Item 2 is consideration of a section 23 report, “NHS financial performance 2012/13”, which has been circulated to members. I invite the Auditor General for Scotland to brief the committee.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“NHS financial performance 2012/13”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland 54
- Hugh Henry Lab 20
- Ken Macintosh Lab 13
- Bob Doris SNP 10
- Tavish Scott LD 9
- Mary Scanlon Con 5
- James Dornan SNP 4
- Willie Coffey SNP 4
- Tricia Meldrum Audit Scotland 3
- Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland 3
- Angela Canning Audit Scotland 2
- Colin Beattie SNP 2
- Colin Keir SNP 2
The record
131 contributionsThank you, convener.The report examines the financial performance of the national health service for 2012-13. We also comment in the report on the financial sustainability of the health service, recognising the challenges and pressures that face the delivery of healthcare services. We publish such a report annually, which allows the committee to monitor progress on how the NHS is responding to the challenges that it faces.We highlight in the report that NHS budgets are getting tighter and demand for healthcare is rising due to an ageing population, more people with long-term health conditions and the impact of factors such as increasing rates of obesity. The way in which health services are provided is also changing, with technological innovation and the planned integration of health and social care. Those changes present significant challenges for the NHS.We found that the NHS in Scotland managed its finances well in 2012-13. All boards met their financial targets and overall they reported a small underspend of £16.9 million against a total budget of £10.9 billion. The surplus is just 0.16 per cent of the total budget—that highlights the very active management and monitoring of the annual financial position that goes on in boards and in the Scottish Government.Given the increasing pressures facing the health services, the NHS needs to increase its focus on long-term financial planning and sustainability if it is successfully to make the changes necessary to meet the growing demand that it faces. Boards produce financial plans that cover between three and five years, but their detailed financial planning is limited to the first year of the plan. We have previously reported that the NHS will need to think more radically about how to deliver services in the longer term. NHS boards have started planning for that, but they have not carried out detailed financial planning to ensure that their strategies are affordable.Boards made significant savings of £270 million in 2012-13 and achieved the Scottish Government’s target of saving a minimum of 3 per cent of their baseline budget. NHS boards also set their own savings targets to break even and overall they made 99 per cent of those savings. However, they relied more than planned on one-off savings, which makes the challenge of finding the same level of savings in future years even harder.The report recognises that the NHS has made good progress in improving outcomes for patients, such as reducing death rates from heart disease, stroke and cancer, but there were signs of pressure in the system in 2012-13. For example, not all boards met their waiting times targets; vacancy rates for consultants and for nursing and midwifery staff increased; and boards increased their use of bank and agency nursing staff and their spending on private sector healthcare. Spending in those areas is still a small part of the overall budget, but the increase reversed the trend of declining spend in those areas in previous years. Auditors also reported that the introduction of the treatment time guarantee in October 2012, which gives eligible patients a statutory right to inpatient or day-case treatment within 12 weeks, has been a particular pressure on NHS boards and it remains a challenge for the future.We make a number of recommendations in the report to both the Scottish Government and the health boards. I will highlight two of those recommendations. First, the NHS needs to increase its focus on longer-term financial planning to show how the pressures and challenges will be managed. All boards should ensure that they follow good practice, including the use of appropriate methods for modelling future expenditure and for looking at different scenarios. Detailed financial planning should underpin all boards’ strategies, including workforce, asset management and information technology strategies.The Scottish Government should also consider moving away from the current framework of annual resource limits, against which each NHS board needs to break even. That would help boards to plan for the longer term and would lead to fewer movements in their budgets during the year.Secondly, savings are an integral part of the boards’ plans to break even, so it is important that their savings plans are realistic and achievable. Boards should improve the accuracy of their short-term savings forecasts in the context of the longer-term financial planning framework.My colleagues and I will be happy to answer questions from the committee.
Thank you. If Angela Canning, Tricia Meldrum or Gemma Diamond wishes to contribute, they should just let me know.I would like to ask about the impact that the financial circumstances are having on waiting times. I refer to exhibit 15, which gives the statistics for the quarter or month ended 31 March 2013. It is clear that there has been significant success on child and adolescent mental health services and drug and alcohol treatment, but there has been significant failure on outpatients, which is probably where many people have their interface with the health service. There has also been significant failure on inpatient/day-case treatment times—of the major health boards, only Lanarkshire NHS Board achieved the target.On accident and emergency waiting times, which is an issue that people feel very passionately about and in relation to which many claims are made about access, there has been significant failure, including in Lanarkshire, where we are told that there has been major investment and major improvements. Those health boards that cover the major population centres, with the exception of Tayside NHS Board, have all failed to meet the A and E waiting time target. Delayed discharges are of significant concern in the areas with the highest levels of treatment. On the second page of exhibit 15, which is on page 37 of the report, only the commendable meeting of the cancer targets gives any glimmer of hope.In describing the financial performance of the NHS, you identify some of the pressures and stresses that it faces not just this year, but in future years. If the statistics that you have reported pertain at the moment, can we expect any improvements in the future, when the NHS will be on tighter budgets?
You are right that the figures in exhibit 15 demonstrate signs of pressure in the health system. That is one of the messages of the report as a whole. The backdrop to that is a great deal of activity to manage the finances, the health improvement, efficiency and governance, access and treatment targets, and the other things against which the performance of the health service is monitored.There are real pressures there, which the health service is working hard to manage. That is why our recommendation about the need for stronger long-term financial planning is the most important one that we make. Our sense is that the constraints on funding for future years and the pressures that will come from an ageing population, higher expectations and the impact of things such as the new treatment time guarantee mean that the status quo will not deliver the change that is required. Health boards and the Government need to ramp up the work that is being done to redesign services and to think more radically about how they can be delivered. We think that that requires better long-term financial management, including scenario planning and longer-term forecasting of the likely financial situation.
