Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Scottish Outdoor Access Code: Proposed Code (SE/2004/101)

Wednesday 16 June 2004 Environment and Rural Development Committee Subordinate legislation 14 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

14 contributions
Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

The next statutory instrument that we have to deal with is the proposed Scottish outdoor access code. Scottish Natural Heritage is required by the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003 to draw up a proposed Scottish outdoor access code, which will set out the rights and responsibilities of access for land managers and for all those who exercise their access rights. The Justice 1 Committee has been designated as the lead committee for consideration of the code, but our predecessor committee, the Rural Development Committee, had a strong interest in the Land Reform (Scotland) Bill during its passage through Parliament. The Environment and Rural Development Committee has therefore been identified as a secondary committee.As a secondary committee, it is our job to draw to the attention of the lead committee any issues that we feel concerned about or any other points that we want to raise, to ensure that they are considered properly. The Subordinate Legislation Committee has considered the proposed code and has confirmed that it has nothing to report. Do members have issues or comments that they want to put on the record for the Justice 1 Committee?

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link

To some extent, I am disappointed that the Justice 1 Committee has been designated as the lead committee for the code. Although I fully approved of the fact that the Justice 2 Committee dealt with the Land Reform (Scotland) Bill during its passage through Parliament, the issues that are covered by the Scottish outdoor access code are very much about practicalities. As a consequence, it might have been more appropriate for this committee to consider the detail of how the code will be implemented.I had discussions with some of the representative organisations that were involved in preparing the code, and I share their general view that access to Scotland's countryside is important, and that we have a long tradition in this country of free access to the countryside, but that there are issues in the code that raise questions that have to be addressed.I will briefly go through some of the matters that have been brought to my attention, particularly issues such as the exercising of rights of access on tram lines within standing crop. That may be a practical way to cross a field—I do it myself when I am on foot—but, if progress is by horse or bicycle, it could be somewhat less practical, and it has the potential to damage crops. Those concerns have been raised with me.There are also issues about the definition of "customary access", which has raised concerns in certain circles. The suggested practices of leaving field margins open and introducing stiles to facilitate access raise points about the liability of landowners for the safety of people who take access under the code.It would be remiss of me not to point out something that has been pointed out from the start of the process, which is the danger that farm animals pose to people who take access in the countryside. A report was published recently from an inquiry in Dingwall earlier this year into an incident in which a man was killed by farm livestock while he was taking access. It remains a grave concern of many people, particularly those of us who keep cattle, that cattle are perceived as passive vegetarians by many people who do not understand what they are in reality. Those of us who have worked among cattle all our lives realise that, in some cases, they are extremely large and extremely aggressive, and that they will take action that surprises many people. That is particularly the case when dogs are involved, because cows have an intense dislike of dogs.It is important that we ensure that the Justice 1 Committee is aware that there are concerns about the access code. I re-emphasise that it is extremely important that we afford people access to our countryside, but there remain concerns among interested organisations, such as NFU Scotland and the Scottish Landowners Federation—I cannot remember what it calls itself now, because it changed its name recently. I hope that the Justice 1 Committee will take those concerns into consideration.

link

I associate myself with the remarks that Alex Johnstone made at the outset. I find it astonishing that the Justice 1 Committee has been made the lead committee on the access code, because if there is anything that more clearly relates to environment and rural development than an outdoor access code, I cannot think what it is. It is a strange decision, and the convener might wish to query the rationale behind it.I understand that the decision was based on the fact that the Land Reform (Scotland) Bill was dealt with by a justice committee, but the code is not the bill; as Alex Johnstone said, the issue is the nitty-gritty of how the access code will work. The Justice 1 Committee is more likely to look at the code in a technical and legalistic way, which is not the same as the way in which we might want to look at it.We received the proposed code only on Friday, so we have not had the opportunity to consult some of the bodies that might have a direct interest in it, including local access forums, where they have been set up. I know of one such forum that has set up a local meeting.Given the time limit—Parliament must deal with the code by 9 September—perhaps the committee has the opportunity to issue a call for evidence to ask people to contact us directly over the next couple of weeks with their comments on the code. I do not know what business we are due to consider in the two committee meetings that we could have before the recess, but I for one would like the opportunity to spend a bit more time considering the access code. The code will have a profound impact on the way that the countryside works from now on.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Having consulted the clerks on the opportunities that are available to us, I understand that the Justice 1 Committee has already issued a call for evidence, so that call is out there. We could consider putting the code on our agenda for next week, because the Justice 1 Committee will not examine the code until the last week before the recess.

