Item 3 on the agenda is an evidence session on a section 23 report, “Scotland’s colleges 2013”, on which we have previously taken evidence from the Auditor General and Audit Scotland. I welcome to the committee our first panel of witnesses: Audrey Cumberford, principal and chief executive of West College Scotland; Margaret Munckton, acting principal and chief executive of Perth College; Susan Walsh, principal and chief executive of Glasgow Clyde College; and Alan Williamson, director of finance at Edinburgh College. I am not sure whether this is a direct interest but, for the avoidance of any potential conflict of interest, I declare that my wife is a member of the West College Scotland board.Before we get into the detail of the report, I want to ask about the title “principal and chief executive”, which now seems to be common currency. Why is your title not “principal” or “chief executive”? Why are both titles used?
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Scotland’s colleges 2013”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Hugh Henry Lab 55
- Susan Walsh Glasgow Clyde College 29
- Martin Fairbairn Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council 27
- Margaret Munckton Perth College 26
- Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council 26
- Ken Macintosh Lab 21
- Alan Williamson Edinburgh College 18
- Mary Scanlon Con 17
- Audrey Cumberford West College Scotland 15
- Tavish Scott LD 13
- Colin Beattie SNP 12
- Willie Coffey SNP 11
- Bob Doris SNP 7
- James Dornan SNP 4
- John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council 4
- Colin Keir SNP 2
The record
287 contributions · showing 1–200It is very simple. The emphasis in incorporation was on colleges operating in a businesslike fashion: principals who previously were responsible only for an institution’s academic element changed their role and, as a result, their title was changed. In other words, the title has become the tradition since incorporation. The chief executive element is supposed to highlight that we are now responsible for the college’s financial wellbeing and the wellbeing of our staff and resources. You will probably find that, over time, the chief executive element will diminish.
That was an interesting response; indeed, it raises a number of other questions.The further education sector is facing real challenges. We have heard a lot of competing and contending comments about that, but, according to Audit Scotland, a reduction in Scottish grant funding of £56 million in real terms compared with 2010-11 contributed to a 9 per cent fall in colleges’ overall income. Given that 9 per cent decrease between 2010-11 and 2011-12 and the further 11 per cent reduction in real terms between 2011-12 and 2014-15, can you all say that you are able to deliver the same level and quality of service to the same volume of students? Has there been any significant change to what you do?10:45
There has absolutely been an impact, but there is a difference between the level and amount of activity vis-à-vis the quality. Over the period that you have just mentioned, enrolments in the three constituent colleges that make up the new West College Scotland reduced by approximately 10,000, so there has been a reduction in the number of people attending the college. There has also been a reduction in the range and level of the provision that we are able to deliver. With regard to quality, however, our performance indicators are increasing, and quality remains a key focus for West College Scotland as we move forward.
So there are fewer students attending, but for those students the quality has not been affected.
Yes.
I want to ask about one thing that I am not quite sure about, which is why particular colleges were brought together and what the significance of that is. However, before I ask that, does anyone else wish to comment? Does Audrey Cumberford’s answer apply to you, too?
Yes, it probably applies across most of the sector, although geographical differences must be taken into account. We have expanded the level of provision with regard to the Scottish credit and qualifications framework to allow students to access degree programmes in one of the Glasgow Clyde College campuses. In terms of local access, that benefits students. As Audrey Cumberford mentioned, the quality has improved in the past year. Cardonald College, which is now a constituent part of Glasgow Clyde College, had no points for action in its latest Education Scotland review. That is not a common occurrence, and I must praise the teaching and support staff for supporting students and allowing that to happen.The issue of volume is a question of definition, as understanding varies as to what constitutes a full-time student and a full-time equivalent. In terms of enrolments, which is the number of people who walk through the doors of the college, Glasgow Clyde College would—if it had existed since 2009—have 14,700 fewer enrolments today.
Right—that is 14,700 in comparison with the number of enrolments in the colleges that amalgamated.
Yes—the colleges that amalgamated to form Glasgow Clyde College. With regard to the cohort of students, the age profile has dropped and we can track the differences in percentage attendance between the different age groups: 16 to 19-year-olds, 19 to 24-year-olds and 24-year-olds plus. The biggest drop is in the number of students who are aged 25-plus.
I want to explore that, because the 25-plus age group is quite significant. Looking at some of the recent news, we do not know what the future of our shipyards in Glasgow might be, and in Paisley—as Audrey Cumberford will know—BASF recently indicated that it intends to cease production. There are one or two other manufacturing companies, and other companies, that are going out of business. That means that those who are affected by redundancy, unless they are nearing retirement, need to think about reskilling and retraining. They would not necessarily fit into the under-25 age group.What is the impact on those who need to retrain or reskill because of job loss, given that—as Susan Walsh said—amalgamation has had a significant impact on attendance in the 25-plus age group?
Some of the issues relate to whether there is demand or need. Some of the reduction in numbers is down to people choosing not to come to college, probably because our sector has not had particularly positive public relations in recent times. Some of it is down to the focus on 16 to 19-year-olds. We welcome that focus and understand that young people need an opportunity, and that the earlier we can provide education for people, the more a positive benefit comes back to their families and to the economy.The issue has been around the fact that, where we have offered programmes previously, we might have reduced the number of times in a year that they are offered or the number of opportunities that are offered. For people who are in jobs, attending a college has always been a way of enhancing their qualifications while still earning. Perhaps the instability in the economy has meant that people have chosen to stay in jobs and are not focusing on their education as well. There are also issues around fees, as people have to pay for training. From that perspective, it is about people choosing not to come and colleges unintentionally but necessarily limiting some of the opportunities that are available.When we consider specific things such as the situation with BAE Systems—my college is very much involved with that company—we need to look at how we work in partnership with other organisations such as Skills Development Scotland, perhaps through the partnership action for continuing employment programme, which helps people to deal with potential redundancy situations. It is flexibility in funding that will allow us to do that.
You mentioned people improving their qualifications while they are working. In a previous experience, I was a teacher, and while I was teaching I was also a lecturer at one of the Glasgow colleges in the evenings. The people who attended those classes were all people in full-time employment who wanted to add to their skills and qualifications. Are those types of classes affected?
I can speak only for my college, but we have certainly seen a reduction in the number of classes that are offered in the evenings. At one point, a local FE college might have been open for four or five evenings a week. As part of our response to our budget cuts, we have looked at trying to concentrate facility use, and that has led to a reduction in access in the evenings. That makes it harder for people who are in full-time employment to go and upskill.
The profile of the portfolio of colleges has shifted in response to both the cuts and Scottish Government priorities. Colleges are good at responding to the priorities of the Scottish Government of the day, but there has been a shift to full-time education at the expense of part-time education.
Thank you. We will now have questions from Mary Scanlon.
Like the convener, I am a relic—if you like—of further education, as I lectured there before coming here. I am delighted to see three female principals here today.I have three short questions. First, I refer to pages 18 and 19 of the report. The teaching budget has fallen by £69 million over two years. There are 48,000 fewer students, which represents a 16 per cent fall—that is in paragraph 32—and the number of part-time students has fallen by 40 per cent. It is tragic that potential mature students are not finding access.I refer to an aspect of Scottish Government policy that we all support: the Wood report. Given all the cuts and the reduction in the courses that are available, given that the age profile has dropped, and given what you said about the limiting of opportunities, if the approach under the final Wood report, which we expect at the end of the year, is to work, will the colleges be able to respond to the need for vocational education for—I think—over-14s? Will you be able to meet the challenges that are set in the Wood report, given the serious cutbacks in provision, head count and finances in recent years?
The strong answer to that is yes: we can respond, and colleges have to play a key role in responding to the Wood report. However, there is a “but”, which is that the resources that we have are for our current activities. If we are looking to put in additional activity in response to the Wood report, the resource will have to come from somewhere. Either that activity will have to replace activity that is under way—assuming that we are all delivering to our maximum capacity for activity, which we are—or additional resource will have to come into the sector to facilitate that additional activity.There is absolutely a willingness in the college sector to respond. Indeed, it is already responding to and delivering on many of the interim report’s recommendations.
