Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Management of patients on NHS waiting lists: Audit update”

Wednesday 18 December 2013 Public Audit Committee About 09:30 Committee business 145 contributions · 13 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

145 contributions
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Members have copies of the report. The Auditor General for Scotland is here, accompanied by a number of members of her team: Angela Canning, Tricia Meldrum and Jillian Matthew. I invite the Auditor General to brief the committee.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Thank you, convener, and good morning. I previously reported on the management of waiting lists in February this year, and the Public Audit Committee subsequently produced its own report in May. The committee asked me to provide an update by the end of 2013, and the report that we are discussing today comments on progress by the national health service and the Scottish Government on implementing the recommendations in those reports.In February, I concluded that the Scottish Government and NHS boards needed to improve their management and scrutiny of hospital waiting lists to assure patients that they are being treated fairly. Key aspects of the systems were inadequate at that time. My update report focuses on progress with improving audit trails and monitoring how waiting lists are being managed, and it comments on trends in NHS boards’ use of waiting list codes and waiting times performance during 2013.Overall, we found that the Scottish Government and the NHS have been working together to implement the recommendations in the audit reports, and there are clear signs of improvement. The NHS boards have better controls and audit trails in place and they are now monitoring and reporting on a wider range of information about their waiting lists.The NHS boards’ use of patient unavailability codes has fallen further, which continues a trend that I reported in February. Between September 2011 and September 2013, the percentage of in-patients who were coded as unavailable reduced by half, from around 36 per cent to 18 per cent. For out-patients, the percentage reduced from around 11 per cent to 5 per cent. Those reductions are shown in exhibit 3 on page 14 of the report.Since October 2012, NHS boards have been using new patient-advised unavailability codes. They include new codes for patients who are recorded as unavailable because they choose to see a specific consultant or because they want to be treated only within their own health board area. We previously recommended that the NHS should introduce those codes so that boards could better identify pressures in the system around their ability to treat patients locally and to meet waiting times targets.In September 2013, 41 per cent of patients with patient-advised unavailability were waiting to be seen in a particular location or by a particular consultant. That suggests that there are pressures on capacity in some NHS boards, and we think that they need to use that information as part of their overall capacity planning.The 12-week treatment time guarantee and the new patient-advised unavailability codes were introduced in October 2012. However, it has taken time for the NHS to update its electronic systems in line with those changes and to accommodate the recommendations in the various audit reports. Those updates will improve NHS systems, but in the interim NHS boards are not able to provide the same level of detailed in-patient data to ISD Scotland as they could before. ISD Scotland is therefore currently unable to carry out the same level of analysis as it did previously, and nationally published information on in-patients is less comprehensive. The NHS is working to resolve that and the Scottish Government expects to have full public reporting in place again early in 2014.Most NHS boards are meeting the national target to treat patients within 18 weeks of referral to hospital, including any required out-patient appointments and diagnostic tests, but there are signs of pressure in boards. The percentage of people waiting more than 12 weeks for an out-patient appointment has increased and, as I previously reported to the committee, boards are finding the new treatment time guarantee challenging.The report makes a number of recommendations to further improve scrutiny of the way in which NHS boards manage their waiting lists. In particular, boards need to implement the necessary changes to their electronic systems as quickly as possible and work with ISD Scotland to provide it with detailed in-patient waiting times data. That will allow better monitoring at a national level and more comprehensive public reporting in this important area of public interest.As always, convener, my colleagues and I are happy to answer questions from the committee.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Thank you. I have a few questions. On page 5 of the report, you note by way of background:“The percentage of people waiting for inpatient treatment who were given a social unavailability code rose considerably between 2008 and 2011.”Why did that happen?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

What we have done on page 5 is to recap the findings from our previous report, which was published in February. There were a range of reasons for the increase, and I ask Jillian Matthew to talk you through them.

Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland
link

As Caroline Gardner said, we discussed the matter last time and raised it as an issue in our report. We found that boards were using the unavailability codes and that the numbers were quite high in certain boards, and we highlighted that.Looking at the records from our previous fieldwork, I note that we did some quite detailed work on the transactions that were carried out in all the systems. In six boards, we made detailed investigations and looked closely at patient records, and we looked for reasons why unavailability codes were being applied. Often, however, there was no evidence there to show why they had been applied. There was a recommendation on that, and we are now seeing that there is a specific code for patient choice reasons where there was previously a gap. Last time round, we were not really able to get into that level of detail, but boards now have that code to show the different reasons why they are applying unavailability codes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

So the figures for unavailability codes started to reduce, but that correlated directly with the rise in the number of patients who were waiting longer than 12 weeks. Because patients are now being recorded as waiting for 12 weeks or longer, that information is now in the public domain as opposed to being hidden, as it was in the past. One figure has gone down while the other has gone up. Is that right?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Exhibit 3 on page 14 shows the trends in waiting times and unavailability for both out-patients and in-patients. You are right to suggest that, as the proportion of patients who are coded as being unavailable has fallen, particularly in the case of out-patients, the number of patients who are waiting for more than 12 weeks—which is the target time—has increased.As Jillian Matthew said, when we did the work for the report that we published in February 2013, it was not possible for us to identify the reasons for the increase and then the fall in the use of unavailability codes, because of shortcomings in the systems that NHS boards had in place. That is why we have made recommendations on the need for better recording and monitoring of those reasons, which we are now seeing.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Okay. On page 9, you note that“the Patient Rights (Scotland) Act 2011 brought in the Treatment Time Guarantee”,and you state that,“Under this, eligible inpatients and day case patients have a legal right to receive treatment within 12 weeks of their treatment being agreed.”What are the implications if that legal right is not met?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Perhaps Jillian Matthew can talk you through that.

Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland
link

Although there is a legal right for patients under the 2011 act, there is no legal recourse for patients under the act if they are not treated within 12 weeks. However, the Scottish Government can decide to step in and take action if it feels that that is required.Boards are also required to advise patients that they have not been treated within 12 weeks as required under the 2011 act. They have to explain why, apologise to the patient and explain what is going to happen for that requirement to be met. They also have to explain to patients how they can complain if they wish to do so.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

It is a bit of a farce, that. People have a legal right, but if it is not met, they do not have the power to do anything about it. They cannot go to court to enforce it and they do not get any financial recompense or an appointment immediately because the 12-week target has not been met. Nothing happens to those who fail to meet that legal right. At some uncertain point in the future, the Scottish Government might step in. It just makes me wonder what the point is of having a legal right when nothing can be done to enforce it. I accept that that is not a matter for Audit Scotland, but it seems rather bizarre that people have been given that right yet nothing can or will be done if the right is not mentioned.You referred to exhibit 3 on page 14 and said that there have been signs of progress and some improvements, yet we see consistently throughout 2013 a rise in the number of out-patients who did not receive treatment within the guaranteed 12 weeks. That is a significant concern. Has there been any indication from the Scottish Government of what it has done to reverse that rise or any indication of when that figure will start to come down as the 12-week guarantee is met?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have reported clear progress on the management of waiting lists, with better recording of the reasons why patients are unavailable and better monitoring of that by boards. At the same time, as you say, we are seeing signs of increased pressure in relation to meeting the waiting time targets, particularly the target that out-patients should be seen within 12 weeks.There is a difference in performance across Scotland, as you can see from exhibit 2 on page 11, which shows which boards are having particular problems and which are performing relatively well. I ask Jillian Matthew to talk about the boards where the Government or the boards themselves are taking action because of the pressures.

Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland
link

In our discussions with the Scottish Government, it has been very aware of the trend and it is working closely with boards where it is aware that there are capacity issues. In the report, we specifically highlight NHS Forth Valley, where 20 per cent of patients are waiting longer than 12 weeks. The health board has recognised that locally and is taking additional measures and allocating additional staff to put on additional appointments.Nationally, the Government is working with boards and is accommodating additional appointments at the Golden Jubilee hospital and the treatment centre at Stracathro hospital. There are capacity issues and high demand in certain specialties such as ophthalmology and orthopaedics, so those are being targeted specifically. Some modelling work is also being done on how demand might increase in the future. The Government is keeping a close eye on the situation.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Exhibit 2 shows that not a single NHS board met the 12-week guarantee, so it is just as well that there is no legal implication from that legal right that patients have. Every board right across Scotland would be in trouble if any action followed from that legal right. NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde is not far away from meeting the guarantee, as is the Golden Jubilee hospital. However, notwithstanding what you have said, in addition to the NHS Forth Valley figure, which stands out, the figures for a number of other health boards show that they are around 5 per cent short of meeting the guarantee, and the figure for NHS Western Isles shows that it is even further away from meeting it. Have those other health boards given any indication of when they will meet the target?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

As Jillian Matthew said, the Scottish Government is monitoring with each health board what its performance looks like and where there are particular challenges that it needs to meet. The treatment time guarantee is slightly different from the 12-week out-patients target, which you can see in the third column in exhibit 2. Six boards were meeting the guarantee at the end of September 2013, but the others were not.Our concern is that the pressure on out-patient services is likely to translate Into pressure on both in-patient waiting times and the overall treatment time guarantee. Therefore, our focus is on ensuring that boards understand that and manage it and that the Scottish Government takes action nationally. We found evidence that they are improving the situation but, as we have said, there are signs of pressure in the system. That is a particularly important point as we head into the winter period.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

I understand what you are saying. It is the guarantee that is the issue. In that case, only the NHS boards in Greater Glasgow and Clyde, Lanarkshire, Orkney, Shetland and the Western Isles and the Golden Jubilee hospital met the standard—all the others failed on that point. None of the boards is meeting the out-patient targets, and most of them are failing to meet the in-patient guarantee.09:45

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am slightly out of touch with health—I have not been on the Health and Sport Committee for quite a long time—and I want to be clear about this. On page 9 of the report, paragraph 9 says that“no patient should have to wait more than 12 weeks for their first outpatient appointment.”Let us say, then, that it takes 12 weeks to see a consultant at an acute hospital. The next bullet point says that“eligible inpatients and day case patients have a legal right to receive treatment within 12 weeks of their treatment being agreed.”So, it takes 12 weeks for a patient to meet the consultant and the patient has to wait a further 12 weeks once the treatment has been agreed—is that correct?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

All three of the bullet points in paragraph 9 apply at the same time to eligible patients. I ask Jillian Matthew to talk you through how they interact. You are right to say that it is complex.

Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland
link

There are two separate periods of 12 weeks. It is 12 weeks to the first appointment at hospital, and at the first out-patient appointment or at a subsequent appointment it is agreed what the patient’s treatment will be. That has to happen within 12 weeks under the treatment time guarantee. However, the 18-week referral-to-treatment standard lies over those two periods. If someone goes on to get in-patient treatment, the period is not 24 weeks—it still has to be within 18 weeks overall.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So, someone could wait 12 weeks to see a consultant. Let us suppose that, after they see that consultant, they require surgery. That surgery would be guaranteed within six weeks because of the 18-week—

Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland
link

Yes, but that is not a guarantee, it is a standard.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

The patient has a legal right, though.

Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland
link

The legal right is for 12 weeks.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Is that to wait 12 weeks to be an in-patient? Is the target 18 weeks from referral by the general practitioner to treatment?

Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland
link

Yes. That is not a legal standard, though. That is the overall—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

In that case, someone could wait 12 weeks to be seen as an out-patient. By simple arithmetic, if 18 weeks is the overarching period for referral from GP to surgery, surgery will take place six weeks after the patient has seen the consultant.

Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland
link

Yes—if it takes 12 weeks for them to see the consultant, but the patient might be seen in a shorter time. A lot of people are seen in less than 12 weeks.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I appreciate that. I needed that clarity.On page 13 of the report, paragraph 17 says that“the size of the waiting list for outpatients at a census on the last day of September increased by 20 per cent”.That is a huge increase, from 208,000 to 250,000. The out-patient waiting list has increased by 20 per cent. Is that more and more people, as the convener has said, and is that why the treatment time guarantee for out-patients is not being met? That is where the bulge is. It is not the case that more patients are being treated, but that is the figure. I think that the pressure to meet the treatment time guarantee has increased in that there has been about 8 per cent more activity—is that right?—given the bulge in the figure. If there is a treatment time guarantee of 12 weeks, we assume that more people will be being treated within 12 weeks, but we have a 20 per cent increase in the out-patient waiting list.I am trying to reconcile the figures. It can take 12 weeks for a patient to see a consultant. We are told that, once the patient has seen the consultant, they have a legal right to treatment within six weeks because of the overarching 18-week treatment time guarantee. Why, then, do we have a 20 per cent increase in out-patients?

Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland
link

That is something that we have tried to highlight. Such an increase in out-patient demand places a big pressure on the boards. It is not entirely clear why there has been such an increase, but there are a lot of possible reasons, including the ageing population and the fact that more people are getting ophthalmology treatments in hospital. You can see that the out-patient standard is not being met by boards because of the increasing demand. Not every out-patient will go on to get in-patient treatment. The number of in-patients has stayed fairly steady, whereas hospitals are having to manage increasing out-patient demand.The two bullet points on page 13 that you highlight say that the waiting list has increased by 20 per cent, but the number of patients who are being seen has increased by only 8 per cent, so there is obviously a struggle to meet the demand at the moment. We spoke earlier about the things that the Scottish Government is doing with boards to address that.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Can you tell me the timescale to which that increase of 20 per cent applies? Did that increase occur between September 2010 and September 2013? Was it an increase of 20 per cent over those three years?

Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland
link

It occurred over that time, yes.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

That is a significant change. Did that coincide with the introduction of the new treatment time guarantee?

Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland
link

The treatment time guarantee was introduced in October 2012, but the increase started to happen before that.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Would it be more relevant to consider how many patients are being treated within a certain time than to ask about the increasing bulge in the number of out-patients? We want to know that more patients are being treated—there is more demand—and that they are being treated within the treatment time guarantee. I am not sure that the section 23 report tells us that, but we are seeing a huge bulge—a 20 per cent increase—in the number of out-patients.

Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland
link

We did not investigate the reasons behind that in detail. The focus was more on the progress that was being made among boards and how they are managing their waiting lists. We do not know how many of the out-patients went on to get in-patient treatment.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Are you saying that there is a lack of capacity? Are more resources required in order to meet the treatment time guarantees that are outlined on page 9?

Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland
link

There are certainly issues around capacity for out-patients and for in-patient treatment.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Overall, the report is encouraging in relation to the direction of travel in data collection and so forth, which was the key issue that we were concerned about.Paragraph 52 refers to “gaps in inpatient information”, and there are clearly issues with data collection. To what extent would those gaps in information impact on the figures? To what extent do they impact on the figures that go up to the Scottish Government? I am trying to get a grip on how serious that is, for want of a better way of putting it.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

As far as we can tell, they do not affect at all the figures in our report, which we highlighted in our introduction. The figures are collected by health boards and we have reported that the way in which health boards monitor them to identify and tackle problems has improved since our report in February. However, boards are not reporting that on to ISD, because the information systems have not all undergone the necessary changes to allow that to happen. The national reporting, which is being done by ISD, is now less comprehensive than it used to be.We think that the most significant gap in the list on page 29 is a comparison of the actual time waited against the reported time waited, taking account of periods of social unavailability. To be clear, we are not suggesting that those issues are not being monitored by health boards—they are, and we think that there has been progress—but they are not currently being reported to ISD.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I want to make sure that I have understood what you have said. Are we saying that the information is being collected but that some of it, at least, is not going up to Government?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is right. Because of the time that it is taking to amend the information systems that are being used by boards, the information that is being automatically transferred to ISD is less comprehensive each time. As a result, the national reporting is less comprehensive. The Government expects to have that issue resolved by early next year and to be able to fill in the backlog. At the moment, however, that is not happening.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

It seems rather an important point that, if the Government is not getting accurate figures, it is very difficult for it to plan and to monitor what is happening.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We agree. That is why we have recommended that that gap be closed as soon as possible. As we say in our report, there is some manual data collection and reporting going on to compensate. However, the information that is available at patient level is less detailed than it has been in the past and than the Government wants it to be again in the future.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

One of the issues that came up after the problem with NHS Lothian, in particular, was that of staff training and the familiarity of staff with systems and with the whole process. Has that situation improved significantly?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have seen some real evidence of progress. On pages 22 and 23, you will see some of our findings. In particular, NHS Forth Valley and NHS Tayside are monitoring trends in the way in which individual staff members use waiting time codes. There has been progress in training staff in the requirements and the way in which the systems work, and some boards are making real progress in identifying staff who seem to have particular training needs and in targeting training at them.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

One of the important things about staff training and awareness is that it is not just a one-off as a result of what happened, but an on-going process. Are you satisfied that it is?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Tricia Meldrum can explain what we know about continuing training and awareness.

