Under agenda item 4, we consider PE1460, on the improvement of services and resources to tackle chronic pain. The committee will take evidence from the Minister for Public Health and from Healthcare Improvement Scotland. I welcome the minister and the HIS witnesses: Robbie Pearson, the director of scrutiny and assurance; Lesley Holdsworth, the programme lead; and Dr Steve Gilbert, the national clinical lead for chronic pain. I also welcome to the evidence session Jackie Baillie MSP.We will go immediately into questions. Any of the witnesses may answer any of the questions.This whole issue has not been handled very well. Can the minister or HIS give an early indication of how HIS will start to capture relevant data and ensure that a clean reporting mechanism is in place going forward?
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Chronic Pain Services (PE1460)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Chic Brodie SNP 9
- Robbie Pearson Healthcare Improvement Scotland 9
- Michael Matheson 8
- Jim Eadie SNP 6
- Lesley Holdsworth Healthcare Improvement Scotland 5
- Jackson Carlaw Con 5
- Jackie Baillie Lab 4
- John Wilson SNP 3
- Anne McTaggart Lab 2
- Malcolm Chisholm Lab 2
- Dr Gilbert 2
- Michael Matheson SNP 1
- Angus MacDonald SNP 1
- Dr Steve Gilbert Healthcare Improvement Scotland 1
The record
58 contributionsHealthcare Improvement Scotland certainly has lessons to learn on transparency, and that point was very much acknowledged in the letter to the committee from the chief executive, Mr Glennie. Indeed, it was very much accepted in the 30 April meeting with the cabinet secretary.Data is a fundamental part of understanding the patient’s journey—how they access care, how they are managed within primary care and how they are subsequently moved into other more specialist services. As we take this forward over the next six to 12 months, capturing data in a robust, transparent and understandable way will be a key issue for us, which goes beyond waiting times into understanding the whole patient experience. Dr Holdsworth will pick up on that point.
I have recently taken over as programme lead for this work. We have been working very closely on exactly that issue with our steering group, our partners and so on and, by the end of this year, we will have some really robust data that will give a better reflection of patient experience, which is obviously very important, as well as an outcome perspective. We are working with a number of partners on that and we will have a report available.
So we have an assurance that there will be no more comments about data being sparse and of poor quality, about it having been construed as misleading or about the documentation not being public facing, and instead will have openness, transparency and robustness.
I assure you of that.
Thank you.
I declare a particular interest in this issue. As some of the panel will be aware, I am one of the co-conveners of the cross-party group on chronic pain, along with Jackie Baillie and my colleague Jackson Carlaw.This is about the amount of data that is collected and recorded and how that data is presented. A number of the individuals who have made submissions and who are very interested in the delivery of chronic pain services are concerned that the data that is being collected or pulled together is not sufficient to record what is actually happening in the various health boards.Through the work of the cross-party group, we know that individuals have raised a number of issues. They have spoken about things happening in one health board area but not in others. There seems to be a discrepancy around what is happening and how people are being dealt with, either at a primary level or by consultants. Does the minister or anyone else on the panel wish to comment on that?
There is no doubt that there has been patchiness in how services have been delivered across different health boards. Different health boards have been moving at different rates on this issue.HIS has taken on board the points that were made about the process that it went through to collate the data and publish its report. There is a need for that to be done much more transparently and for the data that is being used to be much more robust, as Robbie Pearson and his colleagues have recognised. They will seek to address that and do it more effectively, and I am confident that they will. The data provides an important resource for us to evaluate the progress that boards are making on the issue.Achieving a more consistent approach does not mean exactly the same thing happening uniformly in every board area. There will be different responses, depending on a board’s situation. Therefore, we have asked all our boards to have in place a service improvement group, which will be responsible for producing the service improvement plan, and that plan will be submitted to the Scottish Government by the end of this month.The work will then be taken forward and built into local delivery plans. In 2014, part of the plan will clearly set out the progress that each territorial board plans to make in the coming year on improving services around chronic pain. That will allow us to consider the proposed planning and services in local board areas and ensure that those are built into the local delivery plans.The local delivery plans are very clear. They show what the boards say, what they intend to do and how they intend to go about it, so we will see that for chronic pain services. That approach of using the local delivery plans, along with addressing how the data is captured and the service improvement groups, will allow us to measure the data more effectively and to achieve a greater degree of consistency in how boards are dealing with the whole issue.