We also see that we can do a very effective job in replacing some of the existing provision that we already deliver. For example, we want to strengthen the senior phase curriculum under the school-college partnership. We want to enhance what the increased number of school pupils are doing, particularly in their sixth year, by enhancing the range of provision. Some of the displacement that Audrey Cumberford mentioned can be done within the existing school-college partnership arrangements, although we rely on the schools to meet us and work to the same end—the more delivery that we do in the senior phase, the greater the negative impact will be on the utilisation of school staff. We are just being realistic in saying that.On modern apprenticeships, we bid for additional funding annually through the SDS mechanism. The fund is drastically oversubscribed every year. It would be a bonus to us and to Scotland if a more strategic approach was taken to the allocation of the funding in line with Government priorities.
I was in Inverness College on Friday to see the school pupils. A wonderful model is used there—one that every party supports. Are you saying that the SDS funding is limiting what you can do on modern apprenticeships? Bearing in mind that 77,000 are not in education, employment or training, is the budget limiting what can be done?
It is absolutely limiting what can be done. The annual bid process is oversubscribed every year. Perth College has been denied for the second year running any funding for hospitality students, and yet tourism is not only a Government priority but a particular priority for Perth and Kinross.
I am sorry to hear that. I realise that all my colleagues want to come in on the issue, so I will briefly ask my second question, which is probably for Margaret Munckton to answer.I represent the Highlands and Islands, where a different model from that of mergers and regionalisation is used. I am concerned about what is often referred to locally as the top-slicing of the budget by the University of the Highlands and Islands before it comes to colleges. I am concerned that you are perhaps being asked to do more with fewer funds with regard to teaching. I appreciate that the quality is still excellent but, because there is no merger, there can be no economies of scale and you will not be able to achieve similar savings. Does the £15 million cost to run the UHI’s administration and its 200 staff put the colleges in the Highlands and Islands at a financial disadvantage compared with other colleges on what you can spend per student?
I am not sure about the comparison between Highlands and Islands colleges and the rest of Scotland on a per capita resource basis because our higher education is funded differently. However, although it is not easy to draw that direct comparison, it is fair to say that any amount of top-slicing reduces the money that is available for front-line delivery. In recent years—since the university has achieved growth targets—we have been able to increase slightly the unit of resource that comes to the colleges to pay for learning and teaching. That is not to say that the size of the central administrative office is acceptable; indeed, it is still growing. The issue was the subject of a Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council report by Capita—we refer to it as the Capita report—and the report gave clear recommendations. Progress against those recommendations has not been as rapid as any of the partners would have wanted to see.11:00
I understand that that report came out two years ago. Even if you received the same funding per student, as Tavish Scott will also know, we do not have in the Highlands the critical mass in numbers that your colleagues Audrey Cumberford and Susan Walsh enjoy, and the class numbers are often smaller. It would be a sad day if those courses were to leave. Perhaps we will pursue that later.
We have recently done an analysis of data as part of our regionalisation. The class sizes for further education across the Highlands and Islands region vary from nine in Orkney, I believe, to 28 in Perth.
I will go on to my third question.I have met various college principals lately. For colleagues, I refer to part 3 of the report and paragraphs 67 to 69, on the reclassification of colleges. This may be an opportunity for Mr Williamson to come in.We have just heard the Auditor General say that she wants to get away from NHS boards having to balance their budgets every year, but we are now finding that colleges will have to balance their budgets every year, which seems to stifle your ability to use funds. At the beginning, Susan Walsh said that colleges have behaved “in a businesslike fashion”, which they have done since the 1990s. Does the Office for National Statistics reclassification mean a loss of autonomy? Will becoming a Government department help to grow the colleges? I wonder why you are being treated differently from universities and why you are not being allowed to build up reserves. You will not be able to do any commercial work, and I understand that your financial year will change from being the student year, which has always been the case, to the fiscal year. How will you cope with the reclassification to a Government department rather than being what we have always seen as autonomous bodies that have been able to react and respond to local economic pressures?
I think that, across the sector, most would have preferred the ONS reclassification not to come in.
I understand that, in England, legislation was brought forward to prevent it from affecting colleges, but that was not done in Scotland.
Yes, because the classification tends to limit the use of surpluses and similarly the use of any reserves. However, it is about to happen, and we are looking at mitigating arrangements and working as best as we can through the imminent changes.
I understand that you are setting up arm’s-length trust organisations in order to overcome that. Am I correct about that? Will you expand on how that will happen?
That is right. There were two options. The funding council offered to set up an umbrella trust that most of the colleges could join, if they wanted to, but some college boards decided that they would prefer to set up their own trust, as that might give them more flexibility in what they could do.The key criteria for setting up those trusts are, of course, independence and dominant influence. The independence is very much on the legal side. A body can be legally set up as an independent development trust, but that needs to be passed through the auditors to ensure that there is no conflict on the dominant influence side. The dominant influence side means that the accounts of both organisations need to be consolidated, so any surpluses or reserves will be captured in the same way as they would be under the ONS reclassification.
How confident are the principals about the flexibility? Will you be able to continue as you have done in the past? Do you think that the new concept will stifle what you are doing? What change will the reclassification bring for colleges that currently have loans from banks, for example, or even PFI projects? Is it a cause of concern?
In West College Scotland, 21 per cent of our income comes from other sources. That income is critical for strategic reinvestment in what we do and in enhancing our provision, resources and estates. To take that strategic perspective, that is where the challenge is with ONS in moving to an annual cycle. It is fair to say that there are still some unknowns. Colleges are either pursuing their own regional solution via arm’s-length foundations or moving towards the national umbrella trust and working closely with lawyers and internal and external auditors on responses to the questions that you have just asked. It is fair to say that we do not have all of the answers to those questions.
I understand that the reclassification is to be implemented on 1 April, so we are running short of time. The 21 per cent that is coming from other sources is commendable but in relation to your college, Audrey, how will the reclassification affect that?
The effect will be on generating reserves. Our view is that it is important to be able to generate reserves to reinvest back into the college for the benefit of our students, local communities and staff. The public funds that we currently receive pretty much just cover the payroll bill. We have to do everything else by ourselves and by generating income from other sources.
So the reclassification will stop you from generating income from other sources.
It will not stop us doing that, but it means that we will have to reinvest annually. That does not allow for strategic planning and investment, which are important.
I will just leave it there. We could go further.
I would like some clarification on the arm’s-length trusts that you all seem to be exploring. Will they be completely independent? If they are, to whom will they be accountable? How will there be accountability for funding that is either transferred to or generated by those arm’s-length trusts? How will you guarantee benefit to the college from an arm’s-length trust over which you potentially have no control?
There will be no guarantee. We are going with the work of the SFC, which is acting as the main adviser to the sector on this. We need to do it in order to preserve our ability to invest in our facilities, students and staff. It needs to happen or we will be a poorer sector.
I understand why you are doing it and that you could otherwise be, as you describe, a poorer sector. I am interested purely in accountability and the money lines. Where does the money come from and where does it go? How is the money used and who assumes responsibility? Even if you go with the umbrella trust that the SFC is promoting—I presume for the same reasons that you described in relation your own possible arm’s-length trusts—that umbrella trust would also need to be completely independent of the funding council. To whom would it be accountable? If it were to operate Scotland wide and money were generated, for example from Perth College or West College Scotland, and went into the trust, how would you know that the money was coming back to be spent in your area? Could you control that?