Tricia Meldrum Audit Scotland
link

A new controls matrix has come in just recently, which has been developed by the Government, the boards and internal auditors working together. It is quite complex and looks at various issues that boards should be monitoring both in relation to how they manage their waiting lists, use their codes, send out letters and communicate with patients and in relation to who has access to patient information and systems. Information about how boards are complying with the controls matrix should be reported internally on a regular basis, and boards and non-executive directors should continue to scrutinise that and make improvements where they are required. There is now a more robust framework in place that addresses those important issues.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Are you satisfied that that matrix is now embedded across all the NHS regions?

Tricia Meldrum Audit Scotland
link

It has only just come in.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is still quite new. We think that the introduction of the matrix is progress. However, as you have said, continued attention is needed to ensure that it stays up there on boards’ agenda and that staff training is kept up to date as the framework requires.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Are there figures that show the waiting times for each individual hospital, or are such figures collected only on a health board basis?

Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland
link

That information is not available for individual hospitals at the moment. Boards will probably have that information locally but it is not reported to ISD. That is one of the more detailed kinds of information that are missing at the moment but that will be in place again next year.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

It strikes me that, if there are boards with particular problems, some of those problems could be caused by one or two institutions within those board areas, which would be a real cause for concern. I note what you have said—that the boards should have that information but that it is not routinely reported to the Scottish Government.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

You have highlighted the fact that the use of unavailability codes has considerably reduced, which is to be welcomed, but the fall-off has been dramatic, from 36 per cent of patients to 18 per cent. What could explain that?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

When we reported on that in February 2013, it was one of the areas that we looked at closely to try to explain it. Our conclusion was that, at that stage, it was not possible for us or anybody else to explain it, because the systems and records for individual patients did not contain the information that was needed. At the time, our recommendation, which was supported by the committee, was that all health boards should start to use their information systems to record the reasons why a period of unavailability had been applied, and the Government’s guidance, which was coming into effect at that point, introduced new safeguards. Those included the need for health boards to write to individual patients when a period of unavailability was applied, explaining that it had happened and what was meant by the date by which they should be seen or treated, and to make sure that there was that additional check on the process. All of that means that we can now be more confident than we could be in the past that the figures are accurate, but that historical lack of information about why the level was previously so high and why it started to fall simply cannot be reconstructed, because it was never captured in the first place.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

You highlight the fact that it began to fall at the same time as you identified NHS Lothian as abusing the system.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

There is definitely a correlation. It is worth being clear about the fact that we did not identify that in Lothian; it was identified, as the committee highlighted at the time, as a result of whistleblowing within Lothian. The same trend was apparent in the use of unavailability codes across other health boards, but despite extensive audit work on our part the audit trail simply was not strong enough to explain why that happened elsewhere. 10:00

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

So you could not discover that through audit. Since the NHS Lothian scandal was revealed, the figures have fallen from 36 per cent to 18 per cent.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is right.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

On availability codes, the convener said that no one has the right to enforce the supposed legal obligation to meet the targets. You also suggested that the boards are not particularly good at explaining any rights.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I think that we found in the report that boards have made progress in doing that and that the letters that they are now required to send out to patients are a big step forward from the relative lack of information for patients that existed previously. We highlighted that some boards are doing very well. We have a couple of case studies in the report, which I ask Jillian Matthew to talk us through, to explain the progress that we have seen.

Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland
link

Since the treatment time guarantee came in in October last year, boards have had to write to patients to set out the fact that they are entitled to the treatment time guarantee and to pass on information about when they should be treated, and to tell them that they are listed as unavailable or if other changes are made to their status on the waiting list. Boards are doing that.We reviewed examples of the letters that different boards send out. There is no standard template, so the letters vary quite a bit in their level of detail and how clear they are. The case study on page 20 shows where things are being done well and highlights good practice that other boards could take on. NHS Dumfries and Galloway in particular wrote very clear letters and explained the situation to patients very well. In other boards, we saw that the situation was not explained very well; they mentioned the treatment time guarantee but did not really explain to patients what it meant to them or why they had to be treated within a certain time. We think that those letters could be a lot clearer. The Scottish Government has picked up on that and has said that it will be a priority for 2014 to work with boards to make sure that they all send out clear letters to patients.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

How did you find that out? Did you ask patients whether they understood the letters?

Jillian Matthew Audit Scotland
link

We did not do that. It was quite a high-level piece of work. Some boards have said that they are working with patient groups and have received feedback from patients about the letters.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

One of the most worrying comments that you make—it is on page 12—is about the pressure on boards’ capacity to cope. You suggest that some boards refer patients to national services in order to cope with pressure on demand. Is there an overreliance on those national services in some cases, which indicates a lack of capacity building and a lack of focus on providing services that patients need at their local hospital?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I do not think that that is a conclusion that we can draw from this piece of work. We say in the report that the increase in the number of patients not being seen within the standard times, or within the treatment time guarantee where it applies, is an indication of pressures in the system, which are greater for some boards than for others.Referral to the national centres at the Golden Jubilee national hospital and Stracathro is an effective way of meeting patient demand for some specialist procedures. I know from family experience that the Golden Jubilee national hospital is extremely good at planned joint replacements, because it does a very high level of such operations. In many ways, it can offer patients higher quality because of the expertise that it has built up.In this report—and in the report that was published a bit earlier in the autumn on NHS finances—we have said that those signs of pressure are definitely there and that individual health boards need to look at a range of data to identify where their pressure points are and what action they need to take to address them. The Scottish Government needs to be doing that at a national level.Jillian Matthew talked you through some of the examples. In NHS Grampian and NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde we saw exactly that. The Government is putting additional resources into the two national centres, but the signs of pressure are there and will need continued attention to make sure that the treatment targets can be met. Alongside those, the financial targets, the patient quality framework and the other things that health boards are required to get right to deliver the best possible patient care within the money that is available to them also need to be addressed.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Just to explore that for a second, what do you mean when you talk about a lack of capacity? Do you mean a lack of doctors, consultants or nurses?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That can mean different things in different places. Jillian Matthew will keep me right about this but, for example, NHS Grampian is currently investing in additional theatre space and time and additional doctors and consultants to carry out procedures. The problems might well be different in different health boards.We know that orthopaedics and ophthalmology tend to be high-pressure specialties across Scotland. Circumstances are different in different places, and that is why we recommend that individual health boards use the range of data so that they can identify where the pressure points are and what is needed to release them. We also recommend that the Government should stand back and do that across Scotland.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I mentioned that because, in paragraph 15 on page 12, you talk about“increasing vacancy rates for consultant and nursing staff”.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We reported that in our report on NHS finances, in which we talked about the level of vacancies for doctors and nurses. There are pressures, some of which come from things with which we are familiar, such as the changes to doctors’ training arrangements and the working time directive and its impact on the hours that medical staff can work. There is a range of pressures, which is why boards’ ability to understand the demands on their services and to plan for the necessary capacity to provide those services is so important. That information is the starting point, but it is only the starting point.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

