We will move on, as we have important business to deal with. We have three statutory instruments on animal welfare to consider under the affirmative procedure. I welcome the Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development again and his new set of officials.Copies of the instruments have been circulated to members. The Subordinate Legislation Committee reported on the instruments in its third report of 2003 and made points only about the draft Welfare of Farmed Animals (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2003. The relevant extract of the report was circulated to members as paper ERD/S2/03/4/2D for this meeting.As the instruments are subject to the affirmative procedure, the Parliament must approve them before they come into force. Three motions in the name of Ross Finnie invite the committee to recommend to Parliament that the instruments be approved. Before we debate the motions, it is our usual practice to clarify purely technical matters or to ask for explanations of detail from officials, who cannot participate in the debate on the motions.I invite the deputy minister to make an opening statement on all three instruments, after which we will move on to clarification and explanation for members and to the debate.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Welfare of Farmed Animals (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2003 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Sarah Boyack Lab 8
- Allan Wilson Lab 5
- Alex Johnstone Con 4
- Iain Holt Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department 1
- Eleanor Scott Green 1
The record
23 contributionsThe draft Welfare of Farmed Animals (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2003 and their related RIAs—whose availability coincided with the launching of the regulations, I am pleased to say—apply to pig welfare. They implement Council directive 2001/88/EC and Commission directive 2001/93/EC by amending the Welfare of Farmed Animals (Scotland) Regulations 2000 as they apply to pigs. The regulations have been the subject of full public consultation. Separate legislation applies in England, Wales and Northern Ireland.Some time ago, directive 98/58/EC set minimum standards for all farmed animals throughout the European Union and provided a framework for species-specific standards that was implemented in Scotland by the 2000 regulations. Directives 2001/88/EC and 2001/93/EC lay down minimum standards for the protection of pigs and they will be implemented through amendment to the 2000 regulations. Directives that will apply throughout Europe must be implemented in full, but the Scottish regulations do not go further than is required—that is, the directives have not been gold plated by us. The key provision of the directives is that an EU-wide ban on close-confinement sow stalls be fully in place by 1 January 2013.The regulations involve transitional provisions; in particular, they will replace schedule 6 of the existing 2000 regulations. Part I of the regulations contains interpretation; part II covers general additional conditions, including permanent access to manipulable materials; and part III deals with boars—it includes an additional minimum floor area requirement for pens that will need to be met by 1 January 2005 for existing buildings. Part IV deals with sows and gilts. It contains requirements to group house sows and gilts, minimum space requirements and a minimum continuous solid lying area—existing buildings have until 1 January 2013 to comply with those specifications. Part V deals with piglets and changes the minimum weaning age, with the exception of all-in, all-out systems. Part VI deals with weaners and rearing pigs.The directives will be subject to review in 2005. That review will cover castration, space allowances and floor types for weaners and rearing pigs. A more major review will take place in 2008, which, I understand, will consider farrowing systems, among other matters.On the new welfare codes, pigs and cattle were previously covered by codes of recommendation that date back to 1983 and which are consequently in need of updating. The new codes have been prepared to be user friendly and to highlight the legal requirements of welfare advice. The codes have been made under section 3 of the Agriculture (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1968 and may be used as evidence in prosecutions for unnecessary pain, distress, suffering or injury to livestock, for example.Stock keepers must have access to the codes, have knowledge of them and focus on animal welfare. The codes will apply in Scotland—there will be separate codes for England, Wales and Northern Ireland. There has been full public consultation and full consideration has been given to comments that have been received. As a consequence, the draft codes have been adapted.The pig welfare code provides guidance on the new regulations for farmers and the cattle welfare code has been issued in the absence of specific EU welfare proposals. The cattle welfare code takes account of recommendations in the Farm Animal Welfare Council's dairy cattle report and the Council of Europe's recommendations on cattle.I am sure that members will agree that the regulations and welfare codes will play an important part in improving animal welfare standards, so I do not expect them to be as contentious as the orders that we recently debated. I hope that that will be the case and commend the regulations and the two welfare codes to the committee.
I thank the minister. Although I do not wish to prejudge what members will say, I do not expect a lengthy debate. However, I reassure members that, technically, each affirmative instrument can be debated for up to 90 minutes, so there will be time for debate.
I take it that we are talking about both codes and the regulations at this stage.
There should be points of clarification on all three.
I thank the minister for laying the codes of practice. My experience as a dairy farmer led me to read through the code that relates to that. In my view, it simply asks all farmers to do what good farmers have been doing for years.My experience leads me to be concerned about an issue that relates largely to pigs, although it can be more general. The Executive has had a tendency to introduce measures ahead of our competitor countries within the European Union. Will the minister reassure me that the time scales that other countries, such as Holland and Denmark, follow for the introduction of the measures that we are considering will not be so far removed from the time scales that are being applied here that the beleaguered Scottish pig industry will suffer a further competitive disadvantage?
We, too, are extremely conscious of the fact that, on pig welfare, the pig industry in Scotland and in the UK as a whole is in advance of the pig industries in European and other competitor countries. As I said in my introduction, we have been at pains not to gold plate the directive beyond the requirements that are contained in the codes and regulations that are under consideration. That is because we are conscious of the competitive impact of this country's superior welfare provision.The solution is not to dumb down welfare standards—I know that Alex Johnstone is not proposing that—but to secure greater international agreement among those who deal in pig flesh or, more generally, animal meat to ensure that welfare standards in other countries are brought up to match those in the UK and Europe. The time scales that are envisaged might not be what the UK would have wanted—there might be longer lead-in periods—but, in our view, they are sufficient to protect the interests of the Scottish and UK pig industries.
