Item 2 is a section 23 report from the Auditor General for Scotland and the Accounts Commission on Scotland’s public sector workforce. I welcome the Auditor General and her staff and invite her to brief the committee.
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Scotland’s public sector workforce”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland 36
- Hugh Henry Lab 22
- Fraser McKinlay Audit Scotland 20
- Ken Macintosh Lab 14
- Andra Laird Audit Scotland 10
- Colin Beattie SNP 8
- Willie Coffey SNP 6
- Mary Scanlon Con 5
- James Dornan SNP 3
- Angela Cullen Audit Scotland 2
- Christina McKelvie SNP 1
- Colin Keir SNP 1
The record
128 contributionsThank you, convener. Our 2011 report “Scotland’s public finances: addressing the challenges” highlighted that reducing the public sector workforce is the main way in which the costs of public services will be reduced in the face of the continuing financial challenges. Our report “Scotland’s public sector workforce”, which was published on 28 November, examines how councils, the national health service, the Scottish Government and other central Government bodies have changed their workforces since 2009. It also looks at the savings that bodies have made from those changes, what plans they have for the future and what they will need to do to achieve the savings and the other reforms that are required over that period.
In the four years since 2009, councils, the NHS, the Scottish Government and other central Government bodies have reduced their workforces by 26,600 whole-time equivalent posts. The extent of change varies across the sectors from a 1 per cent reduction in the NHS, which is equivalent to about 1,400 whole-time equivalent posts, to a 10 per cent reduction in council staff, which is almost 24,000 whole-time equivalents. We estimate that those changes reduced staff costs by about £1 billion over the three years from 2009-10 to 2011-12.
Around a third of that reduction in staff numbers and costs was due to transfers of staff and services out of the public sector to arm’s-length bodies and other non-public-sector bodies. We estimate that transfers to arm’s-length bodies accounted for almost 10,000 of the 26,600 posts that have been removed. It is worth noting, however, that the public sector pays annual service fees to those bodies for the services that they provide, so it continues to contribute to the staff costs that those bodies incur. Our estimate of a £1 billion reduction in staff costs does not take account of those payments.
Part 2 of the report looks at how bodies have implemented changes to their workforces. Exhibit 7 on page 24 shows the main approaches that have been used by 80 public bodies between 2009 and 2013. They all used pay restraint, and most assessed vacancies as they arose, only filling posts that they saw as business critical. The majority also used staff redeployment. Sixty-nine bodies, including all 32 councils, used early departure schemes and 62 bodies used early retirement schemes. Staff who left through those means vacated around 16,000 whole-time equivalent posts.
The committee will recall that, before the summer recess, I briefed you on our report “Managing early departures from the Scottish public sector”. By using a mix of approaches, the nine public bodies that we reviewed in detail had made the workforce changes that they needed to make to meet their short-term business and financial objectives. We recommend in the report that we are discussing today that bodies should improve how they do that by planning strategically and using the good practice that we identified. We also recommend that they should collect information on the costs and savings that are associated with their workforce change programmes and the impact of those changes on services and staff wellbeing.
In part 3 of the report, we look to the future. Public sector finances will continue to be under pressure for the foreseeable future due to budget constraints, demographic change and increasing staff costs. When we conducted our fieldwork in April and May this year, not all bodies were able to forecast their workforce numbers and costs for 2014-15. Those who could estimated that, overall, workforces would continue to reduce by more than 3,000 whole-time equivalents. At the same time, they forecast that staff costs would rise by £209 million up to 2014-15. The forecast rise in costs is due to a combination of factors including pay increases, pay progression, the implementation of the Scottish Government’s commitment to a living wage and bodies settling equal pay claims.
To meet those financial challenges and reform public services, public bodies need to extend and strengthen their workforce planning. The report lists some of the options that are open to them and we recommend that they think differently about how they will deliver services by prioritising and redesigning services and increasing joint working across organisations and sectors.
As always, my colleagues and I are happy to answer the committee’s questions.
Thank you. Point 5 in your list of key messages on page 9 of the report states:
“The Scottish Government has a number of reforms under way that could help deliver some of the change needed.”
Will you describe some of those reforms?
Certainly. I will pick out a couple, initially. The integration of health and social care is intended to deliver better services to older people and people in general in the community through closer joint working. We think that it also has potential to manage the cost pressures by enabling bodies to consider the ways in which staff work together and think about new roles that break down some of the boundaries between different professional disciplines and the work that staff carry out at the moment, depending on whether they are employed by the national health service or by council bodies. We are seeing similar initiatives around the early years and increasingly in the criminal justice system in relation to reoffending, where the barriers between the prison service and community justice work are being broken down.
Have the potential savings from those three examples been costed and quantified?
We have not done that work at this stage, although we will have some work coming out in the new year on reshaping care for older people.
The issue that you raise is one of the reasons why the workforce planning that we talk about in the report is important. Each body that is involved in the processes of reforming services and working more collaboratively needs to understand what staff it has and what roles they carry out, and also the pressures that it has, such as an ageing workforce or recruitment challenges, as a basis for thinking about making better use of staff, jointly, and redesigning jobs to ensure that people can work more effectively and efficiently.
Paragraph 19 on page 12 states:
“Eighteen NHS and central government bodies increased their staff numbers”.
Can you give us a note—not necessarily today—of the bodies that increased their staff numbers?
