PE1481, by Pat Rafferty, Harry Donaldson and Harry Frew, on behalf of Unite, GMB Scotland and the Union of Construction, Allied Trades and Technicians, is on putting an end to blacklisting in Scotland. Members have a note by the clerk, a SPICe briefing and the petition.I welcome our three witnesses, who are well-kent faces. Thank you very much for coming along today. I invite Pat Rafferty to make a short statement of around 5 minutes. After that, I will kick off with a couple of questions, and I am sure that my colleagues will have questions as well. Neil Findlay, who takes a great interest in the issue, is here and also wishes to contribute to the debate.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Blacklisting (PE1481)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Harry Donaldson GMB Scotland 13
- Chic Brodie SNP 12
- Pat Rafferty Unite 10
- David Stewart Lab 8
- Harry Frew Union of Construction, Allied Trades and Technicians 7
- Jim Eadie SNP 5
- John Wilson SNP 5
- Neil Findlay Lab 4
- Anne McTaggart Lab 1
The record
65 contributionsGood morning. We warmly welcome this opportunity to give evidence to the Public Petitions Committee. The motion on blacklisting that was debated in the Scottish Parliament on Thursday 2 May was entitled “Blacklisting, a Scottish and UK Human Rights Abuse”. In no way was the motion’s title overdramatic or exaggerated. This insidious discrimination in our employment system, particularly in the construction sector, is a scandal that has affected and continues to affect workers and their families throughout Scotland and the UK. It is a national disgrace that has ruined lives and indelibly stained our construction industry, its biggest employers and successive Governments.Most of you will be familiar with the published findings of the Westminster Scottish Affairs Committee—the SAC—and its interim report on blacklisting throughout the UK. You will also be familiar with the revelations of the investigation by the Information Commissioner’s Office—the ICO—into the Consulting Association—TCA.The work of the ICO and the SAC certainly laid bare the depths to which major construction companies sank in actively excluding and discriminating against workers predominantly for their trade union and political activities. We know for certain that TCA held on file details of 3,213 construction workers, many of them trade unionists, and traded them for profit and subversive purposes. We strongly suspect that we are only beginning to scratch the surface of the scandal.It is vital to make it clear to everyone in the room as we move ahead with the committee’s proceedings and the work of the ICO and the SAC that it is frequently cited that blacklisting is not only a problem of the past. Blacklisting did not disappear with the ICO investigation in 2009. Far from it. We are in no doubt that the practice continues on major infrastructure projects throughout the UK and that the influence of its known practitioners runs deep in the Scottish economy.Our evidence today will focus extensively on our strong view that blacklisting is taking place on major infrastructure developments such as the London crossrail project, which is the biggest construction project in Europe. The sacking of 28 workers on the crossrail project in September 2012 through the termination of contracts to Electrical Installation Services—EIS—by BAM Nuttall, Ferrovial Agroman and Kier Construction Ltd—the BFK consortium—for raising basic health and safety concerns relating to tunnelling work suggests to us that the blacklisting of trade unionists continues.However, blacklisting is not confined to the south-east and it is not incumbent solely on Westminster to tackle it, nor should we have to wait for Westminster to begin to resolve the problem. The insufficient legislative framework at a UK level and the evident lack of political appetite to recognise blacklisting as a contemporary issue and reform the law to combat the practice need to be bypassed by other levels of governance.In Scotland, we have the ways and means to start tackling blacklisting seriously and we need to do that. The companies that are involved in the BFK consortium and their subsidiary companies profit significantly from Scottish public procurement. They do so alongside many of their contemporaries that are also named in the ICO investigation and the SAC report. Those companies hold public contracts that are worth billions of pounds and they are responsible for the delivery of essential services in our public sector and local and national infrastructure development.We are firm in our view that a distinct Scottish political intervention is required, as the influence of the known blacklisting firms runs deep into the heart of the Scottish economy. No one can credibly argue that blacklisting has never taken place in Scotland or prove that it does not continue to this day.Over the past few months, a sustained programme of parliamentary activity has helped to raise the profile of the anti-blacklisting campaign, thanks in no small part to the hard work of MSPs such as Neil Findlay, who is present. This meeting provides us with another opportunity to reinforce our campaigning view of what the Scottish Parliament can do to tackle blacklisting. That involves introducing anti-blacklisting measures in the proposed procurement reform bill, including prohibiting known blacklisting companies from tendering for future public contracts, and launching an independent public inquiry convened by the Scottish Government into the extent of blacklisting in Scotland, the companies involved and the human damage done.Existing UK blacklisting laws are insufficient and cannot be relied upon to