The next current petition is PE1495, by Rab Wilson, on the use of gagging clauses in agreements with national health service staff in Scotland. Members have a note by the clerk and the submissions. Members will know that the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing said on 27 February that confidentiality clauses will be removed from standard NHS settlement agreements in Scotland and will be used
“only where there is explicit agreement between both the employer and the employee.”
It is up to members to decide how we deal with the petition. The two main options are to close it in the light of that information, or to continue it—as we are doing with the petition from Alan Kennedy—to allow us to analyse what happens in practice.
It is clear from the correspondence that the committee has received from the Scottish Government and the cabinet secretary that there is a clear commitment to remove confidentiality clauses from standard NHS settlement agreements in Scotland. My concern about closing the petition is that we would not be able to continue our on-going scrutiny function with regard to the implementation of Government policy by health boards in Scotland. I ask the committee to pause and reflect on that point before taking a decision.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
There is an issue. The convener highlighted the cabinet secretary’s wish that gagging clauses be removed from any settlements between an employer and an employee, and any agreement should be dealt with in that manner with regard to such clauses.
The difficulty is that many settlements between employers and employees are subject to employment legislation. As I think Jim Eadie alluded to—he can correct me if I am wrong—it might be difficult to get to the debate and discussion that takes place at meetings between employers and employees so that we can ascertain whether gagging clauses are actually enforced, in financial terms. Employers can do things in ways that do not involve directly stating that a settlement is subject to a gagging clause. The question is how we get information from the human resources departments of the health boards throughout the country on the individual discussions that take place between the employee and employer.
Jim Eadie is right that we should keep the petition open to allow further scrutiny of the practices that are put in place by HR departments and health boards throughout Scotland. We can then get an accurate reflection, and we will know whether they are reflecting what the cabinet secretary has indicated he wishes to happen rather than engaging in a back-door discussion that allows the practice to continue.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
That is a useful point. One possibility would be for us to write again to Scotland’s health boards in six months’ time and ask them to confirm their actual practice, so that we get the information direct from the horse’s mouth.
Members may correct me if I am wrong, but it is my understanding that the cabinet secretary and/or the minister are now getting involved in signing off compromise agreements, although I cannot imagine that they will be signing off all of them. That in itself demands that we keep the petition open.
That will allow us to understand better the rationale behind what has been happening, notwithstanding the signing of compromise agreements. I know that the UK Secretary of State for Health believes that such agreements will not prevent people from speaking out but, as we heard two weeks ago, that has not been the case. It is important that, as Jim Eadie said, we continue to have the ability to scrutinise the issue.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
Chic Brodie is right. The petitioner has been good at submitting evidence to the committee and highlighting cases in which compromise agreements are being forced on employees. If we agree to keep the petition open for six months, I am sure that, if there are any cases out there, they will come back to the committee and we will be made aware of any difficulties that exist in particular health boards.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.