We can certainly do that, within the limits of the data that we have been able to collect. More generally, the report states that there are differences between the sectors and that all the bodies have been recruiting staff to replace people who have left essential posts or to reshape their workforce in planned ways. Fraser McKinlay can add some detail.
I have just checked with our team, and we can provide you with that information, convener.
Is the balance more on NHS bodies or on Government bodies?
Nine Government bodies and nine health board bodies increased their staff.
So, at a time when, for example, direct services that are provided by local government are under pressure and staff numbers are going down, nine central Government bodies increased their staff numbers. It would be interesting to see further details of that, so I thank you for arranging to send them to us.
Can you quantify the potential size of the equal pay claims? I know that those that have been reported so far have sizeable implications for the local authorities concerned. Is there an overall figure?
We considered the claims in relation to local government and the NHS and reported the best estimates that are available in the local government overview report and the NHS financial performance report. Fraser McKinlay and Andra Laird can talk further about each of those sectors. Fraser McKinlay is the controller of audit and he is responsible for reporting on local government to the Accounts Commission.
I am afraid that I cannot recall the number for last year, convener, but I will confirm it for you. The local government overview report for the current financial year, which I think will be published in March next year, will state how much the claims have cost to date and how much local authorities have put aside to deal with them.
Is it correct to say that the figure will be sizeable and it could have a significant impact on local government services?
It will certainly be sizeable. The extent to which it will have an impact on services is a different question, but it will be a pretty big number. As usual, the Accounts Commission will be happy to brief the committee on the overview report. We will be in a position to say how much councils have set aside for potential claims in the future.
My last question for now relates to arm’s-length external organisations; I might come back to them later. You state that, once services have been transferred to ALEOs, there are still financial implications whereby local authorities have to make service payments to those bodies. Does the Accounts Commission scrutinise ALEOs in the same way that it scrutinises local government?
Again, I ask Fraser McKinlay to pick up that question.
The simple answer is that the scrutiny of ALEOs is not the same as the scrutiny of councils, because councils are directly audited by the Accounts Commission under the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973. To some extent, the whole point of ALEOs is that they become different kinds of organisations such as charities or companies limited by guarantee. The interest of the Accounts Commission is in following the public pound, so the commission’s interest—and Audit Scotland’s interest—is in ensuring that councils have strong governance arrangements in place to provide oversight of how the public money that is given to ALEOs is spent on delivery.
You might be aware that, over the past six months, the Accounts Commission has been doing a lot of work and a lot of thinking on that subject. We have submitted several papers to it this year, and we continue to keep a close eye on the topic—in fact, we have asked all 32 council auditors to do some more due diligence work on the position of ALEOs in the audit year that has just kicked off. We want to know how many ALEOs there are, what they are like, how much they spend and what councils’ governance arrangements are like, in order to get as up-to-date a picture as we can.
I note from the summary on page 4 of the report that 15,800 staff left through early departure, which was 4 per cent of the workforce, and that 3 per cent of staff were transferred to ALEOs or other bodies. Further on, quite a degree of private sector involvement is mentioned. For example, paragraph 22 says that
“NHS Forth Valley transferred 541 facilities management staff to SERCO in 2010/11”
and that
“Highlands and Islands Enterprise and Scottish Enterprise transferred 23 staff in total to Atos in 2011”.
Those are private sector companies.
To go back to what the convener asked, do you have a breakdown of how many ALEOs, third sector organisations and private sector companies are involved? How can any accountability or governance be provided in relation to those jobs when the company concerned is completely in the private sector, as is the case in the examples that I mentioned?
You are absolutely right that, in the report, we focus on staff who have transferred from being public sector employees to being employees of arm’s-length organisations or private companies. About 10,000 of the 26,500 reduction is accounted for by staff who fall into that category, so we are talking about a significant number of people. By far the bulk of those are staff who transferred to arm’s-length organisations as opposed to public companies. A total of about 600 staff were involved in the two examples that we cite in the report.
The same principle applies to transfers to private companies as applies to transfers to arm’s-length organisations, as Fraser McKinlay outlined. Of particular importance is the ability to follow the public pound to ensure that the money that is used to pay for those services is managed and accounted for properly and that it provides the service that is intended. We are all aware of the growing interest in the terms and conditions of staff who are subject to such transfers. We did not look at that issue directly in our report, but we are very conscious of it and we will keep it under review as we plan future audit work.
Given the transfers from the public sector to Atos and Serco, can you see from your work whether the intention in future is to give public sector work not just to ALEOs but to private sector companies?
09:45
The examples that we found are isolated ones. It is worth distinguishing those transfers of people from areas where services are being commissioned from private sector organisations as a matter of policy. That is less widespread in Scotland than it is under United Kingdom Government policy, for deliberate policy reasons. Where such large contracts are in place, they throw up particular issues about employment, as your question highlighted, and more generally about accountability for public money. In planning our future audit work, we are focusing on that to ensure that we have proper oversight of those big contracts and that we understand the risks that are associated with them for the good stewardship of public money.
My second question is about exhibit 7, on page 24. I knew that vacancy management is widely used in the NHS, but I had not appreciated just how widely used it is across the public sector in Scotland to manage the workforce. The exhibit shows that 32 councils, 21 NHS bodies and 24 central bodies are doing that. I had not realised that it is the second most commonly used approach next to pay freezes. I understand that, the longer a job is kept open, the more money is saved, but in terms of effective spend, are there concerns that the use of vacancy management can impact on service delivery, given that it is second top of the league?