represent the interests of the workers, let alone deliver justice. The Scottish Parliament, with its current powers, can help to begin to close that gap in the justice system through procurement reform measures.The calls of the joint trade unions for a UK-wide Leveson-style inquiry into the blacklisting scandal have, so far, been resisted by the Westminster coalition Government. It is unacceptable that, to date, not one company named in the ICO investigation has apologised for its discriminatory action and not one worker has been compensated for being blacklisted.It cannot be business as usual for the blacklisting companies. We are looking for the Scottish political community to help us to achieve change and justice and to protect the next generation of workers in Scotland and beyond from the insidious practice of blacklisting. That extends to local authorities, which can play a proactive role in questioning the likes of the BFK consortium’s influence in their areas and supporting our wider campaign for justice and reform.We hope that the evidence that we present today will inform our representatives on the Public Petitions Committee and provoke them to grasp the historical and contemporary effect of blacklisting and put in place a renewed Scottish parliamentary impetus to demonstrate that Scotland can lead the way in the fight against blacklisting.12:00
Thanks very much for your statement. We should congratulate the trade union movement on the work that it has done on this high-profile issue. In your comments, there seemed to be a touch of going back to 1950s America and McCarthyism, because the practices that you describe are very much what happened in that era. Your suggestions on procurement and an inquiry are useful.Before I bring in Neil Findlay, I have a question on one point. The papers refer to the fact that at least one individual has been prosecuted for breaches of data protection legislation. As you know, we have a strong data protection regime in Scotland, but does it need to be strengthened? Are there still breaches of data protection that lead to blacklisting?
I believe that there are gaps in data protection. I do not know whether you had the chance to catch “Panorama” last night on BBC 1, which covered blacklisting in the UK. The ICO raised concerns about the lack of power and bite in attempts to address the issues. The regime should certainly be strengthened. As I said, that point even comes from the ICO.
I bring in Neil Findlay to make a brief comment.
Last night’s “Panorama” condensed the issue well into a short space of time—it was a half-hour programme. It raised the concern that, as Pat Rafferty said, blacklisting continues.We should commend the petitioners for lodging the petition. More importantly, we should commend the members of various trade unions who have suspected for decades that the practice has been going on. Many of them have suffered badly, with their families suffering as a result. We have to thank those people for their determination. I hope that they will see justice.The “Panorama” programme raised the issue in relation to the crossrail project and raised concerns that the practice continues. My fear is that it continues in Scotland, too. Only an inquiry would unearth that. We should consider some of the major contracts that are being let in Scotland at present. One of the contractors groups that are bidding for the Edinburgh sick kids hospital contract—we are down to the last three groups—is stuffed full of contractors who have been up to their necks in blacklisting, and the situation is similar for the Aberdeen bypass. The consortium that is involved in the construction of the new Forth bridge is full of companies that have been involved in blacklisting. The question is whether those companies have changed their practices. Let us hope that they have. However, until the companies admit what they did wrong, apologise to those whom they wronged, agree to pay compensation and agree to get their house in order, we cannot be confident that the practices are in the past.Pat Rafferty suggested that the current process is only scratching the surface of the issue. We can see that if we start to think about some of the other industries in which blacklisting is alleged to have been practised over the years, such as journalism, academia, the offshore industry, contract catering and others. I support the petitioners’ call for an inquiry. If Westminster is not going to do it, let the Scottish Parliament lead and let us do it.We also need major reform of the procurement process. I am not naive enough to think that the practice will be gone for ever—we cannot weed it out entirely—but we should put in place systems that get the message over to companies that look to benefit from major public sector contracts that, if they indulge in blacklisting, they will be dealt with properly.
Good afternoon, gentlemen. Good afternoon, Neil. I have some experience of dealing with trade unions, employee-participation companies and some companies in which management was perhaps a bit draconian and had to be changed. Let me start with the issue of those who were blacklisted. My experience of dealing with the Amalgamated Union of Engineering Workers—with Willie McKelvey, Ernie Ross and all those guys years ago in Dundee—is that there was openness and transparency. The managers whom I dealt with worked pretty hard at that. However, there were those within the trade union, although not many, whose activities were ultimately designed to hurt the 6,500 employees. Do you believe that all the people who have been blacklisted are bona fide, good employees, or do you believe that they just might have had a different agenda?