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link

Has the Justice 1 Committee received any evidence so far in response to that call?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

We can check that out.We will have time to consider the code next week. That would at least give members time to read through the code. Some issues that Alex Johnstone highlighted are dealt with effectively in the code, but there would certainly be no harm in our airing the issues to ensure that the Justice 1 Committee is aware of them. We could ensure that the issues that our committee would be keen to pursue are on the Justice 1 Committee's agenda before it considers the code. If we considered the code at our meeting next week, our comments could be given to the Justice 1 Committee in time for them to be included in that committee's papers, which are issued before the weekend. That would meet members' concerns that environmental and rural perspectives will not be taken on board. Are members happy with that proposal as a practical way in which to proceed?

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I was not an MSP when the Parliament established the requirement for a code, so I have a concern about paragraph 4.7, which is headed "Respect access rights in managing your land or water". The paragraph prohibits land managers from putting up any intimidatory sign or notice—

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

We will come back to the detail of the code next week.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I flag up the issue now because I do not know whether there was any discussion about having standardised language for how such things are communicated. We need to ensure that people around the country understand the instructions that are put up about specific aspects of access. I need to know things like that. Of course, I could go and read up on the issue, but I want to highlight the matter for the Justice 1 Committee. More detail needs to be given on a number of such matters to clarify the practicalities of access arrangements. Perhaps we are aware of those issues in a way that the Justice 1 Committee is not.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

The idea of buying ourselves another week is to allow members to do a bit more reading on the topic so that, when we submit our comments to the Justice 1 Committee, we will have had a bit of space to think through what our priorities are.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I hope that the Justice 1 Committee will read the comments that we have made today.

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

I do not remember any specific issues being raised on that point, but I have previously highlighted the need to have some accepted conventions on signage. That will be particularly important for the wonderful core path networks that are to be developed. Now would be a good time to try to achieve some consensus, so that there is a degree of conformity.

Karen Gillon Lab Clydesdale
link

I agree with other members that it would probably have made more sense for the code to be given to our committee for consideration. However, we can have little argument with that because we probably all voted for the Justice 1 Committee to deal with the draft code. Perhaps we need to pay more attention in the future before we vote on Parliamentary Bureau motions that designate lead committees for such items.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

I confess that I was conscious that the code was coming up, but I did not fight to the death for us to be designated as the lead committee for it. Members might ritually humiliate me over that, but I knew that we had a pretty heavy schedule this month. If we can have a compromise by ensuring that we have time to examine the code before the Justice 1 Committee considers it, we should be able to consider the issues without being totally responsible for dealing with the whole code.The code contains a number of big legal issues. The previous Justice 2 Committee hammered out in detail what it expected to come out of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003, so I assume that the Justice 1 Committee will be concerned to ensure that fine balance. It will want to examine whether the provisions of the access code meet not only the legal objectives but the spirit of the legislation, which was about ensuring that there is real access.We can explore Rob Gibson's and Alex Johnstone's detailed comments in a bit more depth next week. I appreciate that it would be helpful to members if they could have sight of any submissions that have been received thus far. However, we will have quite a tight deadline for feeding our comments back to the Justice 1 Committee. If members have some clear thoughts by next week, that will help us to have a more useful and constructive session.I thank members for their comments. We will return to the issue next week.

  1. Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 16 June 2004 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 2
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 25
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 14
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.