We have replied to the funding council that the single umbrella trust for Scotland is Perth College’s preference. We would therefore rely on that umbrella trust being set up as we been informed it will be set up. Our understanding is that the money will be partitioned. Because 44 per cent of our income is generated outwith the public funding, it is highly likely that we will need to put money in annually rather than being forced to spend it as we generate it within the year. It is vital to us that the money that we generate in that way comes back to Perth College. We have been promised partition, whereby what we put in will be preserved for the good of our locality, but we are not clear how long into the future that partition will last.Only three of us across Scotland have so far voted for the single umbrella trust, so we have been asked to propose a trustee because at least three trustees are needed to go on the initial deed. That can be changed thereafter. We will propose a trustee from our locality who is independent of the college.
If there are three trustees and two come from other areas, in the future there would be nothing to stop those two trustees deciding that the pressures that were faced in the west or the south of Scotland were more significant, so the money could be used there.
Absolutely—so we are relying on compartmentalisation.
That is a leap of faith.
Yes.
You have just rehearsed the arguments that have been had in boardrooms around Scotland over the past six months.The question of how we ensure that the money that is generated by colleges is used to benefit those colleges can be dealt with in the context of the charitable status of the arm’s-length foundations. It is a matter of defining the articles and the constitution so carefully that money could not be used for anything other than the benefit of the students of the institution—the region or the college—that set up an arm’s-length trust, whether the trust is a Scottish charitable incorporated organisation or otherwise.As Alan Williamson said, the issue is very much about independence, but it is also about ensuring that the funds that have been generated are used for Scotland’s learners.
I was just going to repeat what Susan Walsh said. The creation of arm’s-length trusts would give colleges a lot more flexibility in how they can generate commercial income, in particular, which could be reinvested in the college.
What will the charitable status of colleges be in the future? What are the implications for that?
We understand from the funding council that the charitable status of incorporated colleges will be unaffected by the ONS reclassification.
Has that been guaranteed by the charity regulator?
We have had sight of a letter from the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator that says that charitable status will be unaffected.
Right—there should be no financial implications for colleges with regard to their charitable status.
We hope that there will not be.
I thought you said that there was a letter that guarantees that.
There has, indeed, been such a letter.
So why the hesitation?
It was not hesitation. One of the things that we learn as college principals is that the political context changes. As of today, we have a guarantee of what we can expect, but that might change in the future. We do not know.
I presume that that would require a change in the law or a change in the way in which the charity regulator operates, because that should not, in the first instance, be subjected to political influence.
I meant “political” in terms of the political will to change legislation that might have an effect.
Okay.
Could you describe the financial role that the regional boards for the 13 college regions will play, please?
One of the issues is that the regional boards will all be different. I can speak for Glasgow—Henry McLeish will allow me to do that. In Glasgow, the regional strategic body will have three assigned colleges. The funding will go to the regional strategic body and will thereafter be distributed on the basis of evidence related to the regional strategic framework that we are developing in Glasgow. The regional board will be the fundable body.11:15
What will individual colleges do to ensure that they get their fair allocation? Will they simply have to fight hardest at meetings?
Absolutely. You used the term “fight”, but I would say that it is more like tag team. As the three colleges that now exist in Glasgow are part of what historically was known as the Glasgow colleges strategic partnership, we already had an operating framework for working together. In some ways, the regional strategic body is simply putting in a governance layer that would have lain with the college themselves.
In that case, what will the board bring to the party?
The board will bring the capacity to speak with one voice for Glasgow. Glasgow—by which I mean not just the city itself but its metropolitan area—makes the highest gross domestic product contribution to Scotland. The board will allow us to engage with key stakeholders with one voice in a way that was not previously possible.
I get that—and it seems like a fair point—but are you concerned about the potential for individual colleges to lose out? I presume that there will be some concern at lower levels that you are not all going to get everything you want from the overall allocation that will be given to the regional board for Glasgow.
I do not think that anyone ever gets everything they want. The point is that the colleges are better being interdependent than being independent, simply because the regional strategic framework and the college plans that will allow us to meet that framework’s aims are being built from the bottom up, starting with an economic skills analysis and discussions with our key stakeholders, our employers, our schools and the universities. We are not working in isolation and then saying, “I want that bit of the cake.” That is not the mechanism that we are developing.
That is fascinating.Margaret Munckton mentioned losing a hospitality course at Perth College. Does that mean that in the comparable structure in the north there are already examples of colleges other than Perth College not being able to gain funds for particular specialisms that they want to pursue?
I make it clear that the hospitality course was based on modern apprenticeship funding that flowed through SDS.The situation is very different in the Highlands and Islands region, because the University of the Highlands and Islands university court is being proposed as the regional strategic body. In other words, the university court will be responsible for the flow of funds to FE as well as to HE throughout the region. There are well established principles and committee structures to ensure the distribution of HE funding, but the fact is that there is no great competition in that respect. Conversely, the funding envelope for FE is not big enough, so the situation will be slightly different when adjustments are made through the regional strategic body.Concern has been expressed that the top slicing that was mentioned earlier might be applied to the flow of FE funds, but we have received reassurances that that will not happen. However, we believe that, as our FE regional board will be a committee of court, our regional lead will not be appointed through the public appointments process. I understand the anxiety about using that process to appoint the chair of a university committee, but I must point out that the body itself is not a committee of court at this moment in time. The appointment of the regional chair, who will also become a member of the university court, is certainly exercising us at present.
Who will make the appointment if it is not going to be made through the public appointments process?
The appointment will be made by the court itself, which is being reformed at the moment.
I presume that, given the differences, you would prefer the appointment to go through a similar process to that which is used in Glasgow and other parts of the country.
Such an approach would be a lot more transparent and open in governance terms.
On the principle of the system that you are about to be part of in the UHI—I take the point about the size of the cake and so on—how will that work? I presume that you will all get round the table once a year to sort out the allocations for individual further education institutions.
The direction of travel is that the smaller colleges in more rural locations want to offer a wider range of provision. We understand that; we have done that in FE by networked delivery, so we can deliver at a distance. However, we do not feel that that is appropriate for the maturity of the learners—I mean not their age, but their maturity as learners—at FE colleges. If, as a regional board or a committee of court, we want to support more activity being nested in the remote areas, we will need to sacrifice larger class groups in the urban areas. The reality is that a class of 28 at Perth College could be sacrificed for a class of nine in Orkney.
You will have such dilemmas.I will ask about Edinburgh College’s situation in terms of the regional board. Is the situation the same as we have heard it is in Glasgow? Is that how you envisage the structure working here in the east?
Our regional board is formed. The financial strategy is agreed by the board, so we have a good idea of what we will be planning for and, I hope, what we will achieve in future years through our approach.
Okay. I guess that your pitch to the SFC—I assume that this applies to all the witnesses—will be for funds that are based on the assessment that you make in the strategic plan that was mentioned previously.
It will be, although the outcome agreements also tie into the approach. The SFC has its guidance from the Government on what we should focus on through the outcome agreement to make the system much more joined up.
The flipside of that argument is how much discretion local colleges have to answer local economic needs in respect of skills needs and skills training. Will there still be room to make that argument through the structure that comes with regional boards, and therefore to ensure that that becomes part of the overall strategic plan for your region?
We certainly identify needs in the community. That information is fed to the SFC, so it should form part of the outcome agreement.
So, in other words, it is not a straitjacket—there is flexibility.
There is flexibility.
Okay.
The outcome agreements are aligned to the single outcome agreements in relation to the community planning partnerships, so for local colleges there has to be alignment with their local authority CPP areas as well as with the national outcomes.
link
Paragraph 19 onwards of the Auditor General’s recent report on colleges mentions pensions deficits. As has been said, the pensions deficit is £115 million, which is acute and has grown over the years. There seems to be no indication that the deficit will do anything but continue to grow. I understand that that covers only the local government pension scheme and not the teachers, who are in the Scottish teachers superannuation scheme. How do colleges view that deficit? It is a lot of money. I presume that at some point somebody will have to cover it.