I wish to echo that point. The service improvement groups are fundamental in embedding the improvements on the ground. Over the past six months, there has been a positive uptake from NHS boards. Data will become increasingly important in capturing the patient’s journey so that we understand the progress that has been made against the original report five or six years ago.
One of the issues that some of the individuals involved have raised is the financial reporting by health boards of the budgets that are available for the service. Should the committee be aware of any issues with how boards are identifying and reporting on budgetary constraints in the delivery of chronic pain services throughout Scotland?
On the budgetary aspect, chronic pain services would be viewed as a core part of an NHS board’s service delivery. They should be funded within the board’s overall budget for whatever services they need to provide.We have provided boards with some pump-prime funding to help them to establish some of the arrangements that are needed to improve services at a local level. Some of that will help to support the work that boards are taking forward around the service improvement groups. The specific delivery of chronic pain services is funded through the boards’ overall budgets, but we are providing them with some additional pump-prime funding to assist them in taking forward some of the early work.11:15
I have a question on the social care model. In the debate in the chamber on 29 May, the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing stated that the Scottish Government is “very committed” to the principle that services for sufferers of chronic pain should be delivered through not just a medical health model but a social model. How does the Scottish Government intend to achieve a social model of care for sufferers of chronic pain?
A key part of delivering the social model is taking a much more holistic approach to the needs of people with chronic pain. That does not just involve looking at the medical aspect, which is what has traditionally been done under the medical model. Rather than just looking at what treatment people require and what types of clinical intervention might be appropriate, the social model involves looking at the impact that the condition can have on other aspects of people’s lives, such as their daily activities, their lifestyle, their home environment and their employment. That is a much wider and more holistic approach.The chronic pain service model that we are taking forward in Scotland involves a tiered approach. Services can be delivered at a local level and supported through voluntary groups, and there is a range of different services to help to support individuals and give them advice and information. More clinical interventions are made at the primary or secondary level as and when they are necessary. I see the chronic pain service model as a key part of that holistic approach to supporting people.Another aspect is that a number of our boards have established chronic pain programmes and others have pain management multidisciplinary teams. In the past, a patient who presented with chronic pain could see only a doctor to try to get that addressed, but that approach does not necessarily fit in with delivery of the social model. The multidisciplinary approach is important. Occupational therapists, physiotherapists and others can help to support people in addressing effectively some of the other consequences of chronic pain.We try to deal with things at different levels, and alongside that there is a multidisciplinary approach involving different professionals, all of whom have a contribution to make to delivering the intended outcomes under the social model.
Thank you, minister.
Patient participation is an important part of this. What steps is the Scottish Government taking to ensure that there is a greater level of patient participation in the continuing development of services?
I mentioned the service improvement groups. All 14 of our territorial boards will have such groups in place, and they will have patient participation on those groups. Alongside that, we have the national chronic pain steering group, which is looking to increase the level of patient participation in its programme and involve a greater number of patients. Therefore, there is patient involvement both at a local level through the service improvement groups and at the national level through the national steering group.
How does that relate to the HIS work? Perhaps Dr Holdsworth could say something about the work that HIS is doing, or is it all part of the same thing?
HIS is leading on the national group. With the creation of the service improvement groups, we need to look at how we can ensure that they feed in more effectively to the national steering group. I understand that, at its meeting in May, it discussed how it can ensure that the leads for the service improvement groups at a local level can feed in more effectively to the national steering group and how they can also increase patient participation in the process. That will help to ensure that the link from the national to the local level is much more consistent.I ask Robbie Pearson and his colleagues whether they want to add to that.
