Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Wednesday 31 May 2000 Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee Procedure 72 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Showing John Swinney only · show everyone

John Swinney’s contributions

23 contributions
John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Item 3 is on the committee's future work programme. There is a paper from the clerks, some of which will look—if members have good memories—hauntingly familiar in relation to some of the material that we have looked at before. The first part of the paper considers the factors that would affect the choice by the committee of the inquiries that we might take forward from September. Those are the factors that we utilised in deciding on our inquiry last year. In section 2 of the paper, on outstanding commitments, the clerks have highlighted three points that we must bear in mind in addition to the general considerations. Next year we will have a substantial piece of legislation to consider—the Government's proposals on student finance. We expect that legislation to be published in October 2000. At some stage thereafter we will begin our stage 1 consideration of that bill. We must remember that many of the issues that will be involved in that will already have been the subject of substantial consultation, both by the Cubie inquiry and by the Government consultation on the document "Scotland the Learning Nation: Helping Students", whose publication was announced last Wednesday by the minister and which raises some further issues for pre-legislative consideration. We will certainly have a stage 1 process in the autumn and winter. Stage 2 will more than likely take place after the turn of the year. The bill will be much larger than the Education and Training (Scotland) Bill and will absorb a substantial amount of committee time at stage 2. The expectation is that the bill will have completed its passage by the Easter recess next year. That is a major factor that we have to bear in mind for the period from this autumn to spring next year. The committee has started an inquiry on fuel prices. We took evidence in late January—in a meeting in the chamber—then asked a group of members to undertake further investigation privately. We have had one meeting with one of the fuel companies, but other meetings have been difficult to secure due to diary issues. We took a decision as a committee that we would not undertake much more work on this subject until the Office of Fair Trading report on petrol pricing was published. That is still a bit of a movable feast; the most recent indication is that it will be published in late June, which is considerably later than the date expected when we examined the matter in January. We must decide whether we take the fuel price inquiry to an interim conclusion, allocate time to take it further forward or park that inquiry as a whole. In our local economic development inquiry, the committee considered that there were issues of congestion in the lifelong learning sector that it was minded to return to in its inquiries.Section 3 notes three suggestions that were received in response to the recent call for subjects of inquiry from members: Scotland's competitive position; the impact of the new economy; and the funding policies of the Scottish Further Education Funding Council and the Scottish Higher Education Funding Council. Points d, e and f are general issues that have been raised with the clerks in the past year to be included in our résumé of issues on which we have not yet come to a position. Points g to m cover a range of issues that the committee considered as potential topics for inquiry in September, but has not tackled.The paper is for discussion today, with a view to giving the clerks guidance on the inquiries that we are likely to take forward from September onwards, to allow them to develop an appropriate remit. The committee will have to approve the remit at a meeting before the parliamentary recess, with a view to calling for evidence to be submitted before we embark on any inquiry in September. Reflecting on our work in the past 12 months, I would say that the local economic development inquiry was probably the summit in terms of the size of inquiry that members would want to undertake. It was a bit on the big side and took a long time. We have legislation to consider, which will dominate our programme probably from October to February or March, so it might be appropriate to consider having shorter inquiries.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Without asking you to go into the detail of what is in the committee report—

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I would not expect you to. Is it a reflective look at the governance of institutions?

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Does it make forward recommendations?