I can comment on Edinburgh College. Last year, we had a deficit of about £11.5 million and this year we are down to just under £9 million, so there has been a positive movement, mainly because the economy has picked up and the value of our assets has improved over that period.Valuers make a number of assumptions in valuations. One on which there is a degree of flexibility is the pay assumption. They tend to use the local authority pay assumption, in which incremental scales and regular pay awards are built in, but within the college sector, including at Edinburgh College, we have not had a pay award for two or three years, although this year the award will be about 1 per cent. We can therefore get a more accurate reflection of the situation. However, we are limited to the value of the liabilities; when people leave the scheme, that liability is carried and, of course, new members who join a scheme contribute at a lower level.
How does that affect the college sector overall? It depends on the size of the deficit, but the impact is predominantly through the contribution side. If the deficit keeps rising in the future, it is likely that the contributions that the organisations pay will be increased.
The contributions have been increasing. Alan Williamson can help me out on this, but the teachers’ scheme is on a different basis and there is no fund as such, so what is received is paid out. In accounting terms, that system has a different status. The issue of the teachers’ pension scheme is not being avoided; it is just run differently from the local government scheme.
link
One of the comments that was made by the Attorney General was to the effect that there are a number of different contribution rates even within the same pension scheme. It is not explored in any depth in the Attorney General’s report—
You mean the Auditor General.
link
I am sorry—I meant the Auditor General’s report. Perhaps you could give a little more information about how that works.
When there were three colleges in Edinburgh, we all paid separate contribution rates, ranging from 17 to 20 per cent. The contribution rates were based on the age and number of staff, and when we were likely to pay the pension benefits.
Can I have clarification? Margaret Munckton said earlier that contribution rates are increasing. Does that apply to individual participants, or just to employers?
Contribution rates have also been increasing for individual participants.
What scale of increase has there been?
I am not sure, because I am not in the local government scheme.
Does the same pertain to the teachers’ scheme, or does it apply just to the local authority one?
It is proposed to increase the contributions for the teachers’ scheme, but I do not think that that has happened yet. However, the local government scheme contributions have definitely increased.
My contributions have probably gone up over the past three years from around 6 per cent to 9 per cent.
Okay. I am sorry, Colin.
link
The size of the deficit is obviously a worry. However, you are not alone in that situation, because right across the UK changes in accounting and bond yields and so on have resulted in deficits. For you, what would trigger a decision to put in significant sums?
Pensions crystallise only on retirement. Provided we are an on-going business, we will always have people starting in the pension scheme and people leaving it. It is about having faith in that demographic and that we will always have a timeline of leavers and no absolute hit from mass leavers.
link
You have a £115 million deficit now, but what would happen if it went up to £200 million or £250 million? At what point would you be concerned?
The difficulty is that the variation tends to be in response to actuarial valuations of the pension scheme. I am sure that Alan Williamson will be most distressed to hear that I tend to think of accountancy as a kind of black art when it comes to figure changing. Alan alluded to the fact that his college’s pension deficit improved by £2 million last year, as did Glasgow Clyde College’s, although we did not do anything different. The pensions’ value going up and down can contribute to that variability.Margaret Munckton’s comment about crystallisation was very well made, but the other issue is that colleges have to be going concerns. In some ways, that question harks back to issues around the ONS and funding. We cannot tease out one distinct strand, because they are all interrelated. It is our ability to manage the funds that we are given and to generate additional income that allows us to sleep not necessarily particularly well with reference to such a huge pensions deficit, but to sleep, because we understand that our colleges are strong and on-going concerns.
link
The Auditor General’s report mentions only two pension schemes. Are they the only two? Are there any closed pension schemes?
None that I am aware of.
No.
No.
At present there are only two pension schemes in the college sector, for teachers and for support staff. One is a defined benefit scheme, which is the one that is reported as showing a deficit, and the other is a contribution scheme, which is off balance sheet and is just noted in the narrative of the accounts.11:30
I want to clarify something. You mentioned that retirement was one of the issues. If my memory serves me right, there was a significant expansion of the public sector in the late 1970s and into the early 1980s. Does that mean that there will be a bulge of people who are now approaching retirement? Although some of those people may well already have chosen to take early retirement, is there a significant bulge that would otherwise not be there?
I am not sure about the national demographic in that regard, but I am sure that the answer could be researched.When anyone over 50 who is in a local government pension scheme—which includes all our support staff and a lot of our management staff—takes severance or early retirement, there will be a significant pension strain on colleges in terms of what they have to pay.
Has the impact of the early retirements been quantified?
I am not aware that it has been quantified. It may have been.
Surely that should be done. If you say that it is a significant strain, surely you should know how much that strain costs.
The impact has not been quantified on a sectoral basis, but individual colleges collect that information. We lost 154 staff last year from the three colleges that formed Glasgow Clyde College, which cost us somewhere in the region of £4.8 million. We then had a further £770,000 in strain costs. That situation will have been repeated elsewhere in the sector.
link
I will begin by congratulating the colleges on how they have managed a difficult period of change and transition. It is worth putting on the record that there was a 9 per cent reduction in budgets, which was dealt with by reducing the head count, mainly among teaching staff. That was a political choice, and it is clear that you have all managed it well.Currently, we are in a period of modest rising budgets, although I also put on record that that is from a much-reduced baseline. I would like to ask some questions on how you are dealing with the current baseline.We have heard much talk—understandably—about the reduction in head count among those involved in courses. We have also heard that the number of full-time equivalents remains the same; the figure that I have is roughly 119,000 full-time equivalents in relation to courses throughout Scotland.I am interested to know how you map applications to each of your colleges for those courses. The Auditor General’s report recommends that colleges should“implement the Scottish Government’s recommendations to improve the application process to help monitor the demand for college places.”How is progress going in that regard? For example, in Glasgow—I will use the old college names rather than the new ones—if someone applies to North Glasgow College, Stow College and John Wheatley College for very similar courses, would that count as three individual applications even though they are from only one person? That one person may very well get a college place, but the accounting procedure appears to show that two people have been unsuccessful. That is not deliberate, but it gives a false picture of where we are in terms of demand. How are colleges getting on with addressing that key recommendation?
Colleges have always recognised that. Indeed, a person may apply not only to three colleges, but for three or four courses at each of those colleges, so the problem is magnified.That was not of particular concern when we were in a position of growth throughout the 90s and early 2000s. If someone applied and we felt that they had—this term was always used—a reasonable chance of success and we had the student funding to allow it to happen, we ran courses. That is why the college sector grew. That reasonable chance of success criterion is why college education is so important. We now find ourselves with a management information system that does not necessarily meet the needs of the new regime in which we find ourselves operating. In Glasgow we are looking at a common Glasgow application process. However, I would like to separate applications from admissions. Applications to university are handled through the Universities and Colleges Admissions Service. It has a highly motivated, highly skilled and very literate population of applicants. The people who come to colleges are very different. We have people with literacy problems and personal difficulties; we also have real high fliers and graduates who come back into the college sector because they want vocational education. Therefore, it is not necessarily an IT solution that is needed.We have to look at how we can suck data out of existing college applications systems through some platform that would sit above the systems. That would allow us to say that 300 people—it is people who are important—have applied for 56 different courses, for example; it would also allow us to interrogate the information properly, which would give your committee and others that information that you are looking for. It would be much more accurate.
link
That was quite a lot of detail, which I appreciate, but I want to get a sense of whether work is in progress across the college sector to look at a college application registrar, who could audit the process effectively but in a way that did not dissuade people from vulnerable backgrounds from applying to college in the first place. Is such work on-going?
