We will now consider the draft Producer Responsibility Obligations (Packaging Waste) Amendment (Scotland) Regulations 2003. Again, the Subordinate Legislation Committee has considered the instrument and has nothing to report. I will allow a few minutes for the minister's officials to swap round.After that diplomatic pause, I invite the minister to make any opening remarks on the instrument.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Draft Producer Responsibility Obligations (Packaging Waste) Amendment (Scotland) Regulations 2003
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Sarah Boyack Lab 10
- Allan Wilson Lab 8
- John Convery Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department 8
- Roseanna Cunningham SNP 6
- Nora Radcliffe LD 5
- Eleanor Scott Green 1
- Rob Gibson SNP 1
The record
41 contributionsThe draft regulations—which must have the longest name of any draft regulations that I have put before the committee—contain the latest in a series of amendments that have been made to the packaging recovery scheme since it was introduced in 1997. The scheme requires businesses covered by the regulations to take responsibility for ensuring that target levels of recovery and recycling of packaging waste are met each year. They can do that either individually or collectively through membership of a compliance scheme.The primary purpose of the draft regulations is to set new business recovery and recycling targets for packaging waste for the years 2004 to 2008. Those will ensure progress to recover more of that waste stream in line with the objectives of the national waste strategy and to build towards the new European directive targets that are expected to be set for 2008 and beyond.The draft regulations make a number of changes to the existing system, which are aimed at streamlining its workings, improving the quality of data submission and improving accountability. Subject to Parliament's approval, they will come into effect on 1 January 2004. With the other Administrations in the United Kingdom, we consulted widely on the changes during the summer. We sought views on the future targets and on a range of possible measures to improve the existing system. I will outline the most significant changes.The first change is to make the acquisition of packaging recovery notes—PRNs—a statutory requirement. That will eliminate the potential for an obligated party to try to discharge its obligation by an alternative means, which may or may not be directly beneficial to the UK's efforts to meet the directive targets. Secondly, the regulations will make the approved recyclers accreditation process a statutory one. That will set down conditions that recyclers must meet in return for being permitted to issue PRNs. It will also enable SEPA to charge a fee to recover the cost of inspecting and auditing the reprocessor, which it currently cannot do.Thirdly, the regulations will clarify ministers' position as regards the approval of compliance schemes. Currently, a compliance scheme must be approved by ministers before it may register with SEPA, but the regulations are silent about the process itself. The amendments rectify that. Finally, the regulations will make compliance scheme operators legally responsible for discharging the obligations of their members, which will avoid any confusion in future over the legal responsibilities of compliance scheme operators.A number of technical measures have been included in the regulations to ensure more robust collection and assessment of data on packaging use. The measures in the draft regulations were endorsed by the Advisory Committee on Packaging prior to consultation and, when they were put out to consultation, received the broad support of the packaging-using industry. By setting new recovery and recycling targets for 2004-08 and by improving the system in the way that I have described, the regulations will enable Scotland and the UK to meet the packaging directive's obligations. I commend the regulations to the committee.
I will take members' points of clarification and questions.
The policy objectives that are laid out in the Executive note say that the regulations"apply to companies with annual turnover of £2m and which manufacture or use 50 tonnes of packaging products or materials each year".Let me put in basic terms a point that might be obvious to everyone else, but is not obvious to me. When the Executive note refers to companies that"manufacture or use 50 tonnes of packaging products"does it mean that the manufacturer or the person who packages the jammy dodgers will be done under these regulations, but not the supermarket that stocks them on its shelves? Are the supermarkets completely out of the picture in that sense?
No, they are not. We are referring to the manufacture of the packaging, which means that the obligation falls on the manufacturer of the wrapper and the person who makes the jammy dodger and puts it into the wrapper. The regulations apply to everyone in the packaging chain.
But, under the regulations, the supermarket that puts the product on its shelves is not considered to be part of that chain.
It is. Retailers are obligated under the regulations.
I just wanted to clarify that point, because it would be difficult to pursue hundreds of different companies for every piece of packaging.
It would be useful to find out how the packaging chain works.
Yes. It is the key to the whole thing.
How would responsibility for compliance be allocated to the various parts of the process? After all, if we use the jammy dodger example, there is a whole chain right down to the point at which the biscuits are sitting in a great heap on the shelves in their three or so layers of packaging.
The regulations apportion packaging use among manufacturers of the primary packaging product or material; the converters of the packaging material into the packaging product; the industries or businesses that use the packaging; and the seller or wholesaler. As a result, everyone who handles or uses packaging is caught in the system.
All the way down the line?
Yes.
That sounds quite complex, but I assume that, because you have consulted the industry, people now understand their respective roles as far as the obligations are concerned.
I just wanted to clarify that the supermarket does not avoid responsibility because it does not package; it also has a responsibility simply by stocking and selling the goods.
It is a fair point. I should also point out that the chain extends to the importing of packaging.
