Scottish schools are consistently excellent and, importantly, there is substantial evidence that they are getting better. We can see that from last year’s record-high exam passes and the positive school leavers destinations data, from which we should all take great satisfaction.
We have the right elements in place to secure that excellent, world-class system. We are making good progress with the current reform programme to deliver that aim. I compliment the inspiring and dedicated teachers who are rising to the challenge of delivering a modern education for their pupils through the curriculum for excellence.
The glowing picture that the First Minister paints is rather contradicted by this week’s publication from the commission on school reform, on which one of his party’s councillors, Paul McLennan, from East Lothian Council, served. How will the Government take forward the report’s key recommendations, which are that greater school autonomy and greater diversity of provision are required to improve standards and, in particular, help those who are being failed by the current system?
Alex SalmondSNPThe First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
As the education secretary has said, there are some interesting proposals in the document, and they will be treated very seriously. That is why he welcomed the document.
I am sure that Murdo Fraser will accept that the figures that we have on international comparisons show that the relative decline from which Scottish education was suffering was reversed in 2009, when our position of stability in the top quartile of Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development countries was achieved.
I really do not think that Murdo Fraser should get into misrepresenting what the commission said. Let me directly quote Keir Bloomer, who chaired the commission—[Interruption.] On the radio on Monday, he said:
“It’s very important I think to see this in perspective. This is not a crisis, Scotland’s education system is not failing. On the contrary it has high standards, remarkably consistent high standards across the whole range of its schools.”
If that is what Keir Bloomer says, cannot Murdo Fraser try, along with Keir Bloomer, to get matters into perspective? Can Murdo Fraser see the positive suggestions that are made in the report and take them forward for the good of Scottish education?
The commission spoke of the devastating consequences of social and economic disadvantage. Will the First Minister allocate additional resources, to enable schools in disadvantaged areas to tackle the issue head-on?
Alex SalmondSNPThe First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
We look substantially at positive proposals to attack poverty and disadvantage in Scottish society, as the member well knows when he examines this Government’s record in terms of our ambitions for early intervention to tackle what has been an historical failing in Scotland in not achieving the universality of excellence in education that we want to achieve.
I have to say to the member that the way to secure that universality and get every child in Scotland an educational chance is not to impose tuition fees when they try to get into higher education.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.