We would all agree that we want the health service to be able to cope locally with patient demand, but when it does not, it has to take emergency measures. Your report says that NHS boards sometimes rely on national services, and you have also identified the fact that they buy in private sector healthcare. Do you know how much is spent on that?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We reported that in our report on NHS finances, which we published earlier this year. Angela Canning is trying to check on that for you—if we can, we will come back to that in a few moments.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

The report mentions that NHS Lothian—just one health board—is spending £27 million on a range of measures, including private sector healthcare. Does that worry you?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

NHS Lothian faces particular challenges because of the problems that were uncovered when its manipulation of waiting times was exposed back in 2011. At that point, it had a much bigger backlog of patients who were waiting to be treated than it knew about or had planned for. Catching up with that backlog at the same time as dealing with the referral of new patients is clearly a challenge for NHS Lothian and the specific circumstances there.More generally, across the health service, as we say in our report, we are seeing signs of pressure in the number of patients on waiting lists and the number who are not being seen within the target times. That is the reason for our recommendation that health boards should look at the range of information, identify where their capacity challenges are and work with the Government to meet them.

Angela Canning Audit Scotland
link

Yes. You might remember that the Auditor General brought a report on financial performance in the NHS to the committee back in November. It showed that spending on private healthcare increased by around £15 million in 2012-13 to just over £80 million, which was a rise of 23 per cent over those two years. At that time, we highlighted to the committee that that was a reversal in the trend, in that we have seen an increase in spending on private healthcare. However, we also noted that the increase is quite a small proportion of total NHS spending.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

We are seeing more vacancies for nurses and doctors, we are spending more money on private healthcare and we are not meeting demand locally. Those are my three observations.

Angela Canning Audit Scotland
link

That is right.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Could you clarify which two years you mentioned?

Angela Canning Audit Scotland
link

I am sorry—I was trying to read without my glasses on.Spending on private healthcare was £80.3 million in 2012-13, which was an increase of £14.8 million from 2011-12. There was a rise of 23 per cent between those two years.

Angela Canning Audit Scotland
link

Yes, it was £80.3 million in 2012-13.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

And it went up from £50 million?

Angela Canning Audit Scotland
link

Yes, it was around £50 million.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

What was the figure of 14 that you mentioned?

Angela Canning Audit Scotland
link

The figure of 14.8 is the difference between the two years—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

But how does that translate into a rise of 23 per cent?

Angela Canning Audit Scotland
link

Sorry. What we do not have in the report is the baseline figure for 2011-12.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

If there is an increase of 23 per cent, that is fair enough, but what I do not understand is that you are also saying that there was an increase of 14 per cent. I am not quite sure—

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We will clarify the figures for you. They come from our report “NHS financial performance 2012/13”, on which we briefed you at a previous meeting. We will pick up the point separately, to ensure that we do not mislead you.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

Mr Keir and I never get a pass on health matters—we were at the Health and Sport Committee meeting yesterday.Mr Macintosh asked interesting questions and mentioned the increase in vacancies for nurses and consultants. I understand that there are more vacancies because more posts have been advertised and not because existing posts are unfilled. Can Audit Scotland confirm that the cause is an expansion in nurse and consultant numbers, rather than a failure to fill core posts?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The figures come from the financial performance report that I mentioned. I do not think that we were able to break down the vacancies into those that relate to new posts and those that relate to long-standing posts. It is certainly true that there has been an increase in the number of consultant posts, as we said in the report.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

I think that the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing has been able to confirm that, but I wanted to put that on the record.Depending on how we interpret it, the table on page 11 either makes for pretty uncomfortable reading or shows work in progress. I am looking at the column for the target “All eligible inpatients guaranteed to be seen within 12 weeks”. Nine boards either met the target or were within 1 per cent of it, and only one board was outwith 5 per cent. There is still an unmet target, but I contend that the table shows fairly robust performance. In contrast, the data on the target “No outpatient will wait more than 12 weeks for their first appointment” show a significant challenge.When the committee considered the issue recently, Robert Calderwood from NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, which covers my area, said that he used unmet waiting time targets to inform him of where the pressures are in the health board area and then allocated existing resources to the pressure points. The table on page 11 shows that NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde met two out of the three targets in the table, and that it met the third target in 99.9 per cent of cases—so it was 0.1 per cent outside the target. It is important to put that on the record, because it is an example of a health board allocating existing resources effectively to meet the obligations that the Scottish Government places on it. Your report is excellent, because it draws that out quite nicely.What evidence do you have or would you seek in future to show that health boards are using the audit trail to better inform resource allocation? When you come back in six months’ time or a year’s time, such evidence would enable you to say of health boards such as mine, “They have dramatically improved the situation, because they have used the audit process to identify shortcomings. They have allocated existing resources and transformed the situation.”