All member states are required to implement the measures in the relevant directives by 1 January 2003. That should produce a level playing field but, as the minister said, the lead-in time stretches out until 2013. That is not unusual for European Commission directives on welfare.
As members have no further questions, we can move straight to debate. I invite the minister to move motions S2M-190, S2M-232 and S2M-189, in the name of Ross Finnie, which invite the committee to recommend that the codes and regulations be approved. I ask the minister to address his opening remarks to all three motions.
We were somewhat late in laying the codes and regulations in that we have not complied with the deadline of 1 January 2003. That is because of the process of consultation to which I referred and the competing priorities that Alex Johnstone ably outlined. The consultation ended in November and the comments had to be analysed. After we had taken on board the views of the consultees, especially those of NFU Scotland, we finalised the regulations and prepared the pig and cattle codes. That is why we are a wee bit late with their implementation. I have nothing further to add.I move,That the Environment and Rural Development Committee, in consideration of the Draft Code of Recommendation for the Welfare of Livestock: Pigs (SE/2003/173), recommends that the code be approved.That the Environment and Rural Development Committee recommends that the Draft Code of Recommendations for the Welfare of Livestock: Cattle (SE/2003/175) be approved.That the Environment and Rural Development Committee, in consideration of the draft Welfare of Farmed Animals (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2003, recommends that the regulations be approved.
We move to members' speeches.
I have a brief follow-up to the questions that I asked earlier. The process that we are going through on animal welfare on Scottish farms is desirable and I will continue to support it. However, as I mentioned, the pig industry has experienced economic disadvantages. As we move towards a review of the arrangements for farrowing in the pig industry, to which I think the minister referred, and the likelihood that the farrowing crate will in the not-too-distant future be outlawed completely, is the Scottish Executive investing in research, education and training opportunities to develop alternative farrowing systems within the Scottish pig-farming industry, so that when that day comes, we are not faced with a crisis?
I add my voice to Alex Johnstone's point about a phased transition to higher standards. Those of us whom consumers have lobbied about animal welfare will welcome the amendments and the progressive increase in standards that will take place over the years. The new labelling systems that we have will assist those who are keen to see better animal welfare. Alex Johnstone's point about giving farmers the chance to skill up and make the investment necessary to ensure that we adhere to the regulations is important. That advice and guidance will be helpful.
What I wanted to say has largely been said. We have had concerns in the past about gold plating European Union legislation, but as far as animal welfare goes, I—and probably the vast majority of people in the country—would be happy for us to lead the way on standards. I would also be happy that the EU standards be considered a minimum on which we can improve and that we strive for further improvement within the EU.
Does the minister want to pick up on any points that have been made in the debate?
In response to Eleanor Scott's point, in the UK, we do lead the way on animal welfare standards and are particularly proud of doing so. However, Alex Johnstone is entirely right that the 2008 review for the directive will consider, among other things, further developments of loose housing systems in the service areas and for farrowing sows—systems that meet the sows' needs without compromising piglet survival, which is the difficult part. We have, therefore, for a number of years funded research that is directly or indirectly related to the welfare of the sow and her piglets from farrowing through to weaning. A key issue that is emerging from that research is that changes in farrowing systems to improve sow welfare can frequently have an adverse effect on the piglets' welfare. Our research and that which is being conducted in other countries will continue. Our aim is to reach a position in which it is possible to avoid close confinement of all sows.On Alex Johnstone's general point, which I appreciate, the concern is that the higher costs that are a consequence of improving welfare in the UK and other countries—such as others in the European Union—that have relatively high welfare standards might create significant scope for the substitution of low-welfare and, ipso facto, low-cost alternative products. At the moment, World Trade Organisation rules do not provide for competition to be prevented on animal welfare grounds, although they do allow for that under the sanitary and phytosanitary agreement, which is basically about health considerations. However, efforts are being made on that at an international, global level. In fact, there is a conference today in Manila that seeks to reconcile those welfare issues. It will cover not only farm animals, but companion animals, animals in scientific research, draught animals and wild animals.
Will the minister give way, although I know that it is irregular to do so? Will he join me in commending the farm-assured schemes that exist in Scotland, where they relate to animal welfare issues, for the fact that they have taken the lead in introducing higher voluntary standards of welfare and seeking to make some return from the marketplace for the higher standard of products produced by such systems? Will he commend them in future for continuing to do that job for us?
Absolutely. We have to compete on the basis of quality. However, we know that the consumer is predominantly influenced by price. That dichotomy must be addressed.As Alex Johnstone will know from personal experience, the codes on animal and pig welfare are not statutory. As we consider decoupling and modulation in common agriculture policy reform, which mean that a significant element of the single payment would be attributable to the welfare standards of which we are so proud, we would expect farmers to adopt those minimum standards of welfare in order to secure the single payment. There are linkages. As Alex Johnstone says, the farm assurance schemes all help to preserve and conserve the welfare of animals on farms.
Motions agreed to.
That the Environment and Rural Development Committee, in consideration of the Draft Code of Recommendation for the Welfare of Livestock: Pigs (SE/2003/173), recommends that the code be approved.
That the Environment and Rural Development Committee recommends that the Draft Code of Recommendations for the Welfare of Livestock: Cattle (SE/2003/175) be approved.
That the Environment and Rural Development Committee, in consideration of the draft Welfare of Farmed Animals (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2003, recommends that the regulations be approved.
I thank the minister and his officials for attending. The committee will now make its formal report on the instruments to the Parliament.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Sep 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 10 September 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 128
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 23
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
- Work Programme Procedure · 12
- Public Petitions Petitions · 1
- Public Petitions Petitions · 16
- Public Petitions Petitions · 13
- Public Petitions Petitions · 25
- Public Petitions Petitions · 2
- Public Petitions Petitions · 8
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.