Such concerns are the reason why we highlight the range of mechanisms that are used, and vacancy management is one that is very commonly used. The obvious advantage and attraction for public bodies is that it is fairly straightforward to implement. If somebody leaves, their post can be held until the body is sure that the post needs to be filled because it is business critical or another way of meeting the need is found. The risks are that a gap is left and the approach is not based on a strategic view of priorities across the service or organisation, which can limit the options for more flexible ways of filling the gap that the person has left behind.
It is entirely understandable that public bodies are using vacancy freezes as a way of managing their budgets—we have done the same in Audit Scotland—but that is not a substitute for strategic workforce planning over the longer term.
I was thinking about specialist consultants, as I think that there have been concerns about them.
My third and final question is on paragraph 101. When I got to it last night, I did not quite understand what the last sentence means. I know that the community empowerment and renewal bill is about to start its way through the Parliament, but what is meant by the comment
“This includes whether communities could help to provide services directly”?
I did not quite understand that. I represent the Highlands and Islands, and I am thinking about how local communities would provide services. Will you explain what that means?
That is closely allied with the concept of community empowerment, which involves working with communities on what services matter to them and then thinking about the best way of addressing them depending on the characteristics of the place, the people who live there and the problems that exist.
We are certainly not suggesting that public services should be removed, but we are saying that there might be good ways of, for example, encouraging people who live in a small remote community to look out for older people, with the ability to call in professionals when they are needed. Thought could be given to the way in which services that are important for community cohesion can be encouraged by the statutory sector but delivered by people who live there.
Fraser McKinlay might be able to add to that, based on our experience of community planning audits over the past year.
There are lots of good examples of that happening. I know from work in Orkney that communities there do things such as maintaining local cemeteries and monitoring coastal erosion. To take off my professional hat for a minute, where I live, in Haddington, I am involved in my son’s football team, and we have a new football pitch that is entirely community run. In previous years, such a facility would almost certainly have been run by the council. There are examples of that approach, and I think that the community empowerment and renewal bill will be designed to encourage it.
Like the discussion that we have just had about ALEOs, that raises all sorts of interesting questions about, for example, accountability and how the funding works. We are certainly interested in that. In such examples, communities are not just consulted on things but are more directly involved in the design and delivery of public services.
Okay. I will leave it there.
I welcome Christina McKelvie to the meeting. Do you have any interests to declare, Christina?
No, I do not have any interests to declare in relation to this committee, but I refer members to my entry in the register of members’ interests. Please accept my apologies for my lateness this morning.
No problem. Thank you.
link
The convener originally picked up the question of transfers to ALEOs, which are quite significant. I think that Audit Scotland produced a useful a report on ALEOs a couple of years ago. From what you have said, I think that you are going to work into your audit programme a follow-up to that report that has a look at what is happening with ALEOs. Is that correct?
Not specifically that, Mr Beattie.
As you said, a couple of years ago, we produced what was in a sense a good practice guide that said, “If you are going to be using ALEOs, this is how you should go about it.” Even since then, more ALEOs have been created, and it is interesting that there has been a shift towards more ALEOs being created for more personal-type services. For example, there is a new local authority trading company in Aberdeen that delivers care services. For a while, it tended to be leisure services that were transferred into ALEOs, but the model is now being used more widely.
The Accounts Commission in particular and Audit Scotland on its behalf have a real interest in that. If the pattern is going to continue, with local government services being delivered through those different kinds of organisations, what does that mean for our ability to scrutinise the services? This year, we have done work to take stock and ask ourselves whether the Accounts Commission needs any more powers, for example. We are pretty confident that we do not need any more powers at the moment. We think that we already have powers that allow us to follow the public pound and get assurance on how the money is being spent.
Therefore, rather than there necessarily being a separate bit of follow-up work, we have first asked local auditors to give us a good and robust baseline for the current picture in local government, which will inform whether we do anything more. I think that that will inevitably be an increasing feature of our audit work, because that is how services are being delivered.
link
You have certainly touched on an important point in referring to following the public pound. If public funds are increasingly being spent in ALEOs, there should be some way to follow that spending and audit it and to look at the governance of those organisations.
On page 13 of the report, there is a wee case study on South Lanarkshire, which we used as an example of the kind of thing that we are talking about. Quite significant amounts of money in South Lanarkshire—around £21 million in 2011-12—are going into the leisure trust every year. You are absolutely right: the principle of following the public pound is hugely important.
It is also worth saying that it is not a completely barren field in respect of accountability. For example, a charity will be regulated by the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator, and all the bodies will appoint their own auditors and their financial statements will be audited every year. The specific question for us is how we as the public audit organisation ensure that the public accountability for those funds is maintained and assured.
link
Would there not be a different approach by an auditor who is appointed to a charitable body, for example, who really looks at whether the funds have been properly accounted for and so on, as opposed to the public audit approach, in which rather a wider sense of how funds are used and their effectiveness is looked at?
That is absolutely right. In local government, the approach would be around the whole notion of best value. The appointed auditors of the ALEOs will not do best-value audits, for example; their job will be to audit the financial statements. We are therefore thinking hard about how we can use our powers in best value via the council to get assurance that how those bodies are governed and operated is sound.
link
When will you finish your assessment?
The work that the auditors are doing is part of this year’s audit, so we should begin to see that coming through certainly no later than this time next year. I hope that we will see the results of that work earlier, but it depends on when exactly we do the work. I hope that we will have a clear sense of what else we might do about the matter by this point next year.
link
That seems a long way away.