I understand what you say about financial planning. Better, more effective financial planning can make a contribution, but if the issue is rising demand, which is a result of the demographic changes that you mentioned, linked to a greater squeeze on budgets, the boards—regardless of how good their financial planning is—will not be able to meet the targets if the money is not there to allow them to deliver. Does that mean that, in future, we will continue to see targets not being met, because of the squeeze on finances, or does it mean that, given the pressures and demands to which you referred, the targets might have to be revised because, frankly, they are not achievable?
The long-term financial planning that we are talking about is not just forecasting how much money is likely to be available but, within that, carrying out detailed scenario planning for different ways of providing services. For example, in relation to the A and E target, you might look at ways of managing unscheduled care in the round, ensuring that people who do not need to go to A and E do not arrive at the front door of the hospital, keeping more people safely at home or, where appropriate, treating them at home. That kind of financial planning is not just about understanding the money and the pressures on it, but about ways of delivering services. Stepping back and thinking more radically about new ways of doing something and—critically—following up more widely the examples of good practice that we have seen in parts of Scotland are absolutely central to what we mean by better long-term financial planning and financial management.
From what you know and what you have seen, are you confident that we will see positive statistics in these areas or will the problems continue because of the financial circumstances in which many boards are operating?
We know that the pressures are real and that the changes that need to be made will have to be made over a certain period. I suspect, therefore, that there will continue to be real pressure on the targets for the next year or two, which is why we have focused on our very strong recommendation to Government and health boards that they act now to redesign and deliver services in new ways to help reverse that trend.
Is there not an inherent contradiction between the targets beloved of politicians, and the short-term financial pressures that boards operate under and have to deal with?
My view is that any targets on their own run the risk of diverting people’s attention to one particular part of the system instead of their thinking about the system as a whole. In the report, we pull out a selection of targets that matter to people and which are central to the Government’s NHS policy but, both in the report and in our work more widely, we have made it clear that the answer to the A and E target is to look not just at A and E departments but at the whole question of unscheduled care, care for older people and so on. Although the Government’s healthcare strategy does that well, we would like to see more of that being underpinned with detailed service and financial planning for how those changes will happen in practice against the backdrop of serious financial and demand-led pressures.
I agree, but when you were carrying out this analysis and these investigations did you not find that most territorial health boards simply do not have the capacity or time to do that work because they are under such pressure from the centre to deliver on the targets that you have outlined in the report?
As the report makes clear, we certainly think that the focus on annual targets makes things harder. Having spoken to my auditors in all the health boards, particularly the 14 territorial health boards, I know that a lot of effort in the finance department and the Scottish Government’s health directorates goes into ensuring that health boards hit their annual financial targets. Indeed, you can see that in the overall underspend of 0.16 per cent against a budget of nearly £12 billion, and there is a danger that that kind of very precise financial management gets in the way of longer-term financial planning and the detailed modelling that needs to happen. That is why we made our recommendation.
That is fine, but do you not accept that irrespective of which Government is in power it is unlikely that targets will be dropped and that, right or wrong, they are now part of the NHS? What recommendations have you made with regard to easing the pressure on health boards and allowing them to create the time and capacity to carry out the long-term financial planning that you have rightly highlighted this morning?
Our main recommendation is about stepping back from that very intense focus on the annual targets and giving health boards more flexibility to manage things over a longer period, underpinned by strong, rigorous, longer-term financial plans. None of that should be about releasing control of the finances—obviously they have to be properly managed—but it is about focusing less on landing on a particular number on 31 March and more on shifting money and services over a longer period to meet the pressures that we have highlighted in the report.
I suppose what I am driving at is whether Audit Scotland thinks that territorial health boards can achieve that, given the pressures that they are under.
As the detail in the report shows, there are different pressures in different parts of the country but we have no reason to believe that health boards cannot achieve that, especially if support from the Government shifts from the brokerage of and planning for annual financial targets towards a longer-term focus on the changes that are needed in a particular part of Scotland.
Is the Government likely to accept your final recommendation about“moving away from the current arrangements of setting annual financial resource limits for each NHS board”or does that not bring us back to the same problem that the Government loves that kind of control? I suppose that “loves” is the wrong word, but it certainly needs and wants that financial control over health boards.
The indications are that the Government is taking that recommendation very seriously. Some technical accounting challenges and control issues need to be managed as part of that, but I believe that in his recent evidence to the Health and Sport Committee the cabinet secretary indicated that the issue is the subject of serious internal discussion. That is certainly the impression that my team has had from its discussions with the Scottish Government officials.09:45
On page 32 of the report, you say:“The Treatment Time Guarantee is a further pressure on NHS boards”.Some statistics have been set out in paragraphs 73 and 74 but I have to wonder what the comment that“auditors reported that the TTG will require significant resources to achieve and sustain”might mean in the coming year.
I will ask colleagues to respond in a moment, but it is worth reminding the committee that we are due to publish an update on our report on the management of waiting times next month so we are viewing the issue closely against the wider picture.Angela, do you want to pick up that point?
Case study 4 highlights the situation in Lothian, where a lot of money has been invested in trying to increase capacity and pick things up after the backlog of patients that had to be dealt with as a result of the waiting list problem in the board.
Paragraph 73 gives the bald and clear statistic that 565 patients“who were added to the waiting list after 1 October 2012, were not seen within 12 weeks.”What happened to those patients? Did they take legal action against anyone? After all, is that not the implication of the guarantee?
