I reconvene the meeting. We are taking oral evidence from Scottish Government officials. I welcome to the meeting Leslie Evans, who is director general learning and justice; Paul Johnston, who is director of safer communities; Hilary Pearce, who is head of police finance team; and Stephen Woodhouse, who is head of finance and workforce sponsorship unit—which is an intriguing title. They are here to contribute to our consideration of the section 23 report “Police reform: Progress update 2013”.I invite Leslie Evans to make an opening statement.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Police reform: Progress update 2013”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Leslie Evans Scottish Government 142
- Hugh Henry Lab 65
- Ken Macintosh Lab 31
- Tavish Scott LD 24
- Mary Scanlon Con 19
- Hilary Pearce Scottish Government 19
- Paul Johnston Scottish Government 16
- James Dornan SNP 13
- Colin Beattie SNP 8
- Colin Keir SNP 5
- Willie Coffey SNP 4
- Bob Doris SNP 3
- Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Government 3
The record
352 contributions · showing 1–200Thank you, convener, and thanks for the opportunity to provide evidence to the committee in response to the Auditor General for Scotland’s report on police reform.I am here this time in my capacity as the accountable officer for the Scottish Government’s justice portfolio, which includes responsibility for ensuring that the Scottish Police Authority has in place the necessary controls to safeguard public funds. In undertaking that task I draw on a number of assurance systems, including effective sponsorship arrangements between the Scottish Police Authority and the Scottish Government, but I also undertake the performance appraisal of the chair of the Scottish Police Authority—Vic Emery—and meet him regularly.The committee heard last month from the Scottish Police Authority, Police Scotland and Her Majesty’s inspector of constabulary for Scotland. I record my thanks and appreciation for the hard work, energy and commitment that has been demonstrated by all three organisations in making Scotland’s new single police service a reality.As the Auditor General stated in her evidence to the committee on 20 November:“Police reform has involved one of the biggest and most complex restructures in the public sector since devolution, and the biggest change in policing since at least 1967.”—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 20 November 2013; c 1746.It is, indeed, a singular achievement, and I welcome Audit Scotland’s recognition not only of the achievement but of the good practice that has been demonstrated in how reform was effected. So, in addition to passing legislation to establish the Scottish Police Authority and Police Scotland, and supporting the production of a policing plan for each of Scotland’s 353 multimember wards, we established effective project and programme management, appointed both the chair of the Scottish Police Authority and the chief constable six months before the start date of the new service, and enabled publication of the Police Authority’s strategic plan, supported by an annual police plan. All that ensured that Scotland’s policing services were maintained during the transition to the single service.However, it is not only the structure of policing that has changed. For the first time the police have a statutory purpose, which is set out in the policing principles of the Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Act 2012, and is focused on prevention and on delivery of outcomes. The legislation makes it clear that the purpose of policing is to work in partnership to improve the safety and wellbeing of people and communities in Scotland and to promote“measures to prevent crime, harm and disorder.”That is a significant shift from the Police (Scotland) Act 1967, in which the main duty of police officers was“to guard, patrol and watch”.Two years ago, we were visiting our European neighbours to learn about reform; now they are coming to see us.Partnership working is at the heart of Police Scotland’s approach to policing in Scotland. The new structure and purpose enable the police leadership to make a powerful, strategic and cohesive contribution to complex issues that require close working with other sectors and agencies. They include issues such as tackling alcohol, the early years, new psychoactive substances—also known as legal highs—and internet safety for children and young people. Local policing is the bedrock of Police Scotland. There is now a local commander for each division in Scotland, working with communities, councils, community planning partners and other partners to shape and deliver policing in their areas.We are merely nine months into a major reform programme; huge progress has been made, but transformational change of this scale takes time to deliver and to bed down. Both the Police Authority and Police Scotland are confident that they will deliver sustainable savings this year and that they are on target to put in place by the end of this financial year strategies and performance management systems to track progress on realising the benefits of reform, in keeping with Audit Scotland’s recommendations.The Auditor General’s report recognises that the Scottish Government, the Scottish Police Authority and Police Scotland are working together to address the areas that require continued effort, and it recommends continuing joint emphasis to complete that. We agree.Thank you, convener. I am happy to take questions, as are my colleagues.
Thank you. Why did the Scottish Government not prepare a full business case?
As you will know, we prepared an outline case, which formed a very strong and effective basis for the financial memorandum for the 2012 act. In doing so, we were differentiating between an outline business case that explains the feasibility of savings for that particular route of reform and a full business case, which requires due diligence for how the savings are going to be delivered and therefore owned by the new leadership and the new organisation itself.We differentiated between those and provided what was required to take a decision—which was a very full outline business case. It involved a good deal of consultation and was scrutinised by the directors of finance from the police forces themselves. We differentiated between that outline business case and the requirement of the new organisation and the new leadership to detail how and where they were going to change the service in order to enable the reforms and the savings to be made and to be detailed.
So, was there no need for a full business case?
It was essential to have an outline business case and for the information before Parliament—
No—I am not talking about the outline business case. Are you saying that there was no need for a full business case?
There is a need for a full business case, which is what the Police Authority is working on now with support from us, from Police Scotland and from others.
You are preparing a full business case after the event. Just for argument’s sake, suppose that that full business case shows that what you have proposed is a bag of mince. What would you do?
I think that we are confident that it will not be “a bag of mince”.
No—but just suppose that it is, for argument’s sake, since you are preparing a full business case after the event.