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

There was a lot in your question. I will try to pick up on the range of points that you made. First, you are right that exhibit 2 contains a lot of information about what is happening and shows a mixed picture. On the treatment time guarantee—the column on the right of the table—six boards are meeting the target fully, some are within 1 per cent of meeting it and a handful are not meeting it.On the following page, we noted that only three boards have met the treatment time guarantee every month since it was introduced in October 2012. There is a challenge for most boards in that regard—the exceptions are NHS Orkney, NHS Western Isles and the Golden Jubilee national hospital.We also said in the report that the out-patient target is significant, because many of the people who are waiting for out-patient appointments will in due course transfer to in-patient waiting lists and therefore to the treatment time guarantee. That suggests to us that pressure is building up in the system.10:15

You are absolutely right: we say in the report that health boards should be using the wide range of information to understand for themselves where the pressures are, what the bottlenecks are and what they can best do to relieve those pressures. We set out in exhibit 6, on page 25, the range of information that we think health boards themselves should be monitoring to ensure that they can do that. That is quite detailed information, and it breaks down at specialty and hospital level to make it possible for boards to understand in detail what action needs to be taken to meet existing pressures.We have not yet made decisions about when we will follow up this piece of work, but we are interested in the question of capacity planning and how, both at a local level and nationally, the NHS can ensure that it meets the sometimes conflicting demands around targets for scheduled and unscheduled care, the financial targets and the patient quality framework requirements and the various staffing requirements. That is a complicated mix to manage, and we would like to understand better how health boards are doing that.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

That is helpful. As for the role that the committee can play, members might look at individual tables, exhibits and paragraphs in your report and can pick out things that are of particular interest to them, but I am delighted that you will have a hands-on role in working with health boards to ensure that they better set out how they use the audit information to plan better. What is the committee’s role in following through on some of those things? There is no turf war here with the Health and Sport Committee, which will no doubt investigate winter resilience in due course, I imagine, but is there a useful role for the Public Audit Committee in following through on some of the audit information and in examining where subsequent investment goes? Do you think that that would be a useful exercise? I know that it is for us to decide how to proceed, but I am interested to hear your views on how we use the numbers to better inform ourselves about health board actions.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Clearly, that is a decision for the committee to take. It is always helpful to us when the committee endorses our recommendations, as that ensures that they are taken seriously by people in public services. There is also value in the committee taking evidence both from health boards that are doing well—NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde has been discussed in relation to the targets—and from health boards that are facing more significant challenges, so that you understand how they are doing and build up an understanding of what the problems are and what the responses available to health boards might be.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

Much was made by the Scottish Government—I am certainly supportive of this—of the new patient advice line, which is for any patient in the country who is unsure where they are in the waiting time system, what their rights and entitlements are and how the process works. I am interested to know your thoughts on how that is working in its very early stages. In the NHS, you are damned if you and damned if you don’t: if people use the line, that means that there are bad things happening; if people do not use the line, it is not being promoted enough. Sometimes you cannot win in that sort of situation. How do you feel that that is going?The national confidential alert line has also been set up for the NHS: if any NHS staff member feels that inappropriate actions are being taken, whether in relation to waiting times or other areas, they can pick up the phone and report them confidentially.How confident are you that both the advice line and the alert line are helping to achieve robustness in the system and are better informing patients?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The honest answer is that it is early doors for both lines. We refer to the waiting times information line and website in paragraph 28 of our report. It was introduced only in October 2013, and it is designed to give people general information about, for example, what the treatment time guarantee means, how it relates to the other targets, and other complex things of that sort. It is not a substitute for detailed information from each board about an individual patient’s circumstances, and we would like to see more about how those two sources of information interact to give patients better information.We also refer in the report to the confidential helpline, which was introduced a wee bit earlier. The key thing is that, so far, the level of calls has been relatively small. There is no way of knowing whether that is a good thing or a bad thing. When we reported, there had been about 74 calls to the line. It is not possible to be sure how many of those related to waiting times issues, as opposed to wider concerns about healthcare. We are therefore not in a position to discuss the effectiveness of the lines, other than to say that both are clearly good things to have in place as part of a culture of openness about what patients can expect, and they reflect the willingness—indeed, the desire—of the NHS to hear about concerns that people might have about healthcare.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow
link

I will sneak in a final question. You piqued my interest when you referred to the new patient advice line giving general information and how that would marry with the detailed information that each health board would have. Do you envisage that, in future, if the patient had their Commission for Healthcare Audit and Inspection number or a reference number, the computer system and the patient advice line would link directly to the patient’s own care circumstances, so that they could get immediate information about where they were in the system, rather than just general information about their rights?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is a question for Government but, obviously, technology is making it increasingly possible to provide such tailored, personalised information, based on good computerisation. I suspect that that would not only provide more transparency about waiting lists in general but be welcomed by patients.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

On page 21, you state:“The Scottish Government asked all NHS boards to provide it with written assurance that they are addressing”the recommendation on identifying patients with additional support needs. The responses proved to be a mixed bag.This is perhaps not for you to say, but would you be looking for the health boards, first, to improve, and, secondly, to reach the standard of NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde and the six other boards that do what it does; or do you think that an acceptable standard would be to adhere to the more comprehensive action plan that NHS Lothian has put in place? What did you think was appropriate, and what would the Scottish Government have been looking for when it wrote to the boards?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is a really good question. Patients with additional support needs have been a focus of our concern in all the reports that we have done on waiting lists, particularly in the reports that we published in 2010. It seems that they are patients who need and deserve more support but who can be left behind when it comes to ensuring that they are treated properly and in line with the treatment time guarantee and the other standards.The things that we think are not happening consistently enough are highlighted in paragraph 30, which starts on page 21, and which you have highlighted. First, the system should prompt staff to check for special needs and to record them where appropriate. Secondly, there should be a specific field in the patient’s record, so that the information can be retrieved easily and used to monitor performance. That should be done consistently throughout Scotland, so that we are sure that patients are being picked up consistently.Most boards still rely on the GP or other referrer to identify those needs. Getting the systems right, in line with the indicators that we suggest later in the report, would help to ensure that the patients are getting the extra support that they need and that their rights under the waiting times framework are being upheld.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