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I will draw this discussion to a conclusion. We need to consider a sequence of issues that have been raised this morning. I will deal with them in no particular order. We have to acknowledge that we have a commitment to scrutinise the student finance legislation—that is a given. Although it will not take up our time exclusively, it will dominate our work between October and February. Therefore, we will have six weeks of parliamentary time in September and October in which to carry out an inquiry, and we will have about three months in spring and summer of next year in which to conduct other inquiries.On the fuel inquiry, the OFT told us this morning that it expects to publish its report in late June. If my memory serves me correctly, we were told in the chamber on 31 January that the report would be published in mid-March. Then we were told that it would be mid-April, then mid-May. Now we are told it will be late June—and we know that the March deadline already represented a slip in the time scale. I cannot say definitively when the OFT will report, so we have to decide what to do with our inquiry in the context of the information that we have from the OFT and should not depend on the OFT report being published within a convenient time scale. We can arrange private meetings with the oil companies and produce some form of conclusion. However, there are limitations on what we can do, because we have accepted that the channel of communication with the oil companies will be private and our report must respect that commercial confidentiality. We can hold meetings in June and, as the reporter from the sub-group on this subject, I will present a report to the committee on 27 June, bringing the inquiry to some sort of conclusion, even if it is an interim conclusion and we have to return to the subject. We can certainly aim to do that before the summer recess, if that is acceptable. Fergus Ewing has raised another, smaller, subject of inquiry: representatives of Highland Council and the chamber of commerce have requested a hearing from the committee. The question is whether the committee is minded to hear those organisations on either 14 June or 27 June. The committee will have to make that decision in a few moments, in the context of what Fergus said.Our main inquiry for the next parliamentary year boils down to three areas. The first is congestion in lifelong learning, which has been suggested by several members and to which we referred in our report on local economic development services. Some of the issues that are involved will be addressed by Frank Pignatelli in his work on the Scottish university for industry. It is a question of whether we want to take a view on the agenda that he is running, to ensure that it takes the right direction and tackles all the issues that are involved—certainly workplace learning issues, but possibly not the wider issues of service congestion in further and higher education, which have wider implications for the kind of rationalised approach that might be considered.I find it difficult to work out how we could credibly establish a link between an inquiry into the congestion of lifelong learning services and our inquiry into the new economy. I felt that we strained the credibility of the link that we made between local economic development services and the workplace learning environment. We tagged the issue on, to give the impression of a balance between enterprise and lifelong learning, but we did not do it justice. The material that we gathered for the local economic development review gives us a fair body of evidence on lifelong learning issues, which would provide a good starting point for a more detailed inquiry into lifelong learning.The final area to be addressed is a combination of the first two items in section 3 of the programme: Scotland's competitive position and the impact of the new economy. I suspect that we are intending to pose a question for an inquiry such as, "Is Scotland equipped for the new economy of global competition?" The aim of that inquiry would be to test whether Scotland is able to compete in a global environment, whether enough is being done in Scotland, whether we are appropriately focused on the issues that are raised by globalisation and the new economy, and whether we are equipped to handle that challenge.Let me summarise the decisions that we must make. First, we need to arrive at a stance on the fuel inquiry and should try to report back on that by the end of this parliamentary term. Secondly, we need to decide whether to give a hearing to the representatives of Highland Council and the chamber of commerce before the summer recess. Thirdly, we must decide whether, as the first inquiry of next year, we will pursue an inquiry into service congestion in the lifelong learning sector or an inquiry into the new economy and global competition: I cannot foresee a hybrid inquiry of those two, although I am open to other members' views. Maybe we can discuss those decisions and come to a conclusion later.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

The next item on the agenda is consideration of whether the committee wants to have a say in the transport bill. It has not been published yet and scrutiny of it is not expected to be completed by the recess. We will have more time to look at that bill, but we may have to consider some aspects of it at stage 1.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I do not dispute that, but I think that we must be clear about the route that we are taking. In the local economic development report we made a point about congestion in lifelong learning. I accept that there is an education and training dimension to the new economy inquiry, but when directing our clerks to produce a remit we must come up with something that is sufficiently clear to allow us to call for evidence, consider it and report on it. We cannot have a remit for our inquiry that is so broad that people could submit virtually anything to it.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

We are in the process of arriving at our conclusions, so we will reflect on those points.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

