The next current petition is PE1482, by John Womersley, on isolation in single-room hospitals. Members have a note by the clerk and the submissions. Alex Fergusson MSP has an interest in the petition and would have attended today’s meeting, but he had a prior engagement.
I invite comments from members, although I flag up one option, which is to write to the Government seeking confirmation that patient and public views should be sought to inform the proposed review and to ask whether the Government has undertaken a cost benefit analysis of having 100 per cent single rooms compared to 50 per cent over the course of a hospital’s lifetime and, if so, whether it will share that information with the committee.
When we considered the petition previously, I raised a question about expense and, leaving aside the personal aspect, how much might have been saved had we consulted on mixed-room hospitals. To an extent, the cabinet secretary’s letter of 19 March lays out the estimated impact. One also has to look at the longer-term costs arising from the impact of non-socialisation of patients who do not wish to be in single rooms. I have had several representations from people in the medical profession who have suggested that there is a disbenefit from applying a policy of single rooms, because multibedded rooms can assist with the betterment of a person’s medical condition. Of course, that does not apply to everyone, but the 50 per cent rule was initially aligned with that thought.
I am kind of with the cabinet secretary on this. There are people who, in response to public opinion surveys, would say that they would prefer that we still had segregated carriages on trains rather than open carriages, but we cannot provide a mix of both just because people would like that. The development of a hospital is a long-term thing. It might not be easy to simply reconfigure accommodation to suit at any particular moment in time.
Politically, I have supported the Government’s announcements on the development of single-room hospitals for a variety of reasons, including infection control and having en suite facilities for each patient—a whole range of things has influenced my decision on that. Although I think that there is a role for patient opinion in all this, the hospital’s primary responsibility is to heal the patient and have them leave hospital at the earliest possible time and in the best possible health.
I think that a slightly homoeopathic element is being brought into the discussion, rather than a clinical one. I am not sure, therefore, that I feel moved to disagree with the cabinet secretary’s policy position on this.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
I will not rise to the bait of Mr Carlaw’s comments. There has to be a balance and optimal care has to be the driver rather than cost reduction; the comments from other members are largely correct in that regard.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
I will not ask the committee to make an absolute decision just now on whether they are in favour of 100 per cent single rooms. I will ask whether patient and public views should be part of this. There is also the issue of the cost benefit analysis to follow up, on which we did not get a categoric reply. That is what I am asking the committee to do now, instead of making any definitive decision. Do members agree with that course of action?
Members indicated agreement.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.