We are asking the SPA and Police Scotland to realise the outline business case based on strategic decisions that they will make, changes to services, how they manage their estate, the resources that they deploy, the structure of the new policing in Scotland, and the balance between national and local policing. There is a wide range of decisions; it is very important that they be reflected in the financial circumstances of the authority in the future. The new authority and Police Scotland are not preparing a full business case exceptionally or separately but are doing so based on what has already been prepared, and will deliver it themselves. It will be in place before the end of the financial year.
I understand all that, but we have been told that this is the biggest single structural change of services since 1999—since the creation of this Parliament. You prepared—as you described it—“a very full outline business case”.Audit Scotland has indicated that no full business case was prepared; I am sure that it would not have mentioned that fact if it thought that it was irrelevant. You have not looked at a full business case in preparation for this event. Now that the event has happened, you are preparing a full business case. Surely a business case is part of the argument for justification of change?
Absolutely. That is why the outline business case was so comprehensive—
No, no, no. Forget the outline business case. You have just agreed with me that a full business case is part of the justification for change, but you are not providing such full justification until after the event.
I think that the last thing that anybody would have wanted and the least helpful approach would have been for a bunch of civil servants sitting in St Andrew’s house to decide how the services were going to be delivered. You cannot separate the full business case from the way the services are going to be constructed.
No. The business case is not about determining how services will be provided. That is an operational matter for the chief constable; it is also an issue for the board of the SPA. That is a side issue. We are talking about whether the case that was made would justify the change. You have just told me that part of that justification is the full business case, but you did not provide that; we still do not have it. The change has been made but there has been no business case to justify that. Why is that?
The outline business case that informed the financial memorandum as well as the 2012 act and the decisions around the act was scrutinised and held up to account. That was the basis on which the decision for reform was taken; indeed, it was discussed when and how a full business case would be brought to bear. The police, civil servants and the Cabinet Secretary for Justice himself all said that there would be a full financial business case and a corporate strategy to support that business case. Both of those are being enacted now. I think that Audit Scotland said in its report that there should be a strategy of that nature by the end of the financial year. We are well on target—working with the SPA and Police Scotland—to produce that.
If other organisations were planning change, they would normally make a full business case to justify the change to shareholders, boards or whoever. As far as the Scottish Government is concerned, is it correct that when major changes are to take place, there is no need to have a full business case ahead of that?
There is a need for very explicit understanding of the impact of reform and how that will impact on a business case. That was done through the outline business case, which formed the basis of the financial memorandum, in keeping with Treasury guidance.
As far as the civil service senior management team is concerned, is it a matter of policy that you do not provide a full business case ahead of the decision being made when major structural changes take place?
We have to provide a business case that will inform and satisfy Parliament of the case for reform, which is what we did. Parliament was satisfied with the financial memorandum, so it was agreed. We then have to ask the incoming organisation to put flesh on the bones. We ask how it will organise its estate and human resources practices, what the top, middle and lower layers of its hierarchy are and what its staff costings will be. It is then for the organisation, on that basis, to put flesh on the bones.The police were quite categorical about that. The leadership of the SPA and the chief constable were perfectly aware of that responsibility, which is why this year they have been working very carefully on what their strategic intentions mean for the organisation.
Is it correct that you are a member of the senior management team in the civil service?
It is.
In your time in the senior management team, has the Scottish civil service produced a full business case to justify any major structural change that has taken place, or is it the case that full business cases are not produced?
Undoubtedly we must have sufficient information in the business case to inform a decision on reform. That is what formed the basis of the financial memorandum in the 2012 act.
Is Audit Scotland therefore wasting time by making reference to this?
No—not at all. Audit Scotland said that a full set of strategies needs to be in place, including a financial strategy. Vic Emery calls it a corporate strategy for the SPA. It has to be in place by the end of this year and it will be.
In your professional judgment, there is no need to have a full business case ahead of a decision to make a major structural change.
In my professional judgment, we need to be satisfied that the content of the business case as examined at the time of reform is sufficient for the decision. That was the case with the 2012 act. The requirement is then to put flesh on the bones and to ask the leadership of the organisation what specific actions it is taking and what strategies it is following to ensure that the business case is realised.
You told me that it is necessary for you to consider the business case, but if no business case is made, how can you consider it?
The information in the outline business case—which, as I have said, was cited as one of the best that the gateway review team has ever seen—was comprehensive. It was not a short or small document; it was based on a significant amount of research, on the police objective analysis cost allocation modelling that was undertaken, and on a range of consultant, internal and external advice. The police were involved absolutely in creating that.
Why not call that the full business case?
That would have assumed that the decisions that would be taken by the leadership in the early months and the first year of the establishment of the organisation could have been taken at that time.
So, is a full business case actually something that happens when operational decisions are made after the event, in the early months?
I am trying to differentiate between an outline business case, which is about savings being feasible and examined—
I know what you are trying to outline, Leslie.
—and the due diligence that is required, which will require decisions on strategy as well as cost.
I know exactly what you are trying to outline and I know what you are saying about the outline business case. Are you telling me that a full business case does not need to be prepared until after a decision is taken and that that is a matter of policy?
I am not sure what you mean by “a matter of policy”.
Is that what happens?
It is certainly a matter of practice that the outline business case needs to be comprehensive enough to inform the decision on reform.
Yes.
It has to be convincing and it must lay out options and costs. The outline business case and the financial memorandum did that.11:00
Thereafter, once the decision has been taken to go down the route of a single authority—as in this case—the leadership of the organisation would need to take responsibility for putting flesh on the bones in terms of due diligence in relation to the reality of the costs and savings, and the decisions that would need to be taken on a range of issues. That has happened this year, and—in keeping with Audit Scotland’s recommendation—the financial and corporate strategies to cover that will be in place before the end of the financial year.
