Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Scotland’s colleges 2013”

Wednesday 4 December 2013 Public Audit Committee About 10:30–11:45 Committee business 296 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

296 contributions · showing 1–200
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

I welcome the Scottish Government officials Leslie Evans, director general for learning and justice; Andrew Scott, director for employability; Colin Robertson, team leader, sponsorship and funding; and Melanie Weldon, team leader, post-16 college regionalisation. Leslie Evans would like to make an opening contribution.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I thank the committee for the opportunity to provide evidence in response to the Auditor General’s reports on the further education sector. We have found the reports helpful and we have addressed or are addressing their recommendations.

I am here as the accountable officer for the Scottish Government’s education and lifelong learning portfolio. I know that, last month, the committee heard from Laurence Howells, the accountable officer at the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council, so it is worth recapping our different but complementary roles.

I am responsible for ensuring that the funding council’s strategy and delivery align with the Scottish Government’s priorities and that the council has the necessary controls in place to safeguard public funds. Laurence Howells is accountable for the delivery of those Scottish Government policy objectives, the deployment of resources to that end and the associated planning and risk management. The quality of our close and effective relationship with the funding council is fundamental to the success of the Scottish Government reform.

That reform takes three forms. First, as members know, there is a programme of structural change, which is largely complete and which has transformed the college landscape. The Scottish Government recognises that the programme has demanded a massive effort from the sector and has not been without its challenges, but it has created the right foundations and framework to deliver the improvements for learners and employers that inform and drive our reform programme. Learning provision will now be planned and funded on a regional basis for the benefit of learners.

I visit colleges regularly so that I can hear directly from leaders, teachers and learners about their experiences. I have been struck by their commitment, drive and ambition to realise the advantages of the new regional landscape. For example, when I was in Dundee recently, I heard from Christina Potter about the way in which she and her team are shaping the new Dundee and Angus College curriculum to reflect the regional economy.

In addition to that structural change, the Scottish Government’s second strand of reform is a systemic approach to improvement. The funding council is negotiating outcome agreements to ensure greater transparency on the Government’s return for investment and greater accountability for delivery and continuous improvement. That focus on outcomes will help to drive improvements in colleges’ offer to learners and employers.

The third strand of the Scottish Government reform programme focuses on governance and leadership, commensurate with our expectations and our investment. That is realised by the implementation of the Post-16 Education (Scotland) Act 2013.

A reform programme of such scale and ambition is challenging. Audit Scotland’s reports this year and last have captured areas for our continued attention, some of which we will no doubt discuss today. The reforms are by no means complete, and colleges will need continued support to realise the full benefits of mergers, to focus on improvement with an eye on learner success and to strengthen the partnership working that that entails. In that respect, the recent report from Sir Ian Wood contains interesting recommendations for colleges, employers and schools.

I am happy to answer questions, as are my colleagues.

10:45

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

I will ask about the reclassification of colleges. Did you make the decision about whether to reclassify them?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

It was a ministerial decision, but we advised ministers about it. They were keen to look at three things when taking the decision. As you know, substantial public money is invested in the sector—£500 million or thereabouts each year. Ministers wanted to maintain transparency and accountability, which are very important to keeping learner and taxpayer confidence. Of college income, 75 per cent is from the public sector, so that was another key part of the reasoning behind ministers’ decision.

Ministers felt that their decision was in keeping with Russel Griggs’s report, which talked about improving governance in the further education sector, particularly after some historical incidents. He talked about

“real cohesive engagement between Government and the sector as a whole.”

Our interdependency and our work on outcome agreements paint a particular and unique approach to the way in which we are developing further education in association with the rest of the education sector.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

The decision was ministerial. What are its financial implications?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Overall, there are none, in that colleges will still fund college learning. They will go through a slightly different process to access some of their financing. They will report slightly differently to the SFC, although they will not have to supply excessively more financial information and data. Other than that, as you know, we are taking steps to mitigate the effect of some of the circumstances that have arisen through the decision about the ONS and reclassification.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

If there are no implications, what are you mitigating?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Colin Robertson might want to come in on some of the detail. We are trying to ensure that the constraints that are placed in the reclassification process have minimal impact on how colleges operate across the further education sector. For example, colleges currently operate in the academic year, but changing to the fiscal year is part of the Scottish public finance manual.