I think that that is a question for the Scottish Government. As far as we know, they were treated but after the 12-week waiting time implied in the guarantee. That raises a question not only about how the situation was managed for those patients; if the pressures increase and the NHS continues to be unable to meet the guarantee, we need to be clear how that situation will be managed and what the consequences will be for patients and the health service.
My question is whether a figure has been discovered for the additional cost of meeting whatever happened to those 565 patients after the 12-week period and, if so, whether it has been audited and analysed.
At this stage, we have not seen a figure for any additional cost. However, the situation will matter to the patients themselves and the trend will be important.
And will continue to be monitored.
Very much so.
Before I bring in Bob Doris, I have a question of clarification about the points raised by Tavish Scott. I note that spending on private sector healthcare has increased by 23 per cent to £80 million a year. Is that trend likely to continue?
It is very hard to be definite about that. Obviously it is a relatively small sum in the context of the overall health service budget and a lot of it relates to specific circumstances in Lothian with regard to the board’s problems with managing waiting times.Tricia Meldrum might have more to add on this issue.
Lothian was one of the main areas in which we saw this increase, which obviously was to deal with the backlog of patients who were not being seen within the treatment time guarantee period and the waiting list targets. That was a particular pressure and, indeed, Lothian has recognised that it will continue to be a pressure this year and is working to increase its local capacity. We will continue to monitor the situation to see what impact that is having, but we are also aware of other boards that are experiencing capacity pressures and which are making use of the private sector. We will continue to keep a close watch on the matter.
link
That last response was quite helpful in demonstrating that the use of private health provision is not part of the Scottish Government’s direction of travel but is about meeting very specific needs. A very small local example that I can cite is the problem with assisted conception at Glasgow royal infirmary, where those who did not get the service they should have received were given private sector healthcare without delay in a specific one-off intervention. It is important to put on record that this is not about any direction of travel but about one-off circumstances in which such intervention is the right thing to do.I will pick up on some of my colleagues’ assertions. First, we have heard repeatedly about squeezed and tightening budgets, and some of the waiting times figures have been presented as a consequence of that. I know quite a lot about NHS budgets, as I am deputy convener of the Health and Sport Committee. It is important to put on the record that NHS board budgets are being increased by 3.1 per cent this year and that there have been real-terms increases over previous years. NHS budgets are therefore not being squeezed and tightened, but there could be reprioritisation of NHS resources from, say, acute care to community care. Do you think that the pressures on the NHS are a result of squeezed and tightening budgets, or a result of increased demand and the reprioritising of resources within the NHS budget? The assertion is that the pressures are a result of squeezed and tightening budgets.
I think that there is an element of both. We are very clear that there are rising pressures on the NHS because of an ageing population, healthcare innovations that cost more and factors such as increasing obesity, which gives rise to long-term conditions that affect the health service as well as individuals.You are absolutely right that there is a commitment from the Government to maintain budgets for the territorial boards with real-terms increases. The increases for revenue budgets will be very small in future and we are seeing a significant reduction in the capital budget. I am reaching the same stage as the Prime Minister—I cannot see numbers without my reading glasses. The figures are set out in paragraph 2 on page 5 of the report. We tried to break down the figures very clearly.We also know that healthcare inflation tends to be higher than general inflation. The Government’s efforts to maintain the budget in real terms are clearly recognised, but the pressures from aspects such as drug and technology costs will increase the pressure within the health service, even against that background.
link
That is really helpful. It gives a more nuanced view of the NHS’s financial position, although when you mention—
Sorry, but this is important for Bob Doris, given that he made a very significant comment. Can you make sure, Auditor General, that that is stated clearly on the record?
Certainly.
Did you say that it was a bit of both and that there were financial and tightening pressures as well as the other pressures?
link
Convener, I think that we heard that, and if you would let me continue with my question—
No, no, I am—
link
Convener, do you want a supplementary to my question?
Excuse me—I am chairing the meeting, Mr Doris. I just need to get the Auditor General’s point on the record, and then we shall proceed.
For the record, convener, our report is very clear that the revenue budget is forecast to increase by 0.6 per cent over the next three years in real terms, so there is a small real-terms increase. The report contains more detail about the breakdown between territorial boards and other health boards, and between the revenue and capital budgets.
You mentioned that the capital budget was decreasing, and you have accepted that there are squeezes on budgets because of the inflationary pressures on the NHS. Is that correct?
Our report aims to be as clear as it can be about the facts surrounding the budget.
Okay.
I can run through all of that if it would help, but there are both real-terms pressures from demand and a commitment from the Government, which is borne out in the revenue budget, with a small real-terms increase over the next three years.
Right. Thank you. Mr Doris.
link
That was already on the record, convener. I will now try to develop a line of questioning, with your permission.I will have to come back to the financial position of the NHS because I feel that perhaps the convener has yet again muddied the waters. Just for clarity, I note that there is a real-terms increase in the revenue budget, which is money that is spent directly on patients. You talked about a cut to the capital budget, Auditor General, but it is only fair to put on the record that that cut is in the context of a 26 per cent cut to the Scottish capital budget. I think that that provides balance, convener—I am sure that we are all hoping to do that and not have a one-dimensional view of the report.I want to move on. I note that pages 36 and 37 contain information on waiting times targets, which were met or not met. I have a question on the information on page 37 under the “Inpatient/day case treatment time guarantee” heading and that under the “A&E” heading. I note that the figures were taken from a quarter that included winter months. I have no idea whether you will say that that factor had a significant impact on slippage in relation to waiting times targets, but I think that it is reasonable to ask about that for clarification.