I believe that they are bona fide people who have been discriminated against because of the blacklisting process. I do not believe that they have been out there to purposefully undermine an employer in any way, shape or form. It is not in anybody’s interest to do that. It is certainly not in the interests of the trade unions or the people who work on contracts. We are interested in having good industrial relationships with employers, which helps to secure employment going forward. We have never had an agenda to try to undermine that in any way, so I do not accept that point.
Okay. Our briefing notes on the petition indicate what the trade unions have called for, which would have serious implications because the call is not only for full disclosure of the information obtained by the Consulting Association, but for an investigation into links between not just the employers but the police and the security services. Why do you have an issue with the police and the security services? What do you think they are doing in terms of corroborating the blacklisting?
There are questions that go beyond the Consulting Association to the police force itself. We can go back to issues around that with the miners, for example, during the miners’ dispute.
We are talking about now in Scotland.
In Scotland?
Yes.
What we want to try to find out from the police service is what information the police service or department holds about people being blacklisted, which is a contributory factor from the police service’s side.
But the trade unions refer to links between employers and the police and security services. You are not just asking for open information. Our information is that you are asking for an investigation into the links between construction employers and the police and the security services. Why are you asking for that?
It is a matter of trying to get the information from the police service to see whether there are established links between the employers and the police service.
I abhor blacklisting just as much as I abhor bad management, and there is a lot of that around. However, you are asking the Scottish Government to do something while the Scottish Affairs Committee is undertaking an inquiry into the matter. The minister set out the legislative framework and said that blacklisting was not illegal, although we can argue that maybe it should have been. However, the minister has said that we now have a better position in Scotland under the Public Contracts (Scotland) Regulations 2012. We will also have the procurement reform bill, and I am sure that we will all want to ensure that it secures openness and transparency in how contracts are disposed of and the conditions therein. What do you expect from a Scottish Government public inquiry that has not been done or covered and that will not be covered going forward?
Pat Rafferty alluded to the fact that 3,213 people were on the blacklist—that is what the Information Commissioner’s Office found. Only 10 per cent of those people know that they were blacklisted; the rest still do not know. In Scotland, 582 workers were blacklisted, so Scotland has been disproportionately affected compared with the rest of the UK. That is why we firmly believe that the Scottish Parliament should take a lead on the issue and there should be a public inquiry.I go back to what Neil Findlay said. Apologies should be made, because there is no indication that the employers in question have given any consideration to the hurt and the injury that they have caused to families and everyone else who is involved. We should bear it in mind that most of the people who were blacklisted were between the ages of 30 and 50. They have been out of the industry and unable to pursue gainful employment and provide for their families. That is significant. We firmly believe that there is scope for a public inquiry. The same companies are involved in public procurement and are looking for public contracts. Billions of pounds-worth of Scottish Water contracts are open to them.You asked whether some trade unionists might have had ulterior motives. I would flip that question and point out that 60 per cent of the human resources managers who were employed at the time are still employed in the same companies. I would flip the question and direct it towards the companies. It might be that that is why a public inquiry should take place.
I do not agree with blacklisting, and I accept that, in some cases, we have bad management, but in that spirit, you cannot tell me that all the people concerned are okay. The fact that you brought the police and the security services into the issue makes me wonder what else is going on, and that is why I asked the question, against the background of what I have said about bad management and blacklisting.
Interestingly, the issue to do with the police and the security services has come about because we understand between 200 and 300 female green activists are on the lists and have been targeted. Where would that type of information come from, given that it is certainly not the case that all those women work in the construction industry?
So you believe that it is unlikely that the people in question would engage in any action that would hurt or harm the vast majority of people with whom they might work.
That is the belief, but I must make the point that there is no proof, hence our request for a public inquiry.
