Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Plant Protection Products (Scotland) Regulations 2003 (SSI 2003/579)

Wednesday 10 December 2003 Environment and Rural Development Committee Subordinate legislation 49 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

49 contributions
Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

We move on to agenda item 2, under which we have three Scottish statutory instruments to consider under the negative procedure: the Prohibition of Keeping or Release of Live Fish (Specified Species) (Scotland) Order 2003 (SSI 2003/560); the Pig Carcase (Grading) Amendment (Scotland) Regulations 2003 (SSI 2003/565); and the Plant Protection Products (Scotland) Regulations 2003 (SSI 2003/579).The instruments have already been considered by the Subordinate Legislation Committee, which commented only on the first instrument. Copies of the relevant extract from the Subordinate Legislation Committee's report have been circulated to members. Do members have any comments?

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

Does anyone know about the pig carcase grading regulations? One way of grading is to be discontinued and I meant to try to get hold of someone in the pig industry to get an explanation of the regulations. The industry can now use something called AUTOFOM but authorisation has been withdrawn for the use of an apparatus called Ultra-FOM. I wondered whether there will be difficulties with the withdrawal of that authorisation, but for all I know it could be something that has not been used for 20 years. Has the company that produced one apparatus been superseded by another?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

The clerk has some background information from the Executive about the consultation process that was carried out before the regulations came to us.

Mark Brough Clerk
link

The Executive note states that the Executive wrote to the industry in August regarding the proposed amendments, and that no objections were raised.

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

Presumably, anyone who uses Ultra-FOM is happy to move to AUTOFOM.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Yes. If you want a note on that technical point, I suspect that it would be possible to find out some information. However, it seems that there has been a consultation, and no objections were received.

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link

It is interesting that, in the industry, the only issue about pig carcase grading over the years has been lack of consistency in grading. Ultimately, anything that improves consistency will be welcomed by the industry.

Karen Gillon Lab Clydesdale
link

It is an optional measure rather than a compulsory measure.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

It is a negative instrument, so it will go through unless someone is unhappy with it. Are members content?

link

Can I ask about the issue that the Subordinate Legislation Committee raised on SSI 2003/560, on live fish?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Shall we finish dealing with the pig carcase regulations first?

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I do not want to prolong the discussion, but if we are moving from Ultra-FOM to AUTOFOM, or the other way round, is there a means of withdrawing the old chemical, process, or whatever it is?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

None of us is an expert on the matter, but there are one or two questions. The clerk has confirmed that we have the opportunity to bring the matter back next week so that the Executive can address and clarify the points that have arisen. We can get a note from the Executive and come back to the matter next week, if members want to do so.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Are we intending to meet next week?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

We must meet formally next week; the question is for how long.

Karen Gillon Lab Clydesdale
link

I recollect that industries are very quick to make representations to us whenever they think that regulations are controversial. Given that no such representations have been made, my gut reaction is that the regulations are not controversial and that we should just get on with them.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

The matter is in members' hands. However, a number of questions have been asked, some of which we cannot answer as we did not receive in advance the notification that would have enabled us to seek more detailed information.

Alasdair Morrison Lab Western Isles
link

Karen Gillon is right. If the regulations were controversial we would already have heard about them from people who are informed about them and will be directly affected by them.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

We can take the matter forward in two ways. We can ask for supplementary information for those members who want it or we can formally defer consideration of the regulations until next week's meeting. I suggest that we choose the first option. Do members agree?

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

At next week's meeting it will take only half a minute to get reassurance on the points that have been raised today. I would rather that our questions were answered before we took any decision on the regulations.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

I am happy to defer consideration until next week. I do not think that the matter is controversial—

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

I am sure that it will prove not to be, but I would feel happier if our questions were answered before we gave the nod to the regulations.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

As a general point, if members want to raise points of clarification or technical questions, it is good practice to notify the clerks before the meeting, so that we can get the information, or chase it up if the Executive has not supplied it. That avoids a situation in which the matter has to appear twice on our agenda. In this case, we can defer consideration of the matter, but we will not always be in a position to do so.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Roseanna Cunningham wanted to raise a point about the Prohibition of Keeping or Release of Live Fish (Specified Species) (Scotland) Order 2003.