Did the Scottish Government write to boards with an eye to getting that uniform system in place?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Yes. The Government was looking for assurance about the progress that boards had made. At that point, progress was mixed, as we say in the report, and we think that there is more that many boards could do. The approach that NHS Lothian plans to take is promising, and it looks as though it covers the right areas. There is probably scope for boards to learn from each other more in getting that aspect right.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

I have a further question connected to that. I noticed that exhibit 6 on page 25 shows that the“Number and percentage of people with additional support needs recorded”is not included in the ISD benchmarking tool. Is there any particular reason why something like that would not be included?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I am not sure, but Tricia Meldrum may be able to tell you more about that.

Tricia Meldrum Audit Scotland
link

The expectation is that that information would be held within the boards’ own systems, which the boards would monitor themselves. Because there is not a specific field for additional support needs in most boards’ systems at the moment, there is no means to translate that information directly to ISD.ISD has advised that it will continue to keep the benchmarking tool under review. It might add new indicators as required, and as new information becomes available. In future, boards might look to add that in, but there is no specific field at the moment, so ISD does not have any place to draw that information from as far as centralised data are concerned. You would expect boards to be monitoring that themselves.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

There is a recommendation that there be a specific field for that. If a specific field were put in place across all the boards, ISD would then be able to monitor the information and include it in its benchmarking tool.

Tricia Meldrum Audit Scotland
link

We recommended that boards improve how they manage and make information available to patients with additional support needs, and we think that a specific field would help to do that. That recommendation is not currently part of the national guidance, which is really about improving.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Auditor General, you made it clear in your opening remarks that there have been clear signs of improvement since your previous report, and you mentioned the improvement in audit trails, letters and communication with patients, for example. Where are the greatest opportunities in the recommendations on page 8 to take us towards the 100 per cent target that several members have mentioned?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

There are two different issues in your question. On improvements to the management of waiting lists, the most important thing is probably first to fill the gaps in the information that is reported through ISD nationally so that the comprehensive reporting, exploration and challenge can be done very clearly to identify where there are problems and what is needed to address them. That will require finalising the changes to the information systems, which is due to happen early next year.That will provide a baseline to deal with the second part of your question, which is really about tackling waiting times performance. It is clear that there are a number of pressures, which will vary in different places and which need to be looked at as a whole. Progress has been made on getting the information right first of all, and we have seen real progress to improve the way that the information has been used by boards. The challenge now is to ensure that it is used consistently as part of a wider understanding of demand and capacity to highlight exactly where the problems are in a particular board and to plan how best to fill those gaps to ensure that everybody meets the targets and standards that are in place.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Systems and processes get us to a certain point and give us the information that we need to effect such changes. When we initially look at the table on page 11, we think that the picture is not good, but there is a good story to tell if we look beneath that. A lot of hard work is going on.Do you have any information about when people who miss any of the targets are actually seen? Most of the targets might be missed by a day, or they might be missed by weeks or months, and you might be concerned about whatever the answer to that question might be. We are talking about people and their health needs. When are they seen if a target is missed? Is there any information about that?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We think that that is the most important gap in the information that health boards currently report to ISD. Members might remember that, in the report that we published in February, it was possible to compare the reported waiting times for patients with the actual times that they waited, taking into account unavailability codes. For most patients, the gap was not significant, although some patients waited longer for various reasons. However, having that information by health board and nationally is an important way for the health service to manage performance in this important area and for patients to have confidence that they and all of us are being treated fairly. The recommendation to close the gap in the information that is reported to ISD is important to us, as it will give a window on how long patients are waiting at the individual patient level rather than at the average level that is currently reported.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

So we will get that information at some future stage and be able to see when people have been seen, rather than just whether the winning posts have been missed, which is what we see with the targets and the columns in this table. We will see that pattern developing.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have had that information in the past. We reported it in our February report, and the Government expects it to be available early in 2014. We recommend that it is very important that that information is available again for exactly the reasons that you have highlighted.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Thank you for that. That is helpful.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I would like to go through the timeline that is illustrated in exhibit 7. The bill that introduced all the measures was passed by Parliament in March 2011, which means, by definition, that the consultation and the parliamentary proceedings, including its committee proceedings, would have started at least a year in advance of that. However, as you have just said to Mr Coffey, we do not expect to have all the data fully resolved until next year. Correct me if I am wrong, but the Government set out a policy intention to do something in 2010, yet it will take until 2014 to get the data together to allow us to know accurately what is happening.10:30