Since you became a member of the senior management team, have you been aware of outline business cases that have been prepared in other areas?
I am aware of reform that has been undertaken on the basis of deciding which model to use and how to do that, and of further work being done by the incoming Administration.
I want to be clear about what you said. Have outline business cases been prepared on other issues since you became a member of the senior management team.
Do you mean other than for police and fire services?
Yes.
That was done for fire services as well, of course.
Yes.
I do not know whether they were called outline business cases, but they would have differentiated between the costs and savings from reform and the decisions that would have been taken by the leadership of the organisation to put flesh on those bones.
Are you aware that any full business cases have ever been produced by the civil service?
I cannot answer that—I do not have information on that at the moment.
We can clarify that with the permanent secretary.
link
I have a couple of supplementaries on the business case, but I will try to be brief.Mr House and Mr Emery came to committee and were asked very similar questions. I asked them what would have happened to the savings that were planned for the financial year 2013-14 had Parliament waited for another financial year before going ahead with police service reform, and awaited a full business case rather than deciding on the basis of an outline business case. My understanding is that £63.9 million of savings were planned for that financial year, and nearly all of those have already been made. If the Government and Parliament had delayed reform by a financial year, would there have been a financial cost to Government and to the police, given that we are anticipating financial savings in this year of £63.9 million?
A couple of issues at least would have arisen from that set of circumstances. First, if reform had been delayed by another year, there would not have been the savings that have already been accrued in the current financial year.Secondly, delay would have meant that we would have been moving to implement reform during the year of the Commonwealth games and the Ryder cup, which would not have helped in planning for those events.Thirdly, delay would have increased the uncertainty that already existed—it would have done so in any sector—and was being expressed very clearly from various sources as well as the police and the community.In addition, it was not possible until the organisation was established to take the decisions that were required—which the SPA has taken and is taking now—to put flesh on the bones in respect of savings. The savings would have been lost or delayed, and there would have been a great deal of uncertainty at a time when Scotland was anticipating significant events in 2014.Unless we had had a shadow organisation operating alongside eight—well, 10—police organisations, which is a recipe for confusion, those organisations would not have had the capacity to take the decisions to put the business case to the board anyway, because they would not have been in charge of, or executing, decisions in real time.
link
That is helpful, because that was also the evidence that we heard from Mr Emery and Mr House. In your answers to the convener, you had not articulated that particularly, so I wanted to give you an opportunity to put it on the record.You mentioned that the decisions on fleshing out the reforms could be taken only once the reforms had been completed. Again, I am merely reflecting previous evidence to committee to see whether you agree with it. I want to ensure that the arguments that you make dovetail with the arguments that the SPA is making.You mentioned putting flesh on the bones. That is just a description—it means nothing to people. Mr House said that had a full business plan been prepared before he became chief constable, he would have been looking at a fait accompli in terms of reforms in human resources, information technology, capital estate, vehicle fleet and wider procurement. Those are five examples that one would expect a chief constable to be hands-on with when dealing with and working in conjunction with the SPA.Would it have been appropriate for all those detailed decisions to have been taken before there was a chief constable? Obviously, you cannot put a chief constable in place until you have police reform. Once you have police reform and have put a chief constable in place, you have to have various work streams from which a full business plan would flow, in terms of human resources, information technology, capital estate, vehicle fleet and wider procurement. I could go on. I found that to be a compelling reason for not having a full business case, but you have not really said any of that. Those are examples that were given by Mr House and Mr Emery: you have not given examples, other than to talk about putting flesh on the bones. I am not trying to put words in your mouth.
I suppose that “flesh on the bones” is shorthand for what you have described. However, I said earlier that it would not have been appropriate—nor would it have been feasible—for a bunch of civil servants in St Andrew’s house to start taking decisions on issues that would have such a fundamental impact on the operation of the police in Scotland.As I was discussing earlier with colleagues, one of the reasons why I was so keen to ensure that we appointed the chair, and that the chair was then able to appoint the chief constable in advance of the authority’s taking up power, was that we wanted to give them time to make a smooth transition, to prepare the ground, and to get to grips with operational issues and what the shape and size of the authority would be.The items that Bob Doris has described are operationally influencing decisions that the authority would want to take under advice from the chief constable, who is in charge of the new policing operation in Scotland.
link
Thank you.
Before we move on, how did you arrive at the expected figure of £1.1 billion savings by 2026?
That figure was arrived at based on production, testing and scrutiny of the outline business case. It also informed the financial memorandum.
Although there is no full business case or detailed justification, are you fully committed to that £1.1 billion of savings?
We are committed to it, and we tested the figure again after the 2012 act was passed. We asked the Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland and Kevin Smith to do some due diligence work on the likelihood of savings and where those savings would be amassed on the basis of the decision to go to a single authority. Kevin Smith did further work on it at that point.
Will the future funding for the police be predicated on that £1.1 billion of savings?
Yes.
I refer you to appendix 2 of the report, and the progress that you have made in police reform against the recommendations in Audit Scotland’s report, “Learning the lessons of public body mergers”. Out of 10 recommendations, you have achieved two. Of the other eight, one is a definite no, one has not started and six are in progress. Did you read Audit Scotland’s report and act on its advice before you prepared your outline business case?
Yes. We were aware of the public body mergers information and have been using it as a benchmark. Most of the recommendations are in place or in progress. As you might imagine, some take longer than others, and it would not be possible to complete some before the new authority has been in place for some time.I spoke to the committee two weeks ago about reform in further education—both the reform teams have been talking to each other about what they have learned and what they have put in place in terms of public body mergers.