We are also creating arm’s-length foundations to ensure that reserves and money that would otherwise revert to the Scottish Government at the end of the financial year remain accessible for colleges.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

So there are financial implications.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

They are financial not in terms of cost but in terms of process.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

I did not ask whether there are cost implications. I asked whether there are financial implications and you said that there are none. It now appears that there are financial implications.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

There are financial implications in terms of financial process.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

So there are financial implications to such an extent that colleges are having to consider setting up arm’s-length organisations. I do not know whether you heard through the video feed the discussion about arm’s-length organisations in the previous evidence session. Among the concerns that have started to be expressed about arm’s-length organisations that councils have set up is that they have no direct accountability to the bodies that set them up. Once such a body is set up, it is independent and it is required, for legal reasons and for reasons of regulation from OSCR, to operate in the best interests of itself. How can we be sure that, if a college sets up an arm’s-length body or decides to participate in the centralised arm’s-length body that has been set up, the body will return all the money to that college in the way that the college hoped?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

The first thing that we are taking care to describe is the articles of association. Those are closely defined so that they reflect the purpose for a college or the colleges in a region and are in line with the ministerial and college priorities. The defining and describing of those articles of association is an important safeguard, because the spend and activity of the arm’s-length foundation will be evaluated against them.

You mentioned that the arm’s-length foundation will be subject to the law on charitable organisations and to scrutiny and audit by OSCR. Another issue is that, to access funding, colleges will apply to the arm’s-length foundation for the money that they require. As soon as that money goes to the colleges, it will be subject to the same kind of scrutiny as any other finance would be.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

As soon as it comes back to the college.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

That is right.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Given that the college is putting money into the arm’s-length body, who will ultimately decide whether any money comes back from that body? Will that be the college or the arm’s-length body?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

The college would apply to the arm’s-length foundation—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Yes, but who would make the decision?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

The college would decide that it needs money and it would go to the arm’s-length foundation.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Would the college decide that money would come back to it from the arm’s-length body?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Yes, it would apply—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

That is astonishing.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

It would apply to the foundation to—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Who would make the decision?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

The trustees of the arm’s-length body.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

So the arm’s-length body, and not the college, would make the decision.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Yes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

The college would have no say over whether money comes back to it—the arm’s-length body would make that decision. Is that correct?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

The arm’s-length body would evaluate and consider the college’s application and pass funding back to it along those lines.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Who would make the decision?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

The trustees would take that decision.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

The trustees of the arm’s-length body.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I think that I am correct in saying that.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

So the college would have no say over that decision.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Except that the college would prompt the decision in the first instance.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

That is like saying that, if I apply to a charitable trust, I prompt the decision. I would still have no say over whether the charitable trust gave me any money, would I?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I think that the colleges would expect—and certainly we would expect—the arm’s-length body’s trustees to be transparent about the basis on which they evaluate a request. They will have a set of articles of association that will define closely the types of projects and spend—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

The colleges may expect—a bit like Nelson—but they would have no say. One point that is coming out of the discussions on arm’s-length bodies is that the trustees of a trust that is set up by local government have a legal and fiduciary responsibility to the arm’s-length body to take decisions that are in that body’s best interest. They would not be legally responsible to the colleges, would they?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

No—you have put your finger on the issue. The trustees must be responsible for spending money in line with the articles of association. Much of that will depend on the appropriate crafting of those articles of association, so that there is minimal room for lack of clarity or confusion about the spend.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

To whom would the arm’s-length bodies be accountable?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

They would be accountable to the articles of association for transparency on how they spend their money.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Which is accountability to themselves.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

They are trusts so, with charitable status, they are accountable for how they perform and they are audited by OSCR. However, they are arm’s-length trusts—they are at arm’s length from the Government; that is one of the reasons why they are there.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

So the situation is the same as with the ALEOs that councils have set up. ALEOs are responsible to themselves and not to councils, and the trusts that we are discussing will be responsible to themselves and not to colleges.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

That is correct.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

That will apply to substantial amounts of public money that is transferred out of colleges and into the trusts.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Which is to be spent in line with the articles of association.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Notwithstanding the articles of association, the issue once the bodies are established—we know the reasons for that, as we do for the councils’ setting up of arm’s-length bodies—is to whom they are accountable. We have heard in previous discussions that such bodies are accountable only to themselves.

