Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Scottish Outdoor Access Code: Proposed Code (SE/2004/101)

Wednesday 23 June 2004 Environment and Rural Development Committee Subordinate legislation 50 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

50 contributions
Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

I welcome committee members, witnesses, the press and members of the public. We have received an apology from Karen Gillon. I remind everyone to switch off their mobile phones; I know that people are always trying to get in touch with us during our committee meetings, but we do not want phones going off.Agenda item 1 is subordinate legislation. Colleagues will recall that we agreed last week to defer to this week consideration of issues that we want to raise with the Justice 1 Committee in its role as lead committee on the proposed Scottish outdoor access code. The code, which was produced following the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003, sets out guidance on responsible exercise of the statutory access rights that the 2003 act grants.Members have copies of the submissions that have been sent to the Justice 1 Committee. We must identify issues that we want that committee to consider when it scrutinises the code. Who would like to kick off?

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link

What is our contribution at this stage likely to achieve? Is there scope for adjusting the proposed Scottish outdoor access code before it is agreed to? Can changes be achieved?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

As I understand it, we are looking at a draft code that Scottish Natural Heritage has produced after much consultation, dialogue and networking. The Justice 1 Committee must formally consider the code next week and decide whether it wants to recommend any changes. Is that correct?

Tracey Hawe Clerk
link

My understanding is that, although the Justice 1 Committee can approve or not approve the proposed code in its entirety, it is up to the Executive to decide what it wants to do with any detailed comments that that committee makes on the code. Obviously, if the Justice 1 Committee made substantive comments, the Executive could consider them and submit a further draft code.

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link

So, in essence, we are at a take-it-or-leave-it point with the proposed code. Is that the case?

Tracey Hawe Clerk
link

There is a further opportunity. The draft access code provides for SNH to keep the code under review. Although comments might not be taken into account for the current draft, they could be fed into further drafts under the code's review procedure.

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link

Are we confident that the review procedure will be on-going?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

That is set out in the process. I suppose that our role at this point, as a secondary committee, is to ensure that the Justice 1 Committee does not miss anything that we might think is important and which should be dealt with in the code. We are not the lead committee, so the key point is whether we want the lead committee to consider specific issues when it considers the proposed code.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Paragraph 4.7 of the proposed code—it is entitled "Respect access rights in managing your land or water"—is aimed at land managers. It states that they should not erect signs or notices to prevent people from having access. Paragraph 4.7 tells people what they should not do, but the code does not make it clear at any other point when signs should be erected.My concern is that there has been no agreement on the kind of signs that people can erect. I hope that the Justice 1 Committee will concern itself with the wording that should appear on signs if they are erected, and with the positive stating of that wording in the access code. Problems with the wording of signs have been identified previously. For example, all sorts of signs that used extremely strong language were put up during the foot-and-mouth outbreak. Such language is not acceptable and I would like that to be sorted out. An understanding of the language that is acceptable on signs would benefit many people.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

That is a detailed suggestion. The proposed code has different sections and we must read the whole document to get an overview. We can ask the Justice 1 Committee to consider Rob Gibson's suggestion on signage that gives clear guidance and is appropriate in the context of the responsible access rights that are set out in the 2003 act.

Maureen Macmillan Lab Highlands and Islands
link

The submission from the Scottish Countryside Rangers Association seeks clarification in the access code of one or two issues, notably the relationship between the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003 and the Nature Conservation (Scotland) Act 2004. Issues around recklessness and so on have been raised previously in that context. The relationship between the two acts needs to be considered. We were clear that we had assurances that the 2004 act would not compromise the 2003 act, but perhaps the Justice 1 Committee would like to ensure that that is the case.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

That is an important point. We must have considered the Nature Conservation (Scotland) Bill around the time when the proposed access code was being finalised. It is important that the access code takes proper account of the Nature Conservation (Scotland) Act 2004.

Eleanor Scott Green Highlands and Islands
link

That is the point that I was about to make; it was also raised in the RSPB Scotland submission, which said that the access code refers to the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981. The Nature Conservation (Scotland) Act 2004 has updated that act, therefore we want to know the Executive's plans for ensuring that the access code takes account of and reflects the new act.

link

There was a debate during the progress of the Land Reform (Scotland) Bill about commercial activity. Paragraph 2.9 of the proposed access code says that access rights will extend to activities such as a mountain guide taking a customer out hillwalking. The code is clear in that respect, but I wonder about companies that organise walking holidays and take out a group of people rather than a single customer. There is a list of exclusions from paragraph 2.12 onwards, but it is silent on what might be regarded as larger commercial operations, specifically the companies that organise walking holidays, which are a vital part of the rural economy. I am concerned that such companies should not drop through a loophole.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

That is quite an important issue, because it is not mentioned in paragraph 2.14, which outlines conduct that was specifically excluded from the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

That is a good point on which to seek clarification.