We picked the 31 March quarter because the report covers the NHS finances for 2012-13, with the year end at 31 March. Winter generally has an impact on all NHS targets. We will provide an update on that to you next month when we produce our report on the management of NHS waiting times.
link
That is very helpful. What if we were to show the figures from a different quarter—one that did not include winter? We clearly need better management of winter resilience—I would say that that is perhaps what the figures show—and I hope that the Government is taking steps to achieve that. Could the figures in this particular quarter be skewed by the winter months?
I do not want to speculate on that. As I say, we chose the period specifically because it coincided with the end of the financial year to which the report refers. More information will be available to the committee next month in our waiting times updates.
link
Okay. We have heard talk of targets and how helpful they are—or are not. Do you believe that the NHS and the Government are wed to targets? I ask because some of my colleagues raised the matter during yesterday’s health debate in the chamber. Already today, one colleague has said that it is terrible that targets have not been met, whereas another has said that the problem is the targets themselves. The Scottish Government said that it was reviewing the target on patients seeing a general practitioner within 48 hours because of the unintended consequences that that target may be having for patient access to GPs. Did you come across examples of other targets that are well intentioned but which are having unintended consequences for forward planning in the NHS?
I do not think that it would be helpful for me to focus in on individual targets in that way. However, I can say that having information about the performance of the health service is very helpful. It lets those running health boards, us as auditors and the people who rely on and pay for the NHS to understand how performance is changing and where there may be problems that need to be tackled.It is important that the Government continues its work to make the targets rounded and to focus on the whole system, rather than run the risk of bringing about unintended consequences by focusing on one area. It would also be useful to continue the thinking on linking the HEAT targets with the outcomes approach that the Government has adopted, which is generally recognised as a very positive development in focusing on the longer term. Thinking through those linkages would also be a useful way of anchoring the targets in the longer-term achievements that the Government is trying to promote.
link
Page 31 of the report includes information on consultant, nursing and midwifery numbers. There are modest increases in relation to those posts, but there are increases in the vacancy rates, too. Will you provide more detail on that situation?I have spoken before about workforce planning tools. I have suggested that, perhaps, NHS boards were not planning ahead as effectively as they could do—for example, in relation to the move from acute to community care and how quickly they could disinvest from one service and reinvest in another. Do the figures reflect an improvement in NHS boards’ workforce planning and management?
You are absolutely right about the complexity that lies under the figures—they are headline figures that are aimed at giving an indication of travel in the NHS. Questions about the application of the new workforce planning tool would be better directed towards the Government and NHS boards. We hope that the tool will have a long-term impact by matching staffing needs to the changing ways in which healthcare will be delivered in the future. I do not think that we see the evidence of that just from those figures at this stage.
link
You quite rightly mentioned long-term planning. I am very conscious that, to date, £300 million has been spent through the change fund for older people in the NHS. I think that the spend will reach around £500 million before the fund is replaced and, I hope, mainstreamed into NHS board services. The other day we found out that there is a £100 million integration fund, and you have mentioned the integration of health and social care. In scrutinising such significant amounts of money, an issue for us is the ability to track the pound, see how it is used and consider whether that is the best way to meet the desired outcome. I am incredibly supportive of the initiatives, but I wonder whether your office has looked into whether the resources are being used in a way that provides best value, or whether that is something that you are likely to do in the future.My take is that this is about long-term planning. The £80 million in the change fund for older people that will be spent this year is short-term spending. However, the question is what that does this year, and whether it feeds into a mainstream core budget for an improved or redesigned service in years 5, 6 or 7. Have you given any thought to how you would track that spending?10:00
Yes. We currently have a significant piece of work under way, which Angela Canning is managing, to look at the way in which the priority of reshaping care for older people is being progressed. As part of that work, we will look at the change fund. We are due to publish that work in March—
At the end of January.
Sorry—at the end of January next year; I think that the work will come to the committee after recess. There will be more information in there to allow you to investigate that issue.We are keen to see not only how the funding is mainstreamed, but how the successful examples that have been achieved through the use of that money are spread elsewhere across Scotland so that the benefits can be delivered more widely.
link
I look forward to that report, because I am hopeful that the change funds will deliver real difference in long-term planning. Until that is analysed and scrutinised, we just do not know.
I will continue on the same theme, Auditor General. Bob Doris referred to the diagram in exhibit 13. In the heading for paragraph 68, you state that“boards needed more staff time and facilities to meet demand”.The theme of pressures in the system runs throughout the report.Looking at exhibit 13, I was concerned at the increase in the vacancy rates. Over one year, there was a 21 per cent increase in consultant vacancies and a 57 per cent increase in nursing and midwifery vacancies.Exhibit 14 also alludes to the pressures on the system, as it shows a five-fold increase in work done in the private sector. I do not have a problem with that as long as the patient is treated within the required time and given quality treatment; I simply note that it is a five-fold increase in one year.I heard what was said about NHS Lothian. I am looking for the trends in the system, but I do not know whether 80 or 90 per cent of that increase could perhaps be accounted for by the situation in NHS Lothian or whether there is an underlying trend.Over the page, paragraph 69 is headed: “Spending on agency nurses increased by 62 per cent”.The three figures that the paragraph mentions all relate to one year. NHS Lanarkshire, for example, increased its spending on agency nurses from £13,000 to £344,000, while NHS Forth Valley increased its spend from £14,000 to £273,000.With regard to the three figures that are highlighted on pages 31 and 32, is this just a snapshot, or is it an indication of a trend in the NHS? In particular, there is a significant increase in vacancy rates and in the use of agency and bank nurses, which we thought was going to be reduced—in fact, I would venture to say that that increase is probably against Government policy.Are those significant pressures in the system? Will we be able to meet targets in future if those pressures continue, or are they just short term?
