Good morning, and thank you for the opportunity to speak to the committee about the petition.
Ultimately, I respect that it is Parliament’s role to legislate; what I aim to do is simply to inform members in order to aid that legislative process. I emphasise that there is more common ground between me and Mr Chisholm than might immediately be apparent. I am grateful to him for raising the issue because it has brought an issue to the fore.
I believe that Mr Chisholm and I are starting from the same point: we want Scottish public authorities to be open, transparent and honest in their communication, and we want citizens to be confident that they are being told the whole and accurate story, within the law. Where Mr Chisholm and I have differing perspectives is that I take the view that the current legislative framework—that is, FOISA and beyond—largely provides for that.
The main focus of the petition is that the law does not specify that authorities must provide accurate and up-to-date information; it specifies that they must provide the information that they hold. My understanding is that Mr Chisholm requested information from the Scottish Borders Council and was given information that he had good reason to believe was wrong—information that was factually incorrect.
Mr Chisholm challenged the information and the council gave him further information. He was understandably unhappy that the council did not, on the first pass, give him all the information that it held. He appears to have interpreted that as being dishonest behaviour, which resulted in his getting what he sees as inaccurate information.
I can only assume—because he did not take up his right to appeal to me—that Mr Chisholm was content that ultimately, he received all the information that the council held in relation to his request. In that context, I can only speak hypothetically from what I understand of his experience through the petition process. I cannot know for certain whether there was dishonest behaviour, but I can conclude with some confidence that the council did not get it right first time. Had it done so, Mr Chisholm would have received all the information—information that I assume he was ultimately happy with—on the first time of asking.
The evidence last week emphasised Mr Chisholm’s concern that authorities do not have to behave in an honest and truthful way. I think that they do, but FOISA is only one part of the framework that aims to ensure that that is the case. It could be potentially damaging to consider FOISA in isolation from other legislation relating to a range of subjects, which include conduct in public life, public record keeping and how public authorities report.
It might also be helpful to consider a couple of conceptual points. First, there is the nature of accuracy in the context of the debate. My take on Mr Chisholm’s case is that it appears that it was the application of FOISA that was inaccurate, in the sense that had the authority applied FOISA accurately in the first place, all the information that was held would have been given to Mr Chisholm. When that is not the case, FOISA has a remedy.
Another way of looking at the concept of accuracy is to refer to the accuracy of the information on the page. To put it crudely, were the numbers on the page the real ones or the right ones? That fundamentally changes the nature of the accuracy debate in relation to FOISA, because it moves FOISA away from being a measure for challenging access to information to being one in which we are potentially having to check that documents are right before they are issued, in order to determine whether they should even be disclosed.
The second conceptual point that I want to consider is the nature of honesty in the context of this debate. We could ask the hypothetical question: did the council act honestly but mistakenly when it gave out partial information, or did it act dishonestly by knowingly not giving out information the first time round? We cannot know the answer, but an investigation under FOISA could have reached a view on that.
We then come to whether information is correct or right when it is disclosed. What FOISA adds in that context is that it can ensure that the information is disclosed, thus making it public and enabling wider scrutiny in relation to its accuracy or truthfulness. The issue comes up in appeals to me. Sometimes a requester gets access to information to test the probity of a decision by an authority, for example. The requester might want facts or analysis that the authority considered, and if they can prove that the fact or analysis was wrong, they could challenge the authority’s decision. They are holding the authority accountable and enabling that sort of scrutiny. There have been notable cases in which the approach has worked.
The important point is that FOI gives a right to see the information that the authority holds. If we get the information and then find that it is inaccurate, we can challenge appropriately, through the appropriate legislation.
FOISA can also help in that if such scrutiny suggests that what was disclosed was inaccurate because it was altered or information was deliberately withheld, there is provision to investigate the matter further as a criminal matter. I think that my most recent briefing covered that in more detail.
We have a strong law in Scotland. It is recognised internationally, and one of the strongest aspects of the regime is its enforcement provisions. We can enforce every step of the way, and a commissioner’s decision is binding.
Our FOI law is also stringent in ways that might not be immediately apparent. It is not often appreciated that I am obliged by law to accept all valid appeals. That means that I have to issue a decision notice; I cannot choose which cases I look at. Therefore, the citizen has the right, if they make a valid appeal, to get a decision from me. There is always that scrutiny.
The rights are legally enforceable. A good indication of our enforcement powers is that, to date, no Scottish public authority has failed to comply with a commissioner decision. They might have challenged a few through the Court of Session, but they have not failed to apply them.
If I find that an authority has acted unlawfully—that is, that it has not followed the provisions of the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002—that is reflected in a decision notice. Decision notices can be reported on and used by other people in various ways, but I think that they constitute the public reprimand for which the petitioner is calling.
You will have seen, in my previous briefing, information on section 65 of FOISA, which enables us to challenge and potentially to investigate as a criminal matter the deliberate changing of information. Ultimately, if that is found to be the case, there could be a fine of up to £5,000.
One thing that I emphasise about section 65 is that it was recently updated by the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Amendment Act 2013, which put right what we saw as being a flaw in relation to when cases on the sort of allegations that I am talking about could be brought.
10:15
It is also probably worth sharing with the committee that the one section 65 case in which I have been personally involved did not end in a prosecution. It was investigated, but the important point was that it resulted in accurate information being disclosed to the requester. The original information was inaccurate and what the requester ended up with was accurate.
In summary, my concern with the proposal in the petition that relates to public bodies being
“duty bound to provide accurate information”
is that that would fundamentally change the nature of FOISA and could impose a significant resource burden for something that can already be addressed.