Well, two out of 10 is not exactly great progress in my book.Something that has not even been started is the scheduling of “a post-implementation review within six months”. My party supports police reform, but we want it to work and I am disappointed that, given the criticism that Mr House and Mr Emery have taken on this issue, you as the director general for learning and justice have not even started to look at that review. You have also been criticised for not updating estimates or preparing a full business case.
But we have talked about the full business case—
I know, and I do not want to return to that issue.
No. In terms of the post-implementation review—
Surely it is not beyond your ability.
Absolutely. We have started it internally in the first instance—
Well, it was not started when the report was written. Did you start it after the report came out?
No. We had already put the bare bones in place. However, since the publication of the report, we have begun to look at what we have learned internally and I have given a commitment to the boards of the fire authority—
So has Audit Scotland got it wrong? This report was published in November. Have we been given misleading information in it?
It might not have been aware—
The report says that the review was not started.
It actually says: “The SPA and Police Scotland have no immediate plans to carry out a post-implementation review”.It does not mention the Scottish Government at all. As with other reform programmes, we have started an internal consideration of what we have learned from this reform and, long before this report came out, I gave an undertaking to the fire board that I would ask it to be part of the post-implementation review. I shall be doing the same with the police board. I mentioned that when I met the board in August and I am going back to see it again in the new year. There are several different parties involved in this.
Yes, but I do not think that it is fair for you to pass the buck to the SPA and Police Scotland. The recommendation in the report is that“The results of the review should be reported to the Scottish Government to support wider learning and sharing of lessons.”That suggests that you are part of that review.
Absolutely.
It is not entirely outwith your responsibility.
No, and that is why we have started it.
You have started it.
Yes.
But not before the report was written.
I suspect that we started it before the report was written, but I can confirm that for you if you would like.
Obviously then there has been a lack of communication between you and Audit Scotland—
There may be some confusion.
—because it is under the clear understanding that the review had not even been started.
As I have said, the comment in the report is that the Police Authority and Police Scotland “have no immediate plans” in this respect. I actually think that that is understandable, because they have quite rightly and understandably been focusing on the transition process and trying to get the service under way. To give them credit, they need some information and operational experience before they can begin to reflect on the reform.However, we have started that work. Given that we started the reform before the SPA and Police Scotland were engaged in it, it is only right and proper that we start to share some of our learning not only with other reform teams in the Scottish Government but among ourselves. There is much more to be done on this issue.
There is considerably much more to be done. As Mr Doris and other members have pointed out, we have taken evidence from Mr House and Mr Emery, but there are a considerable number of responsibilities that the Scottish Government has—if you like—failed on. For example, paragraph 45 on page 17 mentions“different interpretations of the Act”and“the Scottish Government’s intention behind the Act”.Could you not have done more to assist the chief constable and the SPA in making this merger more successful than it has been?That paragraph also refers to “the lack of good baseline information”.Because we do not have that information, we do not know what the merger has cost or what savings are being made. I would have thought that the Government and the director general of learning and justice would have been responsible for that.Thirdly, the paragraph talks about“a lack of shared understanding and expectations”,and I would have thought that you would have been key to ensuring that this process was smooth. Finally, the reference in paragraph 45 to“the Scottish Government’s changing position over the way the SPA should operate”is quite a damning criticism with regard to a merger that we across the Parliament want to see working.
Absolutely.
So do you take responsibility for failing to ensure that the process could have been much smoother and relationships much better?11:15
I would be naive if I did not say that some things could go better in any reform process, particularly when it is the size of this one. That brings us back to the point about us learning lessons, which is one reason why I wanted to instigate the process quite quickly.As far as the interpretation of the act is concerned, we were in discussion and dialogue on that with the two key players, but particularly with Vic Emery from the earliest point of his appointment. Way back in September and October 2012, we were in regular dialogue as he rightly began to think about how he would want to work with the chief constable whom he subsequently appointed.There was a great deal of dialogue. We had meetings and exchanges of letters. I had meetings with both the key players. We were aware, as it emerged, that Vic Emery would like to adopt a business partnering approach, which I think he mentioned when he appeared before the committee on 20 November. I think that he has admitted that that is a very ambitious approach to the relationship and to the interpretation of the act.The act is permissive and flexible and business partnering would undoubtedly have been one approach to enacting it in a flexible and permissive way. However, as time went on, we became concerned, which is one of the reasons why we intervened at key times. As the Scottish Police Authority and Police Scotland began to get to grips with their roles, we began to have concerns that the approach might end up not being very proportionate and might act as a distraction when everybody wanted to ensure that the transition on 1 April went ahead as smoothly and successfully as possible and that the public would not notice any difference to the service, which in fact is what happened.We worked closely with them over a period of time. We had conversations, we wrote to them and we helped to clarify what we felt was a more helpful interpretation of the act. That is now in place and has been agreed by the board.
All that we have is the Audit Scotland report. That is what the committee is tasked to look at. Has Audit Scotland got it wrong again on paragraph 2 of page 8, where it says:“Planning the move to a single police service was hampered by poor baseline information, a lack of clarity in roles and responsibilities, and difficult relationships between the Scottish Government, the SPA and Police Scotland.”Audit Scotland did not write that three years, two years or one year ago; it did so in November. Has Audit Scotland got it wrong again?
It was written earlier than November actually—I am not splitting hairs.
Audit Scotland refers to “difficult relationships”. We expect more from professional people.