The department should be commended for the in-depth work that has obviously gone into the regulations. Indeed, it is one of the most impressive sets of background papers that we have ever received for a statutory instrument.
It will all be repackaged.
Can I have an idiot's guide to how these compliance companies with members work?
Sorry?
I presume that there are businesses that make it their business to help their members comply. Will you give us the idiot's guide to how those businesses work?
Okay. I must be the idiot.Individual businesses can join what are called compliance schemes. At that point, their recovery obligation is transferred to the scheme, which allows the small or larger business to get on with selling or making whatever it sells or makes and not to worry about the compliance effort. It pays a fee to the compliance scheme, which collates the data, works out the obligation, ensures that the obligation is met and reports to SEPA. The scheme is registered with SEPA.
So it has the same sort of role as an accountant who does your books.
Very much so. The compliance scheme also takes on a member's legal obligation.
We have proposed that, because it was not always the case. Although individual companies that registered with SEPA directly had statutory responsibilities, such responsibilities did not always extend to compliance schemes. That is why such an approach has not always worked and why we have made the change. The only sanction was deregistration, which might not have been the most appropriate under the circumstances. Fines and/or penalties are probably more appropriate for individual breaches.
And presumably SEPA monitors the whole thing. Does it carry out spot checks, audit trails and so on?
It carries out fairly regular inspections and publishes an inspections programme. I do not really know the conditions for various schemes and companies, but I think that no one should go for more than three years without being inspected or audited.
The fact that SEPA will now be able to charge a fee for cost recovery will make it employ more staff to do more.
Yes; SEPA will carry out more inspections.
As there are no other points of clarification or questions, I invite the deputy minister to speak to and move motion S2M-672, in the name of Ross Finnie, on the draft Producer Responsibility Obligations (Packaging Waste) Amendment (Scotland) Regulations 2003.
The draft amendment regulations will make a significant change to improving further recycling and reuse of packaging waste, on which we have a good record over the past five years, during which we have almost doubled our target. I move,That the Environment and Rural Development Committee recommends that the draft Producer Responsibility Obligations (Packaging Waste) Amendment (Scotland) Regulations 2003 be approved.
With regard to the regulatory impact assessment, the risk assessment assumes an increase in packaging waste over the years. There is an obvious increase in what is recycled, but there is also an overall increase in the production of packaging waste. Are there any moves at any level to try to reduce that? That point was raised in our inquiry into the national waste plan.
We are in the formal debate now, so I will take members' comments together. Having looked at all the paperwork, I note that the draft regulations will come into effect on 1 January, which is probably not a day on which we will be looking at the Executive website. It occurs to me that although the draft regulations put quite a significant responsibility on people, they are a good-news story about improving the way in which we treat our waste. Eleanor Scott made the point that we are not talking about less waste; we are talking about dealing with a big problem. I hope that that will concentrate people's minds. It would be useful if the Executive were able to produce some information to go on to the website—even if only for one day—so that people could understand the substance of the regulations. It would take people quite a while to wade through the committee's paperwork. The draft regulations represent another marker in the progress that we are making on the national waste plan. I ask the minister to reflect on my suggestion.
I want a reality check. I am sorry if I missed the figures, but the deputy minister said that we have doubled the amount of recovery. Will he state the figure for recovery that we started with, so that I can understand the amount to which it has doubled?
As members have no more comments, I ask the minister to wind up the debate and to reflect on members' comments as he does so.
The first point, about waste minimisation, was the most important one. Waste minimisation is a key part of our national waste strategy. Built into the draft regulations are incentives for producers and the industry to reduce the amount of waste that they produce and, in so doing, to reduce the requirement on them to reuse or recycle. That will reduce the obligation on and the cost to the producers and society in general of the production of waste. Our waste repackaging, reuse and recycling scheme is well regarded in Europe. It is one of the most efficient schemes and has one of the lowest compliance costs. The figures for 1997 show that we recovered 3 million tonnes; by 2002, the figure had increased to 5 million tonnes, which is a 65 per cent compliance rate across the piece. In 1997, the UK recovery rate was 30 per cent; it is now 58 per cent and increasing. Those are significant improvements, both numerically and in percentages terms, if you like. On the convener's point, it is appropriate that we look at the website and the way in which we disseminate information to the wider public because, as members appreciate, a lot of the information is technical. Although it is well understood by the waste packaging industry, I suspect that it is much less well understood by the man and woman in the street. We will consider that.
The question is, that motion S2M-672, in the name of Ross Finnie, be agreed to.
Motion agreed to.
That the Environment and Rural Development Committee recommends that the draft Producer Responsibility Obligations (Packaging Waste) Amendment (Scotland) Regulations 2003 be approved.
I thank the minister and his officials for attending. The committee will report formally to the Parliament on both instruments.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Dec 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 10 December 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 48
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 41
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 49
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.