The next current petition is PE1497, by Ellie Harrison, on behalf of Say No to Tesco, on supermarket expansion on local high streets. Members have a note by the clerk and submissions. There was a good response from local authorities. I found the submissions quite interesting when I looked through them this morning. Do members have any general comments?
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Supermarkets (High Streets) (PE1497)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- David Stewart Lab 6
- Chic Brodie SNP 4
- Angus MacDonald SNP 2
- Jackson Carlaw Con 1
- Jim Eadie SNP 1
The record
14 contributionsI was interested in the response from Falkirk Council’s chief executive, Mary Pitcaithly, in which she made a number of valid points, as did Alastair Mitchell from the Falkirk business improvement district company and Falkirk and District Town Centre Management Ltd—I suggested that she might contact him. Their comments relate mainly to Falkirk town centre. As they point out, the situation there is quite different from that which is presented by the petitioners in the Glasgow area, but similar concerns to those of the petitioners have been expressed with regard to the district centres in the Falkirk Council area—in particular in Grangemouth, where a new Asda store opened just on the outskirts of the town centre in 2007. That store had a dramatic impact on the footfall in the town centre and hurt a number of independent retailers, which are still trading, but only just.
Similarly, I am aware of the situation in Stornoway—as you will be, convener—where a Tesco and a Co-operative are operating on the outskirts of the town centre and have severely impacted on the footfall in the town centre.
A number of valid points are raised in the submissions that we have received and I have some sympathy with the petitioners when I see what has happened with the larger out-of-town retail stores. However, the other argument from local authorities is that smaller supermarkets—Tesco Metros and so on—seem to retain footfall in the town centres and high streets. I would say that the jury is out on this one until we see more of those smaller stores developing in our high streets.
I am still not entirely persuaded. I invited the petitioners to send us an evidence-based list of the stores that had closed. In fact, I spent some time on Great Western Road on Friday afternoon just to see what it was like and there was hardly a vacant unit the length of Great Western Road. The shops were all thriving and they were busy.
I assume that if some units have gone in the natural course of business, others have taken their place. Specifically, I took time to look for the Sainsbury’s Local unit, which is about halfway down the road between the River Kelvin and the city centre. I looked around and I saw other fresh produce stores that were still operating in that environment. The petitioners attributed the closure of a specific store at the other end to the opening of Waitrose, but in fact the Waitrose store was not a new unit—it replaced an existing supermarket.
I wonder whether these small supermarkets have a prejudicial effect, as has been suggested, or whether they bring a certain amount of pizzazz and attraction to an area that has suffered from a drop in footfall traffic, and collectively bring more business to the area. Like Angus MacDonald, I am not persuaded that it would be right to try to introduce any kind of restriction.
11:00
When the petitioners appeared before the committee, I engaged in some robust questioning on why the name of the company had been used, which concerned me.
Having looked—as I would—at the response from South Ayrshire Council, and having had discussions last week about other developments in South Ayrshire, I am somewhat concerned about the limitation that would apply to the class 1 planning process. A large toy retailer, which will remain nameless, applied to have a shop in the middle of Ayr High Street, but it was turned down because it did not fit in with the development plan or the planning process. We sometimes micromanage things unnecessarily. I share Jackson Carlaw’s view that some of these shops can bring in footfall that there might not otherwise be in the town and therefore bring benefits to other shops.
The key issue for the committee is whether we see this as something that the Scottish Government has a role in; if we do, the suggestion is that we ask the Scottish Government how business rates relief is used to support small and medium-sized businesses. If we see it as a wider issue that is really to do with competition—as members know, that is a reserved issue—we do not really have a locus.
I seek members’ views. Should we continue the petition and write to the Scottish Government? Alternatively, is it predominantly about competition, in which case we do not really have a locus?
There is a tension between the need to promote economic growth at all costs and the need to reflect the views of local communities. There has been an expansion of these businesses in the south of Edinburgh, which I represent. There has to be a balance and it is necessary for each application to be taken on its merits. However, there is concern among the community that some of these developments reduce the footfall for small, independent traders. It would be valuable to have some information on that; perhaps we could ask the Federation of Small Businesses whether it has had any feedback from its members on the impact of the growth in smaller supermarkets.
To balance our consideration of the issues, I add that a Sainsbury’s Local has opened in Marchmont in my constituency. Through a partnership with Remploy, it is employing people who would have had trouble accessing employment in the current labour market. A number of issues have to be considered in reaching a judgment, but there is no doubt that there is concern in the south of Edinburgh about what is perceived to be the overexpansion of this type of businesses.
I agree with Jim Eadie about consultation, but it is about something much wider than the consultation process; it is about looking at how development plans are being developed, and the definition of the retail policy and what areas it applies to. For example, one issue is whether a food shop is allowed to open in a certain part of an area. Funnily enough, the policy is not applied equally across all councils, so I think that a much wider issue is involved. However, I take the point that awareness of the impact on the local community should be part of the application of planning process policy.
We received a full report from the Federation of Small Businesses that probably covers Mr Eadie’s earlier point. Are members agreed that we should write to the Scottish Government about business rates relief? Its response will not be the answer to all the issues that are raised in the petition, but I believe that it would be useful to have that information before we make a final decision on the petition.
I am not sure whether a change to the application of business rates relief will change the policy in question. As I said, we should consider how consistently planning policy is being applied across different areas for the macroretail sector. I am sure that the policy has not been defined clearly enough and I know that it is applied differently by different councils.
We could write to the Scottish Government and ask how it ensures that there is such consistency.
It would be interesting to see the response to that. Experience of my local area suggests to me that there is very little consistency of the kind suggested.
All our regions or constituencies have experienced problems from urban town centres losing footfall as a result of out-of-town developments. I had a one-off meeting with a retail developer the other day who said to me that it is not a zero-sum game. Perhaps I should rephrase that—they said that they are not looking to develop within cities but that they want to develop on the outskirts of cities. It is not a case of developers saying, “Either we develop here or we don’t develop at all.”
I know that BID teams in my area are concerned about city centre developments and how small local and family businesses are losing trade. It is a worry across Scotland.
Yes, but it is much wider than that. I can talk only about some of the towns in the south of Scotland, but it is not just about shops. It is about having places to live in town centres, having entertainment complexes in town centres and having proper transport facilities that make it easier for people to shop in town centres. That is why I have expressed concern about why we are focusing on business rates relief.
Are members happy for us to ask the Scottish Government about the consistency of approach point, to which Chic Brodie referred earlier? We can consider the Government’s response at a future meeting. Is that agreed?
Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 1 Apr 2014 →- 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 66
- 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 14
- 10:45 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- 10:45 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 10:45 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- 11:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- 11:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.