The consensus among the journalists working in the media tower is that stage 3 is particularly complex and difficult to cover. That has consequences for how we construct our reports and cover the issue.
I conducted a wee straw poll among colleagues. I was greeted, by and large, with blank looks. In one case, the response was even worse than that: someone said, “Well, at least you’re the right guy to be doing it because you know where the committee room is.” I’ll not drop Alan Cochrane in it and tell you who said it. Laughter. That is generally the picture among print journalists.
I should say that the SPJA represents not just the print journalists but the broadcasters. Even colleagues at the BBC “Democracy Live” unit, who are probably most closely wired into the minutiae of Parliament’s workings—they describe themselves with pride as the geeks of parliamentary coverage—say that stage 3 is too quick, it is incoherent to the public and the marshalled list of amendments is meaningless. The journalists who work in that unit even find it difficult to pick out the newsworthy items from the marshalled list of amendments. A couple of the words that were used in relation to that were “dense” and “opaque”. That is the reaction of the journalists who know best how the process works.
A specialist health reporter, for example, might be brought in to cover the passage of a health bill but—from a journalistic point of view—the great advantages to bringing in someone like that who has specialist knowledge is nullified by the complexity of the parliamentary procedure. That difficulty impacts on how topics are covered. People tend to cut corners, so the reporting process largely bypasses the ins and outs of stage 3. Mid-afternoon, when it dawns on reporters that they have to file a report on the passage of a bill by 6 o’clock, they will phone the Scottish Government press office to get a quick idiot’s guide to the main provisions; they will tee up the people who are likely to react to it; and they will have the story largely written but for the numbers for the final vote, particularly as they are heading towards newspaper deadlines. A lot of the quite important battles that take place during stage 3 debates about last-minute amendments are dismissed in a single sentence or they are underplayed, so there are consequences for how things are reported.
It was interesting to see in Professor Reid’s written submission the idea of splitting stage 3. That idea has also received a little bit of support from the Law Society of Scotland, and from the Liberal Democrats, I think. It is clearly not for the SPJA to take a view on whether that is a good or sensible thing to do, but it would have a consequence for how the workings of the Parliament were reported. I am well prepared today, so I can give you an example. Earlier this year, the Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill was passed. The BBC website coverage says:
“Increased provision of free childcare is part of a package of reforms which have been approved by MSPs.”
That is the kind of story that reporters knew they were going to be writing at 10 o’clock in the morning. The penultimate paragraph of the BBC coverage states:
“Conservative education spokeswoman Liz Smith tabled a last-minute amendment on the plan that would have limited the named person to under-16s, rather than under-18s. The move was defeated.”
That is the penultimate paragraph. If stage 3 had been split, that would have been the top of the story and the process that I have just described would have happened at what has variously been called stage 3.2 or stage 4—a new stage.
From a reporting point of view, there would be another day of the story and there would be a greater focus on aspects that are currently underplayed. The committee might think that that would be valuable. I do not know.