Agenda item 3 is consideration of two new petitions and, as previously agreed, the committee has invited the petitioners to speak to their petitions. The first is PE1477 by Jamie Rae on behalf of the Throat Cancer Foundation on gender-neutral human papillomavirus vaccination. Members will have the clerk’s note, the Scottish Parliament information centre briefing and the petition itself.I welcome from the Throat Cancer Foundation Jamie Rae, chief executive, and Ewan Lumsden, information support manager. I invite Mr Rae to make a five-minute statement to set the context for the issues in the petition. After that, I will throw the discussion open to questions.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Gender-neutral Human Papillomavirus Vaccination (PE1477)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- David Stewart Lab 10
- Jamie Rae Throat Cancer Foundation 9
- Angus MacDonald SNP 5
- Jim Eadie SNP 3
- Ewan Lumsden Throat Cancer Foundation 2
- John Wilson SNP 1
- Anne McTaggart Lab 1
The record
31 contributionsGood morning, ladies and gentlemen, and thank you for the opportunity to come along and give evidence. I will begin by making it clear why I am so interested in this issue. In July 2010, I was diagnosed with oropharyngeal cancer caused by the human papillomavirus. Thankfully, I went on to make a good recovery, but my experience of the treatment regime and the virus’s effects was, to be honest, pretty awful. It also raised several quality-of-life issues for anyone suffering from human papillomavirus infection who goes on to contract cancer.As background, I point out that we are dealing with a global epidemic of HPV, which is responsible for 5 per cent of all cancers worldwide—and that figure is growing. You might be aware that according to the latest statistics one in two people—or half the people in the room—will be affected by cancer by 2020. As a result, we need to be very aware of that issue because of the burden not just on individuals but on society, the economy and everything else of having to pay for it.HPV is caused by skin contact. It never enters the bloodstream. It is very easy to catch; in fact, 80 per cent or more of the middle-aged population—in other words, most of the people in this room—will have been infected by it or exposed to it. I do not want to panic everyone; thankfully, most people will clear the virus. However, a growing number of people are not clearing it and they are at considerable risk from certain strains.Although there is no cure, there is a vaccine, which is why I am here. At the moment, the vaccine is given only to girls to protect against cervical cancer, which is one of the five strains of cancer caused by the virus. The other strains are anal cancer, penile cancer, vulval cancer and oropharyngeal cancer, all of which are very nasty. They are treatable, but the side effects of treatment and the on-going quality-of-life issues—if you survive—are awful.My question is: why are we protecting only a certain sector of society? The argument for the current policy is that if we vaccinate enough girls we will protect boys. That might have been almost acceptable in the 1950s, but we are in the 21st century and the population is now highly mobile. The UK has good vaccination rates but in general the rest of the world does not, and those who travel will be exposed if they have sexual contact with someone overseas. Indeed, they can be exposed to the virus here, if they have sexual contact with someone living in this country who has not been vaccinated. Moreover, certain sectors of society, such as men who have sex with men, have no protection at all.This is a very serious issue. For a start, it is an equality issue, not just for men who have sex with men but for all men, and my contention is that, as men are equal to women, there is no reason why they should not be protected.
Thank you very much. I note that in your petition you say:“The current Human Papillomavirus vaccination programme is discriminatory”and indeed you touched on that issue at the end of your presentation. Would you like to say a bit more about that?
I do not want to turn this into an issue about sexuality or men having sex with men, but that is probably the most obvious area that should be considered. So-called herd immunity, in which girls are vaccinated, will give some protection to men—not all, but some—but people from certain sectors of society such as men who have sex with men have no protection at all. That is discriminatory. Indeed, that was one of the key areas examined by the Australian Government, which introduced gender-neutral vaccination this year. The Australians, who are world leaders and pioneers in this issue, have made the right decision.Many of the decisions not to vaccinate everyone are based on cost. Although I can understand that laudable view, the fact is that the modelling on cost effectiveness is dated and does not, for example, include the latest types of cancers. That whole area needs to be addressed.An interesting aside is that the guy who discovered the vaccine is a Glaswegian, which means that it is another great first for Scotland. He might live in Australia, but he is very much Scottish. I think that Scotland has a fantastic reputation for innovation in science and we should be taking another lead by doing the right thing here.
Finally, I know that costs are quite difficult to ascertain because of commercial confidentiality. However, if I have picked up your petition right, the figure for Scotland might be around £1.2 million.
It is very difficult to ascertain costs. Figures from the Nordic countries have given us a baseline of €18 per vaccine dose. If Scotland were to decide unilaterally to implement this vaccination programme, which it can do, it would be in a very good position to negotiate a good deal with the pharmaceutical industry. After all, it is very much in the industry’s interests for countries to adopt gender-neutral vaccination.
Thank you very much. I seek questions from my colleagues.
I should declare that Jamie Rae is known to me as a friend and former colleague and that I met him in February to discuss the issue.The research that we have received has flagged up 120 identified subtypes of HPV. For the sake of clarification, can you tell us whether the immunisation programme would cover all 120 or just the high-risk subtypes such as HPV-16 and HPV-18?
The best available coverage is for HPV-16, HPV-18, HPV-6 and HPV-11. Your question is a good one, because this is a complicated matter and a growing area of interest for many scientists. Scotland is again doing a lot of good work on it, but there is still so much that we do not know about HPV. Ten or 15 years ago, there was little or no link with throat cancer but we now know that HPV is responsible for virtually all cases of oropharyngeal cancer, particularly in younger men who neither smoke nor drink, which were the typical risk factors in the past. Although there is no one-size-fits-all solution, there is a good quadrivalent vaccine that protects against the most dangerous strains of the virus, and it is now being used in Scotland.