To conclude, we have broadly agreed that we will aim to have further discussions with the fuel companies and report a position to the committee at the meeting on 27 June, if that is practically possible. We cannot guarantee that as it depends on diaries and the OFT.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Secondly, the consensus, as I judge it, is that we want to undertake some form of inquiry into whether Scotland is equipped for the new economy and global competition, commencing in September. I will ask the clerks for a draft remit to address the point that Fergus Ewing made, to focus that inquiry. We will consider that at our meeting on 14 June. So that the paper can be circulated in advance, any comments on that remit should be made to the clerks by Monday at the latest. I assume that we will then take on a commitment to look at the lifelong learning agenda towards the middle of next year, but we can revisit that in due course. We have a commitment to undertake scrutiny of the student finance bill; we await the Government's timetable on that. On Fergus Ewing's point about the Highland economy, we should look at our remaining three meetings. On 12 June we will consider the Education and Training (Scotland) Bill. The duration of that meeting and whether we can complete stage 2 consideration depends on how many amendments are lodged. The Executive has told us that it will lodge a small cluster of technical amendments, which ministers will speak to, but it is up to members of this committee and other MSPs to decide how many more amendments there are. I am optimistic that we can conclude stage 2 consideration in one meeting. That would leave 14 June with two potential agenda items: confirmation of our remit for the inquiry on the new economy, and any consideration that we wish to give to stage 1 of the transport bill—we will discuss that in a moment. That would leave time to hear evidence from a couple of representatives of Highland organisations, but for no more than 50 minutes to an hour in that meeting. I am afraid that I am going to be the party pooper on George Lyon's suggestion about sending members to Inverness. The rigmarole that we would have to go through to secure the agreement of the parliamentary authorities to send two members would not allow the meeting to take place before the recess. It would be much easier to get the Highland representatives to come here. Duncan McNeil is looking quizzical; I am quite willing to enlighten him of the intricacies if he so wishes.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

A paper has to be sent to the conveners liaison group—it met yesterday—which must approve it. It must then be approved by the Parliamentary Bureau and finally by the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I am sorry, but we will not have a debate about that here; that is just the way it is.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

It seems that we do not do that. It would be a much more straightforward process for them to come here.I will just finish my points. That leaves the meeting on 27 June, at which I would expect to present the committee with a note on the fuel price inquiry. We could agree to meet people from Highland Council and Inverness and District Chamber of Commerce on 14 June, subject to completing our stage 2 consideration of the Education and Training (Scotland) Bill on 12 June.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Yes—unless members want to hear from the minister as well.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I am trying to find out whether the committee is prepared to allocate the time to hear the organisations.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I am happy to ask the clerks whether that can be arranged. I know that videoconferencing has been used already, so it can be done. It could be another innovation of the Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I am sure that the official report will take care of that last remark. I must move the discussion towards a conclusion. Do we agree to hear representatives of Highland Council and Inverness Chamber of Commerce on 14 June, subject to completing stage 2 consideration of the Education and Training (Scotland) Bill on 12 June? Do we want to give the minister the opportunity to make a statement to the committee on 14 June?Members indicated agreement.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

The purpose of the structure of the paper is to ensure that we do not lose sight of those issues. Allan Wilson helpfully suggested that we come back to the issues that had dropped off the agenda last time. From now on, you will see papers with the same structure as the one that we have before us. We will not lose sight of points that have been raised before.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

There is no resistance to dealing with the matter. It is a question of time.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I assure you that it has been examined. My point is that the process takes a long time.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I will write to the convener of the Rural Affairs Committee with the views of this committee and include a copy of the Official Report of this meeting.

  1. Scottish Parliament Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee Wednesday 31 May 2000 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Education and Training (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 Bill debate · 7
  3. Local Economic Development Committee business · 7
  4. Work Programme Procedure · 72
  5. Transport Bill Bill debate · 6
  6. Local Economic Development (Joint Seminar) Committee business · 7
  7. Petitions Petitions · 10
  8. Royal Society of Edinburgh Committee business · 3
  9. Business in the Chamber Committee business · 1
  10. “The same as you?” Committee business · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.