Petition PE517 is specifically concerned with the waste water treatment plant in Seafield, claiming that noxious odours emanating from the plant are hazardous to the health of local residents. Following the circulation of the petition's cover note, there has been coverage in the press suggesting that the City of Edinburgh Council is considering legal action against Scottish Water in relation to the plant. That is a result of independent research commissioned by Scottish Water into the odours emanating from the plant.Members should note the recommended action that is set out in the petition's covering note.Susan Deacon has joined us and would like to speak to the committee on this matter.
Official Report · Committee
Public Petitions
Water Treatment Plants (PE517)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Sarah Boyack Lab 4
- Susan Deacon Lab 2
- Maureen Macmillan Lab 1
The record
8 contributionsI would like to make a few brief points and also acknowledge the work done by the Transport and the Environment Committee in the previous session. That committee was influential in relation to the progress that has been made on this issue. However, it would be wrong to suggest that the issue is resolved either locally or nationally, in terms of statute and regulation.The problem that the petition deals with has a long history. The Seafield plant, which is the largest sewage treatment plant in Scotland, serves Edinburgh and much of the surrounding area. Odour has been a problem for decades, but it was hoped—and expected, on the basis of assurances from East of Scotland Water—that the odour issue would be addressed following a major investment in the plant a few years ago. That investment allowed huge strides forward in local bathing water quality, which was one of its main aims, but the odour problem has persisted. Despite persistent efforts by me, by Gavin Strang, who is the local MP, by the local residents association, by the local community council and by others, the problem remains to be resolved. There have been many meetings, liaison committees, action plans and penalties served against the contractor, but the problem has still not been resolved.Most recently, Scottish Water stepped up its efforts and attitude, and acknowledged the scale of the problem more explicitly. It has also commissioned independent assessment, which local people have long asked for. As the convener noted, the investigating officer from the City of Edinburgh Council has reached the view that a nuisance exists, and consideration is being given to the serving of an abatement notice, on which counsel's opinion is being sought.The committee has the opportunity to make a huge difference on the issue, not just as it affects people in Edinburgh, but as it affects people in other communities in other parts of Scotland with similar odour problems. We appreciate that waste water treatment plants—sewage works, in other words—are vital facilities that are needed throughout the country. However, communities should not have to suffer to the existing extent just because they live close to those facilities. The technology exists to address odour issues. With the will and the investment, those problems can be resolved.The issue relates to quality of life. Smell might be hard to measure—I suspect that that is why it has not been given the attention that other environmental nuisances have had—but it is real to the people whom it affects. As representatives of the local community said when they presented the petition, 4,000 noses can't be wrong.Most recently, as part of its independent assessment, Scottish Water commissioned a customer survey over a wider area than I expected. That covered an area with a radius of a number of miles from the plant. One quarter of residents said that they were affected by the smell. Many had to close windows, could not hang out washing and did not want their kids to play outside on hot days. That is unacceptable. Odour has not been treated seriously enough in the past by service providers or policy makers. The statutory regulatory regime is, at best, overly complex and confusing, and at worst, inadequate. The matter raises planning law and environmental protection law issues. I welcome the Minister for Environment and Rural Development's acknowledgement of inadequacies on the issue, which he gave in response to the Transport and the Environment Committee's efforts in the previous session. He gave a commitment at least to introduce a voluntary code of conduct and to conduct a consultation. Now that we have a new Parliament, I hope that we will keep up the pressure on the Executive to progress the action that it has promised and to ensure that, once and for all, we give odour nuisances the attention that they deserve and that people expect us to give them.I hope that that helped to give the committee a sense of the extent of the problem and the strength of feeling. I look forward to hearing the committee's comments.
I thank the member for her presentation, which was just about kept under five minutes.The committee has three suggested options in the briefing paper. Do members have any views on them? I have followed progress in the local press, and I used to have to visit sewage treatment works, so I know that odour is a sensitive issue. The situation depends partly on people's location downwind or upwind of a sewage treatment works.I do not want to close out the petition, as option A suggests, but I am keen to await the outcome of the outstanding appeal that has been lodged with the House of Lords. Once we know the result, we could keep up the pressure on the Minister for Environment and Rural Development, as Susan Deacon suggested, and ask what measures the Executive will take. As Susan Deacon said, the issue might involve not only Seafield but other sewage treatment works. Relevant factors are scale and location in the built environment, but the matter will not go away. After we know the result of the appeal, the committee can decide how to proceed and whether we want a reporter. Am I right in thinking that until we have the House of Lords result, a legislative proposal from the minister is unlikely? That is guesswork.
I do not know how long we will have to wait for the result of the appeal, but other odour nuisances come not only from sewage works, but from landfill sites, knackeries and rendering plants. I would like to pursue with the minister odour control more widely and not just in relation to the Seafield plant.
We could write to ask the minister whether a voluntary framework or a tougher parliamentary regulatory framework is envisaged. We could do that on the back of the Seafield issue, which is a major concern to people that has been running for some time.
I appreciate that the outstanding appeal has a bearing on the issue and I am sure that the Executive is monitoring it closely, but that does not preclude the Executive's making progress and the committee's putting pressure on the Executive in the meantime.
We have broad agreement that we will write to the minister. If we can return to the petition in a couple of months' time, as we will to our other petitions, we will do that.We have worked our way through our agenda and will now go into private, as we agreed at our meeting last week, to discuss our approach to the budget process. I invite the official report, broadcasting, the public and visiting members to leave the room.
Meeting continued in private until 12:49.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Sep 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 10 September 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 128
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 23
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
- Work Programme Procedure · 12
- Public Petitions Petitions · 1
- Public Petitions Petitions · 16
- Public Petitions Petitions · 13
- Public Petitions Petitions · 25
- Public Petitions Petitions · 2
- Public Petitions Petitions · 8
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.