Paragraphs 34, 35 and 38 of your report refer—not for the first time in such reports—to a lack of information and to information that is not available. What impact has there been on the information in the report? How good an indication is the information in the report, given the limitations on what you could access?
This is the best information that the team could gather, but you are right to refer to gaps and inconsistencies between bodies and sectors. Angela Cullen will talk you through the overall picture, how we have compensated for gaps and the most important gaps that need to be filled.
As Caroline Gardner said, the report uses the best available data. We took the cost information from a range of areas—it was largely from annual accounts in the health and central Government sectors, for example. Local authority accounts do not highlight staff costs separately, so we used local financial returns to capture that information. It is not perfect, but it is the best information that is available. We have tried to fill the gaps.
Part of the methodology for the audit was to capture information from 80 survey bodies. We surveyed all the health boards, all the councils and 26 of the largest central Government bodies to provide us with information to supplement what we knew from their annual accounts. We also used lots of official statistics for staff numbers, such as Office for National Statistics data and the workforce statistics that the NHS publishes through ISD Scotland. We used a lot of that information and tried to fill the gaps by doing an additional survey.
link
What are the error factors? I am trying to get a grip on the information. We have lots of statistics and figures, which give us a good indication of what is happening, but is there an error factor?
I suspect that we have not calculated an error factor specifically, but we have covered all the main bodies—all the health and local government bodies and the largest central Government bodies—so the larger number of small bodies does not have a big impact on the overall picture in the report.
The challenge, which we have focused on in questioning, is the impact of staff who are transferred out of the formal public sector but who are still funded by the public sector in different ways. It is not easy to understand with the information that is readily available what that transfer means for the level of service that is provided and for value for money.
As Fraser McKinlay said, we can compensate for that lack of information in particular pieces of work, but we have to drill down and have a clear focus on what we are trying to achieve. We think that the report gives a good and reliable high-level picture, but there are gaps that are difficult to fill.
link
You highlight at paragraph 91 the fact that staff costs are likely to increase—you estimate a £433 million increase. However, as you say, that assumes that bodies will take no action and that things will stay static, which I assume is unlikely. The figure of £433 million is a lot of money. Are you satisfied that the organisations that you have audited have plans in place to address that?
That issue operates at two levels. Not all the survey bodies could look ahead even one year to give us information for 2014-15—a quarter could not provide that. Even for that short period, some bodies are not where they need to be in financial planning.
More significant in many ways is the longer look ahead to 2020. Given what we know about the likely financial climate that all public services will continue to work in and the pressures that we know are coming, it is critical that each organisation has a strategic workforce plan that gives it a picture for that period and that that is pulled together by sectors and by areas in which public bodies are looking to work together to reform public services and meet the challenges. Such strategic workforce plans are not in place for all organisations, other than in the NHS, which stands out as an example of good practice on that.
link
Did you get the impression that bodies are aware of that problem?
I ask Fraser McKinlay or Angela Cullen to answer, as they are closer to the issue.
10:00
Caroline Gardner is absolutely right. There is a lot of workforce planning activity going on, and we highlight a lot of it in part 2 of our report. All of the bodies that we examined had done workforce planning at service and departmental levels, but they had not necessarily pulled that together into an organisation-wide workforce plan, which we would like them to do—and we have made that recommendation to them.
Through the workforce planning that they were doing, the bodies had started to think about the level of staffing that they had, what they might need for the future and what gaps existed in their skills mix. They had started to try to address that, and we highlighted a couple of examples in our report where the bodies concerned had done so.
Caroline Gardner is right to point out that, according to our survey, 58 of the 80 bodies were able to provide information for next year, 2014-15, at the time when we did the audit. There was an awareness among the other bodies that it was something that they had to do—they had just not done it yet.
We are encouraging those bodies to provide the information, and we are making a recommendation to have rolling three-year forecasting for staff numbers and costs, so that bodies are aware of the staff numbers that they need and the associated costs, at least in the short-to-medium term. They can use that forecasting to build their longer-term workforce plans.
Overall, we say that most bodies have focused on the short term. They have been opportunistic—they have taken advantage of opportunities as they have arisen—and that has allowed them to manage things in the short term. However, that is not enough for the longer term, and it runs the risk of short-term choices being made that might make the challenges for the longer term more difficult. That is the shift that we would like to see coming through.
Before I bring in James Dornan, I wish to ask about the point that Colin Beattie raised regarding staff costs increasing, which is covered on page 36 of the report.
In exhibit 11, you show the staff costs for 2012-13 for councils and the NHS. You then cover the percentage increases due to pay progression—which is an annual increment to which some staff are entitled—and inflation. For councils, the increase is 2.26 per cent; for the NHS, it is 2.02 per cent. Those figures are higher than what has been published in terms of the pay agreements. Where do the figures come from?
I will ask Andra Laird to talk you through the detail. Those are average figures for sectors, so there is a lot of variation within them.
The figures came from the survey work. Individual bodies were asked to tell us what they were factoring into their future budgets for each of the different elements. The figures therefore come from the bodies’ own estimates, taken during the earlier part of this financial year. We have averaged the numbers across all the bodies to give those figures for the different sectors.
Is it not the case that the pay increases for councils and the NHS have been limited to 1 per cent?
It has been; the figures look ahead to what people expect to be doing in the period up to 2014-15.
As members will be aware, there are different elements to the overall growth in the pay bill. They include progression up the pay scales; the inflation element, which has been awarded by some councils but not others; and particular changes to particular staff groups. The figures are averaged for each sector, and we then reach an overall figure for Scottish public services as a whole.