I have a particular worry that the debate about what counts as a head count of student numbers and how big our waiting lists are is almost a distraction that could drive us in the direction of coming up with national e-solutions when what we need are local responses. Should individuals have the flexibility to apply for three or more courses in my college, and to apply to my college and Susan Walsh’s college? Absolutely, because that is the nature of those students. In more cases than not, students who apply to my college saying that they want to do three courses do that because they do not know what they want to do. Colleges are different partly because we put resource into the front-line service to help those individuals decide what is the best course for them and, sometimes, what is the best college for them. You need a local—or, in our case now, regional—perspective. If we start to get into the numbers game, I am concerned that we might become driven by national concerns about counting numbers and demand.I will finish off on my high horse. Renfrewshire is similar to Clydebank and Inverclyde, in that we have very similar demographics and youth unemployment levels. We have approximately 1,500 young people who are not in school, education or work. For me, that is the unmet demand. Forget how many people apply to my college: that is the unmet demand in Renfrewshire. The situation is replicated in Inverclyde and Clydebank. As a college, working with our partners through the CPPs, our responsibility is to address that problem and not get bogged down in whether we have an IT system that can tell somebody somewhere that a person has applied for one or more courses.
link
I did not suggest a solution to how you map out—
I am sorry; the rant was not at you.
link
No. I have to say that I have had enough of scrutinising IT systems at the Public Audit Committee to last me a lifetime, so let us not go there.I acknowledge the comments that you made, Ms Cumberford. Would you acknowledge that, in terms of regional planning, it is important to get a proper and accurate picture of how many students apply for courses and whether they apply across a range of colleges? I do not think that you mentioned whether you thought that that mapping exercise was important to forward planning. I am not sure how colleges can do forward planning without having that picture.
We look across trends and conversion rates, from applications to offers made to people actually turning up on the day. Actually, the demand that is exerted is often articulated when people physically turn up on the day, so any extrapolation of data will not provide clear information about that. However, we can use trends from previous conversion rates and we also get a lot of information from speaking to the students themselves. I know that we are starting to put a likelihood score against applicants. Often when we talk to applicants, they will say that they have applied to such-and-such colleges and we give some advice. Although all the MIS systems record each application, we can filter the data to say that the likelihood is that a particular student will not turn up. That is about people intervention and it is about people talking to individual applicants.
Does Bob Doris have a final question?
link
Before coming on to my final question, I stress that the reason that I have asked about mapping of demand for course provision is that, as well as being a key recommendation from the Auditor General, most people would think that better mapping would be a good thing. I am sorry that, due to time constraints, we are not able to continue that discussion with the witnesses.I do not want to get into the political discussion about full-time equivalents: the Government has said that it has maintained full-time equivalent numbers, whereas the Opposition has said that head count is down. Let us park that argument to one side. Scotland’s colleges are on a secure financial footing because of the tough decisions that they have taken. However, another key recommendation in the Auditor General’s report is on preparing for future capacity. If a political decision is taken further to prioritise certain key groups, such as older students, for modern apprenticeships—I must say to Ms Munckton that different parts of Scotland will argue over who should get those 25,000 apprentices, but that is another issue—will forward planning by Scotland’s colleges enable them to say how they would go about expanding provision for that unmet need? How would they up capacity if such a decision was taken?
That is something that colleges do all the time. During the period from 2002 to 2005, which was probably the most stable financial period that colleges had, we demonstrated that we could rise and fall with demand depending on what was required. Going forward, we absolutely have processes that would allow us to identify areas where growth would be appropriate. We have shown that we can respond to the opportunities provided by new organisations opening up.For example, the largest hospital complex in Europe is currently being built in Glasgow. For that, the local colleges in the west and in Glasgow have been working hand in glove with the health board to ensure that, when the new institution is fully functional, it will have the employees that it needs in areas such as estates, catering, science lab technicians—we even have a new nursing or paranursing qualification. We have the ability to make change and to respond. At the moment, the difficulty is that we just do not have the funds to allow us to meet all the demands that people make on us.
We need to move on, as we are running out of time. I call Ken Macintosh, to be followed by Colin Keir.
On a related subject, it is clear that you are struggling with reduced budgets. You have lost a lot of staff in the past year. Are you looking to lose staff again in the forthcoming year?
Yes.
Yes.
Yes.
Will that be on a similar scale? I think that you lost 1,200 staff across the board in one year. Will the losses be on a similar scale this time or slightly less or slightly more?
I can speak only for my college. We expect to lose some staff but on nothing like the scale of the past two or three years.
The situation for West Scotland College is similar.
As Mary Scanlon pointed out, student head count was reduced by 48,000 in one year. Will head count be reduced further?
That is quite a difficult question to answer simply because we are also facing a changing funding methodology. Some key decisions need to be made to allow us to work out what a full-time student will be in the future and what the value will be of the weighted credit in future. Therefore, we cannot answer that at the moment, but the Scottish funding council needs to give answers on key issues quickly, so that we can plan properly.
In effect, you are going to get less money per student.
Not necessarily—we do not know. We do not know what will be the value of a weighted credit or how many weighted credits will make up a full-time student. We know what that might be roughly, but “roughly” could mean huge variance in the FE budget, so that does not give us any comfort or capacity to plan in detail.11:45
I am conscious that SFC witnesses will give evidence in the following panel, so what would you like them to tell you?
First, we need absolute clarity on the weighted credit and on how many weighted credits will make up a full-time student. We also need much more clarity on the needs-based element. We are concerned about some of the figures that we have heard on supporting extended learning support students. At present, colleges respond to students as they come forward with special needs, but in future that will probably be limited, although not necessarily capped. We also need to know about deprivation funding, which we understand will probably be of a lesser scale than some other funds.
A key word for me is “stability”. Albeit that, given what we have just gone through, the stability in this year’s funding and in what we know about next year’s funding is fairly minor, it is welcome. However, margins continue to be extremely tight. For example, in West College Scotland, on a turnover of more than £50 million, we are forecasting a surplus of £50,000. The analogy that I use is that it is a bit like trying to land a 747 on a postage stamp. It does not take much to swing the figure into a negative. The issue that Susan Walsh just mentioned about certainty on funding is key. The funding scenario has the potential to continue to stabilise the situation, or to destabilise it.
To pick up on the point about development education courses for those with additional needs, an awful lot of such courses—I think that it was between a third and a half of them—were lost in the initial round of funding cuts. Are you suggesting that there could be further cuts to that vulnerable sector?
The funding that I was referring to was for extended learning support, which is for students who are on mainstream programmes but who have additional needs—for example, they might be dyslexic or dysgraphic. At present, such students go through an assessment process and we put together a package that allows them to remain in college and be successful. That is done individually. Those students simply gather weighted student units of measurement, and we draw down funding to allow that provision to continue. Our understanding is that, from the funding council’s perspective, that approach might not be viable in future, and that extended learning support, which has been growing year-on-year, might be not necessarily capped but limited in some way. We have real concerns about that, because as students and their parents and employers become clearer about the kind of help and support that students need to be successful, expectations are greater and therefore there is a greater demand for ELS.
Ms Munckton, do you expect either to increase class sizes or reduce the number of hours that students spend with lecturers and other staff?
At Perth College, we have resisted the removal of learning hours. We have capacity to remove hours, because the current funding system allows us to claim a tariff-weighted SUM and deliver slightly less than that, but we are determined to deliver what is appropriate. That has an impact financially because, under the existing rules, we could deliver less and get the same money. However, as Susan Walsh says, those rules are about to change. The increase in class size is absolutely key to our balancing the books. We now use lecture theatres to deliver theory to 100 students at a time, and they are then split into groups of 20 for practical work.In the workshop situation, there are all sorts of health and safety considerations about having one lecturer to 16 or 17 students, and there are health and safety limits that we will not go over. However, where we can disaggregate the delivery of theory from practical work, we are doing our level best to increase the average class size. We are not doing that at the expense of quality, because we are keeping an eye on and listening to students’ views about the quality of the experience as it is happening.
Is that—
This should be your last question.
Okay. Is that also the situation in the other colleges, in relation to the amount of hours that students get with staff and the size of classes?
There is definitely a benefit from full-time courses at the moment. It is the extra resource that full-time students attract, which we are going to lose under the new funding methodology, that we use to support students and maintain other facilities and services for them.It is about increasing class sizes, but only to a point where they are manageable. We are aware that staff have worked incredibly hard. You kindly said that we have managed the difficult situations that we have faced, but it is the staff who have dealt with increases in class sizes.We have looked at new learning methodologies and the use of IT. As Margaret Munckton said, there is a distinction between practical skills and theoretical knowledge. I think that we would probably all have done the same thing.