Colleges will transfer their money—75 per cent of which is public money, as you mentioned, although some may be private—to the arm’s-length bodies. Those bodies will be accountable only to themselves, subject to the articles of association.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Yes.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

They will not be accountable to colleges, and colleges will have no say in whether that money comes back to them.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I am not sure—I am happy to be corrected on whether colleges will be able to say anything about whether money comes back to them. The process that will be established is that the colleges will apply to the trusts.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

If you cannot tell us whether the colleges will have a say in whether money comes back to them, who can?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Well, I would say that it does say that, because they will apply—

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I would say that the colleges will have that say, because they will apply for the funding. Colleges from another region could apply to an arm’s-length foundation that was not in their region and they would not be—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

I do not know what West College Scotland, in my area, will do, but let us suppose that it sets up an arm’s-length body. The college could not have any say in whether money came back to it, because that would compromise the trust’s independence. The college would have to rely on the trust to make the decision. Is that correct?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

The trust would be responsible for taking decisions in relation to the articles of association.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

So the college would have no say in whether any money came back to it; the trust would make that decision.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

The trust would decide about the allocation of funds to the college. Of course, the articles of association would be closely defined so, if the trust did not spend money on the college, it would not spend money at all.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

The trust would not be accountable to the college in any way.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

No.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

To whom would the trust be accountable, other than to itself?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

The trust would be accountable to itself, based on the articles of association, which would describe its function and parameters.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

It would not be accountable to ministers.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Such bodies are not responsible to ministers. They are arm’s-length—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

The trust would not be accountable to anyone in the Scottish Government, either.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

No, it would not be accountable to the Government.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I have recently taken over my party’s portfolio for further and higher education, so I have just become aware of the ONS reclassification, although I understand that it was announced in October 2010, so it has been known about for three years. A different path has been followed in England, where colleges have been allowed to carry on as they were doing. As a former lecturer, I have no doubt about the success of our FE colleges since incorporation.

Could the ONS reclassification have been stopped in Scotland? Was there a choice? I appreciate that the Scottish Government might not have wished to go down the same road as England. As the accountable officer, did you have a choice about whether to go ahead with the ONS reclassification? Could you have done something to stop it?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

We had to respond to reclassification being imposed. Various routes were available and, as you accurately said, different parts of the UK have taken different approaches. England and Wales have avoided reclassification, whereas Northern Ireland and Scotland have decided to go down a different route.

The convener asked whether a decision was taken. A decision was taken, the implications of which we discussed with ministers. We were made aware of the likelihood of reclassification in the late summer of 2010. At the time, it was not clear what the options would be or what the implications might be, and it has taken quite a bit of time to unpack that. We have done that not just by ourselves but in correspondence with the Treasury in Whitehall. That is the context in which ministers decided whether they wanted to go down that route. England has gone down the route of appointing a further education commissioner, but that sets up a very different relationship with the Government.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I appreciate that. You had options when the proposal was made and you decided to go down the route of reclassification.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

That is correct.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I lodged a parliamentary question to the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning to ask what the benefits of the reclassification of further education colleges are and the answer was that there are none. Why did you choose to go down a route that would bring no benefits to further education colleges?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

We did so because of ministers’ understanding of and view about the disadvantages of going down the alternative route, which I referred to. They were to do with the nature of the funding package in Scotland—the high proportion of public funding and the high level of investment. The choice was also because of what we were looking at in great detail through the Griggs report on governance and accountability and the history of that in the college sector.

Ministers based their decision on those circumstances. They looked at what the alternative route to the one that they chose might mean in compromising some of those important aspects. They not only took a close look at governance and accountability but were clearly sighted on the importance of maintaining a strong and effective partnership with the further education and college sector not just on its own but as part of a wider education journey with higher education, schools and so on. There was a range of reasons why ministers decided to take that route.

11:00

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

There were disadvantages in not going down that route, but there are no benefits either. Colleges are a wonderful success story. The merged colleges will be even greater and we fully support that policy. If there are no benefits—I have yet to meet a college principal who thinks that it is a good idea—why is reclassification happening?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

From ministers’ point of view and given the advice with which they were presented—they weighed up the options; the decision was not quickly or easily taken—the benefits are that the governance and accountability that were under discussion as part of our reform, the Griggs review and the Post-16 Education (Scotland) Act 2013 would be preserved and enhanced. The decision was not taken in isolation from that package of reform or from ministers’ views about the importance of the further education sector—you are right to refer to that—and the substantial amounts of funding that go into it each year.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

If the main reason, as you have said twice now, is to preserve and enhance governance and accountability, did governance and accountability problems exist in colleges, which the ONS reclassification has allowed you to address?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

The Griggs report cited historical circumstances when governance had been less than perfect in some colleges. The report made specific recommendations about the quality of governance, which is important for the ambitions for the further education sector. It was therefore always going to be important from ministers’ perspective at least to maintain a close relationship with colleges and to maintain access to and the quality of governance and accountability in the sector.