We think that they are all early indications of the pressures in the system that we have been discussing and which are there for a range of reasons to do with increasing need, changing patterns of care and so on.I will ask Gemma Diamond to come in with a bit more detail on the trends that we are aware of. The picture is complex, certainly with regard to the vacancy figures. Consultant and nursing staff vacancies have gone up markedly across the year, as you say, but so has the number of staff in post in both those categories.There was a shift last year from 4,427 consultants in post to 4,531, and a small increase in nursing staff from 56,467 to 57,036. That is the background against which we are seeing more vacancies. There are differences in different parts of Scotland and in different specialties. In some specialties it is particularly difficult to recruit, not only in Scotland but throughout the United Kingdom, and, in some instances, globally.I will make one point about bank and agency staff. Bank nursing can be quite a good way of meeting the need for flexibility—in hospital staffing especially—that everyone has to manage, and of bringing back into the workforce nurses who may have had a break to bring up their families or to do something else. Bank nursing can be very well managed to provide good flexibility by using staff who understand the NHS and the service in which they are working. Agency staff bring more problems and risks with them because they tend to be less familiar with the hospital and the ward, and with the ways of working.We would not see bank nursing itself as a problem, but the rise in the use and cost of agency staff seems to be worth paying more attention to, although it is still a relatively small amount of money in the context of the NHS as a whole.
I highlighted that“Spending on agency nurses increased by 62 per cent in 2012/13”,and I understand that there was an increase of around 500 staff in nursing and midwifery. It is important that we have an accurate record of these figures.The notes on exhibit 13 state that 350 of those 500 staff were Scottish Prison Service staff who transferred to the NHS. Those are not new staff—those people were doing work, but their employer was the Scottish Prison Service rather than the NHS. That accounts for the majority of the increase in nursing staff.
You are quite right, Mrs Scanlon—I am not trying to suggest that your question is wrong; I just wanted to put the figures in context.
I felt that it was important to be accurate.
I will ask Gemma Diamond to pick up on what we know about trends in those areas.
Those are the key figures that we look for in the annual accounts so that we can see what is happening with the trend. This year, we saw a reverse in the trend that we had seen previously—certainly for agency staff—of decreasing numbers, as there was a large increase this year.It is too early to tell whether that is a real change in trend or just a difference for one year. We will need to track those figures next year to see whether the trend continues and those signs of pressure remain, or whether action has been taken to change the situation.We know that change in the way in which services are delivered takes a long time to put in place, so it might well be that there is no immediate reduction in those numbers. It is hoped that action that is taken now will reduce the trend in the longer term.
So, you will be looking in future at those three areas—vacancies, agency staff and the five-fold increase in private sector treatment—in order to manage information on trends.Having been a member of a health board in years gone by, and having looked at the Arbuthnott formula and the national resource allocation committee, I know that a lot of time has been spent on coming up with a funding formula for health boards. I am surprised, after 14 years of this Parliament, to see that you have highlighted in paragraph 58 that five health boards are not being given their NRAC allocation of funds.The report states:“These NHS boards have been under-funded by a total of £517 million over that period.”If I was a member of one of those health boards—Fife, Forth Valley, Grampian, Lanarkshire and Lothian—I would be quite concerned that despite the use of a very sophisticated formula to allocate funding, over a period of time, my board had received significantly less and was, to use your own term, “under-funded”.Is it fair to ask all those boards to meet their targets and break even at the end of the year when they are being “under-funded”, according to your report?
That is an area that we look at closely each year, for exactly the reason suggested by your question. It is important to say that we are talking about underfunding against the formula allocation, rather than in absolute terms. However, in principle, if the allocation formula is there, we would expect to see movement towards it over a period of time.We have said, both last year and this year, that there is no clearly discernible pattern that links a board’s financial performance and its distance from the resource allocation formula. We say that at paragraph 59 of the report. Some boards that are below allocation do very well, and some seem to be struggling, and we would like to explore that further in future years. The committee may also wish to explore that question, either with the boards themselves or with the Scottish Government.
You say that there is a“lack of clear plans and an agreed timescale to move towards parity”.Will you look to the Scottish Government to ensure that those boards are given their recommended allocation? I am quoting from the end of paragraph 58. You say that that“adds uncertainty to NHS boards’ planning.”Are you asking the Government to look towards a timescale in which the boards could receive the recommended allocation of funds?
It is entirely appropriate for the committee to explore with the Government what its plans are for movement towards the formula. The point that we tried to make is that such things add uncertainty to boards’ overall financial planning. That fits within the context of our recommendation to strengthen that area.
link
First, we should note the good performance of the NHS and the Scottish Government in managing the NHS’s finances in such a tight way at a very difficult time. There are undoubtedly challenges for the future, but every organisation faces those.Ms Scanlon took my question, but I have another one on pension fund liabilities. Paragraph 84 of the report mentions pension fund liabilities in relation to NHS Highland. Perhaps I missed it, but I did not see anything about pension fund liabilities in the NHS as a whole.
There is something in the report about pension liabilities for the NHS as a whole, which I will ask Tricia Meldrum to point me towards in a moment.We specifically referenced Highland in paragraph 84 because of the challenges that are thrown up by the approach that has been taken there to health and social care integration, which the auditors, the health board and the council have had to work through over the past 12 months. We hope that that will provide some useful learning as health and social care integration progresses.Tricia, can you point me towards the more general reference?
Paragraph 64 on page 30 and the bullet points above that reiterate the points in last year’s report about NHS pension funds.
The challenge is that there has been a delay in the pension fund revaluation over the past couple of years. Since the publication of the report, that may now be closer to being resolved, but we made the point last year and again this year that having up-to-date valuations of the liabilities is important if we are to manage the pension scheme, the contribution levels in the future and the associated risks.
link
Recent revaluations under the new accounting rules in other areas of the public sector, which take into account the reduced bond yields, have resulted in almost 100 per cent deficits right across the country. I presume that we can expect the same for the NHS.