It is the same in Edinburgh.
Good morning. As far as I can see from the report, it is a little bit early to tell how painful or difficult the process that you have gone through has been. What has been the most awkward thing in managing the merger of the colleges into regional entities? How flexible will the management structure be in enabling you to respond quickly to local requirements in future years? I am pretty sure that you have partly answered that, but the projections for public expenditure over the next number of years suggest that it is not going to be easy. We all realise that everybody would like more money, but how are you going to manage this difficult situation if the period of austerity carries on for, say, another seven, eight or nine years?
For us, the biggest challenges in dealing with the funding cuts were having only a short time in which to restructure and integrate systems, and keeping staff motivated when they were going to be applying for jobs, given that, at the senior and management levels, we moved from three to one—that is one of the benefits of the regionalisation, given that the resource is less. Another challenge has been keeping budgets in a break-even or reasonably positive position throughout that period.On the positive side of the regionalisation, systems integration helps with the provision of information. Before the merger, the three colleges in Edinburgh were running off three different systems and they had different working practices—even for finance, would you believe? They were at different stages of automation as well. It was hard to pull all of that together. The benefit going forward is that, once that has all bedded in, it should produce some economies and efficiencies as people get on top of things and we implement the new working procedures. Where we have had to top up with temporary staff to help us through the transitional phase, those staff will then move on, and we will come to a lower cost base as a result.
It is also fair to say that the loss of teaching staff included the loss of many managers. Those affected were on teaching terms and conditions, and included a lot of our middle and senior managers. Of the 1,200 teaching staff involved, a high proportion of the losses at Perth College to date have been among the middle and senior management levels.
At the weekend, I was delighted to attend the graduation ceremony at Ayrshire College’s Kilmarnock campus. The atmosphere and the excitement were incredible. If that is reflected in any way throughout the rest of the college sector, there are exciting times ahead of us.The Auditor General’s report said:“The overall financial standing of the college sector in 2011-12 continued to be generally sound.”It also mentioned that the colleges are sitting on £214 million-worth of surpluses.My question is aimed at Margaret Munckton, because she mentioned that she was unable to fund a particular course. A quick look at the report tells me that your college has £5 million-worth of surpluses. That is public money, from the public purse. Are you able to or did you consider using a portion of that money to fund that course? If not, why not?
We certainly fund courses, including loss-leading courses, and all sorts of things because it is the right thing to do, even though it may not make financial sense to do so. I am convinced that we will take the right decision for the region, the communities and our students. However, that £5 million is not sitting in a bank account. If it were, we would be getting 0 per cent return on it and therein lies the truth. We generate quite a bit—as I mentioned, it is about 44 per cent—of non-public funding annually. We will not spend that haphazardly. We get very little through the capital funding route; indeed, we have not had a lot of the capital funding that other colleges have had. We have a building that was built in the 1970s that is full of asbestos; we also have flat roofs. We have an on-going repairs and maintenance plan and an ambitious estates development plan for the benefit of our communities and our students. We are not able to, nor do we want to, rely on loans, because we would be worse off and restricted with regard to, for example, the covenants that are requested. We were therefore building up the reserves. They certainly do not amount to £5 million. I know that Alan Williamson has detailed information on Edinburgh that will illuminate the situation. The money is not cash to spend; it is an accounting reserve, which is totally different. We have commitments in advance to develop more of our buildings for student residences and to enhance the student experience and for the on-going renewal of plant and equipment, so that our students learn using, for example, the latest computer technology. That investment burden is what those reserves are addressing. The money is not sitting in a bank, waiting for a rainy day. Alan Williamson can give you more of the detail behind that.
Yes, please.
What the Audit Scotland report said about cash and cash equivalents was probably unhelpful because it gave the impression that the colleges are sitting on lots of cash. Edinburgh College is a good example to cite in that regard. On the cash and cash equivalent basis, it would seem that we are sitting on a £30 million surplus. However, we had an outstanding bank loan of about £7 million to pay off as a result of the merger and the banking covenants that we had in place. We also had proposals for a £5 million development at the Sighthill campus. Taken together, that is £12 million already, and it leaves £18 million. Of current liabilities, we have to pay off £12 million to the short-term creditors with a year. That leaves us with £6 million of net current assets, which is a truer reflection of the position. However, some of that money is restricted funds, which we can use only on capital purchases. If we take a long-term perspective and look at our long-term liabilities, we have our bank loan and the VAT that we must pay, which totals £15 million. On top of that, we have provisions and other stuff like that. That is why I believe that the Audit Scotland report missed the other side of the equation. The cash and cash equivalents were identified, but it would have been better to read the liabilities side along with that.12:00
Those were very interesting answers.The Audit Scotland report says that your college has £57 million of reserves.
That is actually the income and expenditure carry-forward. Surpluses come through the income and expenditure account every year.
We can talk about that in the next session.You have described a range of obligations and commitments that are already earmarked, but it seems that, in some cases, choices can be made about how to deploy that money. I was interested to learn that the money is not in any bank accounts and that it is not real money. I will have to pursue that on another occasion.We know that plans are developing on how to treat college surpluses and how to deal with them when you become public bodies next year. Discussion is under way on that. What are your thoughts on how that money can best be deployed?
It would be remiss of us not to make the point that, because of the different accounting principles that will apply to the sector under the ONS reclassification, the sector will record a massive deficit across Scotland in accounting terms. Colleges will need to show the transfer of cash to arm’s-length foundations as money spent. In future, under ONS restrictions, colleges will show deficits in their accounts, so it will look as though the college sector is insolvent.
From £214 million-worth of surpluses? I do not understand that, but perhaps we can come back to the issue.
Perhaps I could speak on the issue of the surplus. My college had a financial strategy to generate 2 per cent of our turnover—around £500,000 per year—as surplus that we earmarked for specific projects.Our financial strategy will now change, because the college does not have the capacity to generate that level of surplus. That is not because we are going to reduce in any way any of the commercial activities that we do outwith our public funding; it is just that we will have to use the money in year to ensure that we maintain the level of service and quality for our students. The methods that we used to generate a surplus will remain, but the level of the surplus will diminish. I am sure that that will be the case across the sector.I was interested in what was said about what will happen when we become public bodies. We absolutely respect the Parliament’s decision with regard to the ONS reclassification; we understand that it has made that decision. However, it further confuses an already complex position. We tend to be of the public sector but not in the public sector. At the moment, our academic and financial years are the same as the universities’, but that will have to change with our reclassification as public sector bodies. On the other hand, we are not party to public pay policy—that does not apply to colleges.We will have to be public bodies as far as accounting practices are concerned but, in other ways, we will not be subject to the same expectations. We are expected to be highly competitive—not with one another but with external providers—to generate income. We are a chimera; we embody bits of everything. That is sometimes difficult, especially for staff, who might think that it is great that we will be back in the public sector, as that will give us a level of stability because the Government will have to look after us. In fact, that is not the case. We understand why the ONS is with us, but the question whether we are public sector will continue to cause complications for college leaders and boards.
I had some specific questions about West and the relationship to students in Clydebank, Greenock and Paisley, but we will just write to you about that. I can raise that with the committee. There was one thing that I wanted to ask in public. It goes back to what Alan Williamson said about the cash and cash equivalents. According to the Scottish funding council, good practice suggests that there should be a minimum of 60 days’ cash. In the past, Reid Kerr College had less than one day’s cash, which is quite a significant departure from the good-practice guidelines. What are the implications of that?