I return to my point about the cohesive engagement between the further education sector and the Scottish Government. I mentioned that the accountable officer roles are different for Laurence Howells and me, but our close relationship with the funding council is part of that cohesion. The reforms that we are bringing about are intended not only to preserve the great standards that are in further education but to develop them further with an outcomes focus.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am not convinced, but I will move on. You mentioned that you had set down the right foundation for learning. The number of part-time students has fallen by about 143,000 and the teaching staff costs budget has fallen by £69 million in two years. I think that all of us round the table are very much in favour of the report of the Wood commission, but do those drastic further education cuts help you to set down the right foundation for learning?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

As ministers set out in their letters of guidance, we asked the funding council to support the education sector to focus on particular sectors of our community. The council was particularly keen to ensure that we improved our learner offer for young people, particularly 16 to 18-year-olds but also those in the 16 to 24 bracket, who might face unemployment when they leave education. Colleges have responded well to that.

Ministers also asked the colleges to look at courses that would produce qualifications and skills that are recognised by employers. That has inevitably changed the profile of the students at colleges. At the same time, the standards and targets that ministers’ set in 2010-11 on full-time equivalence have been not just met but exceeded. Although we have changed the profile, which has been a deliberate response to a ministerial instruction, we have maintained high levels of full-time equivalent places. We are looking to see where that has impacted on other parts of the community—you mentioned part-time learning—and considering what we can do to counterbalance some of that.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You mentioned the students, but what about the £69 million cut in the teaching budget? Does that allow colleges to move forward and to accept and build on the recommendations of the Wood commission?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I know from conversations that I have had with colleges that they are looking closely at their staffing structures, particularly as they merge and have merged. They have had to look closely in a strategic fashion at resources across what is now, for many of them, a regional organisation. They have had to look at voluntary severance and reconstructing their staffing structures to respond to the mergers and reform initiatives that have taken place over the past few months. There is no doubt that that has meant that some people have left the college sector. A large proportion of those who have left have been from the management side, where there have been economies of scale.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am talking about teaching staff, as was outlined in the Audit Scotland report. I am not talking about management.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I appreciate that. There have been some changes to teaching staff.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

We are talking about £69 million.

I return to the ONS reclassification. Am I right in saying that colleges can keep any surpluses that arise from higher education but must transfer to the arms-length bodies surpluses that arise from further education?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Colleges are allowed to keep their surpluses and intend to transfer all of them to their foundations. I am not aware that there is a difference between the income that is created by higher and further education courses, but I can find out and get back to you on that.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I was told that by the regional lead at the University of the Highlands and Islands. I would like to find out whether it is the case.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I will write to you on that.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you.

My final question is one that I have asked several times. We have a regional body in the Highlands called the UHI. Given that it has a £15 million budget and 200 staff, there is no doubt that funds to further education colleges in the Highlands and Islands are top sliced. Are you concerned that that might put those colleges at a disadvantage when providing skills, training and education?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

That is certainly not the intention. All colleges have been asked to absorb the costs of the reorganisation, including the boards that are being set up, within the Scottish funding council’s allocation.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So even money for the Glasgow board will be top sliced prior to going to the colleges?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I understand that the costs of all the changes that will take place across the college landscape, including the boards, will be absorbed by the colleges within their Scottish funding council allocation.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So colleges will receive less money because more will go to boards, which will allocate the funds.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Yes.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So boards rather than the colleges will make the decision on the allocation of funds, and the money is top sliced.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

The money will be top sliced, to use that phrase.

Melanie Weldon Scottish Government
link

The funding council will keep that area under close scrutiny to ensure that the costs are kept to a minimum and that the maximum resource goes to the front line.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Indeed. The financial memorandum for the Post-16 Education (Scotland) Bill set out how much was likely to be required to set up regional strategic bodies in multi-college regions. A particularly close eye will be kept on that.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I am sorry to have another go at the ONS issue, but I want to clarify something. People seem to be drawing a lot of comparisons with what is happening elsewhere and talking about opportunities to follow the system that is used south of the border. My understanding is that the system that Westminster used has in effect semi-privatised colleges. In other words, the Government south of the border took such a step back that the controls—apart from on the curriculum—are virtually nil.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

The landscape in England is very different. There is a high level of private sector investment in the further education sector and colleges have a different relationship with the Government as a result. The Government decided to appoint a further education commissioner. I do not know whether Andrew Scott wants to say something about that.