You mentioned the costs in Norway, and I note from the petition that you have used figures from the Norwegian health authorities to cost the three-dose vaccination at £45. It is always good to err on the side of caution but, given that in my experience most goods in Norway cost nearly twice as much as they do here, it might be that the cost to extend the programme to 27,000 12-year-olds in Scotland might well be lower than the figure you have suggested. Indeed, if a deal can be done with the manufacturers, the figure might be even lower.I have found the Scandinavian and Nordic countries to be pretty much ahead of us on health issues. Do you know whether any of the Scandinavian countries plan to introduce HPV immunisation programmes for boys?
Denmark is looking at it seriously and we believe that it is very close to making its decision. That is the only comment that I can make, because I do not know about the other countries.
But it has been extended in Australia.
Yes. The United States has recommended vaccination for all boys, as has Canada. It has been adopted in two provinces in Canada, where boys are routinely vaccinated.11:45
Good morning, Jamie. In the last paragraph of the background information for your petition, you refer to Australia introducing vaccination for young men; in the paragraph before that, you suggest that 12-year-old boys in Scotland should be vaccinated. What is the age range for which Australia has introduced vaccination? I assume that it would be year-on-year vaccinations for 12-year-old boys, so there would be a recurring cost—but a decreasing one, we hope, as the vaccine is used more readily.
The reason that we have asked for 12-year-old boys to be vaccinated is that the vaccine works best prior to any sexual activity. That is why the vaccine is now given to young ladies about 12 years old. Getting boys vaccinated at a younger age as well would be a practical measure to ensure that people get the most effective use of the vaccine. It would be given to young people aged 12 and under.
There is evidence that the vaccine has a prophylactic effect so, even if somebody has been exposed to some strains of the virus, that does not mean to say that it is too late to be vaccinated. However, best practice is definitely to vaccinate before any sexual activity because the virus is so contagious that it is better to act as early as possible.
Clearly, vaccination would be a decision for the Scottish ministers to take, informed by scientific evidence and advice from officials. The Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation is not currently minded to recommend that the HPV vaccine be made available on a gender-neutral basis. I was struck by the point to which you referred, which is that the JCVI feels that there would be sufficient protection for heterosexual males because of their exposure to girls who have been vaccinated. I am sure that the point about discrimination is not lost on the committee.What independent source of advice and evidence are you aware of that would help to influence any decision by the Scottish Government given that the Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation is not currently in favour?
That is a good question, Mr Eadie. More than 150 of the people who have signed the petition are medical experts. Some of them are world leaders in their field. For example, our own Professor Heather Cubie, who until recently led the HPV research laboratory in Edinburgh, is in favour of gender-neutral vaccination, and she is considered to be a world-leading expert in the field. It is interesting that we have people such as Professor Cubie who disagree with the JCVI.We also have Professor Margaret Stanley, the head of virology at the University of Cambridge. She is credited as one of the world-leading experts on HPV. She is very much in favour of what we suggest. I could go on. The 150 are considerably experienced health professionals. Some of them are international and many of them are lauded and have won accolades the world over for their research work.The body of experience outwith the JCVI is considerable. I hope that the Scottish ministers would, if they are minded to do so, look beyond the narrow advice that comes from that statutory body.
Are you aware of any side effects or risks associated with the vaccine?
No. There has been some press speculation about that and there are individual cases with all vaccination programmes, but we have been using the vaccine in Scotland since, I think, 2007. It is a very safe drug. Its profile shows no significant problems. The most common issue is some redness and soreness around the area where the vaccine is administered in the arm. That is pretty much as far as it goes.
There has been a lot of adverse press, particularly in America, about the Gardasil vaccine, but a lot of it is unsubstantiated and based on loose interpretations of adverse reactions. When it comes to vaccination, adverse reactions include every single thing that happens; they are not necessarily related to the vaccine. For example, if someone has been given the Gardasil vaccine and they then die in a road traffic accident, that is listed as an adverse reaction. There has been some very loose reporting about the Gardasil vaccine, particularly in America. However, every expert to whom we have spoken and all the evidence that we have seen in researching the efficacy of the vaccine has shown that it is a very safe vaccine. It has the minimal side effect of redness and some people faint—but that is more to do with the needles than the vaccine itself.
Do other members have any other questions or points to put to our witnesses?Members: No.
The petition is interesting and well researched. I thank both our witnesses for that. I think that we need to keep the petition open and seek further advice from key organisations including the Scottish Government, Health Protection Scotland and Cancer Research UK. Do members agree with that course of action? Are there any other organisations that members would like to be added to that list?
I agree that the petition should be continued. We could also ask Stonewall and the gay men’s health group for their views.
Who have we agreed to ask?
So far, we have agreed to contact the Scottish Government, Health Protection Scotland and Cancer Research UK. Sorry—I missed Angus MacDonald’s point. Could you please repeat it?
We could contact Stonewall and the gay men’s health group as well.
Thank you.
I have a further suggestion. We could contact the Scottish cancer coalition, which represents the range of cancer charities in Scotland.
Jamie Rae mentioned some of the medics who have signed the petition. It might be useful to approach some of them as well, as they have a lot of expertise in the subject. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.
I thank our witnesses for coming along. We are very interested in the petition and will continue it. You have raised an interesting point. We will get as much evidence as we can and will keep you up to date with developments.I suspend the meeting to allow the witnesses to leave and our next witnesses to join us.11:52 Meeting suspended.
11:53 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 11 Jun 2013 →- 09:45 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:45 Tackling Child Sexual Exploitation in Scotland Evidence session · 115
- 09:45 New Petitions Petitions · 31
- 09:45 New Petitions Petitions · 65
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.