In 1999-2000, Reid Kerr College was going through severe difficulties and had a significant deficit and a very poor estate. The decision that was taken by the board and senior executive at the time was that it was not appropriate to stockpile cash reserves and that we would reinvest any moneys that we generated in the estates and back into the college for the benefit of the community. Over a 10-year period, £21 million has been spent on that campus, of which only £6 million has been supported by the Scottish funding council. The college generated income and used bank loans to pay for improvements for the benefit of students and staff. It had a strategy of working on an overdraft for that period and has successfully done that for 12 years. I absolutely believe that, at that point, given the funding environment that we were in, that reinvestment was appropriate.In the current funding environment and context, that course of action would not be appropriate for West College Scotland. We have a target this year of 35 days’ cash, which will go up to 37 days’ cash next year, although it becomes irrelevant after March 2014 in the sense that we will hold a level of working capital amounting to about £3 million.
Given that you are aiming for 35 or 37 days’ cash, should the Scottish funding council guidelines be reviewed?
It depends on the size of the college and its turn-in liabilities as it goes through the year. Each college would have to consider its situation. It also depends on how quickly a college is turning its debtors into cash, which influences how much cash it wants to hold, because it is really to do with short-term working capital. I have always thought that 30 to 60 days’ cash at least gives us headroom to be able to deal with liabilities should we have a problem bringing in the income.
Thank you for your contributions. We may have further questions, in which case we can write to you. Thank you very much for your time.12:08 Meeting suspended.
12:14 On resuming—
I welcome our next panel, which is from the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council. Laurence Howells is the interim chief executive; Martin Fairbairn is senior director, institutions and corporate services; and John Kemp is director, colleges and post-92 universities.I think that Mr Howells wants to make an opening statement.
Yes. Thank you for inviting us to give evidence on the Auditor General’s recent report. We worked closely with Audit Scotland as it developed the report, which contains a range of useful points.I am delighted that the report records that the overall financial standing of the colleges remains good, and I welcome its recommendations for us as an organisation and its encouragement particularly to continue to develop outcome agreements in the process with colleges.It is worth saying that I am here in my capacity as the Scottish funding council’s accountable officer. As such, I am responsible for delivering the Government’s policy objectives and the deployment of resources to that end, and for the planning and risk management that are necessary to do so efficiently and effectively.It is also worth recording some of the progress that the sector has made. I welcome the comments that were made earlier about the good progress that the colleges have made on regionalisation. Twenty-seven colleges have decided to merge into 10 colleges of scale and influence across Scotland. Working with the new regional college structures, student activity remains constant—indeed, it has slightly increased between 2012-13 and 2013-14. We are about to start to negotiate a third round of outcome agreements with the colleges, and we see with the sector that those outcome agreements will enable us to further improve that system. We have started the process of allocating our funding to reflect need more accurately.Reform is not yet complete, of course. We need to maintain the momentum on the college mergers and ensure that they deliver the benefits that they are intended to deliver to learners, communities and employers. We will work closely with colleges to do so.As I said, outcome agreements are a key method for the future to create transparency in relation to public funds: what they are used for, what is delivered by them and the contribution that the college sector makes to Scotland. As I said, we are just starting the third round of outcome agreements—we have had only two rounds—so there is an opportunity for us all to up our game in respect of them.We will continue to support the enhancement of quality in the sector and will work with it, the College Development Network and Education Scotland.Finally, we look forward to playing our part in implementing the new regional structure that was established by the Post-16 Education (Scotland) Act 2013, and particularly the regional and college boards. There will be a particular focus on Glasgow, Lanarkshire and UHI.
Thank you.I do not know whether you were in the public gallery towards the end of the previous evidence session when we had a discussion on cash and cash equivalents and the Scottish funding council guideline of 60 days. The Audit Scotland report shows that, in 2011-12, only six colleges met that 60-day guideline. What is the point in having that guideline if colleges simply ignore it? How do you monitor whether they meet it? What do you do if they do not meet it?
We were here during that discussion. I will pass over to my colleague Martin Fairbairn to answer those questions.
The Audit Scotland description is broadly correct. We have that guidance, but I should clarify that it is primarily internal guidance for us in the funding council when we are reviewing the financial situation of each individual college. Essentially, we use the guidance as a gateway to say, for starters, what the overall cash and cash equivalent situation looks like. If the figure is round about the territory we expect, we swiftly move on. If it is below that, we either look at the accounts in more detail or discuss with the college what the financial situation is and how it is managing its cash flow on a day-to-day basis. We were in the public gallery when Audrey Cumberford described the situation at Reid Kerr College. Over the years, we have had very regular conversations with Audrey and her predecessors about how they have worked on a day-to-day basis, as that is a more challenging thing to do when there is less back-up. I think that Audrey would admit that.Even if the guidance is an internal rule of thumb, will we need to change it? Yes, we will, partly because the reclassification of colleges changes the nature of our month-to-month interactions. Colleges will project to us more what cash they require for the next month, and we will need to manage that across the sector so that they are able to pay their bills on a month-to-month basis and will therefore be able to operate with less of a buffer on a day-to-day or month-to-month basis.
Do you have any concerns that, if colleges have to operate on a month-to-month basis with less of a buffer and if they have little in the way of reserves to fall back on, that could cause problems in future?
We, with colleges, will need to strike the right balance between ensuring that colleges have enough cash or working capital to operate on what might be best described as a week-to-week basis, and ensuring that we have slick processes in the background so that, if there is sudden change in a college’s cash requirement in week 3 of a four-week month, we can respond quickly to deal with it. That is one of the changes that flow from reclassification. Colleges will become more like non-departmental public bodies that draw down their cash as they need it. However, there is a balance to be struck, because we do not want colleges to do that every day of the week.
I want to explore that issue. Does that mean that the Scottish funding council will be more actively involved in overseeing the management of colleges in a way that it has not been in the past? Does it mean that the SFC will need to expand its management structures to be able to do that adequately?
In terms of the cash management that I described, yes, more detail will be required. At the moment, we decide on the total amount of grant to allocate to a college or university over a year, and then we simply set out in advance the profile of payments that we will make for that full year. We do not change that unless there are very exceptional circumstances. From April onwards, essentially the same approach will be taken and we will say “There’s the total amount for the year,” but on a month-to-month basis we will ask each college what its projected cash requirement is for the month to come and, as long as that is reasonable, that is the cash that we will pay the college on that month-to-month basis.The process will therefore become a bit more involved, and we will have to adjust our own internal resources and staffing in order to cope with it. However, it will not be a huge step from where we currently are on the cash-flow management. It will therefore not have a huge impact, and we feel that we will be able to cope with it internally.I think that you asked for something a wee bit more general about the management of colleges. Is that correct?
Not necessarily. My query is about how colleges will cope if they do not have reserves to fall back on. You used the word “buffer”, so my question is about what the implications would be if the buffer was not there.
Essentially, we have a similar situation at the moment, except that we are sitting in a different part of the spectrum. We have a fixed prediction of how much we are going to pay each college each month, which is pretty much what we stick to. Colleges have their own cash buffers or reserves—or whatever you want to call them. What we are doing is moving a bit more along the spectrum towards the position where the colleges have less cash but we have more interaction with them to be more precise about the amount of cash that they need each month. We will still have the existing balance because each college will still have a working capital or cash reserve to manage day-to-day requirements, but there will also be a closer relationship with us, which will help if the prediction changes within the month.
Okay. I have a further question about your increasing involvement. There were criticisms in the past that senior managers at some colleges were given enhanced pension and redundancy packages, partly in order to slim down for the changes that were to be made. Concerns were expressed that there was not a great deal of clear accountability and that, arguably, senior managers were looking after themselves, ensuring that salaries were put up ahead of retirement and that enhancements were put in place. Will you have an increased role in determining what financial packages are made available to senior staff who take early retirement or redundancy?
We have issued guidance to the sector about severance packages, and the college boards are required to follow that guidance. The actual decisions about individual payments to senior managers are, of course, a matter for the board and not for us. The guidance sets out the governance process that should be followed by the colleges and the matters that they should take into account. We expect them to follow the guidance, which will be the same in the new structure as it is at present.
Would it be possible for you to send the committee a copy of that guidance?