To reiterate the point, Healthcare Improvement Scotland has a legal responsibility to ensure that we comply with the duty of user focus. Given the concerns raised by the petition about the level of public involvement in the chronic pain steering group, perhaps Dr Holdsworth can elaborate a little on the thinking behind the relationship between the chronic pain steering group at national level and the work that is under way at local level through the service improvement groups.
I reiterate what the minister has said. We are currently working on putting in place strong public participation in the service improvement groups, which will collectively have a much stronger and more robust link with the national steering group. At our meeting of the national steering group in May, membership was discussed as an agenda item, so we recognise the need to have much stronger and reinforced patient participation. Work is in hand to take that forward.
The next question is from Angus MacDonald.
Convener, my question on patient consultation has been covered.
We move on to Jim Eadie.
Good morning, panel. We have already heard evidence this morning about the importance of capturing data in a robust and transparent way. Mr Pearson has illustrated the need to do that so that we can understand better the patient’s journey. The minister has said that it is important to evaluate the progress that NHS boards are making. That will no doubt be of increasing importance as we seek to roll out the delivery of the local plans that you mentioned. In Healthcare Improvement Scotland’s “Update Report on Scottish Pain Management Services”, a range of factors are mentioned in the data spreadsheet that were presumably part of the audit but are not covered in the “Detailed findings” section of the update report. Can you explain why that was the case?
As I said at the start, on reflection it would have been preferable to have all the data not only on the website but accessible within the report. That is a point of learning for us in Healthcare Improvement Scotland. In producing the document, a balance had to be struck in providing something that is accessible to the public, but we perhaps pitched the balance in the wrong way in not making the data readily available. The need to ensure that the facts and findings are available is a point of learning for us. We have taken that point from the petition and from other feedback.Dr Holdsworth might want to elaborate on that.
I reiterate what our chief executive said at the cross-party group about this not being our finest hour, but we have taken those issues on board. Do you have a specific question in relation to that?
The question that I posed was about the reason why information on issues such as referral to spinal cord stimulation and waiting list initiatives was not included. Was that because you had insufficient data, or was it because you had sufficient data but chose not to include the information?
The number of people being referred for spinal cord stimulation or residential pain management programmes was very small. Some boards did not refer any patients and some referred one or two, so we felt that we could not draw a conclusion from that. However, it was useful for us to look at how many people were referred and to discuss with boards why some boards sent a lot more patients, so we looked at the variation there.In the tertiary part of the service model, which deals with intensive pain management options such as residential programmes or spinal cord stimulation, we are organising for the centres that perform such procedures to draw up their own referral and treatment guidelines. We want the outcome measures to be more tied down so that there is collaboration between the centres that carry out those more interventional procedures.
I think that you are saying that there was a lack of information available rather than—
There was only a little bit—
Excuse me, sorry. Are you saying that there was a lack of information available rather than a deliberate exclusion of information from the report?
Yes, we felt that it was not something that we could report on.
I have an additional question for the minister, on the development of an intensive pain management service. The Government has made a commitment to that, which has been widely welcomed, drawing on the experience of patients who have had to access the service south of the border. Where are we with that?
NHS National Services Scotland is presently in the final stages of drafting the consultation order, and has also established a specialist group that is helping to inform us in that process, and we hope to publish the consultation next week.
Thank you.
I have already been outed by my colleague as one of the co-conveners of the cross-party group on chronic pain. There are two or three things that I want to ask about, and I shall try to be concise. You have entered into a bit of mea culpa and contrition over the report, but when we are talking about the importance of patient participation, who actually decides who the patient representatives will be? I would have expected them to be a bit more vocal. I would not necessarily want to characterise them as friends of the establishment, but who is responsible for ensuring that the patient representatives are thoroughly independent and are asking the questions that might have led to all this information being available publicly sooner? How do we ensure, going forward, that we have the right patient representatives and ones who will genuinely ensure the independent voice of the patients?
To pick up on your point about patient involvement, we need to learn lessons from this experience, particularly by ensuring that there is an active voice for the service improvement groups and that that voice plays into the national steering group. It is particularly important that that voice is heard as we design local or national services. Dr Holdsworth might want to pick up on your point about the actual involvement.