Andrew Scott Scottish Government
link

The commissioner has just been announced as Dr David Collins. He has powers to step in when a college is failing—the model is that he makes recommendations to ministers when a college is doing badly. We have not tried to create such a model in our approach to governance, which is much more collaborative. The public service philosophies in the appointment of a commissioner and our approach are entirely different.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

So the Government at Westminster has little overview through the commissioner apart from in certain extreme cases.

Andrew Scott Scottish Government
link

That is right. I understand that, when the commissioner intervenes down south, there is a likelihood that the college will be reclassified into the public sector and will cease to be in the private sector. The underpinning philosophy is quite different.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

My second question is a request for clarification. We have talked about funds flowing from the colleges into the arm’s-length trusts. Colleges receive a pot of money from the Government, but they also raise funds from various sources, some of which are commercial. Am I correct in saying that the funds that go to the arm’s-length organisations are not the funds that are supplied by central Government directly, but the funds that are raised by the colleges themselves? I am not saying that that is not still public money when it has been received by the colleges, but it comes from a different source.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Yes, that is my understanding. I think that we are talking about reserves or surplus funding that would otherwise cause all sorts of financial and accountability problems given the close relationship with the Scottish Government, as the ONS reclassification now makes it. The whole point is that the colleges can place those reserves, which otherwise might be frozen, in arm’s-length foundations, where they can access them within the terms of the articles of association.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

On the subject of accounting, when I read the Audit Scotland report “Scotland’s colleges 2013”, I was concerned to find that there was a pension deficit of £115.3 million at the end of 2011-12. How will that be accounted for in the new scenario?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

My understanding is that the accounting will not change and that the deficit will still sit in the colleges budget. Colin Robertson might have a different view on that.

Colin Robertson Scottish Government
link

No, that is right. Reclassification has no impact on the pension deficit.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

So there is no financial impact at all for the Scottish Government.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

No. The position will not change. It was assessed by Audit Scotland as a tolerable risk within the confines of the report.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I do not know whether you have the report with you, but it highlights an apparent anomaly. I would be interested in your comments on exhibit 7, on page 17. I assume that the figure for “Other inc. exceptional costs”, under “Colleges’ expenditure”, has gone up because some of the costs of merger have gone into that line. However, the administration costs seem to have increased as well, although I would have expected them to come down along with other costs.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Indeed. I agree with you. I do not know the reason for that, so I will not pretend that I do. I wonder whether some of the exceptional costs might also be administrative in nature and could therefore be counted in that way. As you say, there are a lot of additional one-off tasks and undertakings to be brought to bear as a result of the mergers, and the cost of those might well be accounted for there. We should ask Audit Scotland about that.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I did, and I do not think that Audit Scotland had the figure.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Can I just clarify something, Ms Evans? In your comments to Colin Beattie, you confirmed that only surplus funds would be transferred to the arm’s-length bodies.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Yes—that is my understanding.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

You also said that those surpluses would not come from public sector funding.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I suppose that, if they were end-of-year surpluses, it would be difficult to differentiate the money that had been brought in as a result of entrepreneurial activity, but it is reserves that are placed in the trusts.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Yes, but at the end of the year, when a college has a surplus that it is considering for transfer, you do not know whether £1 million of that surplus has come from the public sector and £1 million has come from its commercial or fundraising activities—it is just a surplus.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

It is a surplus. That is correct. I do not know whether Colin Robertson wants to say something more about that.

Colin Robertson Scottish Government
link

The existing financial and reporting requirements on colleges through the funding council to the Scottish Government will not change as a result of reclassification. Therefore, any public funds that colleges move into foundations at the end of the financial year will be visible.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

So if a college reports a surplus at the end of the financial year, will it be able to break it down and say how much of it came from public funding and how much came from its commercial and fundraising activities?

11:15

Colin Robertson Scottish Government
link

The amount of funding that the funding council has made available to colleges and that has been transferred into foundations will be clear.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Are you saying with absolute certainty that, when a surplus is declared at the end of the year, its source will be broken down?

Colin Robertson Scottish Government
link

It will be visible through the financial and reporting—

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

When a college declares a surplus now, can you see how it has been generated? Can you see how much of it is attributable to public funding and how much to commercial and fundraising activities?