Things have changed since the report was written—I think that Audit Scotland would recognise that. It is not surprising, given the dynamic nature of reform and the fact that it is the first year of the operation of the new authority and the Police Service. There was certainly a responsibility on all parties to try to ensure that the relationships were as productive and effective as possible.Both Vic Emery and Steve House said at the committee’s evidence session on 20 November that relationships are working well, and they are working well. Such issues are inevitable when you have a completely new set of responsibilities. Let us not forget that the act was also giving a new responsibility to the Scottish Police Authority to hold the chief constable to account and, equally, giving a new power to the chief constable to administer the SPA. It would therefore have been odd if some dialogue had not been required to ask, “How is this going to work?” We helped to support that process. It is absolutely right to say that we intervened on occasion. We wrote to them and had conversations with them. Indeed, the cabinet secretary met the board in 2013 to ensure that there was absolute clarity, which there now is.
But we see in the Audit Scotland report that“the move to a single police service was hampered by ... the difficult relationships”.Things may have improved between October and November but, from an audit point of view—which is our perspective—it is disappointing that the move was hampered by something that could have been solved.
I think that it depends what success is measured by.I understand what Audit Scotland has said. I do not agree that the move was hampered. The sign of success for the new single Police Authority—and the fire authority—is that on 1 April 2013 the new authority and the new service were in operation. It has worked incredibly well. The savings are on target to be achieved—I think that we are less than £3 million adrift from the target that has been set for this year. We have new services operating extremely effectively and a new 101 line. Between them—with support from HMIC—the police and the board have achieved a range of changes to operational and strategic approaches. To me, it does not feel as if success has been hampered, but I recognise that discussions took place—quite rightly—about the interpretation of the act in the early days.
I can only go on the information that is in front of me.How can you talk about savings and costs et cetera, given“the lack of good baseline information on non-operational police activity; in particular, the lack of comprehensive financial information to identify how savings outlined in the OBC would be achieved”?The information is just not there. If there is no clear baseline data, how can you reel off costs and savings? Did Audit Scotland get that wrong as well?
The fact that we had eight different forces and 10 different policing organisations operating in Scotland undoubtedly meant that the creation of a baseline was pretty challenging. One of the areas in which we have invested in reform is in the creation of a single finance ledger and the harmonisation of payroll and HR information, which will assist with the benchmarking and baselining of information. I will pass over to Hilary Pearce, because she might want to give a little more detail on how that difficulty with baseline information was overcome.
Yes—thank you.The costs and the financial analysis that were provided in the outline business case were based on the work of the sustainable policing project, which, as Leslie Evans mentioned, was provided by the directors of finance of the previous eight forces. That was subject to external benchmarking and scrutiny at the time. Further work was done on that to produce the financial memorandum to the Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Bill. Further data on baseline costs was produced in September 2012 through the work of Kevin Smith, which helped with the development of the savings plan for the current year. As Mr Doris mentioned, that is achieving £60.9 million-worth of savings in the current year and is informing the savings plan for the next year.
Before I bring in James Dornan, there is something that I want to clarify with Leslie Evans or Hilary Pearce. I think that Leslie Evans said that the £1.1 billion of savings would be achieved. Do you know how those savings will be achieved?
The £1.1 billion is the figure up to 2026. We have the savings plan that identifies the sources of the savings for the current year, which come from three main groupings—people, procurement and property. Those three areas will be the sources of the savings in future years as well, although the proportions of those savings are likely to change as time goes on. We do not have the detail up to 2026.
So how do you know that the savings will be achieved?
Because the majority—in fact, all—of the savings in the current year will be recurrent. It is the expectation—the police are committed to this—that they will be in future years, too.
So the police are committed to making the savings and you think that they might make them. You said that they will make the savings, but the SPA and Police Scotland have not finalised their strategy to show how they will be achieved. Therefore, the correct answer is that we do not know whether the savings will be achieved.
They are completing their financial strategy for the coming years—it is at an advanced stage at the moment, and it will be published in the spring. However, they cannot do a savings plan up to 2026, because that will depend partly on what the Scottish Government’s draft budget will be and on funding allocations.
I think that that is a reasonable answer, so how can you tell me that the savings will be achieved?
Because, based on the savings plan for the current year and the plan for the next two years, which the police are working on at the moment, the areas from which savings are being generated will continue to generate savings into the foreseeable future.
So the savings that are being made this year and next year will be recurrent.
Absolutely.
That is what will deliver. If that is the case—
There will have to be additional savings in future years as well, but the recurrent savings—
That will be only a proportion of the savings.
It will be the majority proportion of the savings—
Okay. Will you provide a detailed breakdown of how the savings up until 2026 will be achieved?
As Hilary Pearce said, we cannot give you a business plan or rather—
No, no, I am not asking for a business plan.
We cannot give you a financial plan up to 2026. However, what we can give you—it will be present shortly based on the information that we are getting from the police—is the proof of the savings that have been achieved this year and the proof that they are recurrent, so that is a chunk of the savings already. The plan for the subsequent two financial years will also have savings of which a very large proportion if not all will be recurrent. I think that Vic Emery made the point to the committee at its 20 November session that the gap between the recurrent savings—the tough savings that are being driven out by the structure and changes to conditions, estates and decisions about procurement, as Hilary Pearce said, of which the vast majority will be recurrent—will be small, but we would still be expecting the police to reassure us on that.
Leaving aside that small gap for the moment, you can provide me with details about the contribution that the savings for this year and for the next two years, which you confidently say will be recurrent, will make to the £1.1 billion. You know that already, so you can provide us with that information.