I think that we discussed this a few weeks ago in relation to college pension schemes. You are correct that, in revaluations, very small movements in the discount rates and the new accounting rules can have significant impacts on the liabilities. That is why it is important that a revaluation should be carried out for the NHS pension scheme and the other schemes that are affected by the Treasury’s moratorium on revaluing over recent years.
I apologise if this goes over some of the ground that has been covered, but I ask for clarification at the risk of inviting Bob Doris to intervene again. Am I right in thinking that the main conclusion is that demand is increasing but it is forecast that the overall health budget will fall in real terms?
It is true that demand is increasing for a range of reasons. In the first part of the report—on pages 5 to 8—we tried to put on the record what is happening with NHS funding, which is complex. Against a backdrop of very tight financial resources for the Scottish block as a whole, which are the result of decisions that have been made elsewhere, the Government has made a commitment to protect the budgets of the territorial NHS boards in real terms. We expect that to be the case over the next three years, with a small real-terms increase of 0.6 per cent over that period.The exhibit on page 8 shows in cash and real terms what is happening for the special and territorial health boards. It shows very small real-terms increases for the 14 territorial health boards over the years to 2015-16 and varying decreases for the special health boards. There is therefore a complex picture for those two types of board: there is a real-terms increase in revenue spend but a real-terms decrease in capital spend. We hope that our reports in general provide a clear and independent picture of the movements in finances over a period.10:15
That is helpful. Clearly, there are pressures and priorities in the health service spend. Is overall health spending forecast to decline in real terms over the next three years?
We say as clearly as we can in paragraph 2:“The overall health budget is forecast to decrease by 1.6 per cent in real terms over the next three years ... The revenue budget is forecast to increase by 0.6 per cent ... while the capital budget is forecast to decrease”.Within that, the territorial health board budgets go up and the special health board budgets go down.
That means that health spending, whether you divide it into capital or revenue, is going to fall in real terms while demand is going to increase. Is that correct?
I do not think that it is helpful for me to simplify it in quite those terms. The headline figure for the overall health budget is clearly an overall decrease of 1.6 per cent. However, when those figures are broken down there are very real differences between the territorial health boards and the special health boards. Within the special health boards, there is a distinction between those that provide patient services, such as NHS 24, and those that provide support services, and there is a real difference between revenue and capital. People will have different interpretations of the most important feature of that. All that I can do is replay the detail in a way that is as independently based as we can make it.
I want you to clarify something that was commented on earlier. Exhibit 14 on page 31 is striking, as it shows that there has been an increase in spending on bank and agency staff and quite a dramatic increase in spending on private sector healthcare. Does that really represent good value for money?
The increase in both those areas is significant, but it is against a very small base and we are talking about an NHS budget of about £12 billion. For example, the increase last year for private healthcare provision was £14.8 million, which is a very small proportion of the overall budget. The Government has made it clear that its approach is not to prioritise spending on private healthcare provision, but to use that provision where there are problems such as Tricia Meldrum has highlighted, in places such as Lothian, in meeting wider healthcare delivery targets. The question of how that is being managed is better directed towards the health boards concerned and the Scottish Government.It is absolutely true that there has been an increase in those areas, but it is against a small base and it is still a small number within the context of the NHS budget as a whole.
Thank you. I turn to another issue entirely that has been brought to my attention—I could not see it in the report, but you might be aware of it. It is a particular example from NHS Tayside. I am not sure whether it was called a revaluation, but it involved the handover of the assets of non-profit distributing organisations to the health service in 2012. There was a project for the Susan Carnegie centre at Stracathro hospital that had contract costs of £18.4 million and there was a project at the Murray royal hospital site in Perth that had costs of £77.1 million. The facilities cost £95.5 million, but when they were handed over to NHS Tayside they were revalued at £83.4 million. In other words, they lost more than £10 million in value because they were revalued at £10 million less than they cost to build. Would that emerge somewhere in the NHS accounts? Would you audit that?
From paragraph 26 of our report onwards, we talk about the accounting adjustments that are required for public-private partnership projects of various types. I think that the Murray royal hospital is referred to within that, but the Stracathro treatment centre is not. Gemma Diamond is our expert on that, so I ask her to talk you through the position in broad terms. We can provide any other information that is necessary afterwards.
The figures will appear in NHS Tayside’s accounts. The auditors at NHS Tayside raised the issue of the impairment on the valuation in their annual audit report to the board and to the Auditor General. The auditors recommended that the health board work with the Scottish Government to discover why that had happened, and they will follow that up as part of their audit this year. We will look at it next year to see what action has been taken and whether any wider issues arise beyond the issue for NHS Tayside.
Were you surprised to see such a big project lose more than 10 per cent of its value like that? Would you expect to see that? Is that normal practice in the NHS?
We do not have the details to know how the evaluation was arrived at. The auditors assessed the evaluation with the board and have asked the board to look into it and see whether any wider implications for other NHS boards arise from the valuation. We will have to follow that up over the next year, and the auditors themselves will follow it up.
Have any other NPD projects or other construction or capital projects been similarly revalued or asset impaired?
There are a number of PPP projects in the NHS and some new ones are coming on stream. It is something that the auditors routinely keep under review as part of their annual audit work. As Gemma Diamond said, the auditors will report both to the health board and to me, as the Auditor General. If significant issues or a trend were identified, I would certainly consider reporting that to the committee, but that has not been the case so far.
If the NHS Tayside situation was more than a one-off and developed into a trend, you would expect us to be alerted to it.