Good afternoon, gentlemen. I would like to explore with you the second half of the petition, which is about investigating“how to introduce ethical procurement policies and how to ensure that companies who continue to practice blacklisting are banned from tendering for future public contracts.”That opens up the issue of how we ensure that we reform the procurement process. That could perhaps be done through the proposed procurement reform bill or through the consultation that I understand the Scottish Government is undertaking with the Scottish Trades Union Congress, Unite, Unison and the GMB to strengthen the guidance for public bodies.Will you give me a sense of what issues should be covered as part of the reform of the procurement process? What additional questions should we think of asking suppliers during the selection stage of a procurement exercise? How can we ensure that we have revised terms and conditions in contracts that allow us to address the issue? Might they include termination clauses for those companies that breach legislation or guidance?
The forthcoming procurement bill presents a good opportunity to make changes and to make things a bit stricter and tighter. It has been suggested that one of the questions could be, “Have you been prosecuted in the past for blacklisting?” However, I do not think that that would address the issue in any way, because no one has been prosecuted for anything that happened prior to 2009, not even the Consulting Association. Ian Kerr was prosecuted under the Data Protection Act 1998 and was fined by the courts, and the fine was paid by one of the contractors, not to Ian Kerr but to his wife and daughter. I do not know why, but that was the method of payment and how it came about.The questions about procurement must be tighter and stricter. We are dealing with a group of companies that have already been to court and been prosecuted under statutes relating to construction cartels and price rigging for contracts. Quite a number of the companies were involved in that. That is one issue that should be addressed through a tightening of procurement processes.12:15
Do you have suggestions about the questions that we should ask?
We met Paul McNulty and made it clear to him that the questions must be framed so as to make it difficult for companies that have used such practices in the past to continue using them. We as trade unions are meeting, and I have no doubt that we will go back to Paul McNulty with suggestions to make the rules tighter and more stringent. Careful consideration must be given to how the questions are framed.
Is there an opportunity to do something better?
There is an opportunity to address some of the issues, but whether companies continue their practices is another matter. Historically, there was the Economic League way back in the 1950s and 1960s, but people used to say, “That’s the Economic League finished. That doesn’t happen now.” However, the Consulting Association was set up and the practices continued. I have no doubt that Pat Rafferty is right to say that there are hints that blacklisting is still going on in projects such as crossrail.How do we address that in Scottish procurement, and how do we deal with contractors who have been involved in that? As a trade union, we in UCATT have been to the European courts to lodge a claim for one member on the basis of discrimination in employment. Maybe the type of question that should be asked is, “Have you ever discriminated against workers?” The answer would probably be, “No.” How is discrimination then proved? The Scottish Affairs Committee heard about comments that were on files about certain people, and it is a disgrace that people have been denied the right to work because of those comments. Right up until the Consulting Association was raided to access the files, the blacklist was still being used. If that raid had not taken place, the blacklist would still be getting used today and we would not know anything about it or be able to prove anything about it. We have now got the evidence, and some of the companies involved have admitted in front of the Scottish Affairs Committee that they used the blacklist. That admission of guilt gives us the opportunity to deal with some of the issues, and procurement might be an answer.
Do Mr Rafferty and Mr Donaldson have anything to add?
The tender documents could ask potential contractors, “Have you treated anyone less favourably because of their trade union activities or membership?” If any information that companies provided on such a tender document were proven elsewhere to be false, they could be excluded. There is proof, evidence and documentation, and the GMB was lodging 70 defamation cases in the High Court in London as of last week in pursuance of those matters.In answering a simple question like that, a company could—obviously—tell lies, but it would need to think seriously before it did, because if the evidence became available—
I think that we are getting somewhere.
The termination clause is important and it should be part and parcel of the issue. There is further evidence that we have not submitted, which I will submit now. We believe that one of our executive council members, a man called David Brockett, is getting blacklisted from the Southern general project with Mercury. We will pursue that and we will keep the committee informed. That is current—it is happening right now. The get-out clause—the termination clause—is a key point.
I put on record my membership of Unite the union and my participation in the chamber debate that Neil Findlay initiated on blacklisting.My historical trade union membership has brought me into contact with people who have alleged that they were blacklisted. I will throw this open to the panel: although we have heard a lot about employers, the allegation was made to me in the 1970s and the early 1980s that some trade unions were actively involved in blacklisting individuals whose activities—political or trade union activities—were seen to be detrimental to some of the leadership of the unions. The union that I am thinking of no longer exists, as it has been amalgamated many times and it is now in one of the larger unions.Will you comment on your trade union members’ activities in relation to blacklisting? If we are going to open up the issue, we need to be honest with ourselves and we need to be honest about the activities of some union activists or members in relation to blacklisting fellow workers.