It would.
Thank you. You say that you will have no say over the salaries. As we heard, colleges are now being treated almost like Government departments, and there are governance structures and Government guidelines. Are you suggesting that, despite that, colleges will still be free to set their own salaries for senior managers?
In Scotland—throughout the UK, in fact—there is no one single categorisation of a public body. That is perhaps unfortunate, but it is a fact. As one of the witnesses on the previous panel said, colleges will—and in fact do at present—exist in a mixed economy with regard to public body status.The ONS classification at its simplest involves literally moving colleges from one table of reports to a different table. However, Government across the UK has, for a long time, used the classification that the ONS uses to determine other things, such as which financial rules apply to the management of different bodies’ finances.The clearest and most obvious impact on incorporated colleges is that they will have to change their financial year. Committee members may well have seen that there is further information in the Scottish Government’s draft budget to show projected cost expenditure and so on. Those sorts of technical changes are happening.There is an impact on how colleges manage their finances from year to year, as we have just discussed. There is also a range of potential—and they are just potential—other implications for colleges, most of which flow from the “Scottish Public Finance Manual”. They range from reporting arrangements for gifts and losses to how colleges manage their pay and so on.The Scottish ministers have said that they will not apply the Scottish public sector pay policy to colleges as a result of the reclassification. A range of other matters in the “Scottish Public Finance Manual” are under discussion with regard to whether it makes sense to apply them to incorporated colleges.It is not simply the case that colleges are reclassified and then, bang, a whole set of standard stuff applies; everything is worked through on a case-by-case basis.
You will be aware that, in recent years, concern has been expressed about the salaries of principals and senior managers in our universities. They operate almost as a cartel, in that the wages of one will increase as the wages of others in other institutions do so. Very few of them—in fact, none of them, I believe—are now earning less than £200,000 a year, and in some cases they are earning in excess of £250,000.In recent years, the salaries of college principals have also increased significantly. Will the Scottish Government, through ministers, or the Scottish funding council have any leverage or influence if the boards of colleges decide to increase the salaries and other remuneration payments and the retirement packages for senior managers and principals? Is there anything that you can do if college boards decide just to go for it?
There is a range of issues in that question; I will deal with the last bit, on severances and so on, first. To add to what Lawrence Howell said, we have our guidance, which we will share with you, and that guidance includes procedures whereby the arrangements have to be reviewed by the colleges’ auditors. If the arrangements made by a college—or a university, as the same rules apply to each—involve stepping beyond that, the auditors must report that to us.Over the piece, given the public interest in that area, we will take a heightened interest within the existing framework of rules over the next two to three years. Ultimately, however, colleges are autonomous bodies and the ONS reclassification does not change that. Therefore, decisions on such matters are for the boards of management of the individual colleges.
Auditors have been singularly ineffective in constraining the pay and conditions of those at the top of universities and colleges. That does not suggest to me that any change will occur in the future, unless the Scottish funding council decides to operate more aggressively. I look forward to seeing what comes out of your deliberations.We will now have questions from Mary Scanlon. 12:30
My first question is very brief: do you still expect the merger programme and other reforms to generate £50 million of savings every year from 2015-16?
Yes, we do. The evidence is that, as a result of the reform process, colleges have delivered an increase of about 7 per cent in the number of students while receiving about 4.5 per cent less in funding since 2012-13. If we combine those elements, the real-terms efficiency gain is calculated at about £49 million.The situation is slightly different from what we originally expected. As you know, earlier this year, the Government put additional money into the college sector. That has allowed the number of students to grow since 2012-13.It is important to see that the position results from the reforms that the colleges have undertaken. The colleges have restructured and their number is smaller—they are moving from 27 down to 10, as I said.
I ask my second question as a member for the Highlands and Islands. The UHI has a different financial status from other colleges. I am concerned that the £15 million-plus that is used to run the UHI’s administrative office, with more than 200 staff, is top-sliced—that is often said—from the funding before that gets to colleges. That is different from the position for every other college. Student numbers can also be lower in remote and rural areas, so the cost is higher. Is the funding council concerned that, in time, colleges across the UHI network might be given less per student for teaching?
We expect the maximum amount of our funding to support learners and their studies—that is absolutely right. We would be concerned if money was being inappropriately top-sliced, to use that term. However, it is important to remember that some of the money that is held centrally supports library and IT infrastructure, the development of the whole network and so on.As part of our discussions with all institutions and all the regional boards, we will ask them to demonstrate how the maximum delivery is obtained for the money that we provide. One of the key functions of the FE regional board for the UHI will be to bring all that together and ensure that the money is used in that way.
My final question is on the ONS. I am not sure whether you were in the public gallery earlier for the comprehensive discussion about the ONS reclassification, in which the three college principals raised a variety of concerns—I am sure that none will be new to you. In the report, the Auditor General says that the SFC“is looking at ways to minimise the impact of government budgeting rules on the college sector”.We also heard about arm’s-length trusts being set up. Given when the report was written and the fact that the ONS decision will be implemented on 1 April 2014, will you update us on where you are with the arm’s-length trusts?
The Scottish funding council has set out on our website and in the public domain a significant amount of guidance and templates for articles of association and so on—“trust deed” is not the correct technical term—for the arm’s-length foundations.We in the Scottish funding council are establishing what we are referring to as an umbrella foundation, which colleges will have the option of participating in if they so choose. Essentially, the material that we have published on our website describes how we are setting up the umbrella foundation. We are currently looking for trustees to serve on that foundation, and I understand that they should be identified within the next couple of weeks. We are working on that with the colleges that have expressed an interest in being part of the umbrella foundation.The vast majority of colleges have indicated that they wish to establish their own arm’s-length foundations. That is for a variety of reasons, which I can go into if that is of interest to the committee. Those colleges are using the templates and the guidance that we have made available on our website to establish their own arm’s-length foundation. When I had a meeting yesterday with Michael Yuille, who is one of the regional leads working on this area, he described to me how colleges across the piece are making good progress on establishing their own arm’s-length foundations where that is their choice.At the moment, I am reasonably confident that all those arrangements will be in place in time for 1 April. However, if any college hits a difficulty, it can fall back on the umbrella foundation that we are establishing, which can be used where necessary.
The acting principal of Perth College, if I am quoting her correctly, said that only three colleges have voted to be part of the umbrella foundation. However, I appreciate that the issue is a moving target.Why is the reclassification appropriate for colleges in Scotland? I understand that, in England, the Government introduced legislation to ensure that colleges could continue as they were instead of becoming basically Government departments.Secondly, we heard from the principals that, on average, around 30 per cent of college funding does not come from the Scottish funding council. As the convener asked earlier, if 30 to 35 per cent of college funding is to be held by arm’s-length trusts, how does that make the colleges more accountable to this Parliament? As accountable officer, Mr Howells, can you say whether the change will lead to colleges being less accountable to the taxpayer? I am not sure what relationship we as the Scottish Parliament’s Public Audit Committee or you as the Scottish funding council will have with these arm’s-length organisations, which will be totally independent but responsible for 30-odd per cent of college funding. To me, it seems as though colleges will be 30 per cent less accountable.
First, that 30 per cent of a college’s funding will not necessarily go into the trust, as most of that funding will be earned and spent within the same year. Only the balance would be put into the trust. Secondly, the trusts will be set up so that their purposes are aligned with the purposes of the college sector, so the rules on which they will operate will support that. Finally, when the money is spent within the colleges, it will be part of their normal processes and their normal accounting.I can pass over to Martin Fairbairn, who may be able to give a little more detail.
The lady from Perth College, I think, said that 21 per cent of her college’s income comes from other sources. Obviously, we hope that 100 per cent of the money in the trusts will be spent on training and education. As accountable officer, Mr Howells, you will really have no responsibility or remit over that money. It will have nothing to do with you unless it comes within the college budget. Is that correct?
In this meeting
Everything on 6 Nov 2013 →- 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 131
- 09:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 287
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.