I would alert the committee to any significant financial issues that came out of my areas of responsibility in the NHS and the wider public sector. However, so far, that has not been the case.
What would be the next course of action in the NHS Tayside situation? It has been reported by the board. Would we expect the Government to intervene in some way and to report to Parliament? Would we expect Audit Scotland to be involved? How would the situation be accountable in a parliamentary manner, or would it not be?
As I said, if an issue is significant enough to bring to the attention of the committee, I have the reporting powers to do so either through the section 22 powers to report on a board’s annual accounts or through a section 23 report like the one that is before you today.
I would have thought that, in these times of tight budgets, the loss of £12 million on a building project is the sort of thing that the committee would want to know about.
I am not sure that it is accurate to characterise the situation as the loss of £12 million on a building project; it is about the valuation of the asset and the accounting adjustments that follow from that. However, I will look at what we heard from the auditors in relation to the previous financial year and will consider whether there is an issue that would merit further reporting.
Can you clarify what it means? If a project is built at a cost to the public of £95 million and then appears in our books at a cost of £83 million, is that not a loss of £12 million?
No.
What is it then?
Accounting adjustments are required, and without knowing the reasons for the variation—which, as Gemma Diamond said, are being explored between the health board and the Scottish Government and will be reported on further by the auditors—I do not want to speculate on what the underlying cause is.
If there are any further issues of clarification on that, either the member or the committee can write to the Auditor General. I intend to finish this session at half past 10, so I will cut questioning on that issue now. Is there anything to add on it?
No.
I would like you to clarify something, Auditor General. You referred to PPP projects being mentioned in paragraph 26 of the report. Are such projects still being developed?
The acronym PPP is used to refer to a range of privately funded projects, including the non-profit distributing model, the private finance initiative and so on.
Okay. The impression is sometimes given that PPP was abolished, but such projects still exist.
I will leave the obvious discussion about the financial pluses and minuses because I think that we have had enough of that.NHS Lothian is mentioned in several parts of the report, including in respect of the problems with recruitment, which you have explained quite well and which I understand. I was aware that some specialist areas were struggling to recruit, but that is the case not just in NHS Lothian but UK-wide. I believe that NHS boards are having to advertise as widely as the far east to fill particular positions.Three of my colleagues have stolen most of my intended questions, so I will ask about what I am left with from my notes on what interested me. Given NHS Lothian’s problems over the past year or two, have the accounting mechanisms been improved to a state that would allow us to feel confident about where NHS Lothian is going in its financial performance?
I ask Gemma Diamond to come in if she wants to add anything to this. NHS Lothian’s financial statements have been audited every year, as all health boards’ financial statements are. There have been some recommendations for improvements in financial management in NHS Lothian, but nothing significant or out of the ordinary run of things across the NHS. We saw particular problems in the management of waiting times, which were reported on extensively last year, and we will provide an update on that issue right across the NHS. However, the recommendation for NHS Lothian in particular to improve longer-term financial planning, underpinning it with strong forecasts and strong scenario planning, is all the more important because of the pressures that it has faced in the past. There are no differences in its accounts or financial management, but there is a difference in the underlying pressures that it is having to manage.
Have you found any other weaknesses in NHS Lothian’s reporting mechanisms that have not been addressed? I feel as though I am picking on my local health service but, given the problems that NHS Lothian has had, it is important that we all feel confident in the new management regime’s ability not only to address the problems with waiting times in the past, but to produce comprehensive and, frankly, trustworthy reports in the future.
In NHS Lothian, there has been a real focus on earning back the public’s trust and confidence. Its annual accounts received a clean audit certificate this year, as did those of all other health boards. I know that you are interested in more than waiting times, but the work that we are finalising now on progress against our waiting times recommendation shows that NHS Lothian has made a really strong effort to improve the information that is going to the board to enable it to monitor that. We can take that as an indication that NHS Lothian is responding positively to the challenges that it has faced over the past few years.
Thank you. I am going to finish this session at 10.35. James Dornan is next to ask a question.
Auditor General, I share your frustration about some of the blatant politicking going on at this meeting.Can I take you back to the workforce figures that we were talking about earlier? Mary Scanlon mentioned the figures for nursing and midwifery. My partner is a nurse and I know that 10 staff have just been hired on her ward, with more meant to come on in the very near future—that is just one personal example. Do you think that these figures are a one-off? Are they part of an upward trend, or could the number of vacancies decline?
First, I am sorry if any of my words or my body language has indicated frustration with members. Clearly, I am here to respond to questions that members might have on the work that we produce.As Gemma Diamond said, we monitor the question of vacancies very closely through the annual accounts and more widely. We work closely with the Scottish Government to look at the financial monitoring and performance monitoring between the Scottish Government and health boards. It is simply too soon to say what is happening there. There are indications of pressure that we think that the Government and health boards should take seriously, and there is a range of ways in which they can respond to those, by redesigning services and focusing on longer-term financial planning to be able to square the circle of increasing demand and very tight resources.
Nobody welcomes any increase in agency staff but, again, I know that nursing staff are being asked about their bank staff availability, so there seems to be a push in the health service to try to use bank staff again. Do you have any indication that we will see a decrease in the use of agency staff and, as I hope, an increase in the use of bank staff?
I have been resisting all morning the temptation to use that famous quotation from Niels Bohr, the physicist, that prediction is always hard, especially about the future. We simply do not know the position yet. Our strong view as an organisation is that bank staff are better than agency staff as a way of responding to short-term fluctuations but that that is what they should be used for, not filling gaps for the longer term. We are seeing significant work going into workforce planning, but it is early days yet to see the results of that. However, it is something that we will keep under close review. The committee might want to explore that further with health boards or the Government.