As you rightly say, unions have merged over the years, and my union, Unite, is a combination of other sister trade unions that have become part of it over the years. Unite was created only in 2007—we are very young. However, we have investigated and will continue to investigate any involvement of trade union officials in blacklisting. If we find evidence of anything like that, we will deal with it appropriately, as the committee would expect. We do not believe in such a practice and we would not tolerate it—in any way, shape or form—taking place in Unite.
It is interesting that trade unions are willing to engage in the process—in a public inquiry or whatever else—and to take the appropriate steps should it be proven that there has been any such action by any trade union officials. That is the difference—there is a willingness and an openness to do that on our part, which we are not meeting from the opposite direction. Those are some of our difficulties.
That leads to my next question, which is about such things being proven in relation to not just trade unions but employers. Harry Frew mentioned the Economic League’s role. We know the Consulting Association’s role in relation to the information that the ICO was able to pull together. When Ian Davidson MP held a session at the Scottish Parliament with interested MSPs, he clearly highlighted that the ICO found only limited records. The 3,213 cases that we have in front of us are only the cases that we could get records of at the Consulting Association.It was alleged that a number of other areas where records could have been kept were not available or that records had disappeared in some way, almost Enron-like, so that information was no longer available. One of our difficulties is knowing whether we are talking about only 3,213 cases or about a much wider practice of blacklisting not just in the construction industry, but in other industries, such as engineering or HR. In the lead-up to the debate in the Parliament, one person intimated to me that they felt that they had been blacklisted, as they were advised not to apply for a job in personnel because they would not get one.
The reality is that we do not know. As you correctly stated, when the ICO raided the Consulting Association‘s offices, it took certain information, but far more was left behind. Had that additional information been procured, it might well have led to an expansion of where we are.Neil Findlay indicated that the problem could go beyond construction, but we do not know and we do not have the detail. We know that we have proof of the number of cases that John Wilson mentioned. Whether the problem extends further might well come out, and a reason to have a public inquiry would be to open up the discussion and engage and involve a wider group of people. Through that, we might find that, as Pat Rafferty said, there has been a wider abuse of human rights. I hope that that is not the case, but the reality is that we do not know. Are we scraping the tip of the iceberg? We do not know.
I understand that the four areas in relation to which people have experienced human rights abuses are political activities, trade union activities, health and safety issues and environmental activities. Do you agree that those are the four main areas that led to people being blacklisted by the Consulting Association or employers?
The “Panorama” programme last night made it clear that Ian Kerr spent most of his days going through left-wing magazines, reports in the press and various things to collate any small pieces of information that he could on individuals. That was then passed to employers.The fact is that health and safety representatives, who were carrying out their legal function of representing their members in the workplace in the construction industry, where deaths and fatalities have been terrible, were blacklisted for protecting their members and trying to get safe working conditions. That is completely unacceptable.
I understand that three lists—construction; oil, gas and petrochemical; and environmental—were available at the Consulting Association. The environmental list related to things such as the building of the M77—the names of people who climbed up trees were on that list. There were those three lists, but possibly other information was destroyed or taken away before we managed to get a hold of the construction files.The 3,000-odd people that we are talking about were in the construction files. Others would be in the other files that were there and others would have been in files that were hidden or destroyed.
I declare an interest in that I am a member of Unite the union and of Community and I spoke in the blacklisting debate. I hold particularly strong views on the fact that comrades have been disadvantaged throughout their careers as much as they have been.We spoke about the procurement bill and how we could affect that. However, I think—although I am not the one who would make such a decision—that the issue calls for a public inquiry, to ensure that all the questions that are being asked around the table are answered. That would enable us to move forward and influence the procurement bill positively, with clear evidence.
Certainly. One of the questions should be, “Are you prepared to work in partnership with the trade unions through your procurement?” That might address issues for the future. However, the lip service that goes along with that does not form a reality that actually happens.12:30
One of the interesting issues is that, if the employers—those 44 major construction companies—held their hands up, admitted wrongdoing, compensated the individuals and apologised to them, that would be a public statement that would go a long way towards addressing the problem and ensuring that there were no further occurrences of blacklisting in the economy ever again. That would be a step in the right direction.