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

The point is covered implicitly in the next example, which is about a canoe instructor with a party of canoeists. The collective angle has been covered.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

We are presuming that that is all right, but SNH needs to check that.

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

The draft code says that its examples are not to be taken as exhaustive. We have to apply a degree of common sense to such matters.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

I think so, but Roseanna Cunningham's point is that a lot of people would—

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

The code talks about a guide with a hillwalker, or someone with a party of canoeists. It is implicit that a party of hillwalkers or a single canoeist are also included.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

It would not be unreasonable of us to ask for that to be clarified, though.

link

Because such a debate took place during the process of the Land Reform (Scotland) Bill, it would be useful to clarify whether the commercial walking companies, which take out groups of walkers, will be okay in respect of the code. A number of those companies have concerns about what may happen. Nora Radcliffe is no doubt right—and no one wants any decision to be taken that would have an adverse impact on the rural economy—but it is worth the code being a bit clearer on that issue.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

All that the code would need to say is "customers" rather than "a customer". The phrasing is just slightly odd. Let us get it clarified without putting too much heat into it.My main issue with the code is how the information will be disseminated; I was not looking so much at the detail, because I can see that there has been lots of horse-trading. The examples are pitched slightly differently; it is clear that they are meant to be printed in leaflets. The code is great, but people need to know about it. It should be accessible to all land managers and to everyone who is going to be in the countryside. We should ensure that there is a practical link to the tourism industry. I would like the committee to explore that.

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

Do we need to make specific recommendations about the width of coverage that the code should have? In my opinion, every tourist information point should have a copy of the full document. People are referred to a website, but not everyone has web access.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

That is what I meant when I said that the code has to be widely disseminated.

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

We do not want over-reliance on the internet, and for people to be told that all the information is there for them. As Roseanna Cunningham said, not everyone can get the information in that way at the appropriate time.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

That is why I mentioned leaflets. The code has to be disseminated practically for everyone who is likely to be in the countryside.

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link

Paragraph 11 of the NFU Scotland submission contains a sentiment with which I am inclined to agree strongly. It says that, regardless of whether we think that this is an appropriate Scottish outdoor access code, the time has probably come to get the code passed into law. I therefore agree with NFU Scotland's sentiment that it does not want anything to stand in the way of approval of the code at this stage. However, NFU Scotland has grave concerns, as I do, about certain aspects of the code. As a result, I am keen to ensure that we have the opportunity to continue to assess the code against the experience of its implementation.My primary comment is not related to the comments that the committee ought to be making. As a landowner, whose land is all enclosed, my comment is about the Justice 1 Committee's responsibility, before it decides whether to approve the code, to echo concerns about liability, especially in relation to enclosed land. There continue to be a number of concerns. I am not qualified to judge concerns about liability; the Justice 1 Committee should be better qualified to do that. I ask that the Justice 1 Committee does not approve the code without satisfying itself that the liability issues have been covered appropriately.

link

I echo that. Alex Johnstone has made a fair point; it is one that has to be made. Everyone needs to be clear on that aspect.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Have we come up with enough issues to raise with the Justice 1 Committee under our remit? That should keep its members busy.Sustainable Development

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Agenda item 2 is sustainable development. Colleagues have in front of them a copy of "Taking it on: developing UK sustainable development strategy together", which is the United Kingdom Government's consultation document. As part of the process of developing a revised sustainable development strategy, the UK Government seeks submissions on the consultation by the end of July. Given that we are working on sustainable development and that we have commissioned research that is being worked up, we have an opportunity to feed into that discussion.I do not suggest that we attempt to answer all 42 of the consultation questions, but we have the chance to submit some ideas on how we think that the UK's sustainable development strategy could be strengthened. It is clear that we could comment on a number of issues. I suggest that members should give Tracey Hawe and me the job of pulling together some comments, which I will circulate to you after our discussion this morning. That will give us time to contribute to the discussion. Our recess starts at the end of next week rather than at the end of July, so the timing is not ideal, but I think that that would be the best way in which to proceed.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Some of the papers that examine our experience in Scotland indicate that the ability to permeate the economic development of the country with environmental and community interests is quite central if sustainable development is to be carried out in practice. Recently, we have heard about Scottish Enterprise leaders trying desperately not to have any responsibility for environmental issues or communities. To some extent, Highlands and Islands Enterprise has embraced those things; it has a social remit.It is central to sustainable development that the thrust of Government through the economic agencies should be to lay down guidelines on what is expected in that regard. I hope that we can use that as a basis for our comments on the UK consultation.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