We are working closely with the major patient representative bodies—the Pain Association Scotland, Pain Concern and the Health and Social Care Alliance Scotland—and we are also looking to build on the service improvement groups and to get more local representation. We are trying to cast a wide net to get those groups who are active advocates for patients as well as pain sufferers themselves at local level.
I will be full of anticipation to see who the patient representatives are. As a general consequence of the report, there was an underappreciation of where we had progressed to on chronic pain services delivery, and I listened to what you had to say about that, minister. You were with us recently to discuss health boards’ lack of application of the strategy on insulin pumps, and you put a robust requirement on health boards to update you on a regular basis on the progress that they were making towards the plan, which in many respects they had failed on. How would you compare the reporting process that you are requiring in relation to the provision of chronic pain services to that which you put in place for achieving the insulin pump targets?
The requirement for reporting on chronic pain is more robust now than it has been in the past. For example, the service improvement groups for each of our boards have to submit their plans for us to consider. We will have that completed by the end of this month, and we will then look at how to build those plans into their local development plans for 2014. The Scottish Government receives a draft copy of the local development plans for each of our boards, so that we can compare them against what was set out by the service improvement groups and look at how they intend to deliver those plans in the coming year. We have a robust mechanism that allows us to establish a clear pattern of how boards are taking work forward, and also to see which boards are making more progress than others. We must then ensure that, at national level, the steering group continues to monitor progress at local level through the service improvement groups. A combination of factors, including the local development plan, the plans that have to be submitted by the service improvement groups and the national steering group, give us a robust architecture for monitoring how we take this forward and for addressing any issues that might come up in due course.
Finally, in the debate in the chamber, the cabinet secretary announced the consultation to which you have referred. I believe that there are three principal options on which you seek to consult. One is the original intention of the petition, which is a pain management centre equivalent to that at Bath. A second option is some sort of mobile resource, and a third is improved services within local environments. Obviously, in terms of the investment that would be required, the easiest of the three options to quantify is the first, because an equivalent exists and one can understand what it would cost to set up a centre. Is it the Government’s intention that a parallel level of investment would follow each of those three options? Have you quantified what you think the level of investment in chronic pain management would be as a result of whatever option is considered best after the consultation? Could it be a mix of those, or is that wishful thinking, given the level of resource that you have available?11:30
You appear to be ahead of me, because I have not seen the consultation document yet.
I thought that the cabinet secretary announced those options.
The situation will broadly be in that frame. During the debate, some members thought that we were considering consulting on whether we should have a residential service in Scotland or not. That is not the case. We have given a commitment that there will be a residential service of some form in Scotland. We now need to consult on the model for delivering that service in Scotland and we will launch a consultation next week. During the consultation period, we will see what the views are; if views come back around a particular option and if that option is, for example, for a single site which has an in-bed facility and can also provide an out-patient facility, we will consider the resource implications of that for us and how we will fund that particular service. I do not want to get into a situation where I say, “We’ve decided that we’re going to go with option X, because that’s what the budget is.” Let us see the outcome of the consultation and from that point assess what the options are in terms of cost. We have to be mindful that we need to try to provide a service in Scotland that can meet the needs of patients across the country. During the debate, the cabinet secretary referred to the fact that we need to think about how, if we have a single-site option in Scotland, we can ensure that we also provide the necessary support and advice in other parts of the country, such as Grampian, the Highlands or the islands, where that option might not be successful for those patients. We have to find a service option that allows us to provide a special service that may be residential, but also provide support and assistance in remote areas in which people may not be able to access that service as readily.
