lines and concerns who is in and who is out. One would expect local authorities to follow the regulations, but who else are we talking about? I would think that Scottish Water and similar bodies would be included.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

Indeed. The important point is that, theoretically, all public bodies could be included. Education authorities are definitely included. However, this is not about individual bus journeys but about developments that either individually or cumulatively could have an environmental impact. In the health service, too, the issue is more likely to be long-term planning of infrastructure requirements. In those two areas, long-term infrastructural requirements should be planned. If people take that approach, when they come to seek planning permission for individual buildings or structures they ought to be in the position of having done a substantial amount of the work that is required. In the longer term, the process will have a beneficial effect and will smooth the way forward.The regulations apply to all public bodies. As long as the regulations are in force, the plan that bodies prepare must emanate from a regulatory or statutory requirement. That will change when we introduce the proposed bill. Any plan that bodies prepare that would have a significant environmental impact will come within the mischief of the legislation.

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

So the regulatory authority will conduct the strategic environmental assessment and the people operating under the regulations will be governed by it.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Do members have any further questions? We have asked a lot of big-picture questions, but they are fundamental to the process. Nora Radcliffe has a supplementary.

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

It is not really a supplementary. We are in the slightly awkward position of having a statutory instrument that is in force and a bill that will run parallel with, replicate and overlap with it. Are there difficulties in deciding how much effort you put into guidance now, at the expense of work on the bill?

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

I do not think so. Collectively, the members of the bill team have given a great deal of thought to ensuring that there is a certain consistency of approach. The drafting of the instrument formed part of that process, notwithstanding the fact that we have not quite reached the point of publishing the bill. If we take a consistent approach to the way in which we intend to apply the directive, we can be reasonably confident that any guidance that we publish will not be materially affected. We may have to think about some consequential amendments, but I do not think that the instrument will materially affect our ability to produce guidance in the first instance.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Earlier I asked about the progress of the proposed planning bill. COSLA has identified what it regards as an overlap that will make life difficult for it. Presumably, the fact that the two bills are being developed in parallel provides an opportunity to ensure that there is clear guidance that tells authorities what they are expected to do when.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

Again, we must explain in more detail precisely what we think. There are two distinct processes. The regulations are about a plan that may allude to and ultimately call for the building of a physical structure. In that programme or planning process, we want all public bodies to have regard to whether the building will have a significant environmental impact. That will not in any way detract from the need for public and other bodies to comply with the requirements of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, which will be further amended. The act deals with the detailed issue of the planning permission that is required for a particular building. To be honest, I do not see that there is an overlap. However, as I said a few moments ago in a response to either Rob Gibson or Nora Radcliffe, if the public body has properly assessed the building, it should be well on the way to meeting some of the detailed requirements of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

That is a good place at which to leave the discussion, because the regulations are being considered under the negative procedure. I hope that the questions that members have been able to ask in the light of the representations that we have received and the minister's responses on the record will be helpful to the organisations that have concerns about what the regulations mean and to those who are seeking legal interpretations of what they must do and what is proportionate. I thank the minister and his officials.

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link

The minister has said that he is required under the European directive to seek these powers and that the matter will return to us in the form of a bill at some time in the future. We are content with the regulations at this stage.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

The expectation is that the bill will be the excitement after the Water Services etc (Scotland) Bill. I will say no more than that.Are members content with the regulations and happy to make no recommendation to the Parliament?Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 23 June 2004 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 50
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 42
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.