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

In broad terms, that is right. A number of things were happening that affected the availability of that information. First, the new guidance on the waiting times framework and the treatment time guarantee was introduced later than planned because of the problems that emerged at NHS Lothian and the need to make sure that the guidance responded to those problems.Secondly, the recommendations from the audit reports that we and the internal auditors of the health boards produced were taken into account in putting the guidance together. NHS boards have been implementing new electronic waiting list management systems and updating them. There has been a lot of movement from systems that were barely adequate to systems such as TrakCare, which are much better. All that has affected the timeline for getting the information in place. That is not an excuse, but it is a reason for the things that have been happening in the background.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I take that point, but exhibit 7 shows that, in May 2012,“ISD Scotland began planning for the funding and staffing for IT developments required to the national waiting time database.”Am I right in thinking that ministers had said what they wanted to do and had illustrated that two years in advance of ISD starting to do that work in May 2012? Am I missing something here? Why did ISD take so long to begin that work?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The timeline sets out accurately what happened. Questions about why particular pieces of work were started at particular times are for the Government and ISD. However, a lot was happening around waiting lists during that period, particularly in response to the problems that became clear at NHS Lothian.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I am not casting aspersions. I am simply puzzled because, if I was the Government, I would be keen to see the system up and running the minute my bill hit the statute book. Audit Scotland’s timeline illustrates that that did not happen and, although we know to some extent what is going on, we will not know completely what is going on until 2014, which is four years after the bill was an idea in a civil servant’s mind. It seems to be an awful long time to get the data sorted out.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is absolutely right in terms of the national level data, but we are confident that it is being managed better than it was at health board level. It is a game of two halves in that sense.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Is Audit Scotland minded to make recommendations to Governments that are conceiving of legislation that includes data requirements that they should think through the consequences for the management of the data?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have made such a recommendation in audit reports repeatedly over the life of the Parliament, but it is often seen as less important than getting the policy or service in place. It should be just as important.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I have a brief question. We keep talking about the treatment time guarantee, but there is no guarantee. Audit Scotland itself says that the treatment time guarantee for out-patients is “deteriorating”. We also talk about legal rights for patients. Am I right in saying that there are no legal rights? There is a treatment time guarantee that cannot be guaranteed, and the so-called legal rights for patients do not exist. Is it therefore right to keep talking about legal rights and treatment time guarantees?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is a complicated picture and the best that we can do is refer you back to page 9 of the report. The treatment time guarantee is a new right for patients that was introduced in October 2012 under new legislation, which gives eligible patients the right to be treated within 12 weeks of their treatment being agreed.The point of the earlier questioning is that that right is not legally enforceable by patients. It is enshrined in statute, but there is no legal recourse if it is not met, although the Government can intervene with health boards and take any action that they feel is needed. Alongside that 12 weeks from decision to treat to treatment, there are two waiting times targets, or standards: no patient waiting longer than 12 weeks for their first out-patient appointment; and 90 per cent of patients starting treatment within 18 weeks of referral. All those nest together in the way in which Jillian Matthew was explaining earlier. The treatment time guarantee is enshrined in legislation, but patients do not have recourse to law if their right is not met.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Yes, but a treatment time guarantee is not being guaranteed and there is no legal right for patients. Is that correct?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is not legally enforceable under the legislation.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

The legal right is not legally enforceable and the treatment time guarantee for out-patients as you state in this report is “deteriorating”, so it is not guaranteed.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The treatment time guarantee does not apply to out-patients. What applies to out-patients is the target that they should all be seen within 12 weeks of referral.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Well, you say in exhibit 1:“the treatment time guarantee is not being met, and performance against the standard that all outpatients should be seen within 12 weeks has been deteriorating.”

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Those are two different conclusions. First of all, the treatment time guarantee is not being met and—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

It is not a guarantee if it is not being met.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is not a legally enforceable right although it is enshrined in legislation.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Yes, but if I have a guarantee, I think that it is rock solid. If I have a guarantee that something will be done in 12 weeks, I assume that it will be done in 12 weeks. It is a bit of a misnomer to call it a guarantee and a legal right.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

To be fair, we can take that up with ministers rather than with the Auditor General.

Colin Keir SNP Edinburgh Western
link

Like some of my colleagues, I see some improvements in the report. I am happy with the likes of paragraph 34, on page 22, which says that better audit trails and better scrutiny have been identified.I will be a touch parochial, because my constituency lies within NHS Lothian’s territory. NHS Lothian was found out not so long back and is trying to get its act together right now, so I will ask about reporting mechanisms. NHS Lothian has been in a pretty bad place with what has happened over the past period. It has certain difficulties with buildings, for example. Edinburgh royal infirmary seems to have been built too small, with too few beds, and the board is having to go through a reorganisation of beds. It is also pulling in consultants to work in the high-turnover specialty that was mentioned earlier and is having difficulties with, I think, paediatric consultants. Because of the historical difficulties, I was not expecting a massive improvement. Are you examining NHS Lothian’s on-going performance reporting mechanism particularly closely? I do not expect vast improvements in a short period, but will you put in place a longer-term case management system to highlight in future reports how it is getting itself out of the mess that it is in?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

You are right that NHS Lothian has specific problems. It would be facing the same problems as any of the big health boards anyway due to rising demand against the financial pressures to which the NHS as a whole is having to respond. The big backlog that arose when the suppression of waiting list numbers was uncovered has made it more difficult to tackle the backlog and achieve the standards for new patients who are being referred. Obviously, that is still reflected in the performance figures for NHS Lothian, as you can see in exhibit 2.We found many examples of good practice in what NHS Lothian is currently monitoring and the approach that it is taking to identifying where problems are and investing in areas where there are specific challenges. It will take a while for all that to work its way through.Your question was about, I think, our audit risk assessment and monitoring. We do that for all 200 audited bodies for which Audit Scotland has responsibility for me and the Accounts Commission. NHS Lothian, for obvious reasons, is one of the bodies that we are keeping a close eye on at the moment. That tends to start at the level of governance and financial management through the annual audit and then play into the work that the performance audit teams do on specific areas to ensure that there is a good interflow of information.We are keeping a close eye on NHS Lothian and maintaining a good dialogue with the chief executive and the board about their priorities, the progress that they are making and the ways in which they are managing the risks that they see.

Colin Keir SNP Edinburgh Western
link

I was just asking about the continuing management. There has been a major problem, but there are many other problems, particularly centring on the royal infirmary and new assets that will have to be built at some point. However, I am comfortable as long as there is a mechanism for reporting back.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Auditor General, I am aware that you will provide some further information. I thank you and your staff for your contribution to the meeting.10:40 Meeting suspended.

10:44 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 145
  3. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 352

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.