link
Given that we come now to the third and final co-convener of the cross-party group on chronic pain, most of the subject has been covered. The consultation on the specialist centre is very welcome. Currently, we think it acceptable to send people from all parts of Scotland to Bath, so what is proposed would be a vast improvement, whether we have a one-site centre or whether other mechanisms of delivery are explored. I acknowledge, too, the acceptance of the lack of clarity and transparency in the report. That allows us to move on and to welcome the very helpful momentum injected by the minister and the cabinet secretary. That said, may I pursue a little bit the question of what will be done with the data? If I understood correctly, we can expect that at the end of December. I am assuming that it will be in published form. Will that include not just a measurement of patient experience and outcomes—important though those are—but the numbers in whole-time equivalents of clinicians, nurses, physiotherapists, psychologists and occupational therapists? When a multidisciplinary team was described, a box was simply ticked to say that there was one. However, clearly there is a difference between a fifth of a consultant and a whole consultant. Transparency on those figures would be particularly welcome. Equally, the minister mentioned that there would be transparency on waiting times. I take it that that applies to the first and second appointment as well.
On those points, the data is important. It is also important that we can demonstrate the mix of services on the ground and the range of staff involved. We will certainly pick up the point about waiting times and the journey in respect of the AHP advanced practice musculoskeletal project.
link
That was very helpful.My final question goes back to Jackson Carlaw’s point, which I do not think you addressed, of who currently decides the patient representatives on the national steering group.Secondly, I hear a lot of discussion about involving people in the service groups. Admirable as that might be, it does not replace direct representation on the national steering group. Are there plans to increase the number of patient representatives on the national steering group?
Answering the second question first, I have to say yes. Indeed, that is fundamental to our statutory responsibilities and user focus duty. We have not necessarily always got that right in the past, but we are learning from what we have done and will ensure that representation on the group is broadened.
link
With respect, I did not get an answer to my first question, which was a repeat of Jackson Carlaw’s. On the basis of my persistence, I seek leave to ask it again.
Obviously, decisions have been made in Healthcare Improvement Scotland about who should be involved. We and Scottish Government colleagues will learn from that and need to ensure that there is broader representation on the group.
link
So it was this huge organisation—Healthcare Improvement Scotland—that made the decision. Was there no one person who decided the national steering group’s make-up?
That was before my time in Healthcare Improvement Scotland, but I am happy to come back to the committee on the process of making those decisions and the engagement with individuals.
That would be helpful. I always like it when members say that they have a final question and then ask another three.We have had a very helpful evidence session. I am happy to say that things have moved on and hope that with the assurances of openness, transparency and robustness that we have received we do not have the cabinet secretary or, indeed, the minister turning up at meetings and not knowing what the situation is. We will no doubt keep an eye on what happens.The committee now has several options; indeed, members might wish to suggest options of their own. We can close the petition under rule 15.7 on the basis that the chamber debate on chronic pain took place on 29 May, that the cabinet secretary—and, indeed, the minister today—has committed to establishing an intensive pain management service in Scotland and that the Government has set out its aims for implementing the Scottish service model over the two years for which funding has been provided. Secondly—and this might be the more sensible option—we could defer further consideration until November, when we could seek an update from the Government on its short-term commitments such as the delivery of the intensive pain management service.
On the basis that I have ordered a cooked breakfast from time to time and the waitress has forgotten to bring it, I am in favour of deferring further consideration of the petition until November, when we can see the outcome of the consultation and what we are going to receive.
I have to say, Jackson, that it does not show.
It might just be because he is Jackson Carlaw that his breakfast is not getting delivered—but that is another story.I agree with Mr Carlaw that we should defer consideration until November, not just to ensure that the consultation period is over and the cabinet secretary and the minister have deliberated and made decisions on the matter but to allow us to hear again from Healthcare Improvement Scotland about its reporting mechanisms and structures and how it has improved on what was seen as a disaster when it previously tried to report on what was happening out there.
Is that the committee’s verdict?Members indicated agreement.
I thank the minister; his Government officials, Mark O’Donnell, Rachael Dunk and Gillian Gunn; and, from Healthcare Improvement Scotland, Robbie Pearson, Lesley Holdsworth and Dr Steve Gilbert. I suspend the meeting to allow the witnesses to leave.11:39 Meeting suspended.
11:41 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 25 Jun 2013 →- 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:30 Current Petition Petitions · 50
- 09:30 Tackling Child Sexual Exploitation in Scotland Committee business · 60
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 58
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 12
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 15
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.