That is the information that the police is compiling for us. I do not know the date when that will be published. Hilary Pearce might know.
Never mind about when anything will be published. That information is the working basis for what you have just said about the savings. You have that information, so I would appreciate it if you could provide the committee with information on how much of the savings that have been made this year or will be made over the next two years will recur and how much of that will contribute to the £1.1 billion. You can then tell me how much of a gap that leaves and give me an indication, given that you are confident that the savings will be achieved, of how you think the gap will be met.
Yes. We can do that.
I am sorry to do this, but I want to return to the outline business case very briefly, so that a matter can be clarified. The outline business case was part of the financial memorandum that went to the Parliament. We all, as MSPs, voted that through—Interruption. Yes, we did as a Parliament. Some of us now seem to think that the issue has just come out of nowhere and are shocked and cannot believe that there was not a full business case. That should not be the case, because the outline business case was part of the reason why the Parliament passed the legislation in the first place. Am I correct?
That is correct. Indeed, the police, civil servants and the Cabinet Secretary for Justice said that the full business case was the responsibility of the incoming leadership of the new organisation.
Thank you. Will you comment on how you see the Government reforms being met now and in the immediate future?
Sorry, did you say how the savings will be met?
No. I asked how the reforms are being met now and how they will move forward in the immediate future.
The reform has three strategic aims, as you will probably recall, having seen those go through in the act. The first aim is to protect and improve local services. Within that, savings are on track, as we have just discussed, and they have come from the bringing together of the 10 organisations that previously administered the police in Scotland. I think that the whole range of processes, including delayering, as you might call it, voluntary and early retirements, and having a property asset plan, are well on track to fulfilling that strategic aim of reform.The second aim is to create equal access to specialist support. I have mentioned the new 101 number. I believe that, in December, it received its millionth call. The specific new structures that have been set up, such as the national rape task force, emergency event and resilience planning, and an operational support division, means that we get ease of access to specialist reports from commanders across Scotland. Equal access to specialist support is another key plank of the three reform terms from the act. We think that that is well on its way, too. I have been at meetings recently—I mentioned some of the policy areas in my opening statement—that have benefited from having one single police perspective and a strategic input that is well informed, cohesive and consistent. I mentioned legal highs. Another area is early years: I have seen the police making a real difference to the early years collaborative and the way in which we are addressing those issues through partnership working at a local and national level. There have been a lot of unseen and undiscussed benefits from taking a new strategic approach with one single police force.11:30
The third strategic aim of reform, as outlined in the 2012 act, was to strengthen the connection between the police services and local communities. As the committee is probably aware, the police annual plan has informed local police plans. We have 14 divisional commanders, and we have more local authority elected members than ever before involved in scrutinising those 32 police plans and the 353 ward plans: there has been a 150 per cent increase in the number of elected members who are engaged in scrutinising the police at a local level.The work is not finished but, given that we have been operating in that way for nine months, it is testimony to the work of the chief constable and the chair of the SPA—and of HMICS and some of the civil servants who are here today—that we have done as much as we have. There is much more to do, and we still have to learn from reform, but we have had a good start. That is certainly what we are hearing from other parties south of the border, in addition to the international plaudits that have been received.
Have you had any feedback on the new relationship between the single police force and the community?
Interestingly enough, there are two ways in which we might get such feedback. One way is through the local community planning partnerships, which are getting to grips with the way in which policing is working in different ways in their areas. Some of them have adopted a scrutiny role through a full-council approach, and some have taken a community safety perspective. We have had full engagement with, and interest from, community planning partnerships—and other partners, too, particularly in the health sector.The other way—which I discussed with the chief constable yesterday—is through the survey that the police are undertaking with real people, who are the most important element in terms of using services. Previously, the police surveyed 9,000 people, but this year they are surveying 30,000, so we will get a very rich seam of data from real people—as I will call them—about the quality and accessibility of the services that they are experiencing post reform.
Do you know when that report is due?
I do not, but I can find out for you.
That would be helpful. I move on to savings. You say that you have already made savings of £60.9 million this year; I believe that the target is another £3 million.
To fill the gap by the end of this year, savings of £2.985 million, which are still to be identified, are required.
I will just call that £3 million.
Okay.
Are you confident that you are on target to achieve that? What role does the Scottish Government have in ensuring that those targets are met?
I will ask Hilary Pearce to say a bit more about the role that she is playing, but we are confident. There was a meeting this week at which we were keen to ask the police about what the savings plan for the rest of the financial year is looking like, not least because of recent tragic events involving the police that have required a good deal of additional overtime and investment. We had a very confident response from them that they will meet the target, and they gave the same response to the Cabinet Secretary for Justice in November.Hilary Pearce can tell you about the meetings that she attends.
I have regular meetings: Stephen Woodhouse and I meet the directors of finance for the SPA and the Police Service to go through the savings activities. We look at the areas from which the savings are coming and how the process of identifying and generating savings and recording and tracking them is going for the current year. The police said at the meeting on Monday that although they have still to identify just under £3 million of savings, they are fully confident that they will do so.
Does the Government have a role? For example, if the committee heard that there were savings not of just under £3 million but of £13 million to be made, at what point would the Government step in to try to get the police to achieve those savings?
We have a key role in ensuring that the savings are on track. I would be disappointed if we were to discover a gap of that size at this point in the financial year, which is why we have such regular contact and dialogue to exchange information between Government officials and the SPA and Police Scotland.
So it is an on-going process?
Very much so.
Thank you.
I must apologise to Mr Dornan—I did not mean to interrupt his question. Did the Government initially plan to complete a full business case prior to 1 April 2013?