I return to the point about ALEOs. Fraser McKinlay said that you did not see the need for further powers to follow the public pound as it is spent. There is at least one example in Glasgow of an ALEO that has had frequent losses—it has not been a one-off loss. Are you confident that you know how such situations have come about, and do you have the ability to take lessons that could be used by Glasgow City Council and other councils in the way in which they deal with ALEOs?
Yes, I am confident about that—we can do that at the moment.
Councils are allowed to create ALEOs, and some of them are doing so. As auditors, that is our starting position. The report that we published a couple of years ago, which Colin Beattie mentioned, explained how councils that were going to set up ALEOs should do so, and how they should run and maintain them.
As I say, it is something that we and the Accounts Commission are keeping under close review, and our judgment is that there is still plenty that we can do—indeed, there is probably more that we can do—with existing powers to look at exactly the type of examples that you have just mentioned.
There are occasions—there was one such occasion in Glasgow—when other regulators, OSCR in particular, have a very strong locus as well, so we need to ensure that the different regulatory regimes work well together, particularly in the case of a charity. If a charity is involved, that charity and OSCR will be very keen to ensure that the trustees are acting independently, while we will have an interest in ensuring that the council is governing it well. Those two things are not necessarily easily aligned, so that is work that we are progressing with OSCR.
That situation is not straightforward. At the moment, our view is that there are sufficient powers for us to do what we think needs to be done, but it is something that we are keeping under review.
I am delighted to hear that you think that you have a handle on the situation because, when I was a councillor in Glasgow, I found it very difficult to find out how the money was being spent and whether we were getting best value for it.
In paragraph 34 on page 17, which was mentioned earlier, you state in relation to the number of administrative grade posts:
“We do not have equivalent information for councils or other central government bodies.”
Is there a problem with gathering the information that you require from councils? Are some councils deliberately obstructive, is it just that they cannot get round to doing it, or are the systems not in place to make the information easily available to you?
We are not saying that there is a problem with council systems. This takes us back to Angela Cullen’s earlier point that information is collected in different ways by different types of public body and by different sectors. In the central Government, specific statistics cover administrative grades and other types of civil servants. Figures are collected differently for local government, and therefore the comparison is not a straightforward one to draw at all.
There is a case for better information in general as the focus on how savings are being achieved is increasing. The need to maintain services in the face of growing demands is also present, as we know. However, that is not a criticism; it is simply a reflection of the fact that figures are collected differently just now.
So do you think that there is a case for a certain uniformity in how data is collected?
I would put it slightly differently. Clearly, we are not looking to collect information for its own sake. There is a cost involved and we are not looking to fulfil that traditional bean-counter stereotype.
There is an argument for more transparency. Particularly at a time when people are having to make tough choices about how public money is spent, having more information about staff numbers and what staff are doing helps people to understand the impact of those choices.
I will continue with the ALEO theme.
When staff and services are transferred to an ALEO, the local council has no control over the prices that the public are charged for the leisure services, for example—they form quite a bulk of the ALEOs. If the public is making representations about such issues, accountability for prices presumably rests with the ALEO board. The flip-side of what James Dornan was talking about is: if an ALEO such as a leisure trust breaks even or even makes a profit, where does the profit go? Does it come back to the council, or is it just a case of the council making a readjustment in subsequent years to the ALEO’s funding? How does that work?
It will almost certainly depend on how the ALEO has been set up in the first place. All councils will agree terms of reference or a service level agreement—or whatever you want to call it—with the ALEO that they set up, and issues such as how profits will be dealt with will be factored into those agreements. I would certainly expect that any profit that was made would be reinvested back into the service.
You are right that, in the case of a leisure trust, it would be the responsibility of the board of the ALEO to make such decisions. In a sense, that is the point of transferring a service into an ALEO—the whole point of putting such bodies at arm’s length. Certainly, boards of leisure trusts that I have spoken to are very clear that one of the benefits of being an arm’s length body is that, depending on where they are in the country, their competition is not other local authority services; their competition is private sector health and fitness companies.
The trusts would argue—I am not saying whether this is right or wrong—that the whole process of putting them at arm’s length allows them to be a bit more commercial and be a bit more like the private sector, which would be part of the reason for doing that.
I am conscious of other members’ comments on scrutiny, but ALEOs are not new—they have been around for a while. Perhaps the pace of change has accelerated, but I share others’ concerns about accountability. We would not want the functions to slip through the net of public gaze—particularly the gaze of this committee—with such large amounts of public money going through the route to the ALEOs.
I do not know whether Audit Scotland even has the power to do something—it probably does not, given the witnesses’ answers so far—but there must be national scrutiny so that we can see how ALEOs are performing and whether we are getting the value for money that we seek.
The chart on page 17 of the report is about changes in the workforce numbers by age groups. I know that this is a small proportion of the entire workforce, but one box shows quite a drop in the number of staff who are under 20. However, paragraph 32 suggests that a targeted approach to increase the numbers of 16 to 24-year-olds in work has been taken and the numbers are going up. Will you explain what is happening? The figure has dropped 25 per cent. Why did it drop so much? What is happening with the recruitment suggested in paragraph 32?
In broad terms, our concern is exactly the one that you are highlighting: the workforce is ageing. The only age group shown on that chart that is getting bigger is the 50 to 59 age group, and those are people who are likely to be retiring in the next 15 years or so.