That would fit in well with the consultation question about how we should bring together environmental and social concerns at national, regional or local level. We should ensure that economic considerations are on that agenda as well, even though that changes the question that we have been asked. A series of issues that the Government needs to take on board, such as those to do with procurement, flows from Rob Gibson's comment.

link

If those issues had been addressed in Scotland some decades ago, we would not be in the position that we are in now. The example that I am thinking of relates to the building of houses, especially in the social sector. It is clear that a huge amount of the housing stock in Scotland was built in a highly unsustainable fashion. Anyone who knows anything about the history of council housing—in particular, the amount of energy that was needed to heat such housing and keep it in any way fit for people—will know that much council housing turned out not to be at all fit for people and so had an adverse effect on their health. That is a good example to focus on when we are talking about the need for sustainability to be at the heart of everything that we do. If we do not fit in sustainability across the board, we will have a problem.I well remember that, when I was a solicitor for the City of Glasgow District Council, I had to defend situations that were, ultimately, pretty indefensible. That is an example of a situation that we could avoid in the future.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Communities Scotland has probably set out in its sustainable development strategy ways of avoiding that problem in the future.

Eleanor Scott Green Highlands and Islands
link

It would be nice if we could draw on work that the committee has already done, as we cannot start to do anything new in the next 10 days. In relation to question 15 of the consultation paper, which the convener mentioned, our inquiry into the waste strategy might be relevant. That looked at community waste groups and the social benefits that they provide, which are not measurable in the tonnage of waste that is dealt with or the price per tonne. That issue is dear to my heart, as we have had a few problems in the Highland area.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

It is a good idea for us to feed in work that we have done in the past year. That could include the work that we have done in our waste strategy inquiry and the common agricultural policy reform work, which was about linking agricultural support into rural development to provide sustainable rural development and how the economic and social flavour is linked with the environment. There is also the work that we have done on the budget in identifying opportunities for sustainable development. Climate change, which is mentioned in one of the questions, is an issue on which we need to work at a UK as well as a Scottish level to produce a more coherent strategy.

Maureen Macmillan Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I wonder whether we can look at procurement policies and how to help people to adopt sustainable procurement policies. For example, in the Highlands we cannot access recycled aggregates because there is nowhere in the Highlands that processes them. Costs are, therefore, higher and we have to use original aggregates that are being quarried. There are lots of issues around procurement that ought to be addressed.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

We might also want to respond to the question about how the different Governments in the UK work with each other on sustainable development. We will meet the UK Parliament's Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee next week. I hope that that will be a useful opportunity for us to exchange ideas with the UK Parliament and with local government. There are issues around debating what the different Governments and Parliaments are doing and ensuring that best practice is shared. I am not sure that that comes through in the consultation paper, but it is quite a big issue for us.

Maureen Macmillan Lab Highlands and Islands
link

We should also consider the Scottish Parliament's procurement policies.

Alasdair Morrison Lab Western Isles
link

It is essential that, after five years, we liaise with the Welsh—sadly, not the Northern Irish—and the UK committees. The more such liaison we can do, the better. That should be part and parcel of our annual calendar, and there should be a formalised system to enable us to liaise at that level. Interruption.There seems to be some hilarity among the nationalist members.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Do not look a gift horse in the mouth. Please carry on.

Alasdair Morrison Lab Western Isles
link

Eleanor Scott has plotted the way forward as far as this exercise is concerned. We cannot initiate any new work or engage in anything meaningful, but we should, over the next 10 days or so, draw on what members, the convener, and Tracey Hawe—with input from others—deem to be the most relevant parts of the work that we have done and present that as our response to the UK committee.I formally thank Rob Gibson and Roseanna Cunningham for their support.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Okay. We have had quite a good run round the topics and I do not want to prolong the discussion on the issue. I will circulate a draft note for submission to the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee. There will be time for us to respond to the UK Parliament on the consultation, as we do not have to do so until the end of July; however, we will not have time to debate the issue in the chamber. We will try to pick up the threads of this morning's discussion and one or two issues about leadership, to which we have broadly alluded, and circulate a draft note to the committee. If members have further comments, they should let us know so that they can be included.

  1. Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 23 June 2004 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 50
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 42
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.