I was not there at that point, but my understanding is that the intention was always to have an outline business case, because that was what was required to compare and contrast the three different routes of reform that were being discussed as part of the decision that led to—
That is not what I asked. I asked whether the Government planned to have a full business case prior to 1 April 2013. I know that you were not there, director general, but do you know whether the Government planned to have one?
The intention was always that the new leadership would take forward the full business plan, but those people were only in place from October 2012—in fact, the new leadership team was not completely in place at that point—so it was always going to be after that point that there would be the opportunity to develop a full business plan, and that is what is being worked on now.
Given the Audit Scotland recommendations on how to conduct public sector mergers, did the Government plan, in the initial stages, to have a full business case prior to 1 April 2013—yes or no?
I do not think that I can answer that question on a yes-or-no basis. The intention was always to have an outline business case and to have a full business case, and it was always going to be a requirement that the full business case would need to be fulfilled by the leadership of the organisation, for reasons that we have discussed. Those people came in, as it happened, towards the end of 2012. It was unlikely that the leadership could have taken decisions on operational and strategic matters before people had a chance to discuss what those might look like. We would never have said, “It has to be done by this date,” because that would have pre-empted decisions that are the responsibility of the board, informed by the chief constable.
I do not understand that. In evidence to this committee on 20 November, the Auditor General said that the full business case“was the subject of a fair amount of discussion with the Finance Committee when that committee was scrutinising the financial memorandum.At that point, the Government gave a commitment that a full business case or financial strategy would be developed by the service.”—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 20 November 2013; c 1760.
That is correct. It would be developed by the service, and that—
At some point in the future, not—
Well, at a time when the service was in a position to do it, with encouragement, support and investment from the Scottish Government, and that is what is happening.
Now?
It is happening now, and it will be delivered, as Audit Scotland has recommended, before the end of 2013-14.
Are you familiar with paragraph 80 of the Audit Scotland report? It states:“It is therefore not clear which costs are a direct consequence of introducing a single service and what savings could have been achieved by delivering services differently.”Do you agree with that Audit Scotland finding?
That could mean one of two things. I am not absolutely sure, but I will give you my interpretation of both. When we took forward the 2012 act and its financial memorandum, we were looking at three different models of reform, as you know. I am not sure whether the intention of that paragraph is that we should be checking and reverting back to the alternative models—for example, the model with eight forces or a version with three structures. I think that the paragraph is probably referring to the fact that, in the financial memorandum, there was a recognition that there could be costs arising for other parts of or partners in the criminal justice structure, such as councils or other organisations that work in the criminal justice journey. In considering that, we would want to ensure that we were clear about what those costs might be. We would do that by reflecting on it at the end of the first year of operation; it would be difficult to do that without due information at the moment. We would also want to talk to those parties, as we do regularly through the justice boards, where we get the leadership of all the—
I am completely lost by that, because that paragraph is actually about Parliament being clear about the choice that it was asked to make in reflecting on the single service or different options. What that paragraph states to me very clearly is that the costs of the different options were not clear. That is what that paragraph says. Do you agree?
No, I do not agree. I think that—
You cannot not agree. With the greatest respect, director general, the Audit Scotland report is cleared by the Government. As with all Audit Scotland reports, you have an opportunity to say, in private to Audit Scotland, that you do not agree with it, so how can you not agree with it now?
We give feedback to Audit Scotland. The outline business case and the financial memorandum examined and scrutinised three different models for reform and costed them carefully, based on the information that Hilary Pearce referred to earlier.
So you disagree with the paragraph?
If it is saying that we should be looking back to the other models that were considered for reform, that would be possible to do, but I am not sure how productive it would be. Certainly, however, the outline business case and the financial memorandum—which Parliament scrutinised carefully—considered the three different reform models that were up for discussion at the time, and the one that was agreed on, on the basis of costings and savings and on a strategic basis, was the single police service model.
The Audit Scotland report—
Just before you move on, I should say that we can get clarification from Audit Scotland: we can find out from the Scottish Government and Audit Scotland whether the Scottish Government made any comments on that issue.
Thank you, convener.Director general, I am sure that you are familiar with the finding in paragraph 79 of the Audit Scotland report, which states:“the Scottish Government does not distinguish between the costs specifically associated with restructuring and those arising from wider police reforms as identified in the Financial Memorandum.”Why is that the case?
I think that I mentioned earlier that we were aware that the changes in the way in which the police operate as a result of reform might have wider implications for other justice organisations. The financial memorandum says that the costs of those implications are unknown and too complex to estimate accurately. Assuming that we are able to calculate those costs, it is rather too soon to do it at the moment, as there is insufficient reliable data for us to use. That would be something—
How, then, can Parliament have any confidence in the savings figure? You have said that the costs are complex and potentially impossible to discover.
Those are costs for parties outwith and beyond the police. They are part of the criminal justice—
What proportion of the savings would that cover?
I do not have a figure for you, but I am sure that we could find out. The problem at the moment is that reform is in its first year of operation and the implications for other parts of the justice system are unknown. There might not be any implications and, if there are, many of them are likely to be beneficial. However, if there are costs associated with those, we would want to capture them. The financial memorandum says that the costs of those implications are unknown and are too complex to estimate. I would expect that we would need a year of operation before we could make any calculations.
That is a fair answer—but how fair it is depends on the size of the savings, which we will presumably find out in due course.
Hilary Pearce could perhaps add some detail.
We are tracking the accurate costs of police reform in the current year. We have the costs for the previous two years, which Audit Scotland published. After the end of the current year, we will be able to do a comparison. That will not be possible until April.