Colin Robertson Scottish Government
link

I understand that that is not the case at the moment.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

But it will be in the future.

Colin Robertson Scottish Government
link

I think that the expectation would be that if, for example, a college was not going to draw down the level of funding that it required from the funding council, that would be visible.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

I am not asking about draw-down; I am asking about when a surplus is declared. You are telling me about your expectation. I do not know whether that means that that will be in the guidance, regulations or requirements. You are telling me that, in future, a surplus will be broken down and we will be able to see how much of it was generated from public funds.

Colin Robertson Scottish Government
link

It will be part of the funding council’s responsibility in managing surpluses across the wider sector to be able to identify surpluses in individual colleges.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Could Leslie Evans send a letter to the committee that explains how things will be done in future? That takes us to another question. Once a surplus has been declared and broken down into its constituent categories, will the only bit that will be transferred to the arm’s-length body be the non-public sector funds or the public sector funds, or will all of it be transferred?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

My understanding is that all the surplus would be transferred, irrespective of whether it has been generated through a partnership, the private sector or the public sector.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Right. So public sector funds could well be transferred to the public sector body.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Yes, if all those public sector funds have not been used. That is unusual, but it happens.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Right. So public sector funds could be transferred, and at the end of the year colleges will be able to show how much of the surplus is attributable to public sector funding.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I appreciate what Colin Robertson said. It would be difficult to be able to completely disaggregate those things, for the simple reason that colleges use public sector funding to employ all their staff.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

I accept that it could be difficult, but Colin Robertson said that there will be an expectation that it will be done.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I am sure that the funding council will want to analyse how the surplus has been achieved.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Are you sure that it will want to do that or that it will have to do that?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I am sure that it will want to.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

So there is no expectation.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I cannot be categoric about whether there is a written and statutory expectation of the funding council, but I am sure that it will want to do that.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Colin Robertson told us that there is an expectation, but you are saying that you are not sure.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

No. I am saying that I cannot say that there is any formal or statutory expectation. I am sure that the funding council would want to be clear—as it and the college would now—about how any income surplus had been generated, and we would encourage it to do so.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Can you provide whatever requirement there is in writing to us, so that we can examine that?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

We can certainly write to you about that.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

Okay. Thank you.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I want to look at the current cuts that are happening in colleges. Is there a link between the size of classes that students attend at college or their hours in front of lecturers and the quality of education that they receive?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

It is difficult to draw comparisons. The class size might be dictated by the nature of the course. Some courses are theoretical and some are practical. Using the size of class only as a comparator is therefore not necessarily a very accurate way of making a robust comparison.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

So do class sizes and the number of hours that students have in class matter as a measure of Government success or outcomes?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I can give you a good example. I asked representatives of Dundee and Angus College about full-time equivalence, the number of hours that are required and the flexibility in that. They said that they wanted to encourage their young people—not for every course, but for a particular course that they were talking about—to do more independent learning. They wanted to increase the amount of time that students had as independent learners, which is in keeping with curriculum for excellence and with the college’s ambitions for its young people. That would reduce the amount of time that people spend in the classroom. The college wanted 25 per cent of the course time to be independent learning, supported by things such as enhanced information technology, IT learning hubs and learning hub assistants.

The council representatives also told me that the performance indicators for the course and that model of course were going up, which they were satisfied about. Having more teaching hours, which are measured in terms of hours in the classroom, does not always make for an easy and comparable approach to qualitative results. As it happens, those students have fewer hours in the classroom, but their results are going up and they are successful learners in the context of the curriculum for excellence.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

In school education a very clear link is expressed, and one of the key drivers in the stated aims of Government policy is to reduce class sizes at school, particularly in the earlier years of primary. That is driven by evidence that class size matters. Are you saying that no such evidence exists for colleges, or that it is not a factor?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I cannot say that there is no such evidence, but colleges are thinking very carefully—as demonstrated by the example of Dundee and Angus College—about getting the right mix. That mix, unlike in schools, includes job training, theoretical training, independent learning and classroom time for theoretical learning. Colleges consider that mix carefully as part of their response to the Government’s target for full-time equivalent places.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Are you worried that there will be an increase in class sizes at colleges over the next couple of years? Are you worried about the current increase or any forthcoming increase?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I am more concerned about ensuring that the quality of the learning experience is maintained and improved. That is why the funding council and Education Scotland will be taking steps to evaluate the impact of reform and mergers on the quantitative and qualitative nature of that change for the learner. That is where we will get a great deal of information and data.