Another reason for organisations having good workforce plans is so that they understand where the workforce is located, the jobs that they are doing, whether there might be a shortage of teachers, social workers or other groups in 10 years, and how they plan to compensate for that. That ensures that they have the staff that they need in the right place and that their long-term succession planning continues.
On the specific point raised in paragraph 32, Andra Laird has the details.
The drop happened quite simply because bodies stopped recruiting and, when that happens, younger people tend to be affected most. The group is also smaller, so you see the drop more significantly in percentage terms.
The bodies in our case study recognised the effect that the drop was having on the workforce and the fact that young people were not coming in with new skills and thinking. They took the simple decision to go out of their way to open up the doors and bring in some more young people.
Is the figure explained by the transfers? A lot of young people are involved in the leisure trusts that I am familiar with. Has there been a transfer of a higher proportion of young staff through to ALEOs, including leisure trusts? If you think that the drop was a recruitment issue, it seems to me, judging by paragraph 32, that some of the councils are addressing the issue.
There is recognition of the issue. The question is whether the increases are big enough to make an impact on the overall pattern that you see in exhibit 4, which is definitely of an ageing workforce that is ageing more quickly than we all are because of reductions in the younger groups and increases in the older group as people move into it but are not replaced further down.
A common message that you see appearing again and again in the Audit Scotland report is that the Government and various partners are being asked to provide strategic guidance on how to redesign services, work better and so on. We have been saying that for a wee while, so how do we get a handle on how the work is progressing? That is key to the future and to making an impact on the issues.
It is probably expecting too much of Audit Scotland to make more direct recommendations, but your helpful guides at the back of some of your reports take us some way along that route. There is no such guide in this report similar to the ones that I recall in previous reports. Are we where we want to be in the service redesign agenda? Do we need to do more? What does it look like? When might we see those issues coming in front of the Public Audit Committee so that we can scrutinise progress?
The first bit of good news is that a good practice guide will be associated with this work. We are planning to publish it in January, and it will be available for public bodies to use.
Is that an Audit Scotland guide?
10:15
That is right. In our experience, it is easiest—although it is still difficult—to get a handle on exactly how the reform and redesign are going by looking at a specific service rather than looking across the piece. That is how we can get a handle on how public bodies are understanding the scale of the problem, considering the options that they have individually and together, and putting in place plans to achieve reform.
The indications are that public bodies find that quite difficult to do. Committee members will know—some better than others—that the integration of health and social care in Highland has been a year ahead of what is happening elsewhere in Scotland. We have learned some quite useful things about the challenges of bringing workforces together even when it involves, as it does at this stage, like-for-like replacement as a basis for redesign further on.
We are hearing that people would welcome more guidance from the Government, however it is produced, on how to tackle difficult issues with terms and conditions, how to deal with different pension schemes and the pension liabilities that come with them, and how the short-term costs of integration that sometimes arise can be managed. We do not have a magic wand to tell people how to do that part of the reform, but we feel that, if we are to make real progress on integrating health and social care, we need to change the way in which early-years services are delivered, look at reducing reoffending across Scotland’s communities, and get a handle on some of the important workforce issues in order to secure real change in the future.
Will you gather data to let the committee know, at some future date, how the service redesign agenda has been working, what savings have been made, and what council services are working together? Will we see something like that in the future?
We will probably play those big reform programmes into our programme of performance audits and decide, at an appropriate point, to have a look at health and social care integration along with early years services and reoffending—the other areas in which people are trying to make a step change in both prevention and partnership working—to see what we can learn from the progress that has been made so far.
Before I bring in Ken Macintosh, I go back to Willie Coffey’s point about ALEOs and accountability. In many, if not all, cases, when ALEOs are established they have one or more councillors from the local authority on their board. That is supposed to create a relationship and provide some element of feedback to the local authority. Does anyone who sits on the board of an ALEO not have a primary responsibility to the ALEO rather than to the council?
Yes.
Is that a legal requirement?
Yes. In the report that we published a couple of years ago, we spent quite a long time on that. It is an enormously difficult balancing act for elected members. If they are acting as a company director or a trustee of a charity, their only responsibility when they are wearing that hat is to that company or charity. It is difficult for them to strike the right balance and, in places where that has not worked well, that has been partly because people have not been clear about their roles and responsibilities. You have correctly identified one of the tensions that exist, convener.
So if a local authority says that it has some influence over an ALEO because it has a number of elected members on the board, that is just not true. Those elected members sit on the board as independent representatives and there is no requirement for them to carry out any council policy or functions when they make decisions on behalf of the ALEO—indeed, they should not do so.
That is the technical position. Colleagues in OSCR would make it very clear that if a councillor sits as a trustee of a charity, that is their primary responsibility. However, councils would argue that a councillor brings a perspective from the community to the board. They would not be formally representing the council, but it could be argued that it is entirely reasonable for someone who has links with and is representative of the community that the ALEO serves to be appointed to the board of that organisation.
Any councillor who attempts to bring council influence to bear on the ALEO is acting outwith the terms of their responsibility as a board member.
It will depend entirely on the make-up of the ALEO, but that is one of the tensions that councillors have to manage. It is not straightforward.
I highlight that the same tensions apply in the case of the arm’s-length foundations that are being established in the further education sector. There is the same question of how people maintain, on the one hand, independence and, on the other, accountability.
I suspect that we will come to that later.