I do not think that that will ever happen, no matter what we decide. As Harry Frew said, people would pay only lip service unless we legislated properly.Have you seen any of the 3,213 files?
No, we have not.
The GMB has had access to other files, as other unions probably have, but I have not seen them. When I listened to Dave Smith at our congress in Plymouth last week, it was clear that his file contained his national insurance number, his date of birth, photographs, details of his car, his safety credentials, information on his wife and his brother and details of when he complained about asbestos, toilets and so on. That was the sort of detail that it contained. We can tell you what employer put whose name on the list.
You have not seen the files.
They are there and they are available.
But you have not seen them.
I have not seen them.
We have not seen the files personally, but that is not to say that the unions have not seen them. I have not seen the files, but Unite has seen them.
I am asking because it is important to have—although I hate to use the phrase again—clinical evidence.
Seventy cases were lodged in the High Court last week. Clearly, the evidence will come out.
The information that is in the files is the type of information that the police, security services or private investigators use. I am not suggesting that those groups accumulated the information, which is extremely intrusive.I do not want to get you to develop your petition by taking it to another level, but you will know that there was a statement this week in the House of Commons about the allegation that information was passed between Government Communications Headquarters and the American security services. Is there any evidence that mobile phones have been monitored as part of blacklisting?
We do not know. I am certainly not linking our issue to the PRISM programme. The issue about links with security services involved environmental activists and particularly why all those women found that they were on a blacklist.There are concerns about whether there has been collusion with security services; many people think that there might well have been. However, until there is a public inquiry, we can only speculate, as we do not have access to the detail.
I have not seen the large file, but the Scottish Affairs Committee’s report contains extensive extracts from people’s files. The people are not named, but the extracts are a fascinating read. For example, one person’s file says something like, “He might not be a Communist, but his father was.” That is like saying, “He might not have robbed a house, but his dad did.” Another file says something like, “He is suspected of being the twin of someone else.” I never knew that being a twin was an offence. Another one says that someone is suspected of being a member of the Green Party. One even says that someone attended a meeting in Dundee Labour club. I appreciate that some people around this table might think that attending Dundee Labour club is a crime, but I do not.
It is a crime scene.
I think that we should move on.
Some of the extracts are bizarre, to say the least, and I encourage people to read them.The contract procurement issues are important, as Harry Frew said. If, for example, a line in the contract said, “Have you treated employees unfairly for X, Y or Z reason?” and the contractor said that it had not, but it was listed on the Consulting Association database, it would be lying and be in breach of contract. That would give it a motivation to say that it had treated employees unfairly and to apologise for that, pay compensation and get its house in order. Going down that route would capture quite a number of the major companies that are taking huge amounts of money from the system.
We have found the session interesting and informative, but I am conscious of the time. We must move on and decide what we will do with the petition.The petition is important, and I encourage members to agree that we write to ask the Scottish Government whether it supports the petition. The petition suggests a public inquiry. I think that it would be sensible to write to the Scottish Building Federation, too.
I have a number of suggestions. We should also write to the Confederation of British Industry Scotland, the Scottish Trades Union Congress, the ICO, the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities—because some local authorities have entered into joint contracts with some of the companies involved, including some that were named in the crossrail case—and Construction Scotland.
You suggested that you should get in touch with the Scottish Building Federation, convener. I think that you will find that most contractors are in the UK Contractors Group. That is the organisation that you need to contact.
Thank you.
The minister who replied in the members’ business debate and the Cabinet Secretary for Infrastructure, Investment and Cities have said that the Scottish Government wants to talk to interested members about the procurement process. A few weeks ago, I wrote to the Government about that, but I have not heard anything in response. When the committee writes to the Government, can we ask when that engagement will happen?
We will do that.As I said, the session has been excellent. The information that you have given us has been extremely useful. Obviously, the committee is enthusiastic to pursue your petition. We will keep you up to date with developments. I thank you once again for coming along to our meeting.12:37 Meeting continued in private until 12:52.
In this meeting
Everything on 11 Jun 2013 →- 09:45 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:45 Tackling Child Sexual Exploitation in Scotland Evidence session · 115
- 09:45 New Petitions Petitions · 31
- 09:45 New Petitions Petitions · 65
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.