Quite. Is that the main and sole reason why the Government chose not to distinguish between the costs of restructuring and the costs of wider police reforms?
My understanding is that the costs that I described earlier are the ones that we want to examine most closely after the first year.
So that is the main reason for that decision. Thank you.My next question is based on the evidence that was given to us on 20 November and relates to paragraph 72, which says:“The police-led reform team did not agree to provide financial information to the Government before the chief constable was appointed.”I appreciate that you might not have been around at that time, Ms Evans. However, do you recognise that sentence and do you have any reflections on it?
As I mentioned earlier, a fair amount of work was undertaken by all the police as part of the contribution to the outline business case. In particular, work was done by Kevin Smith. We commissioned him to do some further work on behalf of ACPOS on the explicit and implicit costs in the model that had been agreed. He asked other members of the police to contribute to the evaluation of those costings, in order to put a bit of flesh on the bones before the new Police Authority took that responsibility forward.There was some reluctance on the part of the police. I think that some of them felt that they did not want to be seen to be prejudging the role of the Police Authority and the chief constable in describing the full financial strategy, which we spoke about earlier.
What happened when they were reluctant?
We asked Kevin Smith to return to the issue and to encourage them to support him in that piece of work. He did that and we got the reassurance that we needed at the time that the savings were credible and realistic.11:45
Okay. Thank you for that. I have another couple of brief questions on the evidence that the chief constable gave at the committee meeting on 20 November. He was asked:“Is it you, the SPA or the Government that decides what a visible police presence is?”The chief constable replied:“All three have a part in that.”—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 20 November; c 1777.I am sure that you have had a chance to review that evidence. I presume that you agree with the chief constable’s observation. In fact, the chief constable gave not so much an observation but a policy position in response to that question.
I think that that is accurate, in that we are all responsible for the success of police reform in Scotland.
That is not what he said. He was specifically asked who decides what a visible police presence is, and he said that it is all of you.
We all play a role in it. Clearly, his is the operational role, which is absolutely crucial. However, as the Scottish Government, we provide the funding and strategic framework and objectives that inform the Police Authority and the way in which the chief constable administers the police.
That is fine. Thank you for that.You helpfully mentioned in your opening remarks that it is the Government’s responsibility to conduct a performance appraisal of Mr Emery. You will be familiar with the Audit Scotland observations and findings in relation to paragraph 52, which illustrate that under Mr Emery’s control there was board micromanagement of the organisation, and with Audit Scotland’s evidence to the committee that he has had two interim chief executives and three finance directors since 1 April 2013. Given all that, do you have any reflections on his management of the organisation?
I think that there was a discussion about interim chief executives on 20 November. The first chief executive of the SPA was quite clear in the early stages that it was going to be an interim post. My understanding is that applications for the full-time, permanent chief executive post for the SPA closed earlier this week, on Monday. We will therefore have a permanent chief executive very soon.
That is all good, but it is not what I asked about. I asked whether you have any reflections on the fact that there have been three finance directors and two interim chief executives, and on the board micromanaging, all of which happened under Mr Emery’s responsibilities as chairman.
You asked me to comment on my appraisal with Mr Emery. Clearly, I cannot comment on the detail of that, but he and I have been in regular contact. We have quarterly meetings, and Paul Johnston has monthly meetings. We are very aware of the way in which Mr Emery is operating and leading the board, and it has been very successful in terms of the transition to 1 April 2013.
So it is not a concern that there have been two interim chief executives and three finance directors, and that the board was micromanaging.
I do not think that anybody would think that the interim nature of senior management was ideal, but there was a set of circumstances that was very difficult to pre-empt. I do not believe that any of the interim chief executive changes had anything to do with Mr Emery’s style, if that is what is being implied.
Okay. Thank you. I was not implying anything at all; I was just asking you.
link
I refer to the statement that heads paragraphs 74 to 77 in the report, which says:“Limited financial capacity and capability within the police has contributed to the lack of a financial strategy”.Are you satisfied that that capability now exists? If so, has the Scottish Government provided any resources? Where have the police got the resources from that will enable them to produce the business plan and financial strategy?
I mentioned the recruitment exercise that is under way for the chief executive of the SPA. The recruitment of permanent directors of finance for both Police Scotland and the SPA is also under way. Over and above that, we have provided support in a number of ways. Paul Johnston might want to discuss the issue in more detail, but, for example, we have three people on secondment to the SPA, and the Scottish Government’s finance section has given advice about operating in a new financial circumstance. We have also provided cash, if you like—we have supported reform by providing some private sector advice and expertise on financial matters for the SPA.Therefore, as well as the civil servant contact that we have, which Hilary Pearce discussed, we have our own people on secondment with the SPA; we have provided advice from our own finance experts in the Scottish Government; and we have supported the provision of private financial expertise to support the SPA in developing and executing its financial strategy this year. I do not know whether Paul Johnston wants to say anything else on that.
As Leslie Evans has made clear, it is a matter of close engagement at various levels to ensure that the capacity of the new organisations is built up. An entire team in the Scottish Government is in regular contact with both the SPA and Police Scotland to provide them with on-going support on the development of the financial strategy and the corporate strategy. In addition, we have provided support through the provision of staff for short periods of time when that has been necessary, such as through short periods of secondment. Some of those staff are currently with Police Scotland and the SPA. We have also worked with Police Scotland and the SPA as they have looked to recruit permanent members of staff. We are currently involved in that process.
In this meeting
Everything on 18 Dec 2013 →- 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 145
- 09:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 352
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.