link

I am puzzling over the Subordinate Legislation Committee's report on the order, which says that the committee has doubts about whether the order is intra vires or not, which I presume is a long way of saying that the committee thinks that the order might be ultra vires—I do not know why the report does not just say that. The report mentions a definition of Scotland that refers to the Scottish Adjacent Waters Boundaries Order 1999 (SI 1999/1126) and it includes the Scottish Executive's reasons for including in the order the reference to that definition. However, the definition in the instrument itself appears to come from section 126(1) of the Scotland Act 1998, so I do not understand the Subordinate Legislation Committee's point. That committee clearly has a problem with the order, but I am not clear about what that problem is: what the committee says in its report and what the order says do not seem to marry up at all.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

I agree. Having read the Subordinate Legislation Committee's report on the order too, I thought that we would spend time on the matter. Our job is to consider the subject matter of the order, so it is difficult for us to do anything about the order when the key point is whether or not it is intra vires, as we are not in a position to judge that.We have enough time available to include the order on next week's agenda, and I would like the Subordinate Legislation Committee to clarify what we should do about it. The committee's report is not helpful; it simply raises an issue and Roseanna Cunningham is right to say that the committee and the Executive seem to use different reference points.

link

The issue is technical and is not related to the subject matter, so when we send questions back to the Subordinate Legislation Committee, it might be a good idea to copy them to the Parliament's legal adviser, because the question whether an instrument is ultra vires is fundamental.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

The clerk tells me that the Subordinate Legislation Committee receives input from the legal adviser when it considers instruments.

link

We might save some time by copying our queries about the order directly to the adviser.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

We could ask the clerks to make the point.

link

We do not want to be in the position, in two years' time, of having agreed to an order that turns out to have been ultra vires. We would look stupid.

Karen Gillon Lab Clydesdale
link

We need to get back to the Executive to clarify exactly which boundaries are being talked about. I am not convinced that there is necessarily a contradiction, but we need to check. The order raises some concerns with me.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

Our problem is that from reading the paperwork we do not know.

Karen Gillon Lab Clydesdale
link

We should get the full papers, put the issue on next week's agenda and consider it then.

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link

The bit that may be ultra vires is the bit that defines Scotland. If it is ultra vires, does that negate the meat of the order, which is the prohibition on keeping or releasing certain live fish, or will the order stand whether the definition is intra or ultra vires?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

We need to receive proper advice from the Subordinate Legislation Committee and the Executive. I cannot see how we can make a rational judgment on the basis of the information that is in front of us.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I do not know whether the Scottish Adjacent Waters Boundaries Order 1999 supersedes something in the Scotland Act 1998—I do not think that it would. However, I know that adjustments were made to the boundaries during the Scottish elections in 1999—a year after the Scotland Act 1998 was written. I ask to be shown on a map the boundaries that are stated in the Scotland Act 1998 and the boundaries that are delineated in the order, because we know that in certain cases the boundaries may have changed in terms of offshore jurisdiction.

Maureen Macmillan Lab Highlands and Islands
link

That is the point that I was going to make. There was a debate about where Scottish territorial waters should be and where the lines are drawn, as the boundaries may have been different from what people expected.

Maureen Macmillan Lab Highlands and Islands
link

But I presume that the debate was about fish, and the order is about the release of fish. I wonder whether that is where the Subordinate Legislation Committee is coming from.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

I could let the debate go on for some time, but we need additional information. We can come back to this issue next week. The clerks have captured the range of questions. We will see whether, having received the right information, we can have a proper discussion next week.Does anyone have any concerns about the Plant Protection Products (Scotland) Regulations 2003 (SSI 2003/579)?

Eleanor Scott Green Highlands and Islands
link

That is a lovely way to describe pesticides—"plant protection products".

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

If there are no concerns, are we happy to make no recommendation on the regulations?

Members indicated agreement.

Sarah Boyack Lab The Convener · Edinburgh Central
link

We have agreement on one piece of legislation. That is good. I clarify that the other two statutory instruments will come back to us at next week's meeting.

Meeting continued in private until 12:17.

  1. Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 10 December 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 48
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 41
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 49

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.