We will also get a lot of information about the learner experience through the outcome agreements that are being negotiated and enacted with the funding council. The funding council is talking directly to colleges about the employment needs and the skill needs locally, as well as the national framework for their provision.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

What are your expectations? Do you expect staff numbers to decrease over the next couple of years? An 11 per cent real-terms reduction in income has been forecast for the colleges by the Auditor General. Do you expect the numbers to decrease? If so, by how much? Do you expect class sizes to increase? If so, by how much? Do you expect hours to decrease?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

We are aware that teaching numbers have reduced and that staff numbers for colleges as a whole have reduced. That is not surprising, given the amount of change and the mergers that are taking place. Colleges will need to continue to keep a careful eye on the nature of the courses that they provide, on the size of the classrooms and on the staffing skills that they require in order to carry out their responsibilities with the emphasis and approach that have been described in their outcome agreements.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

The Government will ask the funding council to keep a very careful eye on that issue. That will be part of the discussions with colleges regarding the outcome agreements. We would expect the funding council to take that issue into account.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

So, just to be sure, you expect staff numbers to fall further and/or class sizes to increase.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Yes.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

There has clearly been a substantial decrease in the overall headcount. More than 100,000 Scots are not going to college compared with the number who were going to college just two or three years ago. What do you think the impact has been on those individuals, given the opportunities that they have lost?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

As I said, one of the difficulties in measuring learning is that measures such as headcount can fluctuate depending on course and choice, so although I understand that it is an easily captured number, it is not necessarily a consistent comparator for looking at levels of learning. That is why we use full-time equivalents.

Ministers have deliberately told the college sector through the funding council that they want colleges to concentrate on young people aged 16 to 24 and on providing courses that will result in skills and qualifications that are recognised by employers. That means that there will be a shift in profile, not just of students but also of some courses. Some part-time courses that do not result in such qualifications or recognisable skills have reduced as a result of that; there is no doubt about it.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

What has been the impact of that reduction on older people in Scotland?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

I cannot say what the impact has been on every older person who has not gone to college. We are aware that, whereas in some areas the number of full-time equivalent college attendees among women and some people with particular learning needs has stayed stable, the number has reduced for some older people. That is one of the reasons why the Government has given the funding council additional money this year and next to target specifically at older learners and at some part-time students as well.

Although I talked about the change of profile inevitably coming from an instruction from the Government to focus on particular parts of the community, we are looking at where we can mitigate some of the impact of that where we feel that that is necessary and where the funding council spots it. The funding council has also been asked to look at the outcome agreements with regional colleges to see where and how they are taking into account the needs in their local populations, where there may be particular elderly, older-learner or part-time requirements.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

To clarify, are you saying that you are not able to assess the impact on older people who have not had the opportunity to go to college, but that you have been able to identify the impact on certain vulnerable groups? How were you able to assess that there has been an impact on women, and prioritise resources for them, but unable to identify any other impact?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

We have been able to identify other impacts, and I may have caused confusion by the way in which I answered the question. We know that the numbers of women and of some people with additional learning needs and disabilities have stayed stable. We know that numbers of older people attending college have reduced slightly. That is why, as I said, we are taking mitigating action with the funding council discussions on the outcome agreement and the additional money that has been added.

Melanie Weldon Scottish Government
link

There is additional money of about £7 million in 2013-14.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

So what has the impact been? You have identified that there has been an impact and you have identified additional resources to try to mitigate that, but what has been the impact on those women?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

There has not been an impact on women; the number has remained stable. For older people, the full-time equivalents have gone down slightly. We can send you the figures for that if that would help.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Yes.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

The provision of courses for older people, and part-time learning.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

What has been the impact on older people and part-time learners that you are mitigating?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

As I said, we know that the full-time equivalent numbers of older learners have gone down. That is one of the reasons why we asked the funding council to use the additional funding for older people, particularly older women, and we have provided extra funding this year and next in that respect.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

So the numbers have simply gone down and you want to increase the numbers again?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

We have asked the funding council to look at that closely, yes, with additional money and through the outcome agreements.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Do you measure demand itself? How do you measure demand for college places?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

There are two aspects to that. The funding council works with Skills Development Scotland to anticipate what is required sectorally in terms of skills in the skills investment plan, and in regional investment plans. They produce those plans, and the outcome agreement managers who are negotiating future provision with colleges take that into account alongside what the colleges themselves decree, having spoken to employers in their local regions. There is a bottom-up and a top-down approach to forecasting demand in the future.