What you said about the relationship between councillors and arm’s-length companies took me back to the days when I was a councillor. Did you find that, with many of the arm’s-length companies, a structure is in place whereby the board feeds into some sort of governing structure board that takes in all the ALEOs of the local authority?
We did not look at that as part of the work that we are discussing, but we know from other experience that the picture varies. We have asked auditors to report back on the governance arrangements that councils have in place in relation to their ALEOs. Some councils, such as Glasgow City Council, have a centralised model of the type that you describe, where a committee oversees how all the ALEOs work. They are a big part of how Glasgow delivers its services. In other places, the council’s leisure and education committee has oversight of the leisure trust and the care-related committee has oversight of other ALEOs.
There are different models, and it is not for us to say which is good and which is bad. What we are interested in is that councils have an appropriate model of governance that ensures oversight and good use of public money.
I have a question on that, as it has triggered other thoughts. Are ALEOs required to provide any more information to their council than they would provide to an interested member of the public?
The vast majority have, as part of the set-up agreement with the council, a requirement to report to the council on performance and budget arrangements. We would certainly look to see that such requirements are in place.
And that does not affect their charitable status.
No. There is a difference between having control and influence and reporting to a council committee. It is difficult to comment widely because a lot depends on the specifics of how things are set up.
I have a question about the overall numbers, because I am slightly confused. In part 2 of “Managing early departures from the Scottish public sector”, which was published earlier this year, you state:
“The number of staff employed in the Scottish public sector has fallen by about 40,000 since 2009”.
However, in the report that we are discussing today, you state that it has fallen by 26,000. Will you clarify that?
That is a good example of the lack of consistent information that is readily available. The earlier report was based simply on what is published—on the headline statistics. With the new report, we have been able to drill more deeply into the figures and understand them more thoroughly. Andra can help by giving you the detail on that.
Another big difference is that the early departures report included police and fire and the audit that we are discussing does not. When we take those things out, I think that you will find parity between the numbers.
When we take police and fire out? That cannot account for 14,000 members of staff, surely.
Are we talking about absolute numbers of people—
I was going to ask about that, too. You talk about whole-time equivalents in today’s report. Do you know the figure for head count as opposed to whole-time equivalents?
I do, but I do not have it with me. I can get it for you.
Does the figure in “Managing early departures from the Scottish public sector” refer to head count?
Yes.
We think that that is part of the difference. The early departures report focused on head count because that information was readily available. With the new report, we have done some more work to convert to whole-time equivalents, which accounts for some of the difference, too.
As part of your analysis, did you break down the jobs and look at the use of overtime, part-time staff and so on, given the ways in which jobs in the public sector have changed?
We have not done that for this piece of work. We have taken the data as far as we can for the purposes of the report, but it is an entirely appropriate question to ask, particularly against the backdrop of there being more flexibility across workforces in general and of the concerns that are being expressed about a two-tier workforce, in which people in the public sector have more employment protection and better terms and conditions than people outside the public sector or in arm’s-length organisations do. That is an area that we are increasingly interested in, as it becomes clear that those people outside public sector employment still give rise to public sector costs, if I can put it that way. We are increasingly interested in it, but it is not something that we have explored in this report.
It is not just the private sector. There are plenty of zero-hours contracts in universities and elsewhere as well.
There is a concern that, in some cases, when posts are gone consultants are hired, aside from ALEOs and outsourcing, to fill behind the jobs that are lost. Did you look at that at all?
Not directly in this case, but it is something that our auditors are interested in as they carry out their audit work. You will see that we found few examples of services that had been cut or radically changed as a result of budget pressures, and yet we know that a lot of money has come out of some public services over the past three or four years since the austerity regime came into effect. We are interested in understanding better the behind-the-scenes impact of those reductions now, which may not be visible in service levels or service quality, but which may be storing up problems for the future. For example, we have indications from some of our auditors of concerns about weakening the capacity of the finance function in some public bodies. We are keeping a close eye on that, and one of the things that we are recommending in our report is that public bodies themselves need to be more systematic in looking at the effects of changes that they are making to their workforces and at unintended costs such as the need to backfill with temporary staff or consultants. That is very much why we are making our recommendation about systematic monitoring of the impact of changes in the workforce.
Exhibit 7 comes from the survey in which we asked what methods the bodies were using. You will see towards the bottom of the list the line:
“Using more consultants and agency or temporary staff”.
Twelve councils, one health board and nine Scottish Government central bodies are reporting that they have done that. We have not gone to the next level and tried to understand exactly why, how or what that looks like, but that is how the bodies are reporting the increased use of those kinds of people.
I was just trying to find out what the policy behind that is. Clearly, all those bodies have to make savings, and cutting staff costs is the main way to make savings. I would have thought that public policy would be against using consultants. We heard from the chief constable last week that it is not a policy to have backfilling but that it happens on a day-to-day basis when staff are lost, so it is clearly happening. Your report also states that, in the NHS, spending on bank and agency nursing and midwifery staff has risen from £90.5 million in 2010-11 to £110 million in 2012-13, so I am getting a mixed picture about whether we are getting more use of that sort of post. In other words, we are losing permanent jobs in the public sector, but we are just replacing them with more expensive consultants and part-time workers.
The honest answer is that it is not a straightforward picture. It is clearly not a good use of money to make somebody redundant or to choose not to fill their post, and then spend more on backfilling with temporary staff or consultants, but there can be circumstances in which it is a good policy. I can give a couple of examples to illustrate that. If the work is cyclical or there is a short-term peak while restructuring is going on, it might be quite sensible to use a temporary member of staff to cover that, who can then be let go when better-value-for-money arrangements are in place in the longer term. Equally, it might make sense to keep an established post, or a number of established posts, vacant while a regrading exercise is going on or while new jobs are being designed and recruited to. Although, on the face of it, it might look as if it is always poor value for money, our experience is that it is more mixed than that.
