Under agenda item 2, we are dealing with the Farm Business Development (Scotland) Amendment Scheme 2004. Members have copies of the instrument. It is an affirmative instrument, so Parliament must approve it before it comes into force. The Subordinate Legislation Committee has considered the instrument and confirmed that it has nothing to report.I welcome the Minister for Environment and Rural Development, Ross Finnie, who is here to move a motion in his name, inviting the committee to recommend to Parliament that we approve the instrument. As is usual, we have an opportunity to ask technical questions and clarify technical issues when the officials who are with the minister are at the table, but once we move to the formal motion, we will be into the debate and there will be no opportunity for us to do that.I invite Ross Finnie to introduce his officials and make any opening remarks; we will then come back on factual issues.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Farm Business Development (Scotland) Amendment Scheme 2004 (SSI 2004/236)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ross Finnie LD 8
- Sarah Boyack Lab 7
- Maureen Macmillan Lab 6
- Rob Gibson SNP 1
The record
25 contributionsI am accompanied by Stella Smith, from the solicitors division in my department, and by Henry Snedden, who deals with the farm business development scheme in my department.I am grateful for this opportunity to explain a minor but necessary amendment to the Farm Business Development (Scotland) Scheme 2001 (SSI 2001/259). As you know, convener, the Farm Business Development (Scotland) Amendment Scheme 2004 (SSI 2004/236) was laid before Parliament on 24 May and, subject to your committee's consideration, is scheduled to come into force on 5 July.Members will be aware that the scheme is aimed at promoting income-generating opportunities for farming families. However, I have identified an anomaly in the current legislation that could—I stress the word "could"—prevent some family members from receiving support under the scheme. Our aim is to prevent that situation from arising and I have been assured by my officials that no one has been excluded from the scheme on the basis of the anomaly that we have unearthed.Currently, the scheme legislation permits applications from immediate family members of the legal occupier of an eligible agricultural holding. A problem might arise in a situation in which the legal occupier is not an individual farmer but a partnership or a limited company. While a partnership has no legal persona and a limited company has a legal persona, they are not natural persons and, therefore, they cannot have a family or eligible family members. As a result, the legislation as currently drafted could be an impediment to family members of farms that are run as a partnership or a limited company receiving the grant. For example, if a farmer operates his business as a husband-and-wife partnership, the current regulations would not allow his son or daughter to apply for farm business development scheme funding. Clearly, that is at odds with the aims of the scheme and the purpose of the amendment is to rectify that inconsistency.I have corrected the anomaly, on the basis of advice from legal advisers, by clarifying the definition of "eligible persons" at paragraph 2(1) of the instrument. The legal definition of scheme eligibility now includes an additional paragraph that states:"(d) where such legal occupier is a partnership or company, any member of the immediate family of a partner in that partnership or a director or secretary of that company who resides on or adjacent to that agricultural unit and is acting with the legal occupier's consent except where that immediate family member is also a partner in that partnership or a director or secretary of that company;'."I hope that that will have the effect of removing the anomaly. Of course, that does not mean that every member who applies will necessarily be approved, because the FBDS is a competitive and discretionary scheme.I hope that the committee understands that, in drawing the original definition in terms that recognised that many farms are run as partnerships, we inadvertently excluded direct personal relations of those farm operatives. The amendment seeks to rectify that situation and I hope that it has the committee's approval.
That was a good overview of the purpose of the statutory instrument. Does anyone have any technical questions?
I am sorry to say this, but I found subparagraph (d) to be quite ambiguous, although perhaps I am just being a picky English teacher. It talks about"any member of the immediate family of a partner in that partnership or a director … who resides on or adjacent to that agricultural unit".Is it talking about a director who resides there or a member of the immediate family who resides there? The wording does not seem to be absolutely clear.
It is talking about a member of the immediate family. The individual has to be a member of the immediate family and they have to reside on or adjacent to the agricultural unit.
In that case, it should say, "any member of the immediate family of a partner in that partnership or of a director".
It does. I am sorry; I understood the first point that you made, but I do not follow your second point. Clearly, the subparagraph is quite specific. It specifies first of all that, where the legal occupier is a partnership, any member of the immediate family of a partner in that partnership—
Or the immediate family of a director?
It refers to"any member of the immediate family of a partner in that partnership or a director or secretary of that company".The two follow on. The subject of the clause is "the immediate family", and it is the immediate family "of … or", so it is of the limited partnership or the limited company.
It needs a bit of punctuation, then. I am sorry about this, convener. Does the paragraph refer to the immediate family of a partner or of a director? Is the immediate family the subject of the clause, or are there two subjects, the first being "the immediate family" and the second being "a director or secretary"?
No.
Just a second. Before we get ourselves totally tied up in knots about how the grammar could or should be expressed in that paragraph, perhaps the minister should tell us clearly what the intent of the sentence actually is, so that when people who are not sure how they should interpret the punctuation ask in the future what is meant they will be able to find out. Will the minister tell us exactly what the intent of that paragraph is?
That was what I wanted to find out.
Our clear intention is to extend the scheme so that the immediate family of the persons who are either partners or directors of the legal occupier are eligible to apply for grant in the scheme.
That was quite a clear statement. Has reading that paragraph in the statutory instrument and listening to the minister clarified the intent of the statutory instrument?
It was my intention that the minister should clarify absolutely what was meant by that paragraph.
That clarification has been helpful. Are there any other points of clarification or matters of detail that members are keen to explore with the minister and his officials? If not, we can move to the debate. Members will be interested to know that, technically, we are allowed up to 90 minutes for the debate.
Please do not encourage them, convener.
Is it 90 minutes for each member?
No, not for each member but for the entirety of the debate.We move to the debate on the motion. I invite the minister to move motion S2M-1402.
Motion moved,
That the Environment and Rural Development Committee recommends that the Farm Business Development (Scotland) Amendment Scheme 2004 (SSI 2004/236) be approved.—Ross Finnie.
Motion agreed to.
The motion will be recommended to the Parliament. I thank the minister and his officials for coming along to clarify the intention of the statutory instrument and to set out the policy intention that it is meant to deliver.
As they say on such occasions, I am obliged.
In this meeting
Everything on 16 Jun 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 16 June 2004 (Morning) Committee business · 1
- Item in Private Procedure · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 25
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 14
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.