11:30

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Is demand increasing at the moment or staying the same? What is happening with demand?

Andrew Scott Scottish Government
link

Demand has changed quite a lot over the past five years, since the beginning of the recession. I can remember the conversations with college principals around then—they detected a shift towards full-time learning and away from part-time learning right at the beginning of the recession and they attributed that to people retraining.

Over the past five years, we have become much better at estimating what is required by employers. We have set up industry liaison groups. We also have a joint skills committee with the funding council, outcome agreements that reflect local vocational requirements, and skills investment plans and regional skills plans for most of Scotland—or we will have by the end of April 2014—so my judgment is that over the past five years, there have been very substantial changes in the college population and our shaping of that learning requirement around vocational needs has improved greatly.

Andrew Scott Scottish Government
link

Yes; I think that it has.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Okay. You say that demand has changed but, to return to my original question, is there growing demand at the moment? Is there increased demand for college places compared with two years ago or four years ago?

Andrew Scott Scottish Government
link

It is very difficult to estimate demand as a single entity. It goes back to the issue of waiting lists: we examined the proposition that demand was equivalent to waiting lists and found that it was not because the waiting lists of individual courses contained such a substantial element of duplication. It is therefore very difficult to estimate demand as a whole and to meet demand in a single way.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

But you have found extra money specifically for older learners and part-time learners. Is that a reflection of demand or is that simply because those numbers have been cut?

Andrew Scott Scottish Government
link

It is a reflection of the fact that people wanted more money to be provided for older learners and women and for part-time courses. One could provide more or less in any circumstance but, nonetheless, ministers chose to meet the requirements that people placed upon them.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I am just trying to get to the bottom of where we might be going. It is clear that the Government has a very specific policy, which is to target and support full-time or longer courses and younger learners. That is a very clear policy but there is a downside to it, which is that older learners—particularly women returners and part-time learners—will suffer. I am simply trying to identify that downside.

I am trying to work out how you measure demand—what process do you have to work out whether the economy is suffering and whether those individuals who are missing out on opportunities are suffering? What is the cost of that lost opportunity?

Andrew Scott Scottish Government
link

It is an enormously complicated question. The practical answer is that regional colleges are trying to estimate demand of various types in their localities; Education Scotland is doing a thematic review of college application procedures; and various regional colleges are pooling their knowledge about cross-border flows. That will all help a bit. However, I do not think that it is possible—or that it has ever been possible—to quantify the extent of demand in a single figure. Also, there has always been an element of rationing within the lifelong learning budget.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I agree that that budget is a finite resource.

I am intrigued to know about not just the forces and the pressures, but the criteria—the information and the evidence—that you use to make judgments about who will benefit from those funding streams and who will not. Clearly, some people will lose out.

Andrew Scott Scottish Government
link

Clearly, the amount of evidence that one has on any particular group tends to vary, but in 2011 we knew that the long-term effects of unemployment on young people were more substantial than they were on any other group. Between 2008, when the labour market was at its peak, and 2011, when ministers wrote to the funding council, the number of unemployed people under the age of 24 in Scotland close to doubled. There was a certain amount of evidence there.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I agree entirely. At the same time, in terms of headcount, the number of people going to college has fallen from over 300,000 to just over 200,000. That is a dramatic shift. I agree that there was a policy intention, but a vast number of people—100,000—no longer have the opportunity to go to college and I find it hard to believe that that is not having an impact.

Andrew Scott Scottish Government
link

The learning has been condensed. As I observed in my opening remarks, some people have opted to participate on a full-time basis rather than a part-time basis on account of their economic circumstances.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I want to ask about pay, unless there are any other questions on that point.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Renfrewshire South
link

This will be your last question.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

Is it still Government policy to move towards national pay bargaining in the college sector? If so, do you have a date for when that will be in place?

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Yes. Some work on that is already being undertaken, as you may know from Ian McKay, who is looking at the matter closely. It is our intention and hope that that group will produce some proposals that will be ready to create a new construct from the academic year 2015-16. There is still some work to be done on that. In the meantime, regional colleges are looking after their own salary circumstances within their regions.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

It is still Government policy to introduce national pay bargaining.

Leslie Evans Scottish Government
link

Yes.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 128
  3. 10:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 296

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.