Thank you.10:30
I will start by picking up on the point about accident and emergency targets, which are described on pages 36 and 37 of the report. In his opening remarks, the convener talked about significant failures, but my understanding of the information is that there have been significant successes. The accident and emergency target column in exhibit 15 shows that most health boards met or were within 5 per cent of meeting their target. That is a different message from the message of “significant failure” that the convener opened with. For two of the health boards in particular—Ayrshire and Arran, and Lanarkshire—I shudder to think what would have happened and what figures we might have got in this report had Ayr and Monklands hospitals shut.Auditor General, in your opening remarks, you talked about the need for detailed planning and said that it was not being done on the affordability of plans. I want to pick you up on what that might mean. Your report refers to brokerage and flexibility arrangements on a year-by-year basis. Can the boards deploy a brokerage and flexibility mechanism to help them with that detailed planning, or are we stuck rigidly to the annual financial planning that you recommend we should move away from? Do you recommend that we should continue with the flexibility mechanism and, if so, does that mean that we do not need rigorous annual financial targets to be set?
There are at the moment, as you said, very rigorous annual targets, and health boards and the Government take very seriously the need to meet those. That is good in terms of financial discipline, but we think that it can get in the way of the longer-term financial planning that is needed to find more sustainable solutions to the pressures that the health service is under. At the moment, brokerage and other short-term flexibility are the way in which those targets are hit. To come within 0.16 per cent of the targets across the NHS as a whole is not done by chance; it is done by very close monitoring month by month and moving money to where it is needed. Again, that is entirely understandable within the framework that we are working in.We reported last year that those movements were not transparent, but we think that there has been a real improvement this year in boards’ annual reports and accounts in making that more transparent for revenue, although we think that there is still more to do in relation to capital. However, we still think that there is a danger—I think that the cabinet secretary and the Scottish Government now share this view—and that it would be helpful to move away from the annual framework to something that gives a longer-term planning horizon.Our view is that, within that horizon, the ability to respond to the pressures would be strengthened by much more detailed financial planning and scenario plans that look at different possible states in the future and different ways of providing services and so on. It is all about marshalling the best of the NHS to ensure that it can continue to meet people’s needs as we all get older as a population and as our needs change. It seems to us that, on balance, the annual financial frameworks get in the way of that flexibility, so we are pleased to hear that the Government is considering ways of moving away from that to something that provides a longer-term planning framework.
I am very encouraged by that. Thank you.As time is short, I will move to my next question, which is about opportunities for recurring savings. Exhibit 10 on page 23 shows that the biggest return was in the drugs and prescribing area, partly from savings made from drugs coming off patent. Are the savings a trend that is likely to continue, or is the situation likely to get worse? There have been some quite impressive savings for the NHS in the past year or so. Can we expect to see that continue?
I will ask Tricia Meldrum to come in on the detail on that, but you are right that drugs have made a significant contribution to savings. The important point that we highlight that boards need to be aware of is that that is very much affected by specific drugs coming off patent and being available in generic forms that are much cheaper. That tends to happen in chunks, so there is a significant saving in one year from a drug coming off patent, but we cannot rely on the same thing happening on a regular basis. Tricia Meldrum will add a bit of context to that.
In 2012-13, atorvastatin, which is one of the most popular statins, came off patent. It is widely prescribed and used by a lot of people, so that is one of the drugs that have had a significant impact on savings. There will not be quite the same level of potential savings from other drugs coming off patent in the near future, but we are aware that the Government and the boards are carrying out a lot of work on this and are continuing to look at improving the quality and cost effectiveness of prescribing. For example, a national workstream is examining national therapeutic indicators and seeking to identify a small number of drugs and types of drug on which attention can be focused. However, we do not expect to see the same level of recurring savings as we saw in 2012-13, as much of that was down to atorvastatin.
As a very brief—and, I hope, final—point, surely the system must know which drugs are coming off patent in the next one, two, three, four, five or even 10 years. Is the NHS able to build that into its financial planning forecasts? Previously, good progress was made in using generic rather than brand drugs and I think that that trend should be welcomed. Do we, as I think the Auditor General mentioned earlier, build that into our forecasts?
Yes, and you are right to say that it has been a significant success for the NHS. However, our point is that atorvastatin is a real one-off because of the extent to which it is used in the health service, and it is hard to spot another drug that will have as significant an impact on the budget when it comes off patent.
Before I close this evidence session, I want to come back to Willie Coffey’s point about my comments on accident and emergency. I hope that I have not misinterpreted anything, so I ask the Auditor General to state for the record the health boards that met their A and E targets.
We have tried to make the exhibit in question as clear as we can, convener. The four board marked with a green tick all achieved four-hour waiting times for A and E and the boards with two yellow arrows came within 5 per cent—
I am sorry, but could you just list for the record the names of the boards that met their targets?
It is on the record.
I am reluctant to interpret this complex exhibit on the record because of the focus that is being placed on this particular number. It might be useful if I write to you to place that on the record. As you can see, a number of indicators in the column in the exhibit have quite specific meanings and I want to ensure that we do not mislead the committee about what they mean. I am certainly very happy to follow that up.
That would be helpful because, as presented, the exhibit indicates that Orkney, Shetland, Tayside and Western Isles met their target. It would help if you could clarify what the overall statistics mean to ensure that we are not under any misapprehension about their significance.
Convener, I said that most—
I am sorry, but I must thank the Auditor General and her staff for their evidence. No doubt we will follow up the issue at some point.I suspend the meeting for a couple of minutes for a changeover of witnesses.10:37 Meeting suspended.
10:41 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 6 Nov 2013 →- 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 131
- 09:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 287
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.