Again, it comes back to our recommendation about better monitoring and reporting of the impact of workforce changes, with a particular eye on the unintended consequences and costs that can arise if the situation is not managed well.
10:30
Did any examples of poor value stand out?
Andra Laird or Angela Cullen might be able to highlight examples from the report.
What about bank midwifery nurses?
No. As we have made clear in previous reports, bank nurses can be a very good way of providing support on particularly busy wards that need a constant level of staff and attracting back into the workforce nurses who might otherwise have left the service because they could not balance work with domestic responsibilities or lifestyle preferences. Agency nurses tend to be less good value because they are more expensive and do not know the hospital and its systems as well; as a result, the service is of poorer quality. Nevertheless, it is a good example of where some of that expenditure is probably a very sensible use of money and where some of it is not and should be managed down as quickly as possible. It certainly highlights the need to understand what is going on behind the figures.
Exhibit 7, which Fraser McKinlay has already referred to, indicates only 12 examples—all of which are councils, I believe—of bodies that have implemented compulsory redundancies. However, there have been thousands of compulsory redundancies at colleges. Were they not included in the survey?
The data comes from the survey of 80 bodies that we carried out. I will ask Andra Laird to talk you through which bodies were covered.
The simple answer is that we did not include colleges in the audit.
You did not.
No.
But do you recognise that there is—or at least has been over the past few years—widespread use of compulsory redundancies in colleges?
I do not think that we have the data to answer your specific question, but we did not include either colleges or police and fire in this piece of work because of the amount of deliberate reform work going on in those areas. Instead of including them in the broad approach that we have taken in this report, we thought that it would make more sense to review both in specific pieces of work that would let us answer the kinds of questions you are asking.
Could you provide the committee with a list of the 12 organisations where there have been compulsory redundancies?
Yes.
According to the exhibit, they are all councils.
As far as experience is concerned, one difficult question is about the people who are leaving the public sector and the impact of their departure on services. In that respect, the picture in the report is very mixed. In paragraph 100, you talk about “small-scale” service cuts and give the example of grass cutting. However, in paragraph 35, you refer to a loss of 2,000 or so teachers in the past couple of years and an increase in pupil teacher ratios, which I imagine means that class sizes are going up. Given that such cuts will, I would have thought, directly affect the quality of the public service on offer, do you detect any strong policy to protect the level and quality of service, or is that picture also mixed?
In the report, we say that evidence of the effect on service quality and levels is hard to come by because it is not clear that all public bodies are monitoring the situation as systematically as we think they should be. Our experience is that all public bodies are doing their best to protect public services, which is probably why we found so few examples of services being cut or dispensed with altogether. As for our, your and the public’s understanding of the impacts of the financial pressures that public services are working under, we think it very important to have more systematic monitoring and capturing of such impacts and, very specifically, planning for education, social care and health services and the likely impact of an ageing workforce at a time of rising demand and our increasing expectations. Workforce plans would allow the bodies responsible to answer such questions and let them identify more innovative ways of managing those pressures through partnership working and the redesign of services and jobs.
Finally, one of the biggest worries that you highlight is the limits in certain sectors on early departure schemes and any potential to reduce the workforce any further, with the implication of greater pressure on pay and so on. Have you been able to compare the amount of money saved in the public sector through pay freezes and pay controls with that saved by reducing the size of the public sector?
In the report, we have highlighted the overall changes that have been made: changes in workforce numbers as a result of the use of different exit routes—if I can call them that—such as early retirement and early departure, the non-replacement of posts and transfers to arm’s-length bodies and private sector organisations; and the reduction in the overall cost. However, at the moment, it is not possible to break down the differences in the contribution made to cost reduction by the different mechanisms that are set out in exhibit 7. In our report on managing early departures, we were able to give some assurance about the payback period for the investment made in such departures, but there is obviously a wider cost to having fewer people employed in the public sector if there are no jobs elsewhere to absorb those who have left. It is not a straightforward trade-off and does not offer many alternatives in the current financial climate. It is certainly a difficult challenge and, again, it is why we think that information about the impact of the workforce changes that we have highlighted and the terms and conditions of the hidden public sector workforce—if I can use that term—in arm’s-length and private sector organisations is so important. It will give us a sense of those trade-offs and allow you as elected representatives to make decisions about them and the wider public to understand the impact.
Fraser McKinlay said that there was some evidence that some services were transferring to arm’s-length bodies as a result of the personalisation of care agenda. I also understand that, under the same agenda, individuals are able to buy their own care from private sector companies or, indeed, individuals who wish to be employed to provide a particular service. Have you been able to quantify the number of posts that have been affected in that way?
No, convener, but your question allows me to trail a joint report that we are doing for the Accounts Commission and the Auditor General on reshaping care for older people, which will look at the implementation and delivery of that very policy. That report is coming in the spring, so watch this space.
Okay. I thank the Auditor General, Angela Cullen, Fraser McKinlay and Andra Laird for their evidence.
I suspend the meeting for a few minutes to allow a changeover of witnesses for the next item of business.
10:37 Meeting suspended.
10:41 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 4 Dec 2